10 Ways The Prequels Made Star Wars A Better Saga
The Star Wars Prequel Trilogy has its fair share of haters. Since bad critical reviews began instantly from its first press showings in 1999, George Lucass return to his Saga has been the go to whipping boy when it comes to movie disappointments, leading on to a whole stock of go to negativity when it comes to the prequel trilogy's place in the Star Wars legacy. Well I say pah to all that (I would say something stronger but I'm not allowed to). From 1999 to 2005 I loved watching the prequels. I loved what they added to the original trilogy and the extra layers they generated. It wasn't just Revenge of the Sith that bridged the gap between the trilogies it was the whole run of three films. Lucas loves mirroring events and changing the outcomes or outright playing out the same outcomes when it comes to the Skywalker journeys. I very much feel the saga works as a six episode saga as opposed to two three episode accounts where embittered fans can choose to ignore sections because they've convinced themselves Jar Jar Binks in his supporting role was enough to destroy everything they loved about Star Wars or that Jake Lloyds acting abilities really made a difference to how they felt about Darth Vader. Starting with Phantom Menace (the other prequels will come in later articles), I want to have a look at the knock on effects the prequel had; how it helped strengthen a whole lot of elements in the Original Trilogy and how some of these themes might carry forward into the new Star Wars trilogy as we head towards Episode VII.
10. Established a Galaxy In Its Final Days Of Peace
We all love the visuals of the Star Wars galaxy but when we were first invited to join in the fun, the galaxy was at war and vehicles were built accordingly. There was no time for beauty or style. Original trilogy era Star Wars is mass production, guns attached, get em built and get em out there looks. Episode I was before all that. Before the dark times. Before the Empire. What Lucas gave us on Naboo was a depiction of a galaxy at peace. Art Deco designs for vehicles with classic styling, beautifully constructed castles and cities and costumes that felt of a simpler time, of monarchies and idealistic people. Naboo, in part gives us a vision of what the rebels are fighting to protect in the original trilogy. A group of good people in a world full of beauty and style. This, in some ways transfers over to Coruscant as well. Though of course, the fact that this is a world entirely covered in development and technology doesn't exactly lend itself to an ideal planet and of course the political state of affairs is about to take a turn of the worse. Coruscant may be the centre of a galaxy but its over development and corruption is a theme that carries through the prequels and bleeds into the original trilogy, even though the planet is only seen in a sliver of a scene at the end of Return of the Jedi.
9. A View Of How The Master And Padawan Relationship Should Work
In the original trilogy, the remaining Jedi were on catch up. Their numbers depleted, any hopes of turning the galaxy around on the shoulders of two kids whose father brought about most of the galaxys problems in the first place. Through Qui-Gon and Obi-Wan in The Phantom Menace we are shown what Obi-Wan and Yoda were trying to bring out of Luke in the Original Trilogy. We are shown what a master and apprentice duo could achieve. Obviously this theme continues throughout the Prequel Trilogy but in The Phantom Menace we get to see the blueprint of how the Jedi work and of course rather than a half old man, half machine vs an old man and a young boy with barely any training we see what Jedi and Sith can really do with a lightsaber or two when their training is complete. Make no mistake Luke Skywalker is Obi-Wan's new Padawan and old Obi-Wan's similarities to Qui-Gon are no accident. Don't forget Phantom Menace era Obi-Wan describes creatures of a certain background as 'pathetic lifeforms' and seeing what course three prequels and a whole lot of years between trilogies does to change all that is an interesting, if not largely ignored arc for Kenobi. Additionally, note the difference in lightsaber battles between Episode I and the original trilogy. Beyond the better skills, the Jedi and Sith have absolutely nothing to talk about. They are focused and clear with their actions. The Sith want the Jedi dead and the Jedi need to stop that from happening. Jump forward to the original trilogy and the battles are more about people and the connections between them. They have things to discuss and the dramas between father and son or master and apprentice are strengthened even more. Lastly on this section, Obi-Wan is very much aware how the death of his master affected him as a Padawan. Seeing Qui-Gon die in Phantom Menace and how that relates to Obi-Wan's disappearing act in front of Luke in New Hope speaks volumes. Obi-Wan knows what this will ignite in Luke Skywalker and his 'sacrifice' begins Luke's real path to bring down the Empire. Additionally Anakin Skywalker / Darth Vader thinks he knows every secret there is to know about The Force and its reasonably downsized use in the original trilogy era but his old master's disappearing act delivers a surprise to Vader and maybe his certainty of how things are isn't as solid as he once thought. Also there is an argument that upon seeing Luke across the Death Star hanger, the repetition of events may very well have sparked Vader's memories of his own past and given that this situation had happened before, has reminded Anakin he was once the one who had his Jedi master die early in his training.
