10 Times Film Critics Actually Changed Their Mind
Somehow, a few film critics hated Raiders of the Lost Ark in 1981.
While the popularity of critical aggregators like Rotten Tomatoes have effectively diminished the influence of any single film critic, it's still possible for a powerful review to tectonically sway general opinion on a film, and in turn dent its box office prospects.
It's incredibly rare for critics to flatly admit that they were ever wrong about a film - after all, their opinion is their reputation - but every now and then, prominent critics have dared to admit that their original estimation was wrong.
More often than not, critics will admit to changing their mind when a film they initially panned was fondly embraced by the wider critical cohort and even went on to become a certified classic.
Whether waiting mere minutes or as long as 30 years, these critics all publicly turned around on a film they reviewed otherwise to the masses, whether because they simply couldn't connect with the film at the time, they were reoccupied with personal problems, or perhaps even had the movie's star breathing down their neck.
Given that these critics' reputations were hardly compromised by admitting their faults, they're proof perfect that a good critic is an open-minded one...
10. Gene Siskel Was Convinced By Roger Ebert To "Thumbs Down" Broken Arrow
There will never be a film critic duo more iconic than the late, great Gene Siskel and Roger Ebert.
The pair passionately squabbled about each week's new releases on their TV show At the Movies, with each man typically digging their heels in and only growing more defensive over the course of their spirited debate.
However, there's just a single exception where Ebert managed to convince Siskel to change his mind about a movie.
While discussing John Woo's 1996 action film Broken Arrow, Siskel gave it a mildly positive review, though after listening to Ebert complain about it, decided to change his "thumbs up" to a "thumbs down" alongside his colleague.
Ebert himself hardly hated the film, though considered it a pedestrian and unimaginative action flick, and Siskel ultimately found himself unable to argue otherwise.
For the remainder of their tenure together, neither managed to convince the other to change their mind about any other movie, though as you'll see later on, Ebert did sometimes reverse his decision in print.
9. Leonard Maltin Re-Evaluated Alien 25 Years Later
Leonard Maltin is one of America's most recognisable and respected film critics, though that didn't stop him dropping the ball in a major way when reviewing the original 1979 release of Ridley Scott's Alien.
Maltin's initial review was sharply negative:
"Space-age horror film reverts to 1950s formula story, but adds stomach-churning violence, slime, and shocks. Still, this is some people's idea of a good time."
However, when Ridley Scott re-released the film for its 25th anniversary in 2004, Maltin decided to revisit the sci-fi classic and realised he was wrong.
While Maltin has generally pushed back against those who have challenged his negative reviews for the likes of Taxi Driver and Blade Runner, he conceded that Alien is indeed a great film and gave it a strong endorsement in a new review. Of the change of heart, he said:
"I'm a wimp, and when it first came out, it scared the hell out of me. I found it too upsetting so I gave it a review that reflected that. Twenty-five years later, Ridley Scott tweaked it and reissued it theatrically. When I saw it again, I thought it was masterful and I completely changed the review to three-and-a-half stars."
8. Mark Kermode Publicly Apologised To Steven Spielberg For Trashing The "Masterpiece" A.I.
Mark Kermode is perhaps the most notable and prominent British film critic working today, and during an interview with Steven Spielberg for his 2012 film Lincoln, Kermode decided to bury a decade-old hatchet.
In a video released before the interview, Kermode explained that he had the opportunity to apologise to Spielberg for his initial negative review of the director's 2001 sci-fi film A.I. Artificial Intelligence.
Though Kermode didn't think much of it at the time, he re-watched A.I. years later and found the film to be not only great but even went as far as to call it the director's "enduring masterpiece." A lofty claim if there ever was one.
Kermode was in the luxurious position to be able to personally apologise to the man himself for "getting it wrong" the first time, categorically proving that the best and most interesting film critics always keep themselves open to new perspectives.
7. Joe Morgenstern Published A Second Review Of Bonnie & Clyde, Calling His First "Grossly Unfair"
There's perhaps no more famous example of a film critic retracting their previous opinion on a film than Joe Morgenstern and Bonnie and Clyde.
