9 Comedy Filmmakers Who Deserve More Awards Recognition

Isn't it time we gave these comedy legends a bit more recognition?

As the old saying goes: "Dying is easy, comedy is hard." You know what's even harder? Winning an award as a comedic filmmaker. Though some of the most memorable and beloved movies ever made are comedies, a comedy filmmaker can pretty much be resigned to the fact that he or she will never win an Oscar or other top film awards. While TV awards often recognize comedy, rarely can a comedy film have a fair shot at winning major awards against acclaimed dramas. As a result, many great comedy directors and writers have been nominated for little or no Oscars, BAFTA Awards, Directors Guild Awards, Writers Guild Awards, and so on. Even comedy filmmaker icons like Charlie Chaplin, Buster Keaton, Jerry Lewis, and Blake Edwards never won major awards for writing or directing, though they later received many honorary or lifetime achievement awards. Here is a list of 9 of the most talented comedy writer/directors who have never gotten the recognition they deserve for being great filmmakers who made classic movies...

9. Amy Heckerling

Amy Heckerling is probably the most unfamiliar name on this list, but she directed one comedy that is almost universally beloved: Fast Times at Ridgemont High. It was an impressive feature debut, and led to Heckerling directing Johnny Dangerously, European Vacation, and episodes of the short-lived Fast Times TV series. While she spent the late 1980s writing and directing the hokey (but popular) the first two Look Who's Talking movies, she later wrote and directed one of the most popular comedies of the 1990s, Clueless. She even wrote two episodes of the popular spinoff TV series. While Heckerling hasn't had the same career highs since, one would expect that the filmmaker behind two of the most popular high school comedies ever made would've received some recognition for her work, especially being a woman in the male-dominated world of comedy. Even the Writers Guild of America has barely recognized her work, only nominating her for Best Original Screenplay for Clueless (even though Clueless was actually a loose adaptation of the 1815 Jane Austen novel Emma).

8. The Farrelly Brothers

I'm not going to suggest that I think that the Farrelly Brothers should win Oscars, but Peter and Bobby Farrelly were the kings of comedy in the mid-to-late 1990s. The three movies they wrote and directed during that period, Dumb & Dumber, There's Something About Mary, and Me, Myself & Irene, were all major hits. They also directed Kingpin, which wasn't a box office hit but has become a cult classic. While their work since hasn't been as good as those four movies (including the box office bombs Movie 43 and The Three Stooges), it's surprising that they didn't receive more acclaim for those 1990s comedy gems. The two received some minor awards for the There's Something About Mary screenplay and the film itself was nominated for the Best Comedy/Musical Golden Globe, but otherwise the brothers are empty handed when it comes to awards. Though I doubt the Farrelly's next film, a sequel to Dumb & Dumber, will attract much awards consideration, it will hopefully please fans of the pair's wild sense of humor.

7. John Hughes

While John Hughes is best known for his teen comedies (Sixteen Candles, The Breakfast Club, Ferris Bueller's Day Off), his strengths in comedy were much broader. Perhaps his funniest movie is Planes, Trains and Automobiles, which features the best performances by beloved actors Steve Martin and Hughes' favorite actor, John Candy. In particular, humor about family relationships gave birth to some of his best comedy. In addition to the movies he directed himself, Hughes also wrote the comedy classics National Lampoon's Vacation, European Vacation, Mr. Mom, The Great Outdoors, Christmas Vacation, and Home Alone. He would follow the massive success of Home Alone by writing successful PG family comedies like Beethoven, Dennis the Menace, 101 Dalmatians, and Flubber. Though none of these are of the quality of his earlier work, they remain childhood favorites of many. So if his movies are so popular why is John Hughes on this list? Consider this: despite writing, directing, or producing more than a dozen classic movies, Hughes was never even nominated for a major filmmaking award. He received a poignant tribute at the Oscars six months after his death, but that's as close as he ever came to receiving awards recognition.

