10 Underrated Movie Characters That Fans Really Hate
Whenever people try to connect over a film, one of the most common questions to ask is: "Who's your favorite character?" Let's be honest... chances are you're going to say the same characters. Everyone likes Han Solo from Star Wars. Everyone likes Jules from Pulp Fiction. Not to diminish the quality of these creations, but most of the time it's easy to like characters who are intended to be badass or cool - especially when they're played by actors who naturally inhabit these traits. But what about the characters who don't immediately register as cool? Don't they serve as much of a function as the other guys? Let's examine a few "misunderstood" roles - 10 underrated movie characters that the fans hate, in fact, who might deserve a bit more credit... 10. Fredo Corleone - The Godfather
Why's he hated? When your Dad is a mob boss, your older brother is a tough guy womanizer, and your younger brother is a war hero and heir, you have a greatly increased likelihood of looking like a p*ssy. Fredo unfortunately falls into this category. One of his most memorable scenes is reacting to his father's shooting, too late to do anything useful. He just cries impotently in the street. Atta boy. He's also completely locked out of the mafioso information loop. It's telling that, despite being older than Michael, no-one ever questions why Fredo wasn't considered to be an acting Godfather or even a counsel. His only meaningful contribution to the plot is selling out Michael in the second film, leaving his brother no choice but to take him out on an impromptu "fishing trip." Why he's underrated? The Godfather trilogy unfolds like a Shakespearean drama: a "good king" falls, leaving his dutiful son to take over his kingdom with the weight of the crown bringing him lower than he's ever sunk. That's really beautiful, except that the Corleones are actually a very real crime family. The inherent romance of the setting tends to make viewers forget just how base the mafia community is. Nothing allows that hit home more than the pathos of Fredo. Not getting the memo about the tone of the films, he acts how a bitter brother would react in this situation, constantly complaining about Michael's fortunes. He doesn't have the Machiavellian planning of Hyman Roth in his betrayal - he sloppily acts out of pure envy and greed. He's not a worthy opponent to Michael, he's his simpering "little" brother who never had a chance for respect. If he were to be a bit smarter or more ruthless, his death wouldn't have nearly the same impact. He'd just be another criminal for Michael to defeat. Having to kill Fredo communicates just how low criminal underworld can sink.
9. Anakin Skywalker - Star Wars
Why's he hated? Remember the first time you saw Star Wars? Remember when you saw Darth Vader come out of the smoke and break that dude's neck? Wasn't that badass? I wonder what turned him into such a badass? Lucas heard your thoughts and said "Here you go, kids!" So he's a dull, gameless, man-child with rage issues. He also has ludicrous technical abilities and a needlessly combative relationship with the coolest mentor in the history of mentors. Oh, and he's also accompanied by a disappointing series of films. Merry Christmas. Why's he underrated? Look, I'm not going to pretend like Hayden Christensen is a good actor. I'm also not going to pretend his dialogue isn't brain-stabbingly awful or that most of his plot-lines are poorly-handled. What I will say is that he serves the overall context of the series decently, considering what Lucas had to work with. Who was Darth Vader as a character? What were his motivations? How did he become evil? We don't get any of that in the original trilogy - all we know is that he was a good guy who became a Sith. Vader's redemption at the end of Return of the Jedi feels so random and out of left field, mainly because it's barely even foreshadowed and could be thought of as another ass-pull on Lucas' part. The only way it makes sense is if Anakin was intensely conflicted and didn't truly want to be a Sith in the first place. Most of the "whining" the character does might be considered legitimate in real life: he was a slave whose only option in life was to basically become a monk/soldier. No wonder he got a little b*tchy when he grew up. Even then, it's not like he chose to be a Sith, either. He had to choose between possibly saving his wife and unborn child or allowing another Jedi (Mace Windu) who he has no relationship with to murder a captive, which would have made him party to murder by his own world's logic anyway. Tough call, bro. Saving Palpatine left him with no choice but to become his right hand, or else risk his own death (and Padme's, too). With that in mind, it makes sense why, presented with another opportunity to choose between duty and emotion, he betrays Palpatine and redeems himself.
