15 Ways The MCU Improved Marvel Mythology
Is Thanos better in the film universe?
The Marvel Cinematic Universe has single-handedly transformed the film landscape of the 21st century. Sure, there were superhero movies before it and yes, major studio franchises are nothing new. But a shared-universe concept that mixed genres, defied source material conventions, and managed regularly produce quality cinema was unheard of and was a laughable prospect only fifteen years ago.
Now, the MCU is practically a money-making machine that Disney will be milking for the foreseeable future and, since it tends to include good movies and shows, audiences are pretty happy about that all things considered. But one positive element of the MCU that often goes understated is just how much it took from the comics it is based on that it then greatly improved.
Some of those improvements, like the inclusion of a soundtrack and better visuals, are built into the medium transfer from comics to film, but then there are the bold changes to Marvel's historic continuity. These have been used to fix problems from bygone eras, refresh stale or boring characters to be more interesting, or just to make better creative choices that improve the overall quality of the narrative.
15. Captain Mar-Vell's Identity
While 2019's Captain Marvel is widely regarded as one of the weaker movies in the Marvel Cinematic Universe, it is responsible for some of the most drastic improvements from the comics. And one of the biggest is the change of Captain Mar-Vell.
In the comics, Mar-Vell was a male commander in the Kree military who defected to defend Earth as the first Captain Marvel. During his adventures, he protected Carol Danvers from an explosion and, as a result, she was imbued with a portion of his DNA and attained some of his powers. She took on the moniker Ms. Marvel and later adapted to Captain Marvel when Mar-Vell died. While most of the broader elements of this origin are kept the same, the specifics are greatly changed in the movie.
For starters, Mar-Vell is now a female Kree sent to spy on Earth's burgeoning celestial endeavors. Instead of defecting for Earth, she defects to help the Skrulls, re-imagined as alien refugees, and enlists Carol's help to keep a lightspeed engine from falling into Kree hands. To fulfill her mentor's dying wish, Carol destroys the engine and the resulting explosion gifts her with cosmic powers.
This changes the narrative completely, from a woman stumbling into powers given to her by a man to a woman passing the mantel of a progressive initiative to and empowering a younger successor.
14. Skrulls As Refugees
From their inception, the Skrulls have been one of the most insidious races Stan Lee ever created. Their innate ability to shapeshift made them perfect foes for the Secret Invasion story line and forced readers to retrace their steps trying to figure out when certain characters could have been replaced and what that meant for the continuity. So when it came time to adapt one of the most iconic villains in the comics to film in Captain Marvel, Kevin Feige decided to pull a fast one and subvert the audience's expectations.
Anticipating that they would assume the Skrulls would be the evil alien empire they were in the comics, the film maintained that illusion about two-thirds of the way through, at which point it revealed that the Skrulls were not invading conquerors, but rather fleeing refugees, nearly hunted to extinction because people assumed their powers made them dangerous.
On top of being a great swerve that allowed the grand scheme of the MCU to grow from its source material, this painted a whole new level for it to grow on. It was revealed in the post-credit scene of Spider-Man Far From Home that the Skrulls from Captain Marvel, Talos and Soren, had been impersonating Nick Fury and Maria Hill for an indeterminate amount of time. And since they're good guys in the MCU and can't do Secret Invasion, what does that mean for Phase 4?
13. Civil War Being Understandable
Many comic fans lament the Civil War storyline as a case of lost potential. The massive cross-over event was kicked off with a botched raid on a supervillain safe house that resulted in a mass murder and sparked a discussion in the superhero community about how and if it should be policed. Unfortunately, motives and politics were very poorly handled and things were only getting more convoluted as the battle lines were drawn.
Fortunately, the MCU had the benefit of hindsight and while it touched on the notion of superhero politics with the Sokovia Accords, the focus was quickly drawn to whether or not the Winter Soldier deserved to be protected. The sides were initially separated by their views on the accord, but the actual war started when they were forced to declare their intention to either bringing Bucky to justice for his crimes or protect him in order to stop a greater threat.
And even though it didn't really matter in the end because both sides were being manipulated by Zemo, the emotions that sparked the conflict were still there and, through one final revelation, became much more personal. and led to one last blow off between the principal parties of the war. To date, it's one of the MCU's best stories, in no small part because it was a drastic improvement over the source material.
