10 Worst Plot Twists In Recent Movies
Spiral delivered the Saw series' most predictable twist ever.
A plot twist truly can make or break a movie - get it right and it can make repeat viewings extraordinarily rewarding, but get it wrong and it can derail the entire thing.
Generally speaking it's better if a plot twist is in service of the story or characters, rather than the script basically being reverse-engineered around an oh-so-smart reveal the writer came up with first.
And so it's not remotely surprising that so many movie twists end up being either embarrassingly predictable - media-savvy as we all are these days - or just poorly executed.
But before you ask about it - no, Malignant's mind-melting plot twist won't be on here, because it's by far the best and most interesting part of an otherwise bad movie.
These 10 plot twists, however, all drag their respective films down through their laziness, their lack of imagination, and their limp, unconvincing execution.
With stronger writing and direction perhaps they could've worked, but as it stands these rug-pulls don't hit with nearly as much impact as the filmmakers clearly intended.
If you were paying much attention, you probably saw a good number of these twists coming from a mile away...
10. Morgan Freeman Is A Secret Villain - The Hitman's Wife's Bodyguard
In fairness, The Hitman's Wife's Bodyguard's initial revelation that Michael Bryce's (Ryan Reynolds) stepfather is played by none other than Morgan Freeman is pretty hilarious, after which the film proceeds to take this gag and stretch it past snapping point.
Bryce Sr. (Freeman), a legendary bodyguard in his own right, reappears later on to reveal to his stepson that he's actually working with the villainous Greek shipping magnate Aristotle Papadopoulos (Antonio Banderas).
At the end of the film when Bryce confronts Aristotle, he has to also face off against Senior, who continues to do his job and protect Aristotle, leading to a fight between father and son.
Though Senior easily bests Bryce, in the end Bryce is able to overpower his dad by stabbing him in the neck with a pocket knife.
Having Morgan Freeman turn out to be Ryan Reynolds' (non-biological) dad made for a fun cameo, but distending the joke to make him a secondary villain was one step too far. This was the definition of a sidekick character outstaying their welcome in the service of a lousy plot twist.
9. Ikaris Betrays The Eternals (And Flies Into The Sun) - Eternals
It was admittedly genuinely surprising that the Eternals' leader Ajak (Salma Hayek) was killed off in the movie's first act, having been ambushed by the Deviant leader Kro (Bill SkarsgÄrd).
But later in the film, it's revealed that Ajak was actually set up by her fellow Eternal Ikaris (Richard Madden), who pushed her into the Deviant trap after she attempted to speak up to the other Eternals about Arishem's plot to destroy Earth.
It wasn't that difficult to guess that one of the Eternals might be a turncoat, and honestly, there was no more obvious choice than Ikaris, but what really cemented this twist as clunky and underwhelming was the outcome.
At the end of the movie, a guilt-riddled Ikaris flies into the Sun, committing suicide.
Given that it's made abundantly clear earlier in the film that the myth of Iracus, who flew too close to the sun, was actually styled on Ikaris, his demise is a rather cringe-inducing attempt at cleverness that ultimately feels like it was written by a grade-schooler.
8. Ruth Took The Blame For Her Sister Killing The Cop - The Unforgivable
Netflix's new drama The Unforgivable revolves around Ruth Slater (Sandra Bullock), a woman released from prison after spending 20 years inside for murdering a sheriff who attempted to evict her and her 5-year-old sister, Katie, who Ruth was raising.
The film spends most of its time exploring Ruth's attempts to reintegrate into society and make contact with her now-adult sister (Aisling Franciosi), all while the sons of the slain sheriff seek revenge against her.
But late in the film a surprising truth is revealed, that Ruth didn't actually shoot and kill the sheriff - young Katie did, but in order to protect her Ruth decided to take the rap for it.
There are worse ideas for plot twists in movies, but ultimately in this case the execution is so lazily manipulative, designed to surprise and push your emotional buttons by any means necessary, that it actually ends up feeling incredibly icky and offputting.
Beyond that, it undermines the film's initially intriguing examination of a person attempting to return to society after committing a seemingly heinous crime, in turn re-framing Ruth in a less-interesting and totally unchallenging way.