8. Cyclops - X-Men
Why's he hated? The website TV Tropes has a page dedicated to a stock character referred to as the "standardised leader." In weakly-written stories, the standardised leader usually gets character traits that college kids put on resumes to sound useful: "reliable" "hard-working" and "punctual," to name a few. This describes a hall monitor, though, not a likable person. This sums up Cyclops to a tee: he's a satellite character who has almost no scenes to distinguish himself. His entire role in the film is telling Wolverine not to be badass only to look shocked when he does it anyway. Good thing he told him not to bone his wife - oh wait! Why's he underrated? Y'know what I hate about the X-Men franchise? It's not about the X-Men! It's about that goddamn Canadian carpet who calls himself Wolverine. And it's a shame that the first film focuses on him so much, because it undercuts what should have been a more important aspect of the film: the acceptance that Xavier's school is supposed to represent for the mutants. Without it, the films are just depressing. The only character we get this tender feeling from in the film is Cyclops. When Xavier is in a coma after the Cerebro attack, Cyclops talks to him while he's unconscious, reflecting on how Xavier has been like a father to him. In addition, he's the only character who acts as a reminder that the X-Men are, in fact, a team. Shocking, I know. Is this a "tour de force" performance? No - but at least it injects some of the camaraderie from the comic books that the films otherwise lacked.
7. Short Round - Indiana Jones and the Temple of Doom
Why he's hated? As a movie about an upper class white American who goes to a foreign countries and "appropriates" an artifact by force, Indiana Jones and the Temple of Doom is arguably as culturally insensitive as Hollywood movies come. Factor in Indy's sidekick for the movie, Short Round, a short Asian orphan who speaks in broken English, and... well, I can't see how that can be insensitive. Mind you, a lot of films in the '80s had this same stock character (Revenge of The Nerds and The Goonies, for example), which made it seem both racist and cliche. Why's he underrated? Well, Short Round's definitely a racially-inclined character, but he's nowhere near as bad as he could have been. For example, in The Goonies, the Asian kid is called "Data" and carries around a bunch of gadgets that save the heroes. Why does he do this? Um... because Asians are good with technology? He has no characterization beyond just having lots of gadgets on him. In Sixteen Candles, foreign exchange student Long Duck Dong has a gong accompany every mention of his name. Why does that happen? Um... because Asians like gongs? The only overtly "Asian" aspect of Short Round is that he speaks broken English, which is understandable, since he lives in Shanghai and is young enough to logically not know enough English. Most of the other stereotypes are avoided: he doesn't reference East Asia or have any "Asian" skills (except a bit of karate). He's just a goofy kid character, really, and a much less offensive archetype than audiences were used to. On top of that, he and Indy actually have some pretty funny banter.
6. Lola Bunny - Space Jam
Why she's hated? I'm only gonna say this one more time, internet: I don't masturbate to animated women. I don't care if it's all the rage in Tokyo, I have morals, dammit! And even more so, I don't want to masturbate to female animal women! Nothing made me realize this more than the character of Lola Bunny, who pops up in Space Jam to be... sexy? I get it: focus groups told Warner Bros. "you can't have an animated ensemble without a woman! Diversity! Hur hur!" But for the love of God, did they really have to introduce a bunny stripper turned basketball player in this kids' flick? She has no personality or quirks or any of those other qualities that are supposed to make a cartoon, y'know, funny. They even have the nerve to make her a damsel-in-distress at one point when she's injured, despite the fact that she should be as invulnerable as any other toons in the movie. But at least she's sexy, right? Who the hell was the audience for this? Bronies didn't even exist back then! Why's she underrated? Don't get me wrong: I think Lola Bunny is an abomination upon Warner Bros. that I can't forgot. But there are... some... who... like her. You know who I mean. I guess before Space Jam, Furries only had Minerva Mink from Animaniacs to beat off to (and she was only in a couple of episodes due to being deemed much too racy by (wait for it!) Warner Bros. Lola was one of the few animated characters who were overtly-fetishized enough in order to make "acceptable" pornography fodder. So for all you guys destined for hell, be glad that this bunny temptress gave you the first opportunity to indulge your sick and disgusting fantasies. Perverts. (Note: her Looney Tunesiteration is actually pretty cool. Still not turned on though).
