5 Prometheus Questions We Still Want Answered

Which then becomes questions among questions and suddenly we've got dozens of mysteries that need solving...

Opinion is severely divided on Ridley Scott€™s new sci-fi masterpiece in waiting, "Prometheus". You only have to snatch a quick glance at the number of articles that profligate the internet (and this very website HERE) after only less than a fortnight on general release to see the furry of debates surrounding the film and subsequently the amount of fan boy vitriol that these perfectly genuine opinions incite. There are some €˜givens€™ in Scott€™s "Prometheus", though not that many to hang your hat on. The lack of what we were expecting has appeared to overshadow what we have actually been offered and to some extent, this has riled those that wanted something else. Add to this the fact that what Scott has ended up delivering has been unexpected, shadowy and as graspable as smog and you have dissatisfaction aplenty. From even before the opening credits hit our screens, we all knew this would divide audiences. The casual movie-goer may not be concerned for those elements that I am focusing on here, but this does not make them any less worthy. We deserve a little closure and we didn€™t get it and these are some of the reasons why. Here's some questions about "Prometheus" that we all want answered...

1. Why Did Weyland's Trillion Dollar Project Not Occur Earlier?

It seems that the feasibility of this trek across the heavens to accept an invitation (which, let's be honest, is a bit of a reach) from our possible creators relied solely on the evidence found (somewhat conveniently) in one Scottish cave. Was Weyland only convinced of the validity of the project when this last piece of evidence was found? Did the six other discoveries, all purporting to have the same evidence not convince him? If I was his age, I wouldn't be hanging about, quite frankly. I probably wouldn't have waited. Hell no, I'm certain I would have risked it sometime earlier. Also, just how many caves in Scotland did they search in? They appeared to find the evidence they were looking for rather easily. And why Scotland? Given the locations of the other discoveries, what would make them go looking in the Highlands? They clearly didn€™t get a tip off, as we can see Shaw uncovering the find herself. Did they ply some toothless, kilt-wearing harridan with Bell's finest and hastily scribble down whatever nonsense she came out with? "Oh aye laddie, I remember them etchins', they're in them caves, aye"..

2. Is David Doing A HAL9000?

Michael Fassbender's performance in "Prometheus" is truly something to behold and has been lauded by people far more qualified than me to make decisions on its worthiness in this department. What seems odd are the actions of this state of the art robot. He liked to sniff the flowers and he even wanted to look like Lawrence of Arabia, so there were clearly some vanity bugs in his processor. What struck this reviewer was the similarity to Arthur C Clarke's HAL9000 computer. It received conflicting messages that threw a spanner into its works, sending it doo-lally and subsequently murdered everyone with lips to read. For example, why did David give Holloway the black liquid? Did he know what it would do to him? If so, how did he know? If he did know what it would do to him, why give it to him? Was he annoyed by Holloway's comments? Did he have a given agenda from Weyland? If so, how would Weyland have known the relevance of the black liquid? Why would a robot want to ride a bicycle whilst simultaneously playing basketball? And what is he eating? It looks like rice pudding. Would a robot need rice pudding? Arghh!

3. How Did The Crew Board Prometheus Without Knowing Where They Were Going?

The crew of this trip amounts to seventeen individuals. Given that some of these people were picked by Meredith Vickers (Charlize Theron) for purposes that clearly were not known to the majority of the crew (they discussed a possible terraforming survey prior to the briefing), why only choose one biologist? Furthermore, would you have gone on a four year round trip to a destination unknown? Wouldn't it have made more sense to have a vast army of biologists, knowing that the real purpose of the visit was to potentially meet an alien civilisation, with a wealth of knowledge greater than our own? The project cost a trillion dollars, after all. Could they not have shelled out for a little more professional talent? How did two of the crew get separated and then lost from the rest of them. Prometheus had an elaborate 3D map of the entire ship in which they stood and telecommunications the likes of which we have yet to appreciate ourselves to keep in touch with people. Wasn't the storm the reason they couldn't come back? Why did they leave the group in the first place? Why didn't they go back to the ship, like they said they were going to? Apparently, the geologist didn't feel his services were required, despite travelling for more than two years to get there. Based on this assumption, why did the biologist leave with him, given that is his services were most definitely required?

