8 Smartest Decisions Made By Saw Characters
The smartest decisions in the Saw franchise!
In order for a lot of horror movies to work, the main characters have to be a little bit on the dim side, to put it nicely.
After all, when audiences watch one of these flicks, they expect to see a bit of blood, a few guts, and a lot of death, which is why we get moron protagonists that stroll into abandoned buildings at night, have sex in the middle of the woods (also at night), and wander off on their own when they're being chased by serial killers.
The Saw series is no exception here, and across its nearly 20-year history, there have been plenty of dumb moments that left fans scratching their heads. But every so often, certain characters exhibit moments of genuine wit and quick thinking, putting their noggins to good use to outsmart deadly situations, or devise cunning plans.
Now sure, some of these characters ended up dying later on - not surprising, considering the franchise they're in - but regardless, we shall fondly remember these moments as being some of the smarter decisions made within the Saw universe.
8. Eric Matthews Escapes His Shackles (Saw III)
The moment in the original Saw movie where Lawrence Gordon chops off his foot in order to escape his shackles is one of the most iconic scenes in horror movie history - but that wasn't the best way for him to deal with his rather sticky situation.
The best way was demonstrated a couple of movies later by Eric Matthews, who, at the end of Saw II, finds himself shackled up just like Gordon was. Skip ahead to Saw III, and Matthews is seen trying to set himself free: he kicks at the pipe that he's attached to, and uses a hacksaw to try and cut through his chains, but to no avail.
Coming to the conclusion that he's going to have to hurt himself in order to escape, Matthews initially thinks about 'pulling a Gordon' by chopping off his foot, before realising that there's a smarter way for him to go about things. Grabbing a nearby toilet tank lid, he breaks his foot by smashing it several times, which makes it flexible enough (for lack of a better term) to pull from the shackles.
Sure, chopping off your foot or smashing it to bits are probably on equal levels in terms of pain, but at least Matthews' method allowed him to keep all of his limbs attached to his body and not risk quickly bleeding out.
7. Hoffman Tricks Strahm Into Signing His Own Death Warrant (Saw V)
Peter Strahm is one of the most likeable characters in the Saw franchise, and, overall, he's also quite intelligent too - something we'll touch on later.
But in this particular instance... he got played like an absolute fool.
After figuring out that Mark Hoffman has committed several grisly murders, Strahm decides to bring this reign of terror to an end. Following Hoffman to an underground tunnel network, Strahm eventually finds a room with a large glass coffin in the centre, inside of which is a tape recorder.
Upon playing this recorder, Strahm hears a message left for him by Hoffman: if he climbs inside the coffin, he will live, and if he doesn't, he will die. It's a simple little game, but since Strahm knows that Hoffman is a murderer, he isn't just going to climb inside a small glass box for no good reason - so he doesn't.
Seems like a smart move, because that coffin is clearly a deathtrap, right? Well, no. After a brief scuffle, it's Hoffman who ends up inside the coffin, at which point it's revealed that he was actually telling the truth: the coffin was safe all along.
This results in Strahm being crushed to death, while Hoffman, lying inside the coffin, is lowered out of harm's way. Since Hoffman wanted Strahm dead, you could argue that there were easier ways to go about this, but tricking him into rejecting the coffin was still a cunning, cold, and well-calculated move.
6. Emily Uses Her Children As A Survival Tactic (Saw VI)
The shotgun carousel in Saw VI is one of the simpler traps in the series, with the victims not having to sacrifice any blood or flesh in order to survive. Instead, they just sit there and spin round and round in circles, while their survival is determined entirely by one man: William Easton.
Every so often, the carousel will stop, placing one of the six victims in front of a loaded shotgun. At this point, Easton can press two buttons to make the shotgun fire upwards, sparing that particular victim's life. On the downside, he can only do this twice, meaning that four people will eventually die.
Upon learning these rules, the victims naturally start yelling their heads off, pleading with Easton to save them. But rather than pleading via purely selfish means, Emily decides to try a different, smarter tactic instead: she reminds Easton of her children.
When the shotgun is in front of her, Emily tells Easton that her kids can't grow up without her, and this resonates with Easton, who decides to save her. Demonstrating how smart Emily's tactic was, the other victims then start copying her, using non-selfish pleas like 'my parents are ill!' and 'I'm pregnant!' even though it's not clear whether these claims are actually true.
While you could say that this was an obvious move to make on Emily's part, she played the game perfectly regardless - which her survival proves.
5. Brad And Ryan Turn On Dina (Saw 3D)
One of the most frustrating things about horror movies is when the lead characters split up for no good reason, only for them to be picked off one-by-one by a masked, knife-wielding maniac. Why don't they just stick together instead? After all, who stands a better chance of winning? One burly serial killer against one feeble teenager, or one burly serial killer against ten feeble teenagers?
As the extremely cheesy saying goes 'teamwork makes the dream work', and the opening of Saw 3D demonstrates just how true this is, with Brad and Ryan ensuring their survival by actually working together.
At the start of the movie, both men find themselves in a Jigsaw trap alongside their mutual lover, Dina, who has basically been playing them both. The trap is simple: Brad and Ryan can push saw blades towards each other so that one of them will die, or, they can let Dina be killed by a saw blade instead.
Initially, Brad and Ryan try to kill each other, while Dina spurs them on by declaring her love for whoever seems to be winning. However, Brad and Ryan soon realise that Dina is a liar and a cheat trying to get either of them killed, and decide that she isn't worth either of their lives. In a smart move, they agree that she should be the one to die.
Ridding themselves of a toxic relationship, and saving both their lives? Obviously this wasn't a smart move from Dina's point of view, but it certainly was for the two blokes!
4. Simone Chops Off Her Arm (Saw VI)
When Simone and Eddie are locked in a room in Saw VI and told to cut off chunks of their own flesh, they both go about that gruesome task in two completely different ways, and in the end, Simone's method proves to be the much smarter play.
Being a bit on the chunky side, Eddie starts cutting small pieces of flesh right off his flabby stomach, which isn't very efficient. Not that there's a simple or easy way to mutilate yourself, but if we look at things rationally, Eddie's fleshy chunks are pretty small, and they take a lot of time (and pain) to remove.
Simone initially tries a similar method, aiming to slice off small chunks of flesh (in her case, her fingers) to tip the scales in her favour. But when she's unable to go through with this, she eventually says 'to hell with it' and decides to lop off a huge amount of flesh in one big chunk - her left arm.
Yes, it's still painful as hell, and yes, she has to sacrifice an entire arm, but it's undeniable that taking an 'all in one go' approach is far better than chipping away at your body in small pieces. Just look at Eddie, who methodically tried to remove small lumps of stomach blubber, when he could've just chopped off his arm with a few brief swings and won right away. Poor guy.
3. Strahm's Tracheotomy (Saw V)
While most traps in the Saw series have some clear way to escape them (usually a painful way, but still, it's better than nothing) the trap that Peter Strahm finds himself in at the start of Saw V is the exact opposite.
Left alone in a room with a cube-shaped box around his head, Strahm is forced to watch as his miniature prison slowly fills up with water. He has no phone, no keys, and no weapons of any kind. It's a pretty dire situation.
This feeling of helplessness is amplified when the box is completely filled with water, and Strahm starts to drown. With no way out, it looks like he's done for, but at the very last second, he finds a pen in his pocket and rams it into his throat, giving himself a tube through which he can breathe.
It's a moment of pure genius, especially considering how little time Strahm had to work out a plan. Pretty bloody lucky he had that pen on him, too!
2. Hoffman Survives The Reverse Beartrap (Saw VI)
Just like Strahm, Mark Hoffman was placed into a supposedly unwinnable situation at the climax of Saw VI, only this one was set to have a much more grisly outcome.
After being captured by John Kramer's ex-wife Jill, Hoffman is strapped to a chair, and has a reverse beartrap attached to his head. While it's normally possible to escape this particular trap - like when Amanda Young used a key in the original film - Hoffman is basically left for dead, and it's only with some smart, out-of-the-box thinking that he's able to escape the trap with his head intact. Mostly.
After using the beartrap to smash his hand to pieces - allowing him to slip it out of the straps on the chair - Hoffman enters a blind panic, frantically trying to use a screwdriver to set himself free. However, this effort fails miserably.
Then, just as it looks like it's game over, Hoffman decides to ram the front part of the trap in-between the bars located on the door, preventing it from springing open and tearing his head apart. He then has to pull his head out of the trap, sustaining some serious injuries in the process. But crucially, he's alive.
This is another moment of pure genius, with Hoffman able to survive a nearly impossible situation with some truly brilliant thinking. The vast majority of people would have died here, but Hoffman... he clearly had his Weetabix in the morning.
1. Kramer Recruits Gordon To Help Him With His Work (Saw 3D)
While certain characters have displayed isolated moments of quick wit, it's hard to deny that the smartest person in the entire Saw franchise is the one who's been outplaying everyone from the very beginning: John Kramer, aka the Jigsaw killer.
He's obviously not the nicest chap in the world, but he still made countless smart decisions over the years, and if we had to single one of them out, then the way he recruited Lawrence Gordon is arguably the wisest move he ever made.
Gordon was, of course, one of the victims in the original Saw movie, with his desperation causing him to chop off his own foot. After almost dying of blood loss, he was found by Kramer, who - instead of killing Gordon off for good, or leaving him for dead - patched him up, fitted him with a prosthetic leg, and set him free.
Kramer is essentially manipulating Gordon by doing all of this, trying to get him on his side - and in the end, he's successful, gaining himself an incredibly useful ally.
As Kramer puts it, his work in the Saw sequels "would not have been possible" without Gordon's help. As a doctor, Gordon's medical expertise proves invaluable in setting up many of the traps we've seen in the series, such as placing a key behind Michael Marks' eye, and sewing Art Blank's mouth shut. Furthermore, Gordon is able to avenge Jill's death by killing Mark Hoffman, ensuring that Kramer's final request is carried out, even after his own death at the end of Saw III.
Basically, Gordon is an overlooked but hugely important character in the Saw franchise, and things wouldn't have been the same if Kramer hadn't recruited him.
Watch Next
Saw Quiz: How Did These Jigsaw Victims Die?