5. Bella Swan - Twilight
Why's she hated? Twilight has become the go-to critical punching bag since the first film came out. The book is panned, the main actors are panned, the story is panned. And most of all, Kristen Stewart's face is panned. I mean, my God - is the girl wearing a porcelain mask that she thinks will shatter at the slightest expression? The girl is an embalmed corpse. More importantly, her character is considered the bane of feminism: she has no positive qualities aside from being "attractive," so her whole narrative arc revolves around being picked up by the hunkiest monster. Why's she underrated? Because she's an avatar for the writer and women everywhere. Let's be honest: some women do want a strong, complex man to sweep them off their feet and make their problems disappear. Why do you think characters like Cinderella continue to be so popular? Or any Disney Princess, for that matter? Bella Swan is living the dream that so many women wish they could live: girl gets taken to fantasyland. I guess the big problem people have with Bella is the sheer baldness of her as an archetype: she has no character beyond her relationship to the men in her life. She is a bland, shallow shell of a human being who exists for no reason than to be flirted with. However, that doesn't change the fact that she presumably taps into a desire that a lot of women do have, whether they want to admit it or not (not that Stewart's face can express desire. Or sadness. Or life).
4. Sam Witwicky - Transformers
Why's he hated? Transformers is about giant metal robots fighting each other. Sam Witwicky is not a giant metal robot. Fans don't like this. Unfortunately, Michael Bay insisted on having him as a constant factor in the films, even being present during major battles where he only serves as a distraction. On top of that, Shia LaBeouf has acquired such a hatedom with regards to his other films (especially Indiana Jones and the Crystal Skull) that a lot of fans just dislike him by default. Why's he underrated? If you're one of those fans who thinks that the Transformers franchise was perverted by Michael Bay, I've got something to tell you: you're stupid. I mean it... you're freaking dumb. The entire point of Transformers was to shill toys to kids. There isn't any depth to work with. The only adaptable themes from the series are "humans are worth defending" and "giant robots are cool." Witwicky serves both roles. The robots aren't impressive to each other, so we need a constant human perspective to maintain their awe-inspiring nature. Sam Witwicky, weak little chump that he is, is the most "human" human being in the cast. His willingness to jump into the heat of battle, despite his obvious shortcomings, also justifies Optimus' belief in the strength of humankind. Now stop being stupid, fanboys.
3. Batman - Batman & Robin
Why's he hated? Batman & Robin unfortunately came out after the fiscally successful but critically maligned Batman Forever. As such, fans were anticipating a sh*tty film before it even got in theatres. So when the film opened on a batsuit - complete with nipples so pointy they looked like they had been fondled by Mr. Freeze himself - the rest of the film was a done deal. Ironically, for a film as over-the-top as Batman & Robin, the criticism I often hear of BatClooney is that he's bereft of character. He doesn't have the quirkiness of Keaton or the presence of Kilmer. He's just an occasionally-mugging straight man to all the wackiness of the film. Clooney himself recognized how unpopular the film was and promised to refund any fan who didn't like the film (which I have yet to receive, by the way). Why's he underrated? While fans try to assert that Clooney was the blandest of the Batmen, it's important to remember that the franchise had moved miles away from being a character study of any kind (arguably for good reason). The first Batman film had already established the character, Batman Returns was an expressionistic look at his psyche, and Batman Forever was a very literal look at his psyche. We get it: Batman is messed up. There wasn't anything left to learn about the character by the time Batman & Robin was released. Therefore, they went for a light-hearted campfest instead. BatClooney was a throwback to the Adam West version from the '60s: a confident, mildly eccentric playboy who happened to be a superhero. Honestly, BatClooney is the only Batman interpretation that is all-out wish fulfilling: he actually looks like he's having fun being a superhero.
