5 Awesome Ed Norton Performances and 5 That Sucked

There are many great Edward Norton movies out there, but there are also some unfortunate guffs. Don't get angry Ed; we don't like you when you're angry...

Edward Norton came out of absolute nowhere and immediately blew the critic€™s minds as early back as his debut performance. Since then he€™s gone on to star in some of the most popular and successful cult films of the last fifteen years and has risen today to the level of A-list celebrity figure. If Ed Norton is in a film, you know it€™s probably worth watching. Whether he€™s playing a central or supporting role, Norton always brings something to the table, whether that€™s his massive range or his irresistible likeability. That€™s why assembling this list was more difficult than either of the previous lists in this series (the first being Christian Bale and the second being Colin Farrell); when choosing an Ed Norton performance that sucked, you€™re choosing from a decidedly short list. With his recent turn in The Bourne Legacy (which I haven't yet had chance to see, so you'll forgive its absence from this list... I hope), we thought it was about time we took a look back over Norton€™s short career to date, to pick out what we believe to be 5 of his most awesome performances vs. 5 we€™d rather forget €“ we€™re sorry Ed, but there are some, please don€™t get angry. We don€™t like you when you€™re angry. So without further faffing, let€™s hop right to it.

5 Awesome Performances€

5. Rounders (2002)

Norton€™s Character: Lester €˜Worm€™ Burnham Why It Was Awesome: You might have immediately written Rounders off as a niche movie, aimed solely at Poker fans. And while it€™s true, Poker is the dominant motif, the story delves much deeper into the characters than just Kings, Queens and Aces. As Matt Damon€™s ever-present voice over indicates within; you play the player, not the cards. Norton gives a typically fantastic performance here, in a turn that, believe it or not, was inspired by old Bugs Bunny cartoons. Lester is wise-crackin€™ and borderline obnoxious, but with his characteristic knack for duality, Norton somehow fills the guy with an infectious charm, all but forcing us to root for him regardless.

4. Primal Fear (1996)

Norton€™s Character: Aaron Why It Was Awesome: By all accounts Primal Fear is a fairly solid court movie. It follows Richard Gere as a hotshot attorney who agrees to defend a teenager (Norton), who stands accused of murdering a priest. That€™s all well and good, but it€™s not the plot itself that makes Primal Fear a stand-out movie. In fact it€™s Norton€™s own debut performance that makes this legal thriller absolutely unmissable. So good was Edward Norton€™s first ever mainstream Hollywood performance, that he was nominated for best supporting actor at the academy awards that year. In Aaron, he plays an increasingly complex character and it€™s there from where the majority of the film€™s more electrically charged moments emanate. A stunning turn for a then no-namer, which I guarantee the critics didn€™t see coming.

3. 25th Hour (2002)

Norton€™s Character: Monty Brogan Why It Was Awesome: 25th Hour represents Norton in a role to which he€™s most suited in my opinion. It€™s almost a semi-reprise of his astounding turn in American History X; he plays a criminal, a high-earning drug dealer to be exact, who when cornered by the DEA, re-evaluates his choices in life. This movie split the critics down the middle when it was released; some arguing it was vague and self-satisfied, others saying it was Spike Lee€™s best joint in years. Regardless, Norton gives a characteristically thoughtful performance, filled with wit and more than a little hint of regret. It€™s definitely worth the two hours you€™ll give it; not just for Norton, but I can€™t deny, he is a major factor.

2. American History X (1998)

Norton€™s Character: Derek Vinyard Why It Was Awesome: First of all, everyone involved in this masterpiece of a movie, from the Director; to the lead performer; down to the work experience tea-boy, should give themselves a pat on the back. Norton plays Derek Vinyard, a seductive, charismatic white supremacist, who after befriending an African American in prison, attempts to repair the damage his ignorance has done to himself and to his family. Norton really is astounding in his performance here and who knows, if it wasn€™t for the sheer gravitas he was able to bring to the role, maybe the film itself wouldn€™t be considered as excellent as it is. He€™s just so bristling throughout; at first with the venomous, misdirected rage of a Neo-Nazi, but later with an opposing, pity-inducing desperation to repair the damage he€™s caused. Derek Vinyard can€™t have been an easy character to bring to life, but Norton dug deep and managed to turn in one of the defining performances of his career to date.

