8 Most Unexplainable Horror Movie Moments

What just happened couldn't have really happened... could it have?

The Ring
DreamWorks

Horror movies, by their very nature, require viewers to suspend their disbelief, as they are routinely inexplicable. After all, would a couple of teens really wander into an abandoned warehouse in the middle of the night only to split up when they first hear some frightening noises?

Of course, they wouldn't, but the average victim in a horror movie must exist in an alternate reality where horror movies aren't a thing. Still, suspending our disbelief only covers so much, as some scenes require more than a simple suspension of disbelief; some scenes either don't make sense, or they defy explanation.

That's not to say the scenes didn't work for the movies they were in, nor does it mean the movie itself wasn't extraordinary. All it truly means is that a rewatch of a film might make a viewer do a double-take after seeing a scene or moment in a horror movie that is never fully explained.

Once the credits roll, that's it, so if the scene in question remains unexplained, it tends to stick with the viewer. Did what happen really happen, or was it something unintentional on the part of the filmmakers? Either answer may be true in these eight films that contained some truly unexplainable moments.

8. The Random Sheep In 'A Nightmare On Elm Street'

A Nightmare On Elm Street Sheep
New Line Cinema

In the opening scene of A Nightmare on Elm Street, Tina is walking through the boiler room while being stalked by a shadowy disfigured man we now know as Freddy Kreuger. While she's in the building, a sheep runs across her path, and leaves the shot, but doesn't reappear at any time.

It's small, and hardly the most mind-bending aspect of the film, but it piqued enough interest from fans to have people still talking about it decades later. What was the sheep for, and how did it get there? Did it represent something about falling asleep in the same way people 'count sheep' to pass out?

There was no indication, and viewers were left wondering what it was there for. Since the movie's release, fans have speculated that the sheep could represent innocence in Tina, and she was walking to her death in much the same way a lamb is led to slaughter.

Whatever it was supposed to represent may have been lost, but there is a rumor that the original script for the film states that "there is no reason for this," and the sheep may have been nothing more than a surreal visual addition to indicate Tina was in a dream.


7. The The Psychic Connection In 'Signs'

Signs Mel Gibson
Buena Vista Pictures

Signs isn't M. Night Shyamalan's greatest movie, but it does get a lot of things right where suspense and jump scares are concerned. The basic premise of the film revolves around a series of crop circles having to do with an imminent alien invasion.

Shoot to the end of the film, and Joaquin Phoenix's Merrill Hess uses a baseball bat to hit glasses of water while pummeling an alien. The glasses had been placing all around the house by one of the kids throughout the film. Doing this causes water to splash all over the aliens, causing them harm.

Ok, so the premise doesn't make a lot of sense, but if you can get over the fact that aliens opted to invade a planet that was literally covered with water (acid as far as they were concerned), it's not a bad flick. The only problem with it had to do with the connection between the kid, the water, and Merrill, which didn't exactly add up.

Earlier in the film, there were hints of a psychic prognostication related to the water, the aliens, and Merrill's use of the bat, but this was never explained. Theories have cropped up online that Signs may be an allegory about the battle between good vs. evil, and one man's struggle through the extremes of his faith, using the movie's connection to Christianity to explain the connection. While that may be true of Shyamalan's intent, the movie's ambiguity leaves it open to interpretation by not explaining it outright.


6. The Nazi Dream Sequence In 'An American Werewolf In London'

An American Werewolf in London Nazi Dream
Universal Pictures

In An American Werewolf in London, David Kessler's vacation goes a little off the rails when he stumbles across the Yorkshire moors. As soon as he and his buddy wind up off the beaten path, they are attacked by a werewolf. Only David survives the ordeal with a nasty scratch, and he winds up in the hospital.

After he wakes up in a London hospital, he doesn't fully remember what happened, and while he was definitely infected with lycanthropy, he wouldn't turn until the next full moon. This left him a solid month to recover and woo his nurse.

Throughout the month, he's plagued by horrible nightmares, which are disturbing, and somewhat inexplicable, as they don't make much sense. The worst being the one that starts with him in his home in the States, working on his college homework while his family is watching TV. The viewer doesn't immediately know it's a dream, but it becomes clear pretty quickly.

A squad of mutant Nazi monsters storm the house and kills David's family. They then burn his home, destroying everything, which is when he sits up in the hospital bed. It was a dream, and the nurse opens the curtains, but she's quickly stabbed to death, and David has his throat slit.

It's a wildly crazy dream, and it's full of jump scares, but other than that, it's surreal, strange, and inexplicable.


5. The Egg Chamber Blue Light In 'Alien'

Alien Egg Chamber
20th Century Fox

Alien is one of the best science-fiction horror movies ever made, and if there's one thing the movie gets right, it's the building of tension on a grand scale. When the crew of the Nostromo are woken up from their stasis chambers, they move to investigate a distress signal coming from a nearby moon, and all hell breaks loose.

They find an ancient alien spacecraft primed for exploration. There's no telling how long the ship has been there, and the only indication is a dead alien sitting in a large chair in the center of a massive room. Deeper inside the ship, Kane discovers a chamber filled with eggs.

The chamber is sectioned off with a blue light, which he breaks through to get a closer look. Doing so appears to trigger one of the eggs into motion, and as he investigates, a facehugger alien rushes from the egg and attaches to his face.