7. The Baroness Is Estella's Biological Mother - Cruella
There's surely no plot twist in media, and certainly not in properties owned by Disney, more exhaustingly overused than "the villain is secretly your parent."
Star Wars executed this twist so well that basically every single movie since that's deployed a similar reveal has felt like a pallid rip-off.
And so we have the not-bad, not-good Cruella, which overdoes it with one parent-related plot twist too many.
Mid-way through the film it's revealed that Estella/Cruella's (Emma Stone) apparently biological mother Catherine (Emily Beecham) was killed by the evil Baroness (Emma Thompson), who sicced her Dalmatians on her at a party, knocking her off a cliff.
Given that Estella had spent years assuming she caused her mother's death by attracting the attention of the Dalmatians, it's an effective twist that only heightens the Baroness' villainy.
But an additional reveal is piled on thereafter, where we find out that the Baroness was actually Estella's biological mother, who wanted to have Estella killed as a baby so she could focus on her career.
But instead, her confidante John (Mark Strong) gave young Estella to one of the Baroness' maids, Catherine, to raise as her own.
It just feels excessive and unnecessary, to create a contrived familial link between the hero and villain for the sake of lazy added melodrama. Was the Baroness really not enough of a villain already?
6. Schenk Is The New Jigsaw - Spiral: From The Book Of Saw
The Saw franchise is known for one thing above all others: insane, over-the-top, generally unpredictable plot twists.
Even the lesser Saw films have (mostly) managed to deliver amusingly silly twists, though the most recent entry, Spiral: From the Book of Saw, fell massively short of the mark.
Spiral's big reveal is that the new copycat Jigsaw Killer is none other than Detective William Schenk (Max Minghella), the partner of protagonist Detective Zeke Banks (Chris Rock), with Schenk believed to have been killed by Jigsaw earlier in the film.
The rationale for Schenk's decision to take up the Jigsaw mantle and target corrupt cops isn't bad - his own father was murdered by a crooked police officer - but the execution is totally predictable and lazy.
The film tries to get one over on audiences by having Schenk be "killed" by Jigsaw half-way through, but because he dies off-screen and his corpse is suspiciously skinned, it's incredibly obvious to basically any long-time fan of the series that he wasn't really dead, and therefore the likely killer.
As much as Spiral tried to position itself as a gritty soft reboot for the series, it actually delivered the weakest and most easily guessable twist of the entire franchise, which was massively disappointing given the film's huge potential to be a fresh start for Saw.
5. Ethan Is The Killer - The Woman In The Window
The Woman in the Window is a grand old mess of a thriller, albeit one that's at least good for a few laughs at its expense, while marvelling at Amy Adams' needlessly committed performance.
The story revolves around Dr. Anna Fox (Adams), an agoraphobic woman who spends most of her time watching her neighbours from her second-story window, while also imbibing alcohol and chugging medications on the regular.
As Anna begins to become suspicious that one of her neighbours has been murdered, the audience is also led to consider the possibility that Anna is simply deluded and her perception of events is possibly tainted by her substance issues.
There are admittedly a few different twists for audiences to chew on, such as Anna's "estranged" family having actually died in a car crash she accidentally caused, but the kicker is that the killer of Katie Melli (Julianne Moore) isn't the neon-signposted Alistair Russell (Gary Oldman) as suspected.
Instead, the murderer is Katie and Alistair's 15-year-old son Ethan (Fred Hechinger), who also happens to be a deranged serial killer and has effectively been gaslighting Anna during the film. He then attempts to make Anna his next victim, but she manages to fight him off and eventually kill him instead.
On one hand some might enjoy this loony twist as dumb schlock, but on the other it's an embarrassing, unintentionally hilarious misfire for a movie that was courting considerable Oscar buzz while it was in production. Oof.
4. Justin Isn't Really Dead (And Is The Real Villain) - Jolt
Audiences really should know by now that if you don't see a character die on-screen, then they're almost certainly not dead. And that's why Jolt's spectacularly stupid, predictable twist falls totally flat.
The promising action-thriller opens with the high-strung Lindy Lewis (Kate Beckinsale) hooking up with a charming guy named Justin (Jai Courtney), but the next day, she's informed by Detective Vicars (Bobby Cannavale) that he's been murdered.