12. Thanos's Motivation
From his debut, the Mad Titan Thanos has always been one of the single greatest threats of the entire Marvel canon. The self-described Ultimate Nihilist was an alien super-genius, accomplished warlock, and brilliant strategist, and that's without his infamous Infinity Gauntlet. But while he was a terrifying villain in the comics, the MCU did an inarguably better job of presenting his character.
In the comics, Thanos was a once-promising child of the race of Eternals that colonized Titan. However, he threw away his potential in an attempt to woo the esoteric concept of Death, who presented itself to him as a beautiful woman. His love for her drove him to create destructive weapons, conquer worlds, and ignited his crusade to kill as many things as possible as a gift for her.
The movies present a different, more somber Thanos. Instead of trying to court Death, as was hinted in the first Avengers movie, he is motivated by large-scale preservation. He takes an objective view to the problem of overpopulation and sees that the most efficient solution is also the simplest: a massive cull eliminating half of all life in the universe to free up resources and ensure equality throughout the galaxy.
He doesn't see himself as a hopeless romantic, but a reluctant hero who will sacrifice everything, even those he views as family, to save the universe from itself, making him a much more compelling villain.
11. Improved Comedy
To say that comics should be funny is redundant. The first modern comics were humorous pulp strips in newspapers designed to poke fun at politics, culture, and entertainment. However, as the superhero genre became synonymous with the medium, comics have often waylaid humor to be a novelty, almost always playing second fiddle to narrative and character development.
However, adapting these characters and stories to a moving, visual media like film afforded the MCU the ability to make comedy a feature of their content, not a byproduct. Take, for example, Tony Stark in the first Iron Man movie. A lot of his dialogue reads as obnoxious and arrogant, which is very intentional as that is his character at that point in his life.
However, he doesn't come off as unlikable because these lines are delivered by Robert Downey Jr., an actor with impeccable comic timing and a frightening amount of charisma. His confident performance alone brought more laughs in one movie than the Iron Man comics had even attempted to get in decades.
And it quickly expanded from there, with characters who were formerly one-note or almost anti-humor in the comics being repackaged as comedy set-pieces. Sure the comics made jokes over the years, but it never reached the level of mirth and levity that the films provide.
10. The Updated Luke Cage
While the Marvel Netflix shows may be defunct now that Disney+ has formally wedged a massive gap between the two brands, the shows themselves are indeed canon, much to Kevin Fiege's chagrin. Famously, Daredevil, Jessica Jones, Luke Cage, and Punisher were all handled very well and received widespread critical acclaim while Iron Fist and The Defenders were bungled beyond belief and were universally panned.
However, most comic fans agree that the series that truly went above and beyond the call of duty was Luke Cage, mostly because the character has a somewhat tumultuous history in the comics. Debuting at the height of the blaxploitation genre, the original Luke Cage was about as stereotypically African-American as a caricature could get back in 1972. While he was used prominently for a few years, it was always a running gag about how much of parody he was of the blaxploitation archetype and his inability to move past that confining character turned Cage himself into a joke.
Fortunately, Brian Michael Bendis and Heroes for Hire helped to rehabilitate the character decades later, but the comic version of Cage has never fully shaken the stench of his origins. However, Mike Colter's version of the character that debuted in the Jessica Jones series felt wholly authentic, never pandering to a genre or trying to fit an archetypal mold. It was a massive update to the character that completely removed him from his unfortunate debut.
9. More Character Growth
One of Stan Lee's greatest storytelling inventions wasn't a character, but Marvel's famous floating timeline, which allowed decades of comics to exist in a few years worth of continuity while always staying up to date with current events. It was genius move that has arguably done more for Marvel's narrative than any one intellectual property, but it did have an unintended side effect.
Because years worth of comics translated to a much shorter time in the Marvel universe, characters were not able to grow as they properly should. Iron Man, for example, was pretty much the same character he was in mid forties as he was in his mid thirties. Poor Spider-Man went to college, got a job, and got married, all while still being the same nerdy dweeb he'd been in high school.
Fortunately, the MCU has done away with this problem by having the movies largely take place in real time. The Iron Man in Civil War is completely different from the Iron Man that was introduced in his first title movie because since then he battled alcoholism, had a near-death experience in space, retired, and helped build a genocidal AI.
And because he had years to process these events, his character was allowed to grow and change accordingly, something his comic counterpart has never managed to successfully do for very long.
