13 Films That Really Needed Nicolas Cage

Missed opportunities where another classically barmy Nicolas Cage performance could have been forged.

Nicolas Cage is one of the most divisive figures in the film industry: on one hand, he's an Oscar-winning actor who's worked with almost every major director worth mentioning, yet on the other, he tirelessly spends much of his time slumming in terrible, low-rent thrillers for a quick pay-day, in an attempt to pay off his gigantic tax bill. If you haven't already seen it, you should certainly check out Simon Gallagher's article about 10 movies that were almost ruined by Nicolas Cage, and now, we're going to examine 13 movies which would certainly have been much better with Cage's unmistakably eccentric presence. Now, few people are going to seriously argue that The Matrix, The Wrestler, The Lord of the Rings, Dumb and Dumber, Shrek and so on would actually have benefited from Cage taking the lead role, but what about other movies he turned down that he was actually suited for? And what about those roles that were written for him but for whatever reason didn't pan out? On top of all this, we've also included a bunch of our own speculative picks whereby another classically barmy Nicolas Cage performance could have been forged, making said film infinitely more memorable than it ended up being. Still, we don't expect universal agreement on some of our more out-there choices, so feel free to judge for yourselves and make your own suggestions in the comments!

13. Any Expendables Movie

The Role: Pretty much any character Why Nic Cage Would Have Improved It: If you believe Sylvester Stallone, this one actually came close to happening for both The Expendables 2 and 3, even though around a year ago, Cage went on the record and assured us it wasn't going to happen for EX3, and he ended up being "replaced" by Kelsey Grammer. There is literally no role in these movies that Cage wouldn't be totally, ridiculously awesome in, be it as a crazy mercenary who helps out the Expendables during a firefight (ala Chuck Norris in EX2), or as a hammy, mugging bad guy ala Jean-Claude Van Damme. Either way, Cage's intensely-harnessed insanity would go down extremely well with the target audience, and it's safe to say that no matter how bad the rest of the movie might have been, seeing Nic Cage hanging out with Sly and co. would have been an unadulterated cinematic delight. Our gut tells us he'd be a lot more fun as a foe rather than a friend of the Expendables, but hey, considering the franchise is showing no sign of slowing down, there's always hope for the future...

12. Crank

The Role: Chev Chelios (Jason Statham) Why Nic Cage Would Have Improved It: At 2011's New York Comic Con, Crank directors Mark Neveldine and Brian Taylor confessed that they had originally envisioned the series with Cage in mind, and hoped that after directing him in Ghost Rider: Spirit of Vengeance, they could maybe convince him to appear in Crank 3. Fat chance, but hey, we can dream, right? Now, there's little point denying the brilliant effectiveness of Jason Statham in these movies: he gets what Neveldine and Taylor are shooting for, and he's also young and fit enough that he can aptly convey the energy of the scenario. With Cage in the role, Crank would certainly be a very different movie, but seeing him super-charged and turned up to 11 would allow for even zanier scenarios than have occurred in the franchise to date. Plus, the idea of an out-of-breath Cage running around Los Angeles on drugs, beating up gangsters, screwing his girlfriend in Chinatown and so on fills us with more joy than we ever thought possible. The Crank movies are already pretty great, but with a dash of The Cage, they'd be next-level indeed. Still, if Statham is busy filming something else when Crank 3 (finally) gets the green-light, why not just replace him with Cage, and better yet, don't even explain the change in appearance beyond Burned Zombie Chev getting a skin graft. For a movie like this, it'd totally work.

11. Hulk (2003)

The Role: Bruce Banner aka The Hulk (Eric Bana) Why Nic Cage Would Have Improved It: Ang Lee's Hulk was criticised for its slack pacing and rather depressing lack of energy. Eric Bana gave a strong performance in the role of Bruce Banner, though his stoic effort was ultimately poorly matched with Lee's plodding, sedate style: this was a movie in sore need of an extremely lively, energetic performance to bring it out of the doldrums. And who, exactly, does lively and energetic better than Nicolas Cage? He'd nail the duality of the character perfectly, and the moments in which Bruce transforms into the big green dude would have given Cage plenty of room to just go nuts as well as add a few more clips to all those infamous "Nic Cage freakout" YouTube videos. Sadly in 2003 performance capture for the character hadn't yet been employed, but still, seeing a Hulk that somewhat resembled Nicolas Cage would have been something too awesome for words.

10. Either Hangover Sequel

The Role: The token A-lister bad guy (Paul Giamatti in The Hangover Part II, John Goodman in The Hangover Part III) Why Nic Cage Would Have Improved It: After the brilliant hilarity of the first Hangover movie, both sequels were sorely lacking in manic energy, despite increasingly raising the stakes to an often desperate degree and even introducing the likes of Giamatti and Goodman as fleeting villains to spice things up a little. Though the two clearly enjoyed their roles, the parts are badly under-written and just not crazy enough to give either film the significant boost they needed. That, of course, is where Cage would have come in. Seeing an actor as truly unpredictable as Cage telling the Wolf Pack that he's coming after them would genuinely make us fear for their lives and make us feel the tension of the scenario. After all, had writer-director Todd Phillips managed to secure the services of Cage as an insane, gun-totting, drug-snorting bad guy, pretty much all bets would have been off on what might happen next. Have Cage resurrect his inner Caster Troy and just see what happens: nothing short of movie magic.