We all know what happens after that, but we don't know much about the egg chamber. The blue light is a distinctive feature of the scene; yet, the movie doesn't explain how an ancient spacecraft devoid of all power has what appears to be a still-functioning lighting system. More than that, it's not clear what it is ⁠— is it containing the eggs, or is it being used for ambiance? Who knows?

The only thing we know for certain about the blue light is that it was provided by The Who, but that doesn't do much for explaining the scene.


4. Ray's Supernatural Sexcapades In 'Ghostbusters'

Ray Ghostbusters Ghost
Columbia Pictures

Ghostbusters isn't a typical horror movie, and above all else, it's a comedy with a ton of supernatural elements. That being said, there are plenty of scenes in the movie that are added for jump scares, gore, and more. Most of the movie is explainable as movie logic, but there's one inexplicable scene that stands apart from the rest of the film.

After the Ghostbusters begin their rise to fame, the viewer is treated to a montage of their work, and the effect they have on the people of New York City. In one scene, a ghost appears in the form of a beautiful woman above Ray's bed.

While he's initially startled by what he sees, it doesn't take long for the so-called Ghostbuster to sit back and relax as the ghost vanishes and removes his belt and pants. You can fill in the blanks on what happens after his eyes rolled into the back of his head.

So, it's a supernatural sexcapade, but it doesn't add up. Since when do ghosts appear and have sex with Ghostbusters? While this is a comedy, first and foremost, it doesn't track with the rest of the movie, which is arguably a family-friendly flick.


3. The Uninvited Guest In 'Sunshine'

Pinbacker Sunshine
Fox Searchlight Pictures

Danny Boyle's Sunshine is an excellent science-fiction film about a desperate mission to reignite the sun to save humanity. The film follows a lot of real science, which makes it technically well-done, but that's only through the first two acts. When they slingshot past Mercury, the genre switches from sci-fi to a thriller.

The crew located the Icarus I, which was the first mission sent to reignite the sun, only it disappeared seven years earlier. Figuring they had a better chance at accomplishing their mission if they used the other ship's payload, they opted to go across, but things don't go well.

Various accidents begin happening all over the ship, and some of the astronauts are killed. It's later revealed that a new person has boarded the ship. It turns out to be Captain Pinbacker, the commander of the Icarus I, and he's gone insane... homicidally insane. There's more killing and death, and by the end of the film, the mission is a success.

Going back to the part where a single person was able to survive aboard a spacecraft alone for seven years, all the while being burned from close exposure to the sun and having gone completely batty ⁠— that doesn't seem possible. There's no explanation for how he survived for so long on his own, and while his insanity makes sense, his being alive doesn't.


2. Danny's Hallway Ride In 'The Shining'

The Shining Hallway Twins Big Wheel
Warner Bros.

Stanley Kubrick was a masterful storyteller, and his library of films have little to no problems in them at all. The man was a perfectionist (as any actor who worked with him will attest), and he didn't make mistakes. Since that's typically how his movies turned out, when there is something odd, it stands out.

In The Shining, the infamous hallway scene sees Danny riding his Big Wheel around the hotel until he turns a corner to find two twin girls at the end of the hallway. They beckon him to come on over and play, but they shouldn't be there, and it's seriously creepy.

Regardless, the scene was important for the movie, and it's one of those scenes that sticks with a viewer decades after seeing the film. That being said, there is a problem with it, and it's unclear if it was a mistake or done to confuse viewers.

If you were paying attention, Danny started out on the first floor, but after he turns a corner, he's somehow on the fourth floor of the Overlook Hotel. Basically, he couldn't have ridden his Big Wheel the way he did, and rewatching the scene offers up some confusing images that don't explain how he managed to get up there in front of the twins.


1. The Fly & Nosebleed Scene In 'The Ring'

The Ring
DreamWorks Pictures

The Ring offered an interesting take on cursed items by using a strange videotape in lieu of an artifact or supernatural item. When a character watched the tape, they were then called on the telephone, and a strange voice whispers "Seven days," without any additional information. Essentially, the viewer had a week to live after watching the tape.

When Rachel Keller finds the tape and receives the phone call, she dives into it with an investigation to try and ascertain what all of the strange imagery might mean. She's also interested in finding a way to break the curse, which she eventually does by making a copy.

When she's reviewing the tape closely, she gets to a scene that has a fly walking about the glass, as if it's in the video as well as the real world. She pays close attention to the fly, and as she scrutinizes the insect, she reaches toward the screen and plucks it from the tape.

When she does this, her nose begins to bleed, and the creep-factor shoots through the roof. While this was an enticing and frightening visual, it wasn't explained in any real way. Sure, it's a cursed videotape that leads to the viewer's death, but it shouldn't allow for such an impossible act without some explanation.


Watch Next


The Scariest Horror Movie Quiz You Need To Try!

Hellbound Hellraiser II 20
Cinemarque Entertainment BV

1. Exactly How Many Pins Are There In Pinhead's Head?

Contributor
Contributor

Jonathan is a graphic artist, illustrator, writer, and game designer. Jonathan retired from the U.S. Army in 2017 and enjoys researching and writing about history, science, theology, and many other subjects. He writes for ScreenRant, CBR, NerdBastards, Listverse, Ranker, WhatCulture, and many other sites online. You can check out his latest on Twitter: @TalkingBull or on his blog: jonathanhkantor.com