8. Skipping The Hank Pym Problem
Ant-Man has almost always been a problematic character in the comics. The original Ant-Man, Hank Pym, may have been one of the first Avengers, but he was also defined by his domestic violence against his wife Janet and his creation of Ultron. The third Ant-Man, Eric O'Grady, used his shrinking powers to harass women and was described as "irredeemable."
So while it was important that the MCU eventually incorporate Hank Pym in some capacity, he's too important a character to leave out entirely, it was also impossible to imagine a way to make him seem like a hero. Even the comics have failed to present him in a positive light after his actions. Fortunately, the first Ant-Man film found the perfect solution to balance out Hank's problematic elements.
Hank can't be a hero? That's fine, now he's retired and Scott Lang, reformed thief, is taking up the mantel. Don't want to paint him as a wife beater? Okay, Janet is only shown briefly in flashbacks and doesn't make a proper appearance. Don't want to show him as the father of Ultron? That's cool, Age of Ultron has already come and gone and there's no interaction between him and Hank. It was the best way to circumvent what has been a constant, nagging problem in the comics.
7. Moving Away From Norse Mythology
Thor's character in the comics has been some of the most convoluted in Marvel lore. His origin has been retconned multiple times and explained away as either Loki or Odin's manipulations, but one thing has remained constant: a strict and often ironic adherence to the Nordic source material.
While the aesthetics of Asgard were more space-age than the vikings may have imagined, the mannerisms, behavior, language, and relationships of the gods and realms were exactly in accordance to Norse mythology. This includes things like Hela being Loki's daughter, Odin's eight-legged horse being his nephew, Sif being a humble housewife, and the nine realms being physically held together by the world tree Yggdrisil.
The movies wisely made the move to distance themselves to these elements for the sake of both modern conventions and narrative. Loki and Thor are now brothers instead of uncle and nephew to make the dramatic tension between the two more realistic. Sif became a badass warrior because that's more interesting.
Hela became Thor and Loki's long-lost sister because it's easier than explaining how Tom Hiddleston can have Cate Blanchett as a daughter. The nine realms are not separate dimensions united by a physical plant, but just a loose collection of planets scattered throughout space connected by the Bifrost Bridge.
6. Ultron As A Character
Ultron has always been an integral Avengers villain and one of their most iconic foes in the comics. A physical manifestation of their combined hubris, the artificial intelligence designed to safeguard the world in their absence has nearly overthrown the team more than once.
However, despite being so crucial and symbolic in Marvel lore, Ultron himself has never had much of a personality. He is scheming, manipulative, and logical, but these are programmed traits that, unlike the Vision, do not reflect a deeper character. That, along with his origin, was drastically changed and updated in the MCU. Created now by a paranoid Iron Man and an anxious Bruce Banner, the MCU's Ultron was a charismatic sociopath.
In his mission to create peace, Ultron took on more human traits. While he was still a strategist who hid his long-term plans of global annihilation behind his smaller machinations, he was also vindictive, petty, and had a flair for the dramatic. It helped that he was voiced by James Spader, an actor who can play up a character's specific eccentricities like no other.
All in all, the MCU Ultron felt like more of a threat than the comics version because, by virtue of being a character rather than an archetype, he seemed more like a dangerously powerful nihilist than an out of control robot.
5. Power Scaling
Power scaling in superhero comics is often arbitrary because its pointless and vice versa. As long as it makes a modicum of sense, a character's physical strength is always what the writers need it to be depending on the scenario. For example, Hulk might be able to lift a mountain in one comic, but struggle in a fight against the Abomination the next. Thor's strength may be quantifiable and limited, but he can still challenge Galactus the World Eater to single combat.
The MCU takes a much more measured approach to its heroes' power structure by limiting their exposure. In the first Avengers movie, it's shown that Captain America's shield can counter both Thor's Hammer and Iron Man's ark beam and this level of strength has remained consistent throughout the series. Likewise, Hulk is always demonstrated to be one of the most physically powerful being in the Marvel universe, being able to tank his way through bunkers, withstand a barrage of Chitauri lasers, and nearly beating the massive Surtur by himself.
This consistency has helped the MCU to easily build tension where the comics struggled. If Black Widow can take out a room full of men in Avengers but is terrified of Bruce Banner, then the audience knows he's a threat worth taking seriously. Likewise much later when the roles are reversed and the Hulk, a certified powerhouse, is easily brought low by Thanos in the opening minutes of Infinity War.
