15 Unbelievably Hideous Horror Movie Sequels

You'd think Saw V would have killed the franchise...

Saw V Strahm
Lionsgate

What is the genre of film with the biggest franchises? The answer is horror, with numerous horror franchises running at around 10 entries. But is this a good thing? Definitely not.

Sadly, it seems that every good horror film has at least one underwhelming sequel to its name and such sequels almost always conform to the law of diminishing returns. Sure, there are big exceptions, such as Evil Dead 2, Dawn of the Dead and Aliens among others, but those are a minority. In general, horror sequels suck.

The worst thing about horror sequels is that they spoil the original, since they continue the story so badly. A great recent example of this is Happy Death Day 2U, which undermined the original with a weak continuation that over-explained everything.

At the moment, horror is experiencing a revival with great films such as Get Out and It Follows. In order to continue this current winning streak, one important rule should be followed: don't do sequels. Seriously, just leave a great film alone and don't ruin its legacy.

Need any evidence as to why horror sequels are usually a bad idea? Just check out these following monstrosities. They're always a good sign...

15. Alien: Resurrection

Alien Resurrection Sigourney Weaver Ron Perlman
Fox

Sure, Prometheus and Alien: Covenent were pretty weak, but they're certainly not the worst in this wildly inconsistent franchise, which has entirely failed to match the highs of Alien or Aliens. The real low-point is this confused, un-scary and enormously irritating mess which can never figure out what to do with itself.

In fairness, it boasts some memorable gore moments, the performances are fine and it has a couple of interesting themes, but as a narrative, it just doesn't work at all and lacks dramatic weight or genuine tension. It also gets even sillier than the two prequel films, which is really saying something.

Alien: Resurrection speeds through many-tension free chase sequences before concluding with a bizarre finale involving an alien hybrid, thus adding up to a painfully unsatisfying viewing and a sad blot upon Alien's legacy.

In the film's famous basketball scene, Sigourney Weaver actually did the impressive basketball trick shot without special effects. And it's a sad comment that that's the most interesting thing about this movie.


14. Halloween II (2009)

Octavia Spencer Halloween II
Dimension Films

Rob Zombie's Halloween remake isn't great or anything but it was an interesting work and remains one of the most underrated horror remakes out there. Unfortunately, in Zombie's second stab at the franchise he totally lost the plot.

Not only is this a terrible slasher sequel, it's also one of the weirdest ever made. Filled with pretentious dream sequences involving Michael's dead mother with a white horse (yes, really) and featuring the talented future Oscar nominee Octavia Spencer making a meaningless cameo as one of Michael's victims, this one will have you exclaiming WTF throughout.

Unfortunately, despite that it's a very boring film that largely consists of darkly lit, exhausting kill scenes and scenes involving unlikable characters yelling at each other. It also butchers most of the once-great characters; Laurie is just an A-hole, Loomis is an even bigger A-hole and Michael Myers is not only dominated by those weird horse visions but spends much of the film without his mask on.

The performances, in fairness, are fine, but other than that this is an undeniable slog.


13. Spiral

Ring 1998
Toho

Time for an ultra-obscure film that most won't have seen.

This sequel was filmed and released at the same time as Ring, yet it had different directors and writers and only a couple of the same cast members. This was a terrible release strategy and unsurprisingly this was such a bomb it was ret-conned out of existence and another sequel was made instead.

This one is an obscure film that's not worth seeking out. For starters, as a sequel it just doesn't work. The characters from Ring are mishandled, the tape barely appears, it goes in a radically different direction and worst of all, Sadako is now sexualized and not at all scary.

To make matters worse, while the acting is good the script is a confusing, turgid mess and it's woefully short on scares or thrills. Overall, it's an inferior follow-up to a masterpiece and one should just watch 1999's Ring 2 instead, which is certainly superior.


12. The Woman In Black: Angel Of Death

Woman In Black 2
Hammer Films

Sure, horror sequels always set off alarm bells, but given that this one had a genuinely good premise, it seemed this might actually break the mold. Alas, this is just as bad as most other studio horror sequels.

The most infuriating thing about this is how much potential it wastes; after all, it was the sequel to The Woman in Black, which is one of the decade's best British horror films and the rare jump scare-filled horror that was actually scary. In Angel of Death, the performances and cinematography are solid and the villain, the Woman in Black herself, is a brilliant one, but all these positive elements are squandered in a soulless, scare-free and painfully dull flick that'll send you to sleep.

The best advice is to watch the original and pretend this one doesn't even exist. Since it has little connection to the first film other than the villain, luckily that's easy to do.


11. Texas Chainsaw 3D

Texas Chainsaw 3D
Lions Gate

This is a direct sequel to Tobe Hooper's brilliant horror classic that ignores all the previous terrible sequels. Unfortunately, this was another dud and is somehow even worse than Hooper's own sequel, the hideous Texas Chainsaw Massacre 2 from 1986.

