12 Insane Documentaries Way Stranger Than Fiction

Nobody would believe you about Tiger King...

Tiger King
Netflix

Recent global events have made everybody’s lives feel stranger than fiction. It’s hard to believe that everything we are seeing on the news is actually happening and not some kind of weird fever dream we are experiencing.

Being stuck inside and not knowing what the immediate future holds feel like we have all been thrown into some kind of movie. News channels are almost exclusively talking about the pandemic, which appears to be getting worse and worse by the day.

Luckily, most of us have access to numerous streaming services full of content that can distract us from everything happening outside. With plenty of time to kill, why not pass the time by watching some of the most unbelievable documentaries ever made.

Some of these stories will serve as a timely reminder that there are people in this world living an even stranger existence than we are right now. They will also educate you about experiences and scenarios that you will never have, nor ever want to, experience first hand.

12. Don't F**k With Cats

Don't F**k With Cats
Netflix

This three-part documentary series begins with the discovery of a shocking video found on the dark web of a man filming himself killing a kitten. As the video is spread around the Internet, a group of cat lovers come across it and set out to track down the evil culprit.

From there, they uncover more disturbing videos from the same man and are then in a race against time to find him before he carries out any more horrific attacks.

As the group grows larger, they delve deeper into the dark web and get close to exposing the killer’s true identity. However, attempts to alert the authorities are quickly dismissed, as the cat lovers are not deemed as credible informants.

That is until the sick individual moves on from felines and starts targeting humans.

The documentary series gives the viewer an unsettling insight into the world of the dark web and gets far more gruesome than the light-hearted title suggests.


11. Voyeur

Voyeur Gay Talese
Netflix

A seemingly normal Colorado motel is found to be anything but when it is revealed that specially designed ceiling vents and peepholes were created to allow the owner to watch over his guests as they went about their business.

The owner of the motel, Gerald Foos, peered at his guests for decades and kept notes on their activities, from the bland to the disturbing. Journalist Gary Talese published some of his documents in the New Yorker in 2016.

The relationship between Talese and Foos is a large part of the ‘Voyeur’ documentary as both men seemingly compete with each other to be the star of the show. Not that either man has anything to brag about in regards to their involvement in the case.

Foos refers to his voyeurism as “research” and was often encouraged by Talese, who seemed perversely excited, during his own investigation into the motel. By the end of the documentary you will have an insight into a disturbing way of living but you, the viewer, will also feel a bit dirty just for watching the film.


10. Finders Keepers

Finders Keepers
The Orchard

A man at a North Carolina auction is shocked to discover that a grill he bought has a mummified leg inside of it. The leg in question originally belonged to the seller, who lost his limb in an aeroplane crash, but had it mummified so he could keep it.

An obvious, albeit truly bizarre, mistake. But mistakes happen, you’d imagine that the leg would simply get returned, right?

Of course not, that wouldn’t make for a very entertaining documentary now would it?

The filmmakers do a good job of not out rightly laughing at the people involved, but sympathetically hearing each side of the argument. The documentary simply tells the tale of a legal battle of a two men fighting over the ownership of a severed leg, all thanks to one man’s unwavering belief of “Finders keepers”.

Rumour has it he also lives by the mantra of “Whoever smelt it, dealt it”.


9. Tiger King

Tiger King
Netflix

It goes without saying that big cat breeding is a dangerous game. However, it’s not just the animals you need to be wary of. The bizarre cast of characters that inhabit the strange underworld of big cat breeding are just as threatening.

The Netflix documentary series, Tiger King, has set social media abuzz since it was released on the streaming service last month. It has shed light on the bitter, competitive rivalries than take place in this unique line of work.

The owners of the big cat sanctuaries and zoos feud over how to care for the animals. The ferocious feuds go way further than you could ever imagine, leading to lies, deceit, death threats and country songs.

The seven-part series focuses primarily on the multiple disputes between the egocentric, flamboyant Joe Exotic and his long-term adversary Carole Baskin in a tale that has to be seen to be believed.


8. Abducted In Plain Sight

Abducted In Plain Sight
Netflix

The Brobergs seemed like a typical, church-going American family, that was until they were duped by a sociopathic neighbour who became fixated with their twelve-year-old daughter.

This dark, twisted tale gets more unbelievable with every passing moment. The story of how the sick predator convinced a young child to engage in intercourse with him to save the World from an alien invasion isn’t even the craziest part of this film.

Robert Berchtold, the villain of the piece, had a bizarre stranglehold over not only the young girl, but also her family. It isn’t your typical story of a creepy, paedophile abducting a young girl, Berchtold did most of his grooming of the innocent victim in front of her unfathomably naïve family.

The ultimately harrowing documentary will leave you equal parts confused and angry. It will stay with you for days following as you try to comprehend how any of this actually happened.


7. The Imposter

The Imposter
Picturehouse

The Imposter tells the story of a young French man who was somehow able to trick a Texas family into thinking he was their missing 16-year-old son.

That’s just for starters!

From there we hear about how a dark-skinned boy with a French accent fooled not only the family but also the press who had become enthralled by this ‘too good to be true’ story.

We also hear about the imposter’s multiple other schemes that managed to trick authorities into believing his multitude of false identities. At times you will be fascinated by how he was able to get away with it for so long, while at other points you will be shocked at how easy it was to dupe the governments involved in this case.

As the inconceivable story approaches its conclusion, there is one more twist left in store as we learn that the Frenchman might not have been the only person deceiving the public. The film ends with the tease of a possibly even darker secret buried in the backyard of the family.


