10 Universally Disliked Blockbusters (That Really Aren’t That Bad)
Come on folks, is The Last Stand really THAT bad?
In today’s world of instant feedback and Twitter reviews it feels like movies don’t get a chance to breathe anymore. Once the reviews for a highly anticipated blockbuster come out there’s a vicious feeding frenzy, where it’s instantly dubbed the best thing ever or the death of cinema itself, when often it’s neither.
There’s very little middle ground in those views either, and if a film picks up a bad reputation for itself it has a hard time shaking it off afterwards. A lot of times they deserve their public flogging, but a few of them actually have some merit, and their biggest crime is they didn’t live up to impossibly high expectations.
Fortunately, time is kind. These films can build up a fanbase over time and eventually get redeemed. Movies like John Carpenter’s The Thing and Alien got rotten reviews initially, but are now considered classics. And over the last thirty years there’s been a steady stream of enjoyable blockbusters that have - for many different reasons - been slammed by fans and critics, and as a result have low self esteem issues.
They may not be classics, but here a bunch of movies that deserve an appeal hearing.
10. Waterworld
Waterworld is considered the prime example of a huge flop; it was a runaway production fraught with ego battles, bad weather and a rising budget. Kevin Costner was a huge star at the time, so the press had their knives ready when the early buzz on it wasn’t great.
Anyone watching Waterworld today though might wonder what the fuss was about since it’s a perfectly enjoyable adventure. It’s basically Mad Max on the water, with some stunning pre-CGI action scenes like the assault on the floating city. Costner is a bit too glum in the lead, but Dennis Hopper is a hammy delight playing the villain. It also looks stunning, and it will be hard for anybody watching it now to believe all the sets were practical.
Importantly, while it often gets reported as a bomb it actually made its money back, and anybody checking Waterworld out now might be surprised to find themselves having a good time with it.
9. Reign Of Fire
Christian Bale has said he’s embarrassed by most of the films he made following American Psycho, and watching Captain Corelli’s Mandolin or Shaft it’s hard to blame him. Another of those films is the forgotten blockbuster Reign Of Fire, where he and Matthew McConaughey team up to fight dragons in post-apocalyptic England.
The movie received middling reviews and weak box-office at the time, and people felt misled by the awesome poster, which featured dragons and helicopters dogfighting over the skies of London; this doesn’t happen anywhere in the movie. Instead, we get more of a moody character piece, where Bale and McConaughey’s dragon hunter butt heads over how to deal with the threat.
The dragons are rarely seen but are genuinely freaky creations when they arrive, McConaughey is awesome-tastic as the crazed hunter and it has a couple of insanely tense setpieces. Bale may not be proud of his work here, but it was early proof of his blockbuster leading man abilities.
8. Last Action Hero
1993 was poised to be the battle between Jurassic Park and Last Action Hero, and we all know how that one turned out. While it’s true Last Action Hero has issues – namely the really annoying teen acting alongside Arnie – there’s a whole lot to love about it too.
There are some great jokes (Arnie’s Hamlet is one for the ages), Charles Dance is a perfect British villain and it was an early example of meta-commentary before all the cool kids started doing it. It was rare for a dumb blockbuster to also be kind of smart, and while it disappointed many at the time people are only now realising what it was trying to do.
It doesn’t always succeed and some of the gags fall flat (seriously, who thought the animated cat was a good idea?), but Last Action Hero is a secret gem waiting for rediscovery.
7. X-Men: The Last Stand
Is The Last Stand disappointing after the first two X-movies? Yes. Was it dumb killing Cyclops off-screen? Yes. Did it try to cram too many plotlines into a slim runtime, waste the character of Angel and is Vinnie Jones' Juggernaut just the worst?
Yes, yes and yes.
Is it the massive turkey most fans make it out to be? No. The Last Stand is no classic, but it has more merits than its given credit. The concept of mutants taking a “cure” for their condition so they can become normal has powerful subtext, and some of the performances – namely from McKellen, Stewart and Grammer – are fantastic. The death of Professor X was a heartbreaker, Mystique being cured and abandoned by Magneto was a shocker and the love triangle between Rogue, Iceman and Kitty Pryde was well handled.
Brett Ratner has a better grasp on action than Singer and manages to stage a few gripping set-pieces too - just look at that finale. The Last Stand is a letdown for sure, but the universal loathing it inspires feels a bit much.
X-Men Origins: Wolverine, on the other hand...
6. Elysium
Everybody fell in love with Neill Blomkamp after District 9, but it feels like he hasn’t been able to recapture the same lightning; the reception to Elysium was mixed, and the reviews for Chappie were downright vicious. Still, he managed to get a greenlight for Alien 5, his fanboy dream project, although time will tell if that actually happens.
This takes us back to Elysium, his second film and treated by many as the cracks in the exo-suit. While it got decent reviews the audience reaction was frosty, with many critiquing the sloppy story, the in your face subtext and a rare bad performance from Jodie Foster.