While working as a critic for Newsweek in the 1960s, Morgenstern published an emphatic pan of the later-Oscar-winning crime thriller, flatly dismissing it as a "squalid shoot-'em-up for the moron trade."
Morgenstern later noted that the press screening was also attended by star Warren Beatty himself, which no doubt made the viewing experience less-than-pleasant for any critic trying to maintain objective focus. He said:
"I don't know if it made me nervous or not... But it certainly was unusual, especially since Warren spent the whole time trying to read my notes."
The whole experience didn't sit well with the critic, however, and he decided to go see the film again on general release day with his wife where he realised his mistake:
"I got it wrong. I was not ready for the violence and kind of shrank from it."
Though Morgenstern's first review was already prepped for print, he was allowed to publish a follow-up piece that called his initial review "grossly unfair and regrettably inaccurate."
The turnaround from Morgenstern was fully capitalised upon by Warner Bros., who used it as a ringing endorsement of the film's quality, that it could inspire even a well-minted critic-of-note to change his opinion.
The rest, as they say, is history.
6. Roger Ebert Replaced His Lukewarm Unforgiven Review With A Rave Years Later
Roger Ebert has issued tepid reviews or even outright pans to many beloved movies, and one of his all-time most controversial reviews is his lukewarm initial response to Clint Eastwood's 1992 Best Picture-winning Western masterpiece Unforgiven.
Ebert certainly didn't slate the film, but he did call it only entertaining in the moment, stating that he found it "meandering" and its atmosphere "shapeless," which Gene Siskel more-or-less agreed with.
Ebert ended up giving it 2.5 out of 4 stars, but when he re-reviewed it a decade later, he gave it a full, enthusiastic four stars, even adding it to his prestigious "Great Movies" list.
In a 1996 interview, Ebert confirmed that his original viewing of the film was tainted by a preoccupation with his personal life:
"I changed my mind on Unforgiven; I gave it only two-and-a-half stars. I wasn't thinking very well when I reviewed that."
As for the personal issue that distracted him from fairly assessing the movie? His upcoming wedding to his future wife Chaz.
5. Robbie Collin Reconsidered The Paperboy After Panning Its Cannes Premiere
One of the most controversial and talked-about films that premiered at the 2012 Cannes Film Festival was Lee Daniels' scandalous, Zac Efron-starring crime drama The Paperboy.
Its shamelessly pulpy style massively polarised critics, leading to a particularly passionate damning from The Daily Telegraph's Robbie Collin, who in his Cannes review called it a "transcendentally awful romance-stroke-crime drama."
But when the film was finally released in the UK almost a year later, Collin decided to watch it once again, and found his tune completely changed. In his new review, he said:
"As a piece of art this is all lust, no caution; a heady mirage of sex, swamps and soul music that wants nothing more than for you to share in the joke. Thank goodness I finally got it."
His two reviews really only amplify The Paperboy's divisive nature - to some it's lurid trash, to others it's a campy joy, and to critics like Collin, it can be one and then the other.
4. Matt Zoller Seitz Apologised To Todd Solondz For Dismissing Happiness
Todd Solondz's Happiness is one of the most provocative and talked-about independent films of the 1990s, a savagely dark comedy that dares to cover subjects as bleak as murder, rape, suicide, paedophilia, and depression.
Unsurprisingly such subject matter was tailor-made to polarise critics - enough that the Sundance Film Festival even refused to select it - and though Happiness was still genuinely well-received by the press, many prominent reviewers panned it.
In his review for New York Press, Matt Zoller Seitz called Happiness "adolescent" and expressed a general distaste for what he perceived to be Solondz's "smug" storytelling.
But after being blown away by Solondz's 2009 film Life During Wartime, which was a loose sequel to Happiness, Seitz felt compelled to revisit the original.
A new viewing, 12 years after he trashed it, confirmed to Seitz that his initial estimation was wrong. He said:
"It was funny, sad, sincere, ugly, tough, weird, occasionally horrifying. You could not watch it and feel nothing. I had no idea why I panned it."
It gets better, though: when Seitz moderated a Q&A with Solondz in 2010, Solondz asked him directly about his original review of Happiness.
Seitz told the director that he had an "allergic reaction" to it at the time, first viewing Happiness during one of the happiest periods of his own life, where "on some level it threatened" him.