Is Texas Chainsaw 3D the stupidest horror film ever made? It's certainly up there. It's difficult to think of another horror film with as many plot holes. For starters, the main character was born in 1974 and the film takes place in 2012.

She should be nearly 40, yet is played by an actress in her 20s. The film only gets dumber and dumber as it goes along. Its many gaffes and dumb character decisions might make you laugh at first, but after a while it's just irritating instead of funny.

It eventually leads to a monumentally idiotic ending that's likely one of the silliest in horror history. Meanwhile, it simply isn't scary, the characters are irritating, the dialogue is horrendous and it serves as a highly unsatisfying direct sequel to the original. Halloween (2018) this certainly ain't.


10. Insidious Chapter Two

Old Man Insidious 2
Stage 6 Films

There are disappointing horror sequels and then there's this. Since the crew of the excellent and terrifying original were on-board, this had no excuse to be as crushingly dull, lazy and downright indifferent as it turned out to be.

This sequel just isn't scary and this time the jump scares don't work at all, while the story is also dreadful. In fact, 'story' is a term that should be used loosely since this doesn't have much of a plot. All it truly does is tie up the loose ends of the original for the entire movie.

With this one, the most logical explanation is that James Wan was distracted making The Conjuring and failed to put any effort into this. Unlike The Conjuring Universe, which has largely managed to turn out films that are OK at the very least (aside from Annabelle and The Nun), Insidious is one of those horror franchises which just wasn't worth sticking with after the first film. What a shame.


9. The Final Destination

The Final Destination
New Line Cinema

The Final Destination series has proved surprisingly consistent over the years and the other four films worked, especially the first and fifth films. This fourth installment did not. At all.

If there's one word to sum up The Final Destination it would be 'lazy'. This is nothing more than a carbon copy of the first three movies which entirely lacks their creativity and doesn't even seem to be trying to thrill the viewers. To make matters worse, it's also performed by one of the worst film casts you'll ever see. There is not a single remotely good performance here.

The death scenes are painfully bland (and ripped-off from all the first three films), the characters are one-dimensional and the film does nothing more than go through the Final Destination formula without ever giving a damn.

With this one, watch the admittedly great opening racetrack disaster, then switch off after that. There's nothing else to be gained here.


8. Seed Of Chucky

Seed Of Chucky Seed Of Chucky
FX

Bride of Chucky was great. Seed of Chucky was not.

Where the franchise-reviving Bride of Chucky was hilarious and occasionally quite sweet, Seed of Chucky is meaningless, ugly, staggeringly unfunny and just a complete mess from top to bottom. The vocal performances are still great, but aside from a hilarious Shining reference, none of the jokes land at all and it also fails to be scary. To be honest, it barely resembles a Child's Play film and feels like a garbage piece of fan fiction.

To date, this is easily the worst Child's Play film (yes, it's even worse than Child's Play 2 and Child's Play 3) and unsurprisingly it killed the franchise for nearly a decade. It eventually came back in the form of direct-to-DVD movies and a recent remake... which have all been pleasantly surprising, so at least Chucky, one of horror's greatest villains, is now getting the good material he deserves.


7. Saw V

Saw V Strahm
Lionsgate

This is another film that's so empty and dull it's unlikely to provoke any real reaction from the audience. It isn't scary, it isn't disturbing, the acting is dreadful, the script is even worse and there isn't even a good twist ending this time. All the elements that defined the franchise's better films, such as Tobin Bell, clever twists, moral ambiguity and good death scenes, are largely absent here.

This is the worst film in the Saw franchise and since we're talking about a franchise that includes Saw III, Saw IV and Saw 3D, that's saying a lot. This is very much a sequel with no fresh ideas that was only released to meet the franchise's annual Halloween release date and make money.

Looking on the bright side, a year later we did get a return-to-form with Saw VI but even so, this monstrosity is surely one of the laziest and most effort-free horror films of recent times.


6. The Texas Chainsaw Massacre: The Beginning

The Texas Chainsaw Massacre The Beginning
New Line Cinema

2003's Texas Chainsaw Massacre remake was the first of many terrible 2000s horror remakes and it was a thoroughly tedious affair, yet somehow this prequel makes the remake look like Citizen Kane.

Did anyone want a sequel to such a forgettable remake? No. Did anyone want or need an origin story for Leatherface? That's an even bigger no. Therefore, this is a film which generally felt entirely unnecessary and since it was such a forgettable film that entirely failed to justify its existence, this felt like a giant middle finger to everyone who saw it.

This could be one of cinema's worst origin stories, since it barely even qualifies as such and shows Leatherface's first killing spree and nothing else. As well as being utterly bankrupt on a narrative level, it's also a woefully unscary film that, like so many horror films from its era, coasts along on jump scares and gore, not atmosphere or suspense.