1. Fight Club (1999)

Norton€™s Character: The Narrator Why It Was Awesome: One word usually epitomizes how most people feel after watching Fight Club €“ David Fincher€™s adrenaline-fuelled adaptation of Chuck Palahnuik€™s novel - for the first time: Wow. You might think you€™re going into an action movie from the title and the trailer alone, but you€™re not. You€™re going in to one of the most vital, irreverent and cerebral comedies available for audience consumption. Yes it€™s a comedy, at heart. It€™s not all outwardly hilarious though; sometimes it€™s shocking, sometimes purposely provocative, sometimes it€™s perverse. But it€™s always, somewhere deep down, pretty damn funny. You might have risked losing a lesser actor into the background by putting him next to Brad Pitt at this stage of his career. And true, Pitt is on fire in Fight Club but Norton somehow steals the show as his exact opposite. Pitt oozes amorality, he€™s alive with passion and he loves a good scrap but Norton is at first unassuming, and plays €˜down-on-his-luck-but-holding-it-together€™ seemingly with complete believability. The coup de grace for Norton though is when he and Pitt€™s Tyler Durden start to bleed together; Norton manages to bring out a venomous, yet masterfully controlled bile from somewhere within himself that literally blows away every other performer that€™s unfortunate enough to share screen time with him, Meatloaf and his bitch-tits included. If you haven€™t seen this movie, what the f*ck are you still doing here? Go, buy it, you will not regret it for a second.

€and 5 That Sucked

5. Pride and Glory (2008)

Norton€™s Character: Ray Tierney Why It Sucked: Pride and Glory is by no means a great movie, yet it€™s not quite a terrible one either. Who knows, if it was made 20 years ago, maybe it€™d have had a different reception, but released in 2008, it was just an all too familiar story. Norton isn€™t exactly terrible here; he just doesn€™t seem to be pushing himself to deliver that killer performance, instead falling back on old cop cliché crutches. Maybe it was the direction, maybe it was the decidedly tepid script; either way, this can€™t be considered even anywhere close to Norton€™s finest hour.

4. Keeping the Faith (2000)

Norton€™s Character: Father Brian Finn Why It Sucked: Again, I€™m not filled with any sort of vengeful hatred for Keeping the Faith, Norton€™s directorial debut. On the other hand, I€™m not particularly enamoured with it either. As a movie examining a love triangle, it€™s decidedly shallow in its definition of love and as a comedy its humour is surprisingly thin on the ground. As well as directing duties, Norton takes the role of one of the central characters. His performance as the hopelessly love-struck priest is good; it's Ed Norton we€™re talking about, he€™s never fully terrible. But it€™s not amazing. It€™s not even great; it€™s just€ good. I€™m not sure I buy Norton in a clean cut comedy setting. I€™d much prefer to see him struggling to contain a violent alter-ego than struggling to make an audience laugh.

3. Death to Smoochy (2002)

Norton€™s Character: Sheldon Mopes / Smoochy the Rhino Why It Sucked: I€™m going to go on record and say that Death to Smoochy isn€™t actually all that bad. It was a complete commercial flop however, netting back only 10 of its $60m budget, and was pretty much universally panned by critics upon its release in 2002. Following Norton as the rising children€™s TV star, Smoochy the Rhino, who€™s unwillingness to play ball with the network lands him as a target for assassination, his performance here is wild and unrestrained, for me echoing elements of The Narrator in Fight Club if he was on Skittles flavoured Prozac. It€™s good for a few belly laughs, but ultimately, Norton €“ and indeed the entire movie €“ was just too strange and inexplicably vacant of emotion to be considered prime viewing.

2. The Invention of Lying (2009)

Norton€™s Character: Cop Why It Sucked: Despite having a terrific sounding comedic cast, which contains some of the cream of modern comedy €“ and Jennifer Garner €“ and boasting a pretty unique premise (in a world without mistruth of any kind, a man invents lying and can€™t seem to stop), The Invention of Lying is decidedly tepid. Alright, maybe Norton was in this movie for all of three minutes so it might be a little unfair to judge (hey, finding bad Norton movies is a difficult task), but I just can€™t imagine why he would have even considered attaching himself to such an uncharacteristic role in such an uncharacteristic movie. He shows up, delivers a little spiel in a thick Massachusetts accent and he€™s gone. And like the movie itself, he makes little to no impact.

1. Stone (2010)

Norton€™s Character:Gerald 'Stone' Creeson Why It Sucked: Edward Norton and Robert De Niro, together in one movie? Awesome right? Wrong. Admittedly some people loved this seemingly never ending character study about a convicted arsonist, his wife and his parole officer, who just can€™t manage to keep it in his pants. Ok, maybe €˜Why It Sucked€™ is a little harsh, but in my eyes, this is definitely one of Norton's more lacklustre performances. His surprisingly restrained performance seemingly builds and builds, but never fully manages to build to that killer moment. And despite De Niro being arguably at his best in years, Stone€™s ultimate surprise is in Milla Jovovich completely stealing the show. Didn€™t see that coming did you? So there you have it; 5 Norton performances that ruled and 5 that drooled. Still, even in the €˜sucked€™ list there are movies that are worth at least a look in. Norton is a phenomenal performer and to be perfectly honest, the fact that he hasn€™t yet won an Oscar boggles the mind. Did we miss anything out? Or did we bad-mouth something unjustly? Do let us know, but be nice won€™t you?

Contributor
Contributor

Stuart believes that the pen is mightier than the sword, but still he insists on using a keyboard.