9. Spider-Man

The Role: Norman Osborn aka Green Goblin (Willem Dafoe) Why Nic Cage Would Have Improved It: There's no denying that Willem Dafoe gave a rock-solid performance as Norman Osborn, who becomes progressively more insane over the course of the movie as the Green Goblin persona takes hold. The role was originally offered to Cage by director Sam Raimi, though despite being a huge comic book nut, he turned it down for reasons unknown. We love Dafoe, but when faced with the possibility of Cage taking the role instead, we'd give it to him no contest. Spider-Man is thankfully already a pretty great movie, but Cage could have taken the Green Goblin to an entirely different place. Dafoe's Goblin is undeniably sinister and creepy, whereas Cage's would probably have been sillier and more outrageous, which is of course entirely within the goofy spirit of Raimi's Spider-Man movies anyway. Plus, the idea of Nicolas Cage playing James Franco's father is pretty damn hilarious, admit it.

8. Drive

The Role: Driver (Ryan Gosling) Why Nic Cage Would Have Improved It: It's hard not to admit that this one will be a tough sell. Drive is a cult movie with a rabidly protective fan-base, and more to the point, it stars actor-du-jour Ryan Gosling in one of his most memorable roles. Drive is no doubt a solid movie, though Nicolas Winding Refn's slow-moving, "artful" vibe does prove as frustrating as it is intriguing. Sure, it's awesome when Gosling stomps a guy's face to pieces in a lift, but watching him stare into the middle distance for half the movie isn't exactly the most invigorating thing we've ever seen. Nicolas Cage may not have the boyish good looks of Gosling, but he's got a vividly expressive face that we could watch all day, which is all-too important given Refn's prerogative with this movie. Sure, he'd look hilarious in that scorpion jacket and casting him opposite Carey Mulligan would be totally ridiculous (her character would need to be recast for an older actress), but seeing Cage challenged to turn his trademark insanity inwards and express himself through more subtle facial motions would be a fascinating acting masterclass to observe, and we know he'd rise to the occasion. Given how well he slotted into Werner Herzog's artful yet brilliantly bonkers Bad Lieutenant: Port of Call - New Orleans, we expect he'd be a total blast here, especially when compared to Gosling's competent if not particularly exciting work here.

7. Fantastic Four

The Role: Victor von Doom aka Dr. Doom (Julian McMahon) Why Nic Cage Would Have Improved It: There's a lot to complain about in Tim Story's Fantastic Four, from the general goofiness of the whole outing to the slack premise and, well, the lame villain. Dr. Doom is one of the most iconic bad guys in the history of comic books, and yet Julian McMahon gave a curiously stilted, dull performance in the dual role, suggesting he was entirely wrong for the part. The part needs an actor who can bring a little more life to the troubled bureaucrat as he transforms into Dr. Doom, and Cage would have unquestionably knocked the role out of the park. Still, the real fun would have come when Cage got to play a cackling, wild bad guy, and though keeping his ridiculously expressive face behind a metal mask isn't exactly the greatest idea, perhaps not using that lame-a** mask from the actual 2005 is a good start: it limited McMahon's expressiveness and looked totally dumb. Get Cage, give him a mask with a little wiggle room, and this movie would have instantly been a lot better.

6. Encino Man

Encino ManThe Role: Link (Brendan Fraser) Why Nic Cage Would Have Improved It: Encino Man (known as California Man in Europe) is far from a great movie, and its greatest contribution to the world has been kick-starting the career of Brendan Fraser (see how that went). However, did you know that Fraser's role as Link, the caveman thawed out in the 20th century, was originally set for Nicolas Cage? Cage is only a few years older than Fraser, so certainly could have pulled the part off, though considering he'd already starred in the acclaimed likes of Raising Arizona and Wild at Heart, why on Earth would he have starred in something as goofy as this? While Cage couldn't have done much about the movie's so-so script, and Fraser is admittedly good at playing slackers, the thought of seeing Cage eating food out of a dog bowl, screaming at a helicopter, flipping around, drinking mustard and basically being as deliriously insane as possible is just hilarious.