Critical turnarounds don't get much more complete than that. Seitz even penned a follow-up article taking a deep dive into his relationship with the film, with a headline that straight-up apologised to Solondz for getting it wrong in the first place.
3. Peter Bradshaw Walked Back His Original Negative Review Of The Devil Wears Prada
The Guardian's chief film critic Peter Bradshaw delivered a less-than-flattering two-star review of Meryl Streep's Oscar-nominated 2006 dramedy The Devil Wears Prada, where he praised Streep's performance but didn't have much else nice to say:
"Now, I'll be the first to admit I don't 'get' fashion, but to intimate its ephemeral pleasures to the non-believer and non-understander, I think you'd need a more astringent and detached - and a funnier - movie than this."
However, in 2016 Bradshaw responded to a reader asking if he'd ever changed his mind about a film he reviewed, and he replied that he watched The Devil Wears Prada on TV years after reviewing it and "really enjoyed it."
ha yes. The Devil Wears Prada. Didn't like it much at the time — saw it later on TV and really enjoyed it
— Peter Bradshaw (@PeterBradshaw1) September 21, 2016
2. Lou Lumenick Admitted He Was Wrong About Raiders Of The Lost Ark... 30 Years Later
Years before he became the chief film critic for the New York Post, Lou Lumenick wrote for the New Jersey newspaper The Record, and after just two months working as a professional film reviewer, found himself beating down what would become one of the most beloved blockbusters of all time.
In 1981, Lumenick issued a lukewarm review to Spielberg's Raiders of the Lost Ark, calling it "a very entertaining junk-food movie that will be forgotten long before [Spielberg or George Lucas'] previous work."
Lumenick went on:
"Raiders is almost totally derivative, a technically proficient but empty-headed homage to movie serials of the 1930s and 1940s that has absolutely nothing of its own to say. While the film is a great deal of fun, it lacks the creative sparkle of Spielberg’s earlier efforts... Kids will probably love it, but its campy humor is much less satisfying for adults than Superman II."
He also called the premise "deliberately hokey," the dialogue "corny," the humour "hamfisted," Harrison Ford "hardly memorable," and complained about Spielberg's "excesses as a director."
As reviews that aged like milk go, it's tough to beat this one. 30 years later, Lumenick expressed regret over "dissing" the film, and in a spot of good humour even republished his original review, which otherwise isn't available online.
1. Roger Ebert Reviewed A New Cut Of The Brown Bunny, Settled His Feud With Director Vincent Gallo
Given that Roger Ebert is and probably forever will be the world's most iconic film critic, it's fair that he gets a second entry on this list.
Considering his fascinating history with Vincent Gallo's 2003 experimental drama The Brown Bunny, it's certainly a spot well earned.
Gallo's film premiered at the 2003 Cannes Film Festival, where it caught immediate ire from critics and audiences alike for its unconventional style and particularly an unsimulated oral sex scene performed by actress Chloe Sevigny on director-star Gallo.
Upon leaving the Cannes press screening, Ebert told a waiting TV crew that The Brown Bunny was "the worst film in the history of the festival," which ignited a feud between himself and Gallo.
Gallo called Ebert a "fat pig with the physique of a slave trader," to which Ebert replied, "It is true that I am fat, but one day I will be thin, and he will still be the director of The Brown Bunny."
The squabbling continued, but Ebert re-reviewed the film when a new cut premiered at the Toronto International Film Festival later that year, with almost 30 minutes chopped off the original runtime.
Shockingly, Ebert posted an adulatory three-out-of-four-star review of the new cut, saying:
"Gallo went back into the editing room and cut 26 minutes of his 118-minute film, or almost a fourth of the running time. And in the process he transformed it. The film's form and purpose now emerge from the miasma of the original cut, and are quietly, sadly, effective. It is said that editing is the soul of the cinema; in the case of The Brown Bunny, it is its salvation."
Speaking in 2018, five years after Ebert's death, Gallo was however left unsatisfied by Ebert's turnaround, deeming it "both far-fetched and an outright lie," and proclaiming, "If you didn't like the unfinished film at Cannes, you didn't like the finished film."
Either way, for a critic to change their stance so drastically is nothing if not a testament to the power of editing.