8. Why An Army Of Droids Was Not The Way Forward
Again, this theme is one that continues through the entire Prequel Trilogy but what Lucas did with the battle droid armies in Phantom Menace was set up the limitations of machines and why a much better option was people or indeed Clones. Arguably Lucas went for droids because its a kid friendly option when it comes to laser swords cutting off limbs left right and centre but really the core to this choice was setting up a bad guy the galaxy could come together to side against when Palpatine so required (arguably its also why some regions of space are a little anti-droid like in the cantina in New Hope). Additionally, droids are mass produced and even the best Jedi can be overwhelmed with sheer numbers. Lucas gets a lot of criticism for his roger roger simpleton battle droids but I feel that this plays into what hes trying to say with their inclusion in the world of Star Wars. Droids are not good enough to win battles but they are good enough to cause conflict and distract the enemy as Palpatines master plan plays out. Plus they are easily controlled and can be turned off at the flick of a switch (or at least the blowing up of one) and a battle is won. Incidentally, Joss Whedon did exactly the same thing with the alien baddies in The Avengers but because they dont drop any roger rogers, movie goers didn't seem to have a problem with the simpleton approach to on mass bad guys. Of course they should have had more of a beef considering the alien swarms had no reason to all stop working really.
7. Jedi In Their Prime Wasn't As Great As We Once Thought
The Prequel Trilogy starts off slow when it comes to sheer numbers of Jedi doing the Jedi thing (that would come later in Attack of the Clones) but The Phantom Menace gives us an insight into the Jedi way. Of course this was not exactly the depiction of Jedi heroics we all expected and instead we get a lot of talking and Jedi really only sent into situations to negotiate. Ill openly admit, despite loving Phantom Menace, the first time we saw Yoda and his crew I was a little underwhelmed. I'm not entirely sure what my four year old mind dreamed the Jedi did before the dark times but it seemed like it should be more than sit around mulling over situations and turning away kids who are obviously Force gifted. Of course, this is entirely the point. The Jedi had no real enemies any more They had become a tool for the Republic to use, rather than a group with their own agenda. They are in fact largely redundant at the start of Episode 1 and this in many ways this highlights the line Tarkin drops in New Hope about the Jedi being an old religion. The Jedi are extinct, their fire has gone out of the universe. You, my friend, are all that's left of their religion. More than ever the Jedi, in a time of largely peace in the Galaxy were an organisation that had become disconnected from their previous historical significance and the people they fought to protect do not seem to have enough of a connection to them to fully understand their usefulness. This once again gave Palpatine an angle he could manipulate. Of course there's also the sore point that is midi-chlorians. Nobody likes their inclusion in the Star Wars Saga as they reduce the magic of The Force down to a quantifiable thing about micro-organisms that create life and connect us with The Force. Looking at where were at in Episode 1, the Jedi feel like they know it all. They decide the next moves of everything in their order. Much like the Sith in Episode IV. They have time to dissect, study and think about every little thing and they've obviously generated a system for detecting an individuals power level. There numbers are strong and obviously this midi-chlorian thing has enabled them to speed up their training numbers. Looking at the Original Trilogy, the Jedi are all about The Force and theres no mention of these midi-chlorians. Could it be that they've realised that its more than just that? It was more than a science. It wasn't about the Jedi controlling The Force, it was more about The Force leading the way and following the path. I dont think therell ever be a time when midi-chlorians are accepted in the Star Wars fan community but there is an argument that their inclusion in Episode 1 is to highlight the fact that there was no magic in the Jedi order in that era. The wonder of The Force was lost on the Jedi and that is why they could lose when it came to the Sith using the chaos of the dark side in a time of science and order. Yes, the midi-chlorians dont sit right but the fact they are not part of the Jedi way when we get to the New Hope and beyond shows the Jedi have changed their approach somewhat. Blue ghosts and life after death has added a whole new angle to the Jedi belief system and the science side of things has all but disappeared it seems.
