10 Worst PG-13 Horror Films Since 2020

Stay away from these tepid horrors if you have any sense about you.

Fantasy Island Movie
Sony Pictures Releasing

The PG-13 rating for movies was introduced in 1984, thanks in part to a suggestion by Steven Spielberg, who didn't want films like the Indiana Jones series to be slapped with an R rating just because some bloke got his heart pulled out.

To be fair, that was a bit much for a PG.

Since then, PG-13 has become a safe haven for films that lie somewhere in between kid-friendly and full-on gorefest. A number of famous horror pictures have adhered to these rules and gone on to be massive successes, whilst others, well, they end up on lists like these.

In theory, a PG-13 rating should mean that more people are able to see a movie, leading to more profits for those involved. Unfortunately, this only works if the films are actually good, and these recent outings were absolute disasters.

To be clear, not all of these movies were bad because of their certificate, as they would have stunk no matter what the MPA said about them. Others, though, were severely hampered by trying to play it safe and, in an effort to appeal to everybody, ended up pushing everyone away.

10. Tarot

Tarot Movie
Sony Pictures

As the makers of Ouija found out, sometimes it's not enough to base a movie around a vaguely scary children’s toy. In 2024, the team behind Tarot discovered the same truth.

A group of students come across a tarot deck and begin to play, despite the old adage that you should never use someone else’s cards. Lo and behold, the kids begin to die in seemingly-unexplainable circumstances, until the survivors realise that the deck must be destroyed.

Tarot follows the same basic structure as most “haunted item” movies; the characters discover the item, they start dying, they try a bunch of stuff to fight it that all leads to one final showdown. 

It might have been saved if the characters were in any way likeable or even properly fleshed out. They die, and within five seconds, you’ve forgotten about them, which is never a good sign. Whilst some of the kills were pretty exciting, none of them left enough of a mark to justify having money spent on them.

Sadly, an actual tarot reader wasn’t on hand to warn of how badly this movie would turn out.


9. Umma

Umma movie
Sony Pictures Releasing

Sandra Oh seems like an absolutely top tier human and, for the most part, her body of work is very impressive. However, nobody bats a thousand, and one of Oh’s worst ever stinkers came out in 2022.

Umma - a Korean word meaning “mother” - is about Oh’s character Amanda and two key relationships in her life; one with her daughter and one with her recently deceased mum. Thinking she is finally free of her controlling hand, Amanda is in for the shock of her life when Umma’s spirit returns to haunt her family farm. 

There’s some really nice ideas about generational trauma and the role of women in the family that this film tries to get across, but, sadly, they never materialise properly. The premise is certainly interesting, but nothing else about Umma is, as it follows the formula of so many haunted house stories that have come before. 

Critics and viewers alike were let down by the final project, so maybe this is a case of something being disappointing rather than bad, but there’s no way to watch Umma without feeling shortchanged.


8. Abandoned

Abandoned Movie
Vertical Entertainment

With Emma Roberts, Michael Shannon, and John Gallagher Jr. on board, 2022’s Abandoned was set up to be a great big hit. However, as you can probably tell from it being on this list, it wasn’t. 

A couple (Roberts and Gallagher) and their newborn son move into a new house in the country, even though they know that a horrible murder took place there many years ago. Like all oblivious people in horror films, they don’t think anything will come of is, but oh boy, were they wrong about that. 

If you’re wondering where you’ve heard that set-up before, it’s because countless horrors have begun in exactly the same way. Not a great start for Abandoned, and it doesn’t get much better. 

Not a great deal of anything happens during the film and the stuff that does happen isn't new. There’s themes of post-natal depression and motherhood, but they’re never explored in any meaningful way. Also, because of the tame age rating, it never gets gory enough to justify its non-story. 

There is no reason at all to watch this movie, so take its own advice and abandon it.


7. Brahms: The Boy II

Brahms The Boy 2
STX Entertainment

2016’s The Boy had one of the most shocking and maligned plot twists of the entire decade, when it was revealed that the porcelain doll at the heart of the story wasn’t possessed by a dead child, but that the child was now an adult who was living in the walls instead.

Despite the response to this moment, The Boy got a sequel in 2020, this time taking its name from the dead-not-so-dead kid. In this sequel, a mute boy discovers the Brahms doll buried near his new home and forms a bond with it. If you need more context, you’re going to need to watch the first film, because it’s way too confusing to write down.

Brahms: The Boy II has no idea what it wants to be, as it simultaneously tries to incorporate elements of home invasion, possession, family abuse, and psychological horror, all to no effect. It also makes zero effort to connect to the previous film, besides the doll, of course. 

It looks boring, it sounds boring, and, for the most part, it is boring. At least with the original film, there’s the suspense before the crazy ending - where was that here?


6. Five Nights At Freddy’s

Five Nights At Freddys
Universal

Settle in and prepare to hear the tragic tale of the Five Nights at Freddy’s movie, a story that, ironically, ended up being more terrifying than the actual film.

The idea to adapt the incredibly popular video game series - which puts players into the shoes of a night watchman at a restaurant full of haunted animatronics - was around for eight years before it finally happened. In that time, two other films with a similar premise - The Banana Splits Movie and Willy’s Wonderland - got released, and both turned out to be better than 5NAF’s final effort.