While those points were valid, the movie has more going for it than some give it credit. The cinematography and production design are top notch, giving the film a real lived in feel. The action scenes are well executed, and Blomkamp designed some nifty gadgets like the rifle that shoots through walls. Sharlto Copley is terrifying as Kruger, the agent hunting down Matt Damon’s thief and the movie comes alive whenever he appears.
Blomkamp admits he could have done a better job with Elysium, claiming the story should have been more developed. No argument here, but he should be happy he still made an inventive and refreshingly R-rated sci-fi thriller.
5. Ghost Rider: Spirit Of Vengence
Nic Cage’s movie star days seem to be over, with his hammy acting increasingly appearing in straight to DVD schlock even his fans are avoiding. It'd be easy to place some of the blame at Spirit Of Vengeance, his last swing at leading a big budget comic movie, but it already had an uphill battle overcoming the stink of the awful first movie.
While critics and fans slammed the sequel, they’re really missing out on the fun. The movie is utterly unhinged - helmed by the directors of Crank, they give it a crazed style of its own. The story is a lazy repeat of Terminator 2, but they just use it to frame crazy action like the mine scene or let Nic do his wildest overacting; not to mention the moment the Rider pees fire.
Spirit Of Vengeance is essentially a live action cartoon, intent on delivering the most demented comic book movie ever made. The biggest problem is the PG-13 rating holding it back, but if you go along for the ride you won't be bored.
4. Ghostbusters II
The conversation around the new Ghostbusters has gotten so toxic it’s near impossible to have a civilised discussion about it online. However that movie pans out, it seems a lot of people are trying to defend the reboot by claiming Ghostbusters II was terrible, and the new one looks way better. Hmmm - let’s examine that for a second.
Ghostbusters II is noticeably weaker than the original; it repeats the story with minor tweaks, the freshness is gone and there’s a lot of silly !*$%. That said the cast is still great together, with Bill Murray being a sardonic delight. Vigo The Carpathian makes for a creepy villain, it has some quality gags and the abandoned train tunnel sequence is pretty terrifying for a family comedy.
It may not live up to the standard set by the original, and a lot of critics like to dump on it (including Bill Murray) but it’s not nearly the car wreck people claim.
3. Prometheus
Expectations for Prometheus were sky high; how could they not be? It had Ridley Scott returning to the Alien franchise to direct a (sort of) prequel, with a cast that included Michael Fassbender, Idris Elba and Charlize Theron. How could that not be awesome?
Sadly the movie fell short of its own potential; the reviews were mixed, and fan reaction was mostly negetive. While Prometheus has its share of issues (massive plot holes, dumb character choices), it’s still an entertaining mix of lofty sci-fi drama and trashy b-movie. It’s a big budget epic that questions the origin of mankind, and what it means to be human. The first half is a genuinely absorbing mystery, and Michael Fassbender’s performance as David the android is perhaps one of his best.
It then mixes those classy elements with an alien abortion scene, Michael Fassbender’s head being used to beat Guy Pearce to death and annoying characters being killed by their own stupidity. So yeah, it’s messy movie for sure, but it’s an ambitious, beautiful and intriguing one.
2. Constantine
If you’re going to cast anybody to play a blond haired, Liverpudlian occult detective who was modelled after Sting, then Keanu Reeves isn't really the obvious pick. Nevertheless, chosen he was to play the character in the movie version, which still makes fans angry to this day despite the movie being pretty good. Yes, you read right.
Reeves has a lot of fun playing the chain-smoking cynic, and it’s one of his better performances. Constantine also has a lot of eerie, inventive monsters and imagery (Hell looks terrifying here), and it's a unique fusion of film noir and horror. Tilda Swinton and Peter Stormare steal their respective scenes, and while the movie is surprisingly dark for PG-13 it balances things out with jet black humour.
Shia LaBeouf is annoying as Constantine’s partner, but at least he gets throttled to death to make up for it. It’s not the most accurate adaptation of the comic, but it didn’t deserve the concentrated waves of hate it received either.
1. Predator 2
Predator 2 rocks; it’s a violent, fast paced action movie with creative setpieces and likeable heroes.
Yet for some reason, it often gets dismissed, with many claiming the only memorable thing about it is the Alien skull seen in the Predator spaceship.
While it suffers from a lack of Arnie – which is true of most movies – Predator 2 still stands on its own. Danny Glover makes for a great lead, Bill Paxton steals every scene as his sidekick and Gary Busey is a great slimy villain. The movie has quality action with the subway attack and the slaughterhouse ambush, and it even introduced iconic Predator gear like the wire net and the spear.
The movie probably could have used a trim, since the final showdown drags out far too long. Nitpicks aside though Predator 2 is an underrated gem, and it’s a mystery it has such a weak reputation. Go watch Alien Vs. Predator: Requiem, if you want to see what a really terrible Predator sequel looks like.
Can you think of any other big blockbusters that are unfairly maligned? Share them in the comments thread below.