6. Wild Wild Country

Wild Wild Country
Netflix

To some people, Bhagwan Shree Rajneesh was a mystifying, spiritual guru, teaching his followers his theories on how humanity can better itself. To others, however, he was a highly dangerous cult leader and potential terrorist.

Wild Wild Country documents the story of how the controversial figure built his own community from the ground up in an Oregon desert, with help from his thousands of followers. The film tells the story from the perspective of some of the cult’s most committed disciples, as wells as some locals that didn’t take too kindly to Rajneesh’s arrival.

It wasn’t long until it grew much larger than a local dispute as guns, drugs and attempted murders lead to a worldwide investigation into Rajneesh and his people.

The rapid rise of this community is both impressive and terrifying. The cult-like following that was built on peace and love lead to the exact opposite and became one of the most controversial, yet widely unknown, stories in America’s recent history.


5. Evil Genius

Evil Genius Netflix
Netflix

A planned heist goes wrong when pizza delivery man, Brian Wells, exits a bank and is stopped by the police. They quickly discover that Wells has a homemade bomb strapped to his chest, which he doesn’t know how to remove, and an intense stand-off ensues.

Before they can get any answers from him, the bomb goes off, taking Brian’s life and leaving the authorities dumbfounded.

Who strapped this bomb to him? Was Brian Wells just a pawn in someone else’s plan in this ill-fated bank heist?

At times, it feels like this was just a dangerous game that was plotted by some unstable individuals. But the constant reminder of the victim’s unnecessary death maintains an uncomfortable and eerie atmosphere throughout the film.

This four-part documentary series examines the suspects involved in the case and reveals potential motives for the bank robbery. It revolves around a cast of unreliable characters each giving their own narrative as the filmmakers attempt to answer as many questions as they can that surround this intriguing story.


4. Jesus Camp

Jesus Camp
Magnolia Pictures

‘Jesus Camp' is an uncomfortable look at an Evangelical Christian camp for children. The unsettling devotion the children appear to have to their religion is questioned in this controversial documentary that ultimately lead to the closure of the camp.

The camp’s leaders openly describe the process as 'training Christian soldiers for a future war'. It’s safe to assume that this is a metaphorical war but it is a disturbing use of imagery nonetheless.

The film primarily focuses on three different children all with varying levels of commitment to the program. One child is determined to become a pastor when he is older, while another is seen questioning the religion and is clearly confused by the intensity she experiences while at the camp.

The filmmakers maintain that there was no hidden agenda in their documentary; they were simply trying to offer an honest reflection of what occurs at the camp. That didn’t stop the shock and outrage of people that watched it upon it’s release.


3. Jim & Andy

Jim & Andy: The Great Beyond (2017) -  Jim Carrey
Netflix

Actors are often celebrated for their ability to inhabit the characters they are portraying. But as we’ve heard on many occasions, some actors find it easier to switch on and off from their roles than others.

The portrayal of an already eccentric performer, Andy Kaufmann, was brought to life by Jim Carrey in the 1999 movie, Man On The Moon. But the documentary ‘Jim & Andy’, released almost twenty years later, unearths behind the scenes of footage of Carrey’s bizarre behaviour during the recording of the movie.

Carrey’s attempt to dive into the psyche of Kaufmann is difficult to watch at times as he desperately attempts to transform into the man he believed Kaufmann to be. He appears to miss the mark in many ways, despite giving a widely celebrated performance in the role. However, people like Jerry Lawler speak about the difficulty he had in dealing with Carrey during the shoot, whereas he found Kaufmann to be disciplined and friendly off-screen.

In the documentary, Jim Carrey openly speaks about the intensity of the shoot and long-lasting affects it has had on him. The newly released footage will leave the viewer questioning the commitment actors have to their art and ask whether or not it can go too far.


2. Fyre

Fyre Ja Rule
Netflix

What was supposed to be the greatest festival of their lives turned into a nightmare for the excited, young rich kids that had purchased tickets to the Fyre Festival.

The grandiose promises from the organisers were later exposed as dirty lies, but only when it became too late for the festival-goers, who were left stranded on a desert island. People may find joy in laughing at the snobbish, spoilt kids that were affected by this scam, but this is truly a sad tale for everyone involved.

That’s not to say there isn’t humour to be found in the ridiculous scheming of the organisers. Billy McFarland and his team created a huge amount of buzz through viral videos and other social media antics, but the festival was always doomed to fail and fail miserably.

Fyre tells the story of the scheming and deceit that went into organising the bogus festival, as told by members of McFarland’s team. You have to fell sympathy for some of his team who sincerely tried to make this event happen.

You won’t believe how far one man was willing to go to get crates of bottled water for the festival!


1. Three Identical Strangers

Three Identical Strangers (2018)
Neon

A case of mistaken identity seemed like a fairly inconspicuous incident, but nobody could have imagined the spectacular story that the simple incident set in motion.

When the man heard about his look-alike, he was shocked to find that they shared the same birthday and had also both been adopted shortly after their births. He was determined to track this man down.

He was able to find him and discover that he had an identical twin. Not only that but when the story hit the tabloids, another man came forward to reveal that they were identical triplets.

The unbelievable tale of the three men finding each other and comparing uncannily similar childhood stories begins as a heart-warming film. But it quickly takes a sinister turn when they discover that their similar paths were no accident.

When investigating their pasts, they uncover a terrifying scandal of how they were deliberately separated at birth as part of a project to investigate the Nature vs. Nurture debate.

What follows is a heart-breaking story of how the three men battle mental health issues and struggle with dealing with their own identity.


In this post: 
Tiger King
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Freelance journalist and serial moaner, obsessed with the ludicrous world of professional wrestling.