To anyone paying the least bit attention, it's hilariously obvious that Justin isn't dead, and that he's almost certainly going to return later on as the real villain.
More than anything else, why would Jai Courtney show up for a mere glorified cameo with nothing close to a payoff?
And so, in the final 10 minutes of the movie Justin emerges out of the shadows, revealing that he faked his own death and has basically been behind the entirety of the movie's events. Unsurprisingly, he doesn't stay alive for long after making his presence known to Lindy.
Given the obvious potential of a Crank-style action vehicle for Kate Beckinsale, what a crushing disappointment this was, topped by a staggeringly braindead, low-effort twist.
3. Death Is The Cure - Awake
The recent Netflix sci-fi thriller Awake is a monument to failed promise, totally fumbling its intriguing concept, whereby a global catastrophe wipes out all electronics as well as people's ability to sleep.
It isn't long before human civilisation begins to break down, with the very real possibility of humankind being rendered extinct through sleep deprivation.
However, there's hope that protagonist Jill's (Gina Rodriguez) daughter Matilda (Ariana Greenblatt) - who is for some reason able to sleep just fine - might represent the key to saving everyone.
At the end of the film, Jill's son Noah (Lucius Hoyos) also finds himself able to sleep after being fatally electrocuted and resuscitated, and because Matilda drowned and was revived at the very start of the film, the curing method becomes clear: dying (temporarily) and being brought back.
And so, Awake concludes with Matilda and Noah drowning their mother and then resuscitating her, seemingly curing her and providing a solution for all of humanity to save themselves.
Again the idea isn't inherently awful, but the execution is so clunky and reliant on contrivances - namely both of Jill's children implausibly dying and coming back - that you're more likely to be left groaning at the "cleverness" of it.
2. Anthony Hopkins Was Behind It All - The Virtuoso
In total honesty, there's very little worth remembering about the painfully generic hitman thriller The Virtuoso, where the titular assassin (Anson Mount) is tasked with taking down a rogue hitman by his mentor, who just so happens to be called The Mentor (a slumming but entertaining Anthony Hopkins).
Though Hopkins spends almost his entire role either sat in a chair talking over the phone or standing still and expositing, you'll be awarded no points at all for guessing that he's actually the primary antagonist.
Indeed, the Virtuoso's last job has actually been part of a convoluted ploy by the Mentor to have his protege wiped out, feeling that he's lost his touch as a hitman following a prior botched hit.
In a slightly unexpected move, though, the film doesn't end with the Virtuoso figuring this out and killing the Mentor. Rather, the Virtuoso is killed by another assassin working for the Mentor, the Waitress (Abbie Cornish), who has gotten close to him in order to carry out the hit.
Hiring Anthony Hopkins to play your scenery-munching baddie isn't the worst idea in the world, but with such a limp, generic, cliched execution, it just feels like a massive waste.
1. Ray Actually Dies In The First Act - Sweet Girl
Netflix's recent action-thriller Sweet Girl boasted a twist so utterly bonkers and ridiculous that it basically caused the movie to go viral.
On the surface, this is a straight-up revenge thriller as Ray Cooper (Jason Momoa) and his daughter Rachel (Isabela Merced) hunt down those responsible for the death of their wife and mother, who passed from cancer after life-saving drugs were suddenly pulled from the market.
Ray and Rachel get into their fair share of scrapes throughout the film, including a standoff at a subway in the first act which ends with Ray being stabbed.
We then skip forward two years in time where father and daughter are still plotting to take down the Big Pharma CEO responsible for their wife/mother's death, though in the third act the film drops a mind-melting clunker of a twist ending.
It actually turns out that Ray died from his subway stabbing, and everything we've seen him doing over the last hour-plus has actually been carried out by a dissociative Rachel. Right.
Given that we've seen Ray kicking some major ass against some very large adversaries throughout the movie, it's simply laughable to consider that his pint-sized daughter has in fact been doing these feats.
This is a classic case of a movie trying so hard to be shocking and unpredictable but ultimately just disregarding the basic internal logic of its story and characters. Fight Club did it so much better.