Thankfully no more films were made in this particular continuity, but still, the franchise currently isn't doing great. It's definitely time for Leatherface to hang up the chainsaw for good.


5. Paranormal Activity: The Ghost Dimension

Paranormal Activity The Ghost Dimension Leila
Paramount

Paranormal Activity is one of the worst horror franchises in history. Virtually all of the films, including the first one, sucked and only the third one was any good. This sixth installment was another complete dud.

While a Paranormal Activity movie being bad is about as surprising as the sun rising in the morning, this still managed to feel like a let-down. The marketing promised answers to the franchise's mythology and core narrative, but for the most part the film doesn't answer any questions and several important franchise characters aren't even in it.

The only impressive thing about this one is that it clears the low bar set by the rest of the franchise and is even worse than the others, including the atrocious Paranormal Activity 4.

A film so bland and lazy it provokes little more than a passive shrug, The Ghost Dimension is an insultingly dull and scare-free horror film. Still, at least this is the last Paranormal Activity film... for now anyway. Fingers crossed.


4. Halloween: The Curse Of Michael Myers

halloween the curse of michael myers paul rudd donald pleasance
Buena Vista Pictures

Even in such an inconsistent franchise that includes Halloween 5, the aforementioned Halloween II (2009) and the horrors of Halloween: Resurrection (the one with Busta Rhymes karate kicking Michael out of a window), The Curse of Michael Myers is still the series nadir.

It has Donald Pleasance, in his last film appearance, doing his typically excellent work as Loomis and the always lovable Paul Rudd makes quite a good feature film debut here, but other than that this is an unmitigated disaster.

Jamie Lloyd is unceremoniously killed off early on, the film looks incredibly amateurish, it's never, ever scary, the script is devoid of any weight and the less said about the Cult of Thorn, the film's laughable explanation for Michael's evil, the better.

Thankfully, this ghastly horror film has been retconned since the recent Halloween film ignored all the sequels. Therefore, it'll hopefully be quietly forgotten.


3. The Ring Two

The Ring Two Emily Vancamp
DreamWorks Pictures

The American remake of Ring was arguably over-praised, but good lord, at least it was better than this... thing.

Filled with bland writing, terrible CGI and overdone jump scares, The Ring Two is a staggeringly dull, wet and tension-free mess that simply couldn't be less scary if it tried.

The only thing shocking about this movie is that it's directed by Hideo Nakata, the excellent horror director who directed the original Ring. Judging by his unusually bad directing here, it seems likely he was also aware of how bad the film was and realized he couldn't save it.

After all, even the world's most talented director couldn't save a film that features a 'scare' in which a poorly-rendered pack of CGI deer attack a car in a moment that somehow feels even stupider than the opening of Grown Ups 2.

2017's Rings, which was critically mauled, was also a terrible film but even that wasn't as bad as this.


2. The Rage: Carrie 2

Carrie 2
MGM

The original Carrie is an achingly sad horror masterpiece and one of the genre's all-time greatest films. In stark contrast, The Rage: Carrie 2 might be one of the worst sequels ever made in any genre. Unsurprisingly, only one person from the original returned: Amy Irving as Sue Snell. Unfortunately, the film kills her off meaninglessly, which is one of the many dreadful decisions this un-scary disaster of a horror film makes.

This one mimics the arc of the original, but fills it with misguided choices such as a pointless romantic subplot and removes all the pathos, fear and tragedy that made the original so special. Since it copies its predecessor so much the film comes off as even more of an insult to it.

Emotionally void, forgettably acted, flatly directed and entirely bland, Carrie 2 is a train-wreck with nothing to offer save for some entertaining gore; unfortunately, that comes at the very end. All in all, a complete turkey.


1. Jaws: The Revenge

jaws the revenge
Universal Pictures

After his miserable time making Jaws 2, Roy Scheider declined to return. While it was a shame to see him absent, at least Roy Scheider was spared the humiliation of appearing in this, unlike poor Michael Caine. Jaws: The Revenge is usually cited as one of the worst films ever made and frankly, believe the hype. It really is that bad. Ironically, it's a sequel to Jaws, arguably one of the best movies ever made.

The script is putrid, the directing is awful, the acting is wooden, the narrative is nonsense, the special effects are ghastly and the film doesn't even try to be exciting or suspenseful. This is that rare film that is incompetent on every conceivable level and it doesn't even offer unintentional laughs.

Michael Caine famously said: "I have never seen [The film], but by all accounts it is terrible. However, I have seen the house that it built, and it is terrific." Well, at least something good came out of, let's face it, the worst horror sequel ever made.


In this post: 
Saw-V
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Film Studies graduate, aspiring screenwriter and all-around nerd who, despite being a pretentious cinephile who loves art-house movies, also loves modern blockbusters and would rather watch superhero movies than classic Hollywood films. Once met Tommy Wiseau.