5. Batman Forever

The Role: Harvey Dent aka Two-Face (Tommy Lee Jones) Why Nic Cage Would Have Improved It: Joel Schumacher's Batman Forever is no classic, though it is for the most part a criminally underrated Batman movie. It's rough around the edges, sure, and one of the elements that often catches a lot of flack is Tommy Lee Jones' absurd performance as Two-Face. While Jim Carrey is memorably manic as The Riddler, Jones' performance is a mostly forgettable collision of ridiculous mugging and bad make-up. What was supposed to be a serious character was essentially made into a cartoonish joke. While Cage wouldn't be able to do much about the crappy make-up, we suspect that given his self-confessed comic book fandom, he'd probably have shown the character a little more respect and delivered a more reigned-in, less hammy performance. Sure, there's only so much one can do against the script and Schumacher's campy style, but there was still room to emphasise the terror of Two-Face rather than turn him into a flat-out comedy act as Jones did. If Cage's roles in films like Vampire's Kiss and Face/Off prove one thing, it's that he can be really freaking creepy when he wants to be.

4. Natural Born Killers

The Role: Mickey Knox (Woody Harrelson) Why Nic Cage Would Have Improved It: Oliver Stone's wild satirical thriller about two lovers who go on a nation-wide killing spree is better remembered for its ambitious style rather than its two central performances, even if Juliette Lewis and Woody Harrelson do admirable jobs in the roles of Mallory and Mickey Knox. What's interesting about the movie, though, is that for the most part, Harrelson gives a curiously restrained performance, when given Stone's over-the-top direction and Lewis' more out-there turn, there was certainly plenty of opportunity for Harrelson to go full psycho. For Cage, this could have been the next logical evolution from his role in Wild at Heart, approaching similar subject matter albeit in a far more extreme, go-for-broke manner. We can only imagine that Stone would have encouraged Cage to take Mickey's mania as far as possible, and this would only have enhanced the movie's trippy, off-the-page tone. As it stands, Natural Born Killers is a pretty underrated movie, but with Cage in the lead role, it could have been a classic.

3. Green Hornet

The Role: Benjamin Chudnofsky (Christoph Waltz) Why Nic Cage Would Have Improved It: Nicolas Cage was originally cast to play the villain in Michel Gondry's Green Hornet, though at that stage in production, the villain was called Mr X and differed somewhat from the eventual bad guy, Benjamin Chudnofsky, played with tongue-in-cheek aplomb by Christoph Waltz. Though Waltz clearly has a lot of fun in the part and gets to enthusiastically spout lines such as "I'm ungassable!", it sounds like Nicolas Cage had something altogether more interesting to offer. Cage reportedly insisted on giving his character a Jamaican accent, and when Cage quit, Gondry stated, "I was quite relieved when he announced he no longer wanted the part." Still, the movie completely blew without Cage, and at least seeing him sport a ridiculous Rasta voice might've made the film a little funnier and less boring. As for Cage's take on the situation, he said that, "I think Seth Rogen and Michel had a different take on the character...I had to have some humanity and to try to give it something where you could understand why the character was the way he was but I don€™t think there was enough time to develop it." Still, all we're hearing is "Jamaican accent". That alone has us sold on Cage being a better choice for the villain than, well, anyone else.

2. Daredevil

Daredevil Nic CageThe Role: Bullseye (Colin Farrell) Why Nic Cage Would Have Improved It: Daredevil is a heavily flawed movie, and though the Director's Cut is a significant improvement, one element that still falls horribly flat is Colin Farrell's take on one of the film's villains, assassin Bullseye. Much like Tommy Lee Jones' aforementioned performance as Two-Face, Farrell takes a character that's supposed to be intimidating and terrifying and turns them into a corny joke. The crappy one-liners didn't help, but Farrell totally mis-interpreted the character, and in the darker Director's Cut, he especially sticks out like a sore, goofy thumb. The thought of Cage playing a bald-headed dude with a bullseye tattoo on his forehead while clad in a black leather jacket is a curious visual image for sure, but again, Cage has enough respect for the comic book medium that we suspect he'd give a more grounded rendition of the character and actually seem like he was putting some effort in. Sure, we'd still have the corny dialogue, though hopefully Cage wouldn't ham it up quite so much. Above all else, Cage is just a much more interesting actor than Farrell, and he would have kept us glued to the screen.

1. The Number 23

The Role: Walter Sparrow (Jim Carrey) Why Nic Cage Would Have Improved It: One of the biggest complaints about Joel Schumacher's ridiculous thriller The Number 23 is that Jim Carrey was wildly miscast in the lead role, as a man who has to fleet between being devoted to his family and, well, something a whole lot more sinister. Though the movie would have been terrible even with Daniel Day-Lewis in the title role, we suspect that Nicolas Cage would've been a far snugger fit for Walter Sparrow. For starters, he's got a ton of experience playing characters with erratic personalities: just look at Vampire's Kiss, Face/Off, Bad Lieutenant, Matchstick Men and Adaptation. In addition to arguably becoming cinema's go-to-maniac, he's proven he can play the down-to-Earth family man (Con Air) with ease, and so would likely have a much firmer handle on The Number 23's admittedly absurd plot twists and turns. It'd still be a bad movie, but at least Cage would make it a lot more fun than the depressing dirge it ended up being in Carrey's misplaced hands. Are there any other roles you wish Nicolas Cage had taken up? Let us know in the comments!

Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.