6. 'Little' Annie
Talk to most prequel haters and it wont be long before the topic of Anakins age being all wrong will come up. I couldn't disagree more. Lucas opted for as young as possible so that we see Anakin at the earliest point that would make it interesting. This prevents conjecture over his upbringing and past. We meet this kid at the right age to prevent further mystery (beyond his immaculate birth but of course that comes up in Revenge of the Sith anyway) and despite some iffy acting from young Jake Lloyd we see that Anakins journey was reflected in Lukes journey. Because of that, we begin to see why Obi-Wan and Yoda probably had a whole lot of fears when it came to the son of Skywalker, given his similarities to his father. Skipping back to young Anakin, I dont get the angle that fans wanted some teenager hot head bad ass on their screens, showing a young Vader as a tyrant ready to turn to the dark side. Why the hell would the Jedi even take a kid like this on and if they did why wouldn't they have taken him out long before he had the chance to turn to the dark side, right? The angle Lucas took is far more heart breaking and a whole lot more in tune with what was going on in the Original Trilogy. Anakins fall is as much to do with the Jedi as it is his own terrible choices. In Episode I, the Jedi are already keeping this boy at arms length. Theyre not welcoming or understanding or even willing to find a home for him. Its really only Qui-Gon who is giving us a view of what the Jedi should be like towards a child of considerable power and Qui-Gons death is very much a catalyst towards the fall of Anakin Skywalker and in many ways gives Anakin a father figure he can never bring back.
5. The Initial Mistakes With Anakin Skywalker
For now, with Phantom Menace as a template, we know why Luke was way too old to begin the Jedi training in the Original Trilogy. As per the Jedi rules, even eight year olds were pushing it age wise. We know that Obi-Wan wasn't a natural when it came to being a master to a young apprentice and wasn't 100% committed to the idea of this chosen one. We also get a sense of why taking on Luke had to be something that happened naturally, rather than being a journey thrust upon him like Anakins early Padawan days turned out to be. Over the next few articles, the mirroring steps of Anakin and Luke will be covered more in depth but after Episode I, we know that Anakin has stepped into an order that didn't really want him in their ranks, with a master who only took him on through a commitment to his own fallen teacher. Basically, we know Anakin isn't getting the best education and lining this up alongside the Original Trilogy, Luke had an even worse start. But maybe this was the key to how events turned out
4. Thats Where Leia got Her Feistiness From
Star Wars girls are the best, right? In The Phantom Menace we already get to see where Leia gets her attitude from. Padme (or indeed Queen Amidala) shows us the two sides to Lucas girls. Both mother and daughter carry off the posh voice front of their role in the galaxy and both aren't afraid to get their hands dirty. They also have a knack for falling for the rogue but that's something for a later article. In addition, were shown where Leias perseverance to do the right thing comes from, especially when Padme makes the shock move to go back to Naboo to save her people. Luke and Leia may very well get their Force sensibilities from their dad but they certainly seem to have got their sense of right and wrong from their mother. Of course we also know where they got their R2 unit from too!
3. What Darth Sidious Was Looking For In The Ultimate Apprentice
Forgetting what we know about Star Wars for a few minutes, lets look at where we are at the start of Phantom Menace. A hidden enemy (Darth Sidious) has been making plans to take over the galaxy. Hes a Sith and the Sith can only work in twos, because theyll kill each other if there are more. As we enter the events of Episode 1, we are presented with Darth Maul. The ultimate apprentice. Loyal, powerful. highly skilled and in on the plan for Sith dominance. At last we will have revenge. Maul is the ultimate Sith. He's very much a blueprint for what Papaltine needs in a follower but of course Obi-Wan puts a stopper on that one. In Maul we can see what Sidious would want out of Anakin. He's Maul with power. The training is there already and all he needs is to turn him. Because of this, as the Saga advances we can see just how much of a disappointment it must have been when Anakin was reduced to the suit and of course why Palpatine's eye turns towards Luke Skywalker. As we move through the prequels, well look at how Sith politics inform us of what Vaders and Palpatine's larger intentions were in the Original Trilogy but as at Episode I, were given a blueprint for how the Sith operate and how theres one pulling the strings while the other one mingles with the puppets, very much the continued case in the original trilogy.