4. The Mandarin Reveals
At the time, the big Mandarin fake out in Iron Man 3 divided fans. The Mandarin had long been one of Iron Man's most prominent villains in the comics, but had also been a very problematic Asian stereotype. So the reveal that Ben Kingsley's version of the character was actually a propaganda mouthpiece for AIM incensed die-hard fans of the comics who had been anticipating a perfect adaptation delivered by a venerated actor and relieved fans who were concerned about seeing a racist caricature on screen.
But time has been kind to this creative decision and most of the fandom has gotten behind Kingsley's washed up English actor Trevor Slattery, helped in no small part by the hilarious reveal which definitely softened the blow. It was also helped by the one-shot All Hail the King, which revealed that there is in fact a "real" Mandarin hiding in the MCU somewhere and is expected to appear in the Phase 4 Shang-Chi movie.
And while he may present a problem in that film, it was definitely a good idea to skip over him for Iron Man 3. It avoided a bigger controversy, got one of the biggest laughs the MCU ever delivered, and the one-shot hinted that Trevor Slattery might make a reappearance.
3. Star-Lord's Personality
Perhaps the best creative decision that the MCU ever made was hiring James Gunn to direct the Guardians of the Galaxy franchise. The success of Gunn's gonzo filmmaking style paired with the House of Mouse's money opened the doors for the likes of Taika Waititi and Ryan Coogler to make their own unique stamp on the Marvel Studios brand. But it also almost completely reinvented one of the key Guardians.
In the comics, Peter Quill, a.k.a. Star-Lord was a much more advanced person that the character Gunn and Chris Pratt presented in the MCU. He was a grown man who was much more of a straitlaced leader type, like Cyclops or Captain America just in space. But Gunn decided it was better to have the character be in perpetual arrested development, unable to cope with the loss of his mother and using his rogue charm and space-faring adventures to keep himself from processing his own guilt.
It was a much more nuanced take on what had previously been a very stereotypical sci-fi character. Because he was starting from the point of a man-child, Star-Lord was able to grow as a person throughout the subsequent films. And Pratt's great comic acting and Gunn's creative liberties paired brilliantly to create one of the most beloved and human players in the MCU's roster. This was even reflected in the comics, where he changed to his more famous, swashbuckling personality.
2. Hawkeye's Importance
Hawkeye has always been something of an underrated character in the comics. This makes sense because he still uses a bow and arrow in the 21st century and this is supposed to make him as powerful as Iron Man or Thor. While he was always embroiled in major storylines, it wasn't until Matt Fraction and David Aja's exciting makeover of the character in 2012 that the comics started to take him seriously.
However, the MCU has treated him very differently and with a respect that the comics never outright gave him. Though many consider his role as a member of the Avengers to be a joke, the films set him up to be the heart and soul of the team, a central figure who doesn't lead them but is integral to keeping them together. The reveal of him being a family man in Age of Ultron is what motivates the team to rally and the loss of his family during the events of Infinity War made him the driving emotional force behind Endgame.
His brief relationship with Quicksilver was the only thing that ever gave the character any real depth and his dark turn to the Ronin persona was the most impactful way to establish how low the heroes had fallen. He may not have gotten his own movie yet, but the MCU has all but made Hawkeye a crucial player in it's grand narrative.
1. The One And Only Nick Fury
The Nick Fury in the MCU is not actually a representation of the original character in the comics. Debuting in 1963, the original Nick Fury wasn't only a younger, James Bond-style secret agent leading the Howling Commandos squad, but he was also white. So white that when he was represented in a 1988 TV movie, he was played by the Hoff.
The Samuel L. Jackson-based Nick Fury most audiences are familiar with originated in the early 2000s in Marvel's now-defunct Ultimate line, and he remains one of the few good creative choices to come out of that alternate timeline. However, he was never a character in the main Marvel continuity.
Until, that is, he came out in full force during 2012's Avengers. Once Samuel L. Jackson had firmly established that his version, the cool, experienced, and manipulative director of S.H.I.E.L.D. was the superior version, the comics introduced Nick Fury Jr., the white Nick Fury's secret illegitimate son who happened to look an awful lot like the movie version.
There's almost no point in comparing the new and old versions of the character. One was from a pulp era where Cold War spy thrillers could only get so graphic and the other is Samuel L. Jackson if he ran an organization of spies and had a team of superheroes at his beck and call. There's a clear winner between the two.