7 Movie Plot Holes No One Ever Talks About
Why does no one discuss the glaring problem with Harry Potter?
Some movies have obvious and gaping plot holes. Then there are movies that have plot holes that you’ve probably never even noticed, like why didn’t Kevin McCallister just call the police? Why didn’t his mom just call the house? Why did the adults let Fuller have Pepsi right before bed, knowing he’d do an impression of a lawn sprinkler?
So many questions, so few answers.
Here are a few more you’ve probably never even thought of...
7. It Can't Rain All The Time - The Crow
The Crow is the story of rocker Eric Draven and his fiancée, Shelly Webster being murdered violently on Devil’s night, the day before their wedding. A year later, he comes back from the dead, and kills the people who killed him. Fairly straightforward, and an instant classic, matched only by Citizen Kane as one of the best movies ever made.
That doesn’t, however, mean it didn’t have one glaring plot hole. When Eric comes back from the dead, he rescues a young girl from getting run over in the streets. It just so happens this young girl is his old friend, Sarah. During the exchange, he doesn’t let her see his face, causing her a mild agitation. When she complains about the constant rain, he quotes one of his songs saying, “It can’t rain all the time.”
Instead of assuming that this complete stranger was likely just one of Eric’s fans, she immediately believes he’s back from the dead.
But that’s not the only time this happens. When escaping from the pawn shop, he meets Officer Albrecht, the very same officer who investigated Eric’s murder. The conversation leads to talks of Shelly and Eric's deaths, so later Albrecht takes an old band photo of Eric, draws a scribbled couple of lines, and decides “Yep, that is most assuredly the guy who died a year ago that I saw at the pawn shop.” Albrecht didn’t know Eric personally, so he couldn’t have used an excuse like “Well he recognized his voice, maybe.” Instead, this former police detective immediately jumped to resurrection.
More likely options would be:
1. Eric had a twin brother with a flair for the dramatic, who came to town to get revenge for his brother’s murder.
2. One of Eric’s band members did it, seeking revenge for his fallen band mate.
3. One of Eric’s fans did it, seeking revenge for his favorite singer.
But no, everyone simply assumes he’s back. In fact the only person who reacts to this news properly is T-bird. T-bird was the leader of the gang that killed Eric and Shelly to begin with, at the behest of Top Dollar. When Eric knocks off the other embers of the gang, no one says anything about him being there, but when he goes after T-bird, the gangster recognizes him, and says, “I know you. But you cant be you, you died. This is the really real world, you don’t come back in the really real world!” he has a full on meltdown before dying in a blaze of glory.
The funny thing about that is, in the TV series, The Crow: Stairway to Heaven, they actually close that plot hole. At first, Albrecht doesn’t believe that the guy he's caught is really is Eric. When he finally is convinced, he believes that Eric never actually died, and instead faked his death, and had been on the lam for a year. He immediately takes Eric into custody for questioning, believing he had something to do with Shelly’s death. The show had its faults, but it did shore up that hole quite nicely.
6. Where Did The Gas Come From? - Waterworld
This one can really apply to any post-apocalyptic story that had sufficient time pass between apocalypse and the storyline taking place. In the movie Waterworld the world has been covered in water. If you haven’t seen it, look it up, Kevin Costner drinks piss. Good times, good times.
In this movie, everyone is using gas powered engines for everything. There’s a problem with that. Who is drilling for oil, and processing it into gas? Gasoline has, at best, a shelf life of about six months, and that’s when it’s been kept in the best of conditions.
Say what you will, but it’s highly unlikely that there’s anyone out there doing all that.
5. King Kong Villagers Build Giant Door For No Reason (1933)
Imagine, if you will, you’re a villager, on a small, skull shaped island. On your island are giant monsters, including tyrannosaurus rexes, brontosauruses, stegosauruses, and a massive gorilla, which you treat as a god named Kong.
These monsters are dangerous, and wreck your village with regularity, so you and your fellow villagers build a wall big and strong enough to keep those monsters away from your little neck of the beach. Now, you know you need a door to get through the wall, because on the other side of the wall is all the food and prey you and your people need to feed yourselves.
Now, you have a choice right now. You and your villagers are the only people who need to get through the door, so how big do you build it? Now, logically, you would say, “no bigger than a normal door.” And that alone makes you much, much smarter than the people who built this wall.
What the villagers of Skull Island did was build doors the exact height and width of the giant gorilla god they wanted to keep out. Why would you do that? Why would you even think that was a good idea? Hint, it wasn’t!
They were squished horribly after he knocked the doors open. Seems like building a giant wall to keep out the things you don’t like wasn’t a good plan. *CoughTrumpCough*
4. Why Didn't The Witch Tell Dorothy About The Shoes Earlier? Wizard Of Oz (1939)
In the movie version of the story, starring Judy Garland, the good witch of the north tells Dorothy to take the ruby slippers, and head to the emerald city. A lot happens, and in the end, Dorothy finds out that didn’t work too well for her.