6. John Landis

Though John Landis isn't strictly a comedic filmmaker (he directed Michael Jackson's Thriller music video, for example), the list of funny comedies that he directed is legendary: The Kentucky Fried Movie, Animal House, The Blues Brothers, Trading Places, Spies Like Us, ¡Three Amigos!, and Coming to America. On top of that, he co-wrote the scripts for The Blues Brothers and the cult classic mystery comedy Clue. When Saturday Night Live alumni wanted to make movies in the 1980s, Landis was often the first choice for director. Though he directed several duds in the 1990s (Oscar, Beverly Hills Cop III, The Stupids, and Blues Brothers 2000), it's hard to find flaws with the string of hits he directed in the late 1970s through the 1980s. For a guy who started working in a Hollywood mail room, Landis made quite a career for himself as a comedy director. While Landis did win an Emmy for directing a documentary about comedy legend Don Rickles, he has never been nominated for any notable awards for his comedy movies. In fact, Landis' three nominations for the Worst Director Razzie Award outnumber legit nominations he has received for his movies.

5. Frank Oz

It's undeniable that Frank Oz is best known for his puppetry. He's the voice and hands behind Yoda from Star Wars and the original puppeteer of many Muppets, including Miss Piggy, Fozzie Bear, Animal, Grover, Cookie Monster, Bert, and Sam the Eagle. Being Jim Henson's close collaborator for nearly thirty years is enough to make Oz a show business legend alone. But Oz is equally adept at directing films as he is at puppetry. After wetting his feet by co-directing the fantasy film The Dark Crystal with Henson, Oz went on to direct The Muppets Take Manhattan (he also co-wrote the screenplay), the comedy musical Little Shop of Horrors, and notable comedies Dirty Rotten Scoundrels, What About Bob?, In & Out, Bowfinger, and the original version of Death at a Funeral. Oz's work on The Muppet Show and Sesame Street netted him three Emmys. But as far as his impressive comedic films, he's only received a few festival wins for Death at a Funeral. While you can't blame people for showering those loveable Muppets with gold, Oz has certainly proven he has mastered more than puppetry in his long career.

4. Ivan Reitman

Like John Landis, Ivan Reitman's career as a filmmaker hasn't been exclusively in comedy but it's how he built his reputation. Reitman directed popular comedies like Meatballs, Stripes, Ghostbusters, Twins, Ghostbusters II, Kindergarten Cop, and Dave after kicking off his career with Cannibal Girls, a horror comedy he wrote and directed. Reitman also produced other comedy favorites like Animal House, Private Parts, Road Trip, Old School, and EuroTrip. Few filmmakers of any genre can claim to have had a hand in creating so many classics. Like others on this list Reitman hasn't been as successful with some of his later efforts, including Junior, Fathers' Day, Evolution, and My Super Ex-Girlfriend. And when it comes to awards, Reitman has been just as unsuccessful as his peers. However, Ivan Reitman may take some comfort in the fact that his son Jason has already received far more awards and accolades than he ever has. In fact, Ivan Reitman's sole Oscar nomination came in 2010 for producing Jason's movie Up in the Air. Though Ivan Reitman hasn't produced Jason's other movies, he might consider doing it again to finally win some awards.

3. Christopher Guest

Christopher Guest spun a career as a bit-part television comedy actor into becoming one of the all-time funniest comedic filmmakers. Inspired by his experience starring in the mostly ad-libbed rock mockumentary This Is Spinal Tap, Guest periodically gathered his friends to create four comedies with improvised dialogue, Waiting for Guffman, Best in Show, A Mighty Wind, and For Your Consideration. Guest also directed two other scripted comedies, The Big Picture (which he co-wrote) and Almost Heroes, but they were not as well received. Nonetheless, Waiting for Guffman and Best in Show frequently land high on "funniest movies ever" lists and a song written for A Mighty Wind was nominated for an Oscar. Guest himself has received praise and awards for his roles on television and popular movies like The Princess Bride, but his filmmaking talent has mostly gone unrewarded. Surprisingly, the Writers Guild of America nominated Best in Show for Best Screenplay, even though all of the dialogue in the movie was improvised. The irony is probably not lost on the guitarist of the world's most famous fictitious rock band.

2. Harold Ramis

Several filmmakers on this list also were actors or screenwriters in addition to directors. However, none of them did all three as well as Harold Ramis. While audiences might know him best for his on-camera appearances in Stripes, Ghostbusters, and Knocked Up, his acting was eclipsed by his work as a writer and director. Ramis seemingly had a hand in more than half of the classic comedies released between 1978 and 1984. In fact, upon his death in February 2014 many were surprised to find out from his obituaries that Ramis wrote Animal House, