8 Problems With John Wick No-One Wants To Admit
Hollywood's most overrated franchise today?
2014's John Wick was the little film that could. It was a reasonably low-budget action film that no-one expected much from, but it did extremely well and has now spawned a beloved and highly successful franchise that's not only among the most acclaimed Hollywood franchises today, but one that pretty much relaunched the career of its star, Keanu Reeves.
But is this deserved?
It is undeniable that the John Wick films have plenty going for them. The world-building is superb, the cinematography is brilliant, the sound design and soundtrack are strong and they are well-made, but it's also arguable that these movies are considerably less strong than their critical reception suggests.
Obviously, this won't be a popular opinion and each to their own, but it does feel like the franchise has got away with a lot of mistakes that other Hollywood films get criticised for all the time, which makes the popularity of these movies feel surprising to say the least.
As the franchise continues to expand, with both a spin-off and a TV series lined-up, hopefully it'll soon fix these mistakes and fully earn its lofty critical standing...
8. The Tone Is Very Inconsistent
Firstly, what is the tone that franchise writer Derek Kolstad is going for? It's often very confusing.
A lot of the time, the John Wick trilogy is very dark, especially with John Wick losing his beloved wife shortly before the first film starts... but then, the movies are also frequently very silly and are filled with dark humour.
After all, this is the franchise where a man kills tens of people over a murdered dog, a stolen car and his house being burnt down and there are lots of ridiculous moments, especially in Chapter 3 (John Wick falling from the roof of a tall hotel and surviving lingers in the memory).
There's nothing particularly wrong with being over-the-top, but this franchise doesn't have a hint of self-awareness. It plays everything straight and po-faced and the films are ludicrous without ever being charming in a thoroughly jarring manner. Speaking of silliness, that leads right onto the next point.
7. So... How Does This Secret Society Work?
As cool as the world-building in the John Wick films is, there are a Lot of things which make no sense.
Everyone in New York seems to be involved with the society, especially at the end of Chapter 2 where everyone present in Central Park seemed to be answering to Winston (Ian McShane), and at the start of the third film a random taxi driver and a random homeless man were also members. Not only this, but John magically knew they were involved... somehow.
Additionally, the entire thing is apparently overseen by the Elder, some guy who sits in a tent in the middle of the desert. How on earth can he oversee anything from there? Oh, and what about the way in which no bystanders ever react to the fights going on, even when they're occurring in the crowded New York Central Station? All of this is just thoroughly implausible.
There was also that bizarre scene in Chapter 2 involving a bank run by Jewish caricatures, which felt like antisemitism on the film's part.
6. Most Of The Cast Is Wasted
All things considered, this trilogy does have an Incredible cast. Aside from Keanu Reeves, there's Ian McShane, Willem Dafoe, Laurence Fishburne, Halle Berry, Anjelica Huston, John Leguizamo, Game of Thrones' Alfie Allen and Jerome Flynn, The Wire's Lance Reddick and even the late Michael Nyqvist. And... almost all of them are wasted.
None of them do anything wrong exactly, but most of them are given nothing to do and simply carry out largely undemanding parts. In particular, Willem Dafoe was criminally under-used in a nothing role in the first film and only Ian McShane has ever really made his mark, although that was undermined by his nonsensical switch to villainy at the end of the third film.
It is tragic that a franchise which does not deserve this cast at all has roped so many fine actors in only to have them doing so little. Speaking of performances, there have been some pretty underwhelming supporting parts as well, most notably from Common, Ruby Rose, Asia Kate Dillon and Mark Dacascos.
5. The Villains Are Awful
In terms of villains, the John Wick films are incredibly underwhelming.
The exception is the first film's Iosef Tarasov, who was a good side-villain but to be honest that was more thanks to the still-underrated Alfie Allen's stellar performance than anything else.
Throughout the trilogy the pattern is the same: a caricature foreign guy is the main antagonist. In the first film, it's a stereotypical Russian gangster. In the second film, it's a stereotypical Spanish gangster. In the third film, it's a stereotypical bald Asian martial artist.
All three of these villains are uninteresting characters, especially Chapter 3's Zero, who's definitely the worst of the bunch. In fairness, Michael Nyqvist and Riccardo Scamarcio did OK work as Viggo Tarasov and Santino D'Antonio in the first and second films respectively but Mark Dacascos gave a very wooden performance as Zero. Chapter 3 also boasted the Adjudicator (Asia Kate Dillon), a member of the High Table (the body governing the entire organisation of assassins), who was also a dull villain played poorly by Dillon.
The side henchmen are never interesting either and are always killed by Wick before they can make an impact anyhow.
4. John Wick Isn't An Interesting Character
John Wick has some things going for him as a character. While he seems like a great guy Keanu Reeves is an often-wooden actor but he is good as Wick, while the stuff about his wife dying was moving and the first film did a very good job at creating a sense of him being a legend and getting audiences invested despite it being half an hour before Wick actually picks up a gun. But, is he an interesting character? In the first film, yes, but subsequently, arguably not.
John Wick is a blank, indestructible superman figure who is never in the slightest bit of danger and lacks any real personality. Whatever situation he's in he'll always emerge with barely a scratch. He's a ridiculously overpowered character without any suspense attached to him, so it's impossible to get invested in anything he does since we already know the outcome.
He's also, let's face it, a psychopath who kills scores of people without ever giving a damn, so he's getting harder and harder to like with each movie.
3. The Scripts Are Garbage
OK, fine, no-one goes to see the John Wick films for the writing, but the scripts are weak for the most part.
The world-building is great, but take that out of the equation and it's hard to call these movies well-written. All three of the films have flat dialogue, no real character development (for the most part) and lack charm, warmth, soul or true emotional connection of any kind.
They're just empty as hell and while many great action films are, all things considered, pretty soulless in some ways, they will usually counter-balance that by being charming and likeable. Unfortunately, likeability is non-existent in John Wick. It's just death scene after death scene after death scene.
2. The Franchise Is No Better Than Other Hollywood Action Films
Film critics get a lot of flak these days and while that actually isn't fair at all (they're usually quite trustworthy), cases like the John Wick films do undermine their credibility.
The John Wick films are talked about as if they're an antidote to the average Hollywood action film and that's simply not true. What are some of the main problems with (some, though not all) Hollywood action movies today? They don't have any tension, they lack any substance, the villains are underwhelming, the main character is invulnerable... the John Wick films tick all of those boxes.
It is true that the cinematography is better than in other modern action films while the martial arts-based action sequences are unique for this era and the R rating certainly adds plenty, so in a handful of areas John Wick is superior to other modern action films. Nevertheless, with the terrible writing and complete lack of suspense that plagues all three of the films, they really aren't anything new or superior in the grand scheme of things.
So, the fact that these movies get such positive reviews when they make SO many mistakes that other action movies get attacked for doesn't feel very fair.
1. The Action Sequences Have Zero Tension
Finally, here's the number one problem with John Wick: there's no tension. At all.
The film's action sequences are exciting at first glance since they're directed with smoothness and clarity, with the shaky-cam that's often plagued Hollywood films nowhere to be seen, and the action scenes are often very inventive and nice to look at. That being said, a good action sequence needs to have suspense and danger, which is something entirely absent here.
In every fight scene, John Wick takes on every bad guy with no difficulty whatsoever and is completely indestructible. You could put John Wick in a large, empty room with 200 armed assassins and you'd know perfectly well that he'd still survive with hardly any injuries at all. There are never any stakes and watching the film's well-choreographed martial arts is initially fun but it gets stale remarkably fast.
This isn't to say that the action scenes are bad since they are undeniably very well-made, but they're also arguably very flawed and ensure that the John Wick trilogy is not as thrilling as the hype machine proclaims.