4. The Weylands?

I can't help but hear MC Hammer playing in the back of my head on a loop - Do what they wanna do, say what they wanna say, live how they wanna live, play how they want to play, the Wey-land Fa-mi-ly. And thinking about it, this bunch of possibly psychopathic overachievers are not too dissimilar to the Addams Family at all. They are certainly scary enough to compete with them. Firstly, why was nobody surprised to find out that Weyland was actually not dead at all, after what they had been told, and also aboard the ship? Did this not strike anyone as odd that they didn't know of it already? If he was alive all along, then why get your holographic double to tell the crew you were dead? And why dress up like Dave Bowman in 2010? It does explain, however, the fact that the holographic image of Weyland seemed to know exactly where Shaw and Holloway were sitting in the briefing, despite his speech allegedly being a recording. Why was it relevant for us to know that Meredith was Weyland's daughter? There was nothing done with this information. Additionally, and this may just be fluffy head-scratching, why didn't David have to wake her from stasis? Everybody else needed to be woken by him. I'm with Idris Elba on this one. I think she's a robot too.

5. The Engineers?

My immediate reaction at the end of the movie was just what the hell was it we did as a species to annoy The Engineers so much? At the beginning of the film, they came across as quite philanthropic, even generous. Granted, they were clearly an ugly bunch with no sense of style in hoodies or any kind of tolerance for a sunny day, but that kind of intelligence really should not, on an apparent whim at least, set about in motion the destruction of a species it itself created just because it turned out to be significantly better looking (not to mention a good deal less aggressive) than they were. Secondly, just why did the holographic recording of the Engineers show them running away from something? What were they supposedly running away from? Was it one of those aliens that ruined the whole film for just about everybody in the final scene? Was it one of those slippery buggers that Shaw inexplicably managed to remove from herself, that somehow grew to unfeasibly outlandish proportions in an unfeasible amount of time? Odd that one god-fearing human could manage to stop what all of these albino hulks could not, even with technology vastly superior to our own. All of this pales into insignificance, of course, when you consider that the Engineers were planning our destruction, but only decided to do this after they had already been back to Earth at least half a dozen times to talk to the Mayans, the Babylonians, the Sumerians, even the Scots etc, in order to encourage these civilizations to scribble their knuckle-dragging monkey paintings on the walls of some insignificant caves. Now call me old-fashioned, but I was under the impression that as a film-maker you should at least attempt to tell an entire story in one sitting. We all know there's going to be a sequel, Ridley Scott admitted as much even before we sat down to it in the UK on the 1st June, but is it fair that we have been left with many more questions than answers? Many people have said that the film suffers because it is all but incoherent. I understand their concerns. On the first viewing, I was left scratching my head like a gibbon presented with a Rubik's Cube, but my faith in Scott as a storyteller was still grounded and solid. By the end of the second viewing, my resolve was shaking a little, less confident but more hopeful that Scott hadn't made a complete turkey. By the end of the third viewing, I have to admit my confidence has returned, though I am a little aggrieved by such an obvious attempt to part me from my hard earned folding money a second time, to achieve closure on a story that should rightfully be over already. Let's be honest about it though, you know you're going to be champing at the bit when the next one comes out. Like it or not, you want the answers, just like I do. Perhaps Scott is not the fool everybody suggests he has become....

Contributor
Contributor

Steve Leadbetter is a 43-year-old father of three, from Manchester, UK. He has been complaining about movies for almost twenty years, but only started writing it all down when he got grumpy, impatient and old. He's worked for several movie sites previously, but has been writing reviews on his new movie blog at http://chocolateraisins.blogspot.co.uk since the start of this year. You can also follow his incessant movie whingings on Twitter @choc_raisins