5 Best Philip K Dick Film Adaptations

More often than not Hollywood proves that it doesn't know dick about Dick but here's five movies that at least got some bits right...

With the fast approaching release of the Total Recall remake (August 3rd) it's only appropriate to take this time to look back at some of the best adaptations of Philip K Dick material to film.

Philip K Dick adaptations have a mixed past. Some have worked brilliantly - not only following the message and theme of the original story but expounding upon it in ways that PKD the man himself would have approved of. But others have failed miserably - abandoning the themes that made Dick famous in favor of shoot-em-up action adventure (I'm looking at you John Woo and Ben Affleck!). More often than not Hollywood proves that it doesn't know dick about Dick!

With that being said, here is my top 5 list of PKD adaptations.

5. A Scanner Darkly (2006)

Based on Philip K Dick's 1977 novel which itself is based very loosely on people that PKD knew and associated with, this novel focuses very heavily on the affects of drug use and the potential consequences for society and individuals in general. This is most evident in the fact that the main character Arctor is not only an undercover cop but he's actually charged with investigating his alias who is a heavy drug user.

The film captures a lot of this confusion perfectly as well as the themes of using the tech and the substances in the original story as a cloak to keep the wool pulled over the viewer's eyes.

The Good: The cast is terrific. Keanu Reeves pulls off confused and brooding well. Woody Harrelson and Robert Downey Jr. are perfect as paranoid stoners. If anything the guys in the cast make Winona Ryder's acting look sub-par.

The Bad: Rotoscoping. Linklater loves it. It is cool for about 5 minutes and then it pulls you out of the story and you realize you are watching a cartoon. Live action with minimal CGI would have made this movie something special.

Written word to film differences: Very few if any.


4. Minority Report (2002)

Based on PKD's 1956 short story THE Minority Report, the film is the story of a future detective agency charged with preventing crime through the use of precognition (Precogs) and the program's leader. Of course not everyone is happy with the thought that people are detained and imprisoned indefinitely when no actual crime was committed. And what about self-determination and fate? If you are foreseen as committing the crime and you know, can you stop yourself?

Both the story and the movie explore these themes although the film version is a bit more heavy handed in its take.

The Good: Exploration of PKD themes. Above average acting all around by the entire cast. The mechanisms of precrime work almost word for word as they do in the book. The mystery and the use of the actual Minority Report was actually done better in the movie.

The Bad: Bubble gum storyline. As is par for the course Spielberg inserts his own brand of feel good tragedy. The entire brooding Anderton storyline - the drugs, the loss of a son, etc. - are all add-ons that were unnecessary. The scene where Anderton is faced with his victim is a HUGE letdown. It's almost the equivalent of having Greedo shoot first in the Cantina - ALMOST. And the happy ending probably had PKD rolling in his grave.

Written word to film differences: Anderton is old and full of self-doubt in the story. In the movie he's Tom Cruise (literally). The son-kidnapping-revenge storyline is specific only to the movie.


3. Total Recall (1990)

Though We Can Remember it for You Wholesale just doesn't have the same ring it was the original title of the 1966 short story. Thus proving once again that PKD is the master of the short form (you'll find 3 adaptations of short stories in this list).

The story revolves around a man who wants to escape his boring day-to-day life so he decides to take a fake trip (a frip?) to Mars. Once the "memory" is implanted into his brain the fun begins. We learn that the protagonist Hauser/Quaid may or may not:

1. Have been to Mars.

2. Acted as a secret agent.

3. Be married to a deadly kickboxing version of Sharon Stone.

The movie is hugely campy and has a bit of a cult following.

The Good: The writers and the director Verhoeven really seem to understand and respect the theme of reality breaking down. The film is fun and clever. And did I mention campy? The best thing about the movie is that by the end you aren't really sure if you just witnessed a false implanted memory or if all of this actually happened in the movie's world. Or was the whole movie just an implant in my head? I just blew my own mind!

The Bad: Unless Schwarzenegger is swinging a battleaxe or trying to kill John Connor he is a horrible actor. He's just bad here and to boot the movie takes a dweeby little immigration clerk (from the story) and turns him into Conan. Half of the fun of the story is watching an everyman try to figure out just what the hell is going on!

Written word to film differences: Quite a bit. But the big one is the ending. If the 2012 version (with Colin Farrell) ends like the story it might move that version to #1 on my list.


2. Blade Runner (1982)

I nearly left this one out of my list for a few reasons. The first reason being that its on everyone's list its so obvious. The other reasons have to do with things left out of the book (Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep). But since PKD glowingly approved of this film (the only adaptation he lived long enough to see) then I can hardly leave it out.

Both stories follow a detective charged with finding and killing perfectly human-like androids who escaped from off-world colonies and returned to Earth. It's never really explained why they come back to Earth but they do. It's also never really explained why they have to be killed (since they have a limited lifespan) but hey its Scifi so we suspend some disbelief.

The movie and the book are very dystopian and the real strength of the moview is that the dystopia is front and center. The story is there but the real story is just how crappy this world is. Most everyone has left Earth because...well its just so crappy. Animals are mostly all extinct thus all the electric sheep dreaming and all.

The Good: Truly a gorgeous film. It's breathtaking and hard to look away. The acting is stellar. Rutger Hauer turns in the performance of his life as the Replicant leader Roy Batty. "I've seen things you people wouldn't believe..." is one of the great lines of cinema. The ending is also ambiguous enough to leave you guessing - exactly on par with PKD.

The Bad: Some of the things left out of the story from the book to movie were detrimental. In the book the motivating factor, the thing that drives Deckard is his pain in the ass wife and his desire to make money to buy her nice electric animals. When your highs are marked by finding a real toad in the wilderness and your lows are marked by discovering its fake then you have serious problems.

The title is also horrible. Nowhere in the book does the phrase "Blade Runner" appear. Deckard doesn't even carry a knife.

The sequel potential. Remember how Matrix: Reloaded made The Matrix less of a movie? Blade Runner doesn't need a sequel but the word is we are getting one.

Written word to film differences: Mostly what I've mentioned above. Thematically they are very similar. The Rachel character is changed pretty dramatically from the book to movie - not necessarily for the worse. Also Deckard has a wife in the book.


1. Screamers (1995)

Again, a very stupidly named adaptation (nowhere in the story The Second Variety will you find the word "screamer") but a great one. The story follows a group of off-world soldiers engaged in a bitter war after the mining operation there went sour. The escalation of the war has grown and grown mostly through the use of self-replication robots (that has fail written all over it!).

One of the things that makes Total Recall so great is what makes Screamers so great. B-movie campiness. This movie is chock full of it. Peter Weller really delivers here. Never at any point when I first watched this movie did I feel like I had a handle on what was coming next. It's space horror before space horror was a genre except instead of a ship there's a whole planet - full of deadly robots who might be the soldier in the bunker next to you or the little orphan kid.

The Good: Peter Weller. Peter Weller. Peter Weller. With lines like this, "Jefferson are you coming or just breathing hard?" what's not to love. The theme of what and who is real is so thoroughly explored here it was nearly exhausting. And no happy endings here.

The Bad: The rest of the cast is pretty horrible. The effects make claymation look like state of the art technology. There are some pretty large plot holes here. But all of this simply adds to the campiness.

Written word to film differences: The short story is based on Earth and is a pretty heavy handed cold-war allegory. Many of the characters are new to the film (mainly for dialogue based exposition).


Contributor

When Jason is not watching films and TV (and writing about them) he can be found in his garden in the southern US.