2. Strengthening The Drama Between Luke And Vader
Episode 1 is what I like to call a meet and greet movie. We meet the players, see the situation and we build from there in the sequels. New Hope was largely that too and because of that we can begin to compare the two journeys that the two young Skywalkers took. From the get go, these are boys without fathers in their lives. They are both in relatively stable but under privileged situations and both on Tatooine. Both dream of bigger things as they go about their day to day lives. Anakin is extremely gifted but cannot get out of his slavery binds (something that continues throughout his life even when hes free), Luke is held back from the big wide world as his Uncle and Aunt know what waits for him out there and are trying to protect him from it ('it' being his father). Both boys have their world widened by the Jedi and both boys are offered a way off of their home planet but here is where the differences begin to sneak in. Luke is welcomed into the world of The Force with open arms. Hes told he has power, potential and trainable skills from day one. Luke is told that his father was a great Jedi and is very much encouraged to follow that path. Anakin on the other hand is protected from danger due to his young age and told by the Jedi that hes good but too much of a risk to support. They also stick a further boot in when Yoda explains that Anakin is full of fear and that will probably lead to the dark side (but of course the Jedi have grown lazy with no real enemies to worry about, so letting him simply go, without training seems like a good idea to them for now). Bringing the Skylwalker boys together again, both have a teacher that rebels against what they are ordered to do in order to train them. Luke was unaware that Obi-Wan was setting a much larger ball rolling when he met up with the young Skywalker but Anakin was very much aware that Qui-Gon was willing to work outside of the Jedi order to train him, giving Anakin a role model when it came to doing what you believed in, even when youre told not to. Both Skywalkers have a teacher that they look up to and want to learn from and of course they both lose that teacher to a Sith. Im not sure how a much of a difference there is between Luke witnessing his master dying and Anakin hearing about it via Obi-Wan but in both cases both Skywalker boys are supported by Obi-Wan Kenobi in their continued training. However, the differences are, young Obi-Wan is still very much trying to stick to the Jedis rigid rules whereas older, wiser Obi-Wan has had time to mull over the Jedi orders failure with Anakin and knowing that, he probably takes on a lot of that guilt himself and is determined to get it right this time and be more in tune with Qui-Gons original intentions.
1. The Jedi Need Some Love In Their Lives
Anakin is set to bring balance to The Force but what is that exactly? Two Sith = Two Jedi? Maybe but probably not. For me its more than that. Lucas goes deeper into this in Revenge of the Sith but as at Episode I its already clear that the Jedi need some love in their lives. My take on the Jedi in Episode 1 is that they are so distanced from nature and the living force that they are lost, at least in a spiritual sense. Qui-Gon knows it and its hinted that he picked that up from his Master Count Dooku, who became so disillusioned with the Jedi way that he left the order because of it (but of course that comes later). Jumping forward to how this relates to the original trilogy, Lukes defiance of Obi-Wan and Yodas warning about saving his friends in Empire highlights just how the Skywalker clan are here to change things. Luke and indeed Anakin are willing to put responsibility aside for love and of course knowing what we know about Anakin Skywalker now, we can see why Yoda and Obi-Wan were so worried (more on that when we hit Episode III) There will be more examples as we head into Episode II and III but for now we know Luke, like Anakin, isnt like those around them. They see a greater importance in friendship than they do logic and the both of them will do anything for their loved ones. They also see droids as more than just machines and even bond with them (a trait we all loved Luke and Anakin for, right?), unlike those around them who see droids as things to help with their lives This theme of love being the tipping element to either bring down a Jedi or bring back a Jedi is very much the core to Star Wars for me and going forward with these articles, I will explore this a lot more. Sadly as at Episode I, we see a loveless set of Jedi and Sith with only Qui-Gons legacy pushing Obi-Wan to make the choice to take on Anakin. This in itself is an act of love in honour of Obi-Wans fallen master and its this act of love that springboards us into the real story. Of course, as a side note, Anakin and Padme also make a love connection in Episode I (however odd that may seem given their ages) but make no mistake, it's love and the love of those around him that took Anakin down his path and it will play a key part in all of his major events through both trilogies. I'll see you again with more prequel articles , where I'll cover the all knowing R2-D2, the C3-PO / Vader connection and of course the continued strengthening of the original trilogy as the prequels rolled in from 1999-2005. See you soon and may the force be with you.