The witch shows up again and says “Oh, you coulda gone home whenever you wanted, your shoes could have sent you home, LOL. #sorrynotsorry.”
Why didn’t she tell Dorothy about the shoes from the get-go? What, was she hoping Dorothy would be able to off her colleague to the west? It made her look like either the biggest !*$%, or the dumbest witch ever.
Thing is, in the greatest series of books ever, The Wizard of Oz, it was two separate witches that told Dorothy what to do. The unnamed witch of the north sent Dorothy to the emerald city, while Glinda, the witch of the south, told her that her silver shoes had the power to send her home. Splitting the characters makes the first witch’s ignorance of the power of the shoes understandable.
3. How Is The Factory Still Running? - Charlie And The Chocolate Factory (2005)
How is this factory still running? Before even the kids arrived, that factory should have been shut down. Depending on where the story takes place, either the MHRA or the FDA should have been checking that factory regularly to ensure safe practices and standards for production.
The first visit from an agent, and BOOM! shut down.
Agent: So, you have squirrels shelling your nuts for you?
Wonka: Yes, they’re very efficient, and have been trained for this specifically.
Agent: You have literal rodents, vermin, handling your food? Food people eat?
Wonka: Uh-huh!
Agent: And earlier, I saw you have unpaid villagers from some rain forest doing all the work?
Wonka: Yes, the Oompa Loompas. I saved them from the vermicious knids.
Agent: Riiight, and you ride a boat around in your chocolate, yes?
Wonka: Isn’t it wonderful?
Agent: Riiight, so, you’re shut down forever. Never give your chocolates to another living soul, you horrible slave driving, vermin employing, chocolate polluting monster.
2. Men In Black III Didn't Really Need To Be So Complicated
The basic plot of MIB3 was that Agent J, caught in the past, had to help a young Agent K get a small device into orbit. This device would ensure that the Earth was protected from threats in the future.
The problem? They had no way to get it to space without using a NASA rocket. They succeed, and the timeline is saved. See, it had already happened in the past, so K just needed to make sure it still happens, because a villain from the future went back to change it, and man, this was a convoluted plot.
There’s a bit wrong with all that. Namely, you’re an organization that deals with aliens and alien immigration. It’s not beyond the realm of believable that there are a few interstellar spaceships on Earth at the time of the story. How hard would it have been to call in a favor or two? “Hey, Zxytlpok, we were wondering if we could borrow your ship for a bit, we need to make a quick trip to the atmosphere real fast, is that cool?”
Hell, isn’t it entirely likely there would have been an agent of the MIB that would have been an alien themselves? Or even some kind of interstellar organization that transported aliens to or from Earth, like some kind of space bus?
But no, lets hinge the safety of earth on an unproven NASA rocket. Good job, MIB, really… stellar.
1. Harry Potter And The Goblet Of Fire
Oh the comment section should be fun for this one.
Harry Potter’s fourth installment is possibly the absolute worst in the series. It’s completely different from the rest of the books. The other six were equal parts mystery, wonder, suspense, and celebration. Goblet was just a painfully long action movie, with very little of the other elements. Then there’s the giant, throbbing plot hole.
Barty Crouch, in the guise of Mad Eye Moody, has a job. He has to get Harry to Volde- uh, he-who-must-not-be-named. To do this, he bewitches the Triwizard Cup to become a portkey, then makes damn sure Harry touches it. This is all planned out by you-know-hissle, and his plan goes off with only one hitch, Cedric Diggory touches it too.
But why go through all that? Why not bewitch a quill, a shoe, or any other thing, call Harry to his office, toss it at him, and go about his day? Why risk Harry not being the first to the cup? Why did Crouch make Harry a better fighter along the way? Why not just send him to you-know-who, let the real moody out of his trunk, and skip town? Hell, he could have let the weakened moody out, left behind his stuff, and rode the portkey with Harry, and been showered with praise and adoration by no-nose-snakey-face forever.
And while we’re on the subject of the portkey, why did he make it a two-way key? We never see that anywhere else, unless it’s on a timer, like the ones for the Quidditch World Cup. Every other portkey is one-way, such as the ones the order uses in the beginning of Deathly Hallows, to get from the order homes to the Burrow. Moldy-wart was absolutely the worst plan maker ever.
Or was he? Maybe, just maybe, Crouch had actually pulled a Regulus Black, and turned on chalk-white-bald-boy, and went through this ridiculous setup to ensure Harry was as prepared as he could possibly be to face you-know-who. Maybe he made the key two-way to ensure he’d have a way to get back to Hogwarts. Maybe his constant drilling on defending against the dark arts was to make Harry a better soldier in the war on the Death Eaters. Who knows?