Starring Josh Hutcherson as the unfortunate employee, the movie featured a threadbare plot, unfunny jokes, and monsters that wouldn’t have felt out of place in a regular Chuck E. Cheese. Some fans of the games enjoyed it because it was stuffed full of inside jokes, but those were of no comfort to anyone who’d never played them. 

After almost a decade of waiting, Five Nights at Freddy’s underdelivered in almost every single way. However, it did make an absolute killing at the box office, so expect a sequel in the next few years.


5. Imaginary

Imaginary 2024
Blumhouse

In the same year (2024) that John Krasinski released a family comedy about imaginary friends, Jeff Wadlow directed a similar story but through a horror lens instead.

In Imaginary, children’s author Jessica, her new husband, and his two daughters all move into her family home. Jessica feels bad that one of the kids, Alice, has nightmares about one of her characters, so is delighted when Alice falls in love with one of her old teddy bears.

It’s not just a bear, though - it’s an evil bear!

Alice quickly falls under the bear’s spell, as it tries to lure her into a magical demon world called the Never Ever. Themes of imagination and childhood fears are rife throughout this picture, and whilst those are usually fertile ground for storytelling, this crop failed to yield. 

Many viewers felt that Imaginary spent way too much time establishing its setting and characters and not enough time driving the story forwards and delivering on the scares. There was also a limit imposed on how freaky the Never Ever could get, thanks to the age rating, which rendered that part of the movie not worth waiting for.


4. The Turning

the turning
Universal Pictures

Fans of the 2020 Netflix series The Haunting of Bly Manor have author Henry James to thank in part, as his 1898 work The Turning of the Screw served as the basis for the story. The novella was also adapted into a feature film that same year, but that got far less positive attention.

The Turning centres on a nanny at a stately home who is put in charge of a young girl traumatised by the death of her parents. That harrowing experience begins to manifest in real life, causing all sorts of issues. 

Originally, this movie had the best pedigree possible, as Steven Spielberg was the one who initially commissioned it. This didn’t last though, and the project got bounced around from director to director until it finally saw the light of day.

As well as being as scary as a Polly Pocket, The Turning also didn’t seem to make much sense, as many character motivations and plot points remain woefully in the dark. Stories begin and end with no real impact and viewers were left scratching their heads instead of hiding behind a blanket.

It does have nice sets though, which is… something. 


3. Night Swim

Night Swim
Universal

Horror has a proud history of taking things that aren’t normally considered scary and turning them into nightmare fuel. Sometimes though, even the best minds in the business can’t make something scary, as was discovered with the release of 2024’s Night Swim. 

After Ray Waller comes down with a mystery illness, he and his family move to a new home with a swimming pool which should help with his rehabilitation. As Ray spends more and more time in the pool, he starts to exhibit stranger and stranger behaviour, as he has been possessed by the evil spirit that lives in the water. 

Drowning is a nasty way to go and there have been plenty of great horrors set at sea, but a domestic swimming pool? You’re going to need to put some serious work in to make people afraid of that. 

Sadly, Night Swim did not do the work and, as a result, the characters never feel like they’re in any real danger, rendering the whole thing completely pointless. 


2. The Unholy

The Unholy Jeffrey Dean Morgan
Sony Pictures Releasing

Based on the 1983 James Herbert novel Shrine, The Unholy went through a whole heap of trouble just to get made. It was announced in 2018, dragged on for two years, and then finally got going only to have production halted by the pandemic.

Was this a sign that the universe didn’t want this film to come out? Perhaps… 

A series of so-called “miracles” attached to a small town attracts the interest of a journalist (Jeffrey Dean Morgan) who is looking to re-energise his career after a scandal. His investigation turns up more than he bargained for, as these supposed acts of kindness are actually linked to a malevolent spirit. 

Alongside the Walking Dead actor, Katie Aselton, William Sadler, and Cary Elwes also appear in the film. This wasn’t enough to save it, though, as The Unholy lived up to its name in the worst possible way. 

Its drab and dreary approach to the source material is why some people think a PG-13 horror can’t work, but all this proved was that they need creativity to be frightening. The Unholy had no such spark and was more likely to bore an audience to death than to scare them.


1. Fantasy Island

Fantasy Island Michael Pena Lucy Hale
Sony Pictures Releasing

In 1977, a TV show launched that depicted a remote location where guests would be granted their wildest dreams for a hefty price. 43 years later, somebody thought it would be a good idea to re-imagine this show as a horror. 

The idea was good, but the execution was highly flawed.

This is 2020's Fantasy Island (another Jeff Wadlow joint), which shared a similar premise but with a dark twist. It featured a pretty stacked cast including Michael Peña as the island’s mysterious overseer and Lucy Hale, Maggie Q, and Michael Rooker as some of the guests.

Unfortunately, this movie was less of a fantasy and more of a living nightmare. The dialogue was painfully wooden, not helped by a bafflingly bad script, and considering how rich the subject of wishes gone wrong is, even within the confines of a PG-13, the film made no attempt to reach beyond its basic premise.

Bad acting, bad writing, and, above everything else, a chronic lack of scares, Fantasy Island successfully killed any interest in the IP and will go down as one of the worst films of the decade in any genre. 


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Jacob Simmons has a great many passions, including rock music, giving acclaimed films three-and-a-half stars, watching random clips from The Simpsons on YouTube at 3am, and writing about himself in the third person.