10 Times DVD Extras Lost Their Mind

How a DVD helped solve a murder case.

All Good Things
Magnolia Pictures

To most people right now, using a DVD is a thing of the past - as we live in an age where you find find just about anything via either a subscription to something like Netflix, or by just googling it.

And while this is mostly a great thing, it's not without downsides: like the death of the humble DVD extra. Seeing commentary or recorded footage from behind the scenes of a film was always an exciting concept, since you liked the film enough to buy a DVD of it in the first place.

It always felt like a weirdly kind gesture, too - as someone in the production team thought people would like an extra feature so much they had it added in. Even if it was a totally sub-par game you had to use your remote to awkwardly control, you can still appreciate the effort.

But some films went much further than this with their DVD extras. Much, much further. Between hidden musicals, hilarious treats, and cruel pranks, many films have such insane bonus features that it almost makes you wish that DVDs were still a huge thing.

10. An Extra Musical - Dr. Horrible's Sing Along Blog

dr horrible
Mutant Enemy Productions

Dr. Horrible's Sing Along Blog follows the trend of musicals having people sing where they shouldn't with a determined focus. So much focus, in fact, that even its DVD commentary track is entirely comprised of songs.

Named "Commentary! The Musical", this feature contains an extra whopping fourteen songs, which range from actually discussing the film itself, to just being the most meta creations music has possibly ever seen.

There's something so delightful about the fact that this was slid into DVD copies without much fuss. The idea of someone, having watched the film, idly slipping on the commentary tract only to find a full extra musical is both surreal and delightful. When you think about the amount of time it must have taken, it's absolutely insane that everyone opted to go the extra mile to create something that only those who browsed extra features would enjoy.

Nowadays, you can buy a copy of Commentary! The Musical itself. It really says something about the level of work put into the film that even its commentary is impressive as an entity all on its own.


9. An Optional Drinking Game - Wild Zero

Wild Zero
Dragon Pictures

Wild Zero is a criminally underrated zombie flick. It's over the top, it includes a rock band, and contains more explosions than you could have ever dreamt of in one film.

It's also especially cool for one unique feature: an in-built drinking game. Enable this in the DVD menu, and every time one of the Wild Zero drinking rules is broken - because, say, an explosion happens - a little beer mug appears in the corner of the screen, helpfully reminding you to take a quick swig.

It's a surprisingly helpful feature, as you get to avoid the part of a drinking game where drinking makes you forget the rules of the game, and thus when to drink.

It also perfectly fits the tone of the film, as this is entirely the sort of thing you're supposed to watch with a few friends, and a couple nice beverages in tow.

It's not perfect - not by a long shot - but that isn't a civic crime when the film insists you drink every time someone combs their hair (which they do at every given opportunity).


8. Carrot Top Watches The Film (For The First Time) - Rules Of Attraction

Rules Of Attraction Party Gif
Lions Gate Films

It's worth saying from the offset that comedian Carrot Top's feature commentary is not on the Rules of Attraction DVD because he was involved in the film's creation. It's not even because the film is the same type of comedy that he uses - because Carrot Top's prop-laden routine is a far cry from the film's self-purported pitch black blend of comedy and drama.

And this point, you may be very confused why Carrot Top gets commentary on this DVD at all. Does he have... some kind of insight into the film?

It's actually kind of the opposite.

You see, Carrot Top's commentary on the film... is recorded the very first time he watches the film. And so you're actually just watching the comedian react to the events that take place. It should in theory be dull, but the fact he gets super into the plot's many twists and turns actually makes it worth watching.

But there's absolutely no reason for it to have existed, and the total absence of logic in the DVD extra feature only makes it all the funnier.


7. Learn To Cook - Once Upon A Time In Mexico

Puerco Pubil Once Upon A Time In Mexico
Columbia Pictures

Robert Rodriguez is a pretty damn good film maker - and arguably also a pretty good cook. Combine this with a penchant for adding ten minute features in DVDs of his work, and you have an almost inevitable conclusion.

And so, the DVD extras for Once Upon a Time in Mexico contains the "10 Minute Cooking School", which features Robert cooking up some Puerco Pubil, which is a rice meal we see in the film itself.

It's incredibly sweet, really, because the video itself is somewhere between a Youtube cooking tutorial and your friend or family showing you this cool recipe they know.

It also reveals that Rodriguez keeps a little menu of foods he's especially good at cooking in his house, which he explains he has so that when people come round they can choose what meal they want to eat. This is unmistakably one of the sweetest details to learn about someone by accident, and is also wild to have as an extra feature on a notably gritty film.

Many of the creator's other films also contain this feature on their DVD editions - for example, the film Grindhouse contains a classic Texas BBQ.

Now that DVDs are mostly a thing from the past, we can only hope and dream that Rodriguez makes a cooking channel. For our sakes.


6. Watch The Film (In An Alien Language) - Galaxy Quest

Galaxy Quest
DreamWorks

As a homage to all good sci-fi films and tropes, Galaxy Quest manages to place an absolutely magnificent extra feature in its DVD.

In fitting with a film that shows a bunch of imaginary alien races - complete with their own languages - Galaxy Quest comes with a function that allows you to listen to the whole film dubbed in the alien dialect of Thermian.

Obviously, you won't be able to make out a single word of it, which makes it the kind of thing only put on by possible very lonely people, or otherwise people enjoying a small dose of the devil's many herbs and spices. Either way, you're watching an hour and forty minutes of a film, that - unless you've memorised it - will be basically indecipherable.