2. The Grinch - How The Grinch Stole Christmas
Why's he hated? Well, this one is a bit mixed. How The Grinch Stole Christmas was an enormous success and actually earned Jim Carrey a Golden Globe nomination for his portrayal of the title character. At the same time, the film was nominated for a Golden Raspberry (an award invented by copywriter John J.B. Wilson to mock bad films) and several purists said Carrey's portrayal wasn't respectful of the original. Whereas the vocal performance and animation for the original Grinch was malevolently understated, Jim Carrey was very much in "wacky" mode. Add to this the fact that, by 2000, Jim Carrey's shtick was showing its age, and it made his zany performance here an easy target for critics. Why's he underrated? First off, I really liked the film (at least as a kid, I did). Secondly, while I agree that Carrey's performance is nothing like the original's, it's important to remember that the audience and intent was very different. The animated film was made when mass appeal animation could still be a bit deranged (Looney Tunes is the best example). Not to say we don't have animated series like that now, it's just that once it's taken to the big screen, unless your intro has that big 'ol Magic Kingdom in the beginning, you can't get away with much. Because of this, the Grinch had to turn down the malevolence (which Carrey did). If the Grinch was as creepy as the original version, parents would get antsy about letting their kids view it. Carrey's performance hits a comfortable medium, -he's still clearly threatening when it's necessary, but someone you could imagine being a decent guy deep down. Also: whereas the original Grinch was a 2D drawing, Jim Carrey was a 3D person. As such, one has to appreciate the amount of skill it took to act through a costume so uncomfortable that Carrey had to learn pain-relieving exercises just to get through it. Golden Raspberry award my ass.
1. Scrappy-Doo - Scooby-Doo
Why's he hated? "Wait a minute! He's not a film character!" Whoa, now: relax. Scrappy-Doo wasn't originally a film character, but was a universally-loathed part of the TV series. So loathed, in fact, that TV Tropes titled its page for fan-despised characters after him. Scrappy was brash, annoying, and a myriad of other awful things. He was basically what would happen if the Chicken Hawk from Looney Tunes had a lot more focus. And that's where we get to the worst aspect of his character: he was unavoidable! Near the end of its run, the series wanted to "shake things up" by introducing a sidekick to Scooby-Doo. Because some dumbass thought that a talking dog who was a sidekick to a pothead who was in turn a sidekick to an entire group of teenagers needed a sidekick of his own for some reason. As such, his entire role became an instigator of needless conflict. Remember how most of the humor from Shaggy and Scooby revolved around them trying to run away from trouble? Remember all the inventive ways they would try to outwit the bad guy? Well what if, instead, they always have to save Scrappy from getting beat up (which always plays out in the same manner, mind you), and that's it? Funny, right? Why's he underrated (and on this list)? Well, because he is in a film: 2002's Scooby-Doo. Now, yes - most people think that the film sucks. And it probably does: it was an attempt to cash in on a long-dead franchise that had awful CG and a concept that was inappropriate with regards to the source material. But honestly, I really liked it as a kid. I like the fact that it did just kind of laugh at the whole premise of the series and forced it into a mostly inappropriate sci-fi/fantasy/whatever plot (similar to the film adaptations of The Brady Bunch and The Addams Family). Most of the fun I had with it was in picking up on all the elements the film was deconstructing, or at least making light of. The element most deconstructed was, of course, Scrappy-Doo. By the time the film was released, of course, fans hatred of the character was legendary. Therefore, it was only appropriate that the film acknowledge just how much of an annoying little sh*t Scrappy would be in real life: a flashback shows him peeing on Daphne, spouting his terrible catchphrase, and finally being responsible for the Mystery Inc. crew breaking up (mirroring the show's real-life cancellation). It turns out in the end that Scrappy was actually the villain of the film, plotting revenge on the crew for abandoning him. "Puppy power" indeed. You have to give the creators of this film credit; not many franchises would outright destroy one of their own characters like this. I mean, sure, the series had been off the air for decades, but still, to acknowledge such a huge misstep takes some balls. And that's the exact reason why Scrappy-Doo finds his place on top of this list. Like this list? Let us know in the comments section below.