Given the creators knew this, you have to give them mad respect for recording the whole film's dialogue again in a language they knew nobody would be able to uncover. There's a level of whimsy at place here that is undeniably impressive - even if it is also entirely confusing.


5. Some Graphic Novel Shorts - I Am Legend

I Am Legend Comic Short
Warner Bros.

I Am Legend is one of those films that, if someone told you it was out of a comic book, you'd entirely believe it. The action, setting and storytelling are all carried off with aplomb - and the deleted ending is the sort of shocking twist that any good comic series knows to throw in at least once.

Presumably, the creators of the film were very aware that they had adapted the book version of I Am Legend - which contains a badass but relatively mundane protagonist - into something far more of a graphic novel. We can presume this because the DVD version of the film comes with four animated comic shorts, which show the outbreak of the zombie-esque virus around the world.

It's a shame that these couldn't have been interspersed within the film itself, really, because the dimension and depth they add to the universe really is spectacular.

However, they do also support the idea that the "zombies" are just a strange, aggressive form of human evolution, as the book itself states. Unfortunately, because the ending of the film was changed, these shorts don't quite mesh with the story it tells - and more's the shame for it.


4. Shakespearian Subtitles - Monty Python And The Holy Grail

Monty Python and the Holy Grail - Knights
EMI Films

There's two things that are absolutely crucial to know when it comes to the gentlemen who comprised the comedy supergroup known as Monty Python. One is that they are very, very funny - and the other is that they are all incredibly intelligent red-brick university graduates.

But why are these things important? Well, they're important because they combine to explain why, when the team made Monty Python and The Holy Grail, they gave the DVD one very important feature - which was titled "Subtitles for People Who Don't Like the Film".

These subtitles replace the actual lines of dialogue in the film with lines from Shakespeare's play Henry IV. Because the team working on this were clearly intimately familiar with the play, they're able to make these Shakespearian replacements actually fit what is being said pretty well, albeit without much of the comedy the regular script provides.

When you think about it, the idea that the Monty Python crew were able to perfectly use parts of Shakespeare's work to create practically another film within their film is both impressive and suitably hilarious.


3. An Accidental Crime Confession - All Good Things

All Good Things Ryan Gosling
Magnolia Pictures

All Good Things is a film that is based around the life of Robert Durst, who was the suspect in an as-of-then acquitted murder case. Durst had been imprisoned until 2005 for confessing to tampering with police evidence related to his court case, having chopped up a man he supposedly accidentally killed in order to prevent his own criminal charges.

Despite all this, when All Good Things came out in 2010, Robert was delighted, and offered to give commentary on the DVD. That's right, a man involved in a murder case that had been acquitted due to a lack of evidence decided to publicly talk at length about it.

This would go somehow without much thought, until another piece of media was made about Durst - this time a HBO documentary named The Jinx. Durst would also agree to be interviewed for this show, only he would ultimately forget he was wearing a mic and then discuss the murders he had done to himself in the bathroom.

He'd be immediately arrested, having managed to pull off an accidental confession that you'd call unbelievable if you saw it in a film. His commentary in All Good Things would be used as evidence against him - which is currently still ongoing as of today.


2. Samara Comes For You - The Ring

Samara The Ring
Universal Pictures

Given the sheer terror The Ring inspires in so many of us, the DVD extra in America versions of the film was almost excruciatingly cruel.

Should you leave the film on its menu screen, it will decide to mess with you in the best possible way, playing the Ring footage while not allowing you to pause or exit it. You know, the footage you just watched ruin lives in nightmarish ways - and that now appears to be about to ruin your life, as your paranoid mind now suspects.

If you aren't messed up enough by that alone, it then has one final ace up its sleeve - and oh boy, it's a real doozy.

After playing you this footage in a way that suggests you're about to die in seven days, the DVD then plays the sound of a phonecall, that's intended to sound as though it's coming from behind you. Said phonecall is, of course, suppose to give you a heads up of your imminent demise - and because you've almost definitely just watched the film, you are very, very aware of that.

It's a genius extra feature, if also an entirely sadistic one.


1. Yoda Breakdances - Star Wars: Revenge Of The Sith

Yoda Breakdances Star Wars
LucasFilm Ltd.

A lot of DVD extras are elaborate, containing huge commentary sections with hours of content. While it's always great to get to see more about a film you loved, sometimes a shorter extra feature is better.

Take, for example, Yoda's extra breakdancing scene, nestled away in the extra features of the Revenge of the Sith DVD. It's a ludicrous idea. It's a silly idea. It might even arguably be a huge red flag that someone, somewhere on the development team was coming very close to a very big breakdown.

But it's a breakdown we can only be grateful for, as seeing the trickster Jedi master get loose and funky is so strange that it's legitimately absolutely hilarious.

It's not lazily animated, either, as every turn and crump is delicately rendered with what must have been painstaking effort. Add in the nice little detail of a collection of Stormtroopers jamming along in the background and you have one of the most unusually funny moments in the series' history.

This said, it's heartbreaking that the little green sage never got to bust a move in any of his fighting scenes. Really could have added something to the franchise.


Watch Next


Film Quiz: Do You Know The True Stories Behind These Iconic Movies?

Goodfellas Poster
Warner Bros.

1. Which Real Life Crime Was Depicted In Goodfellas?

Contributor
Contributor

I like my comics like I like my coffee - in huge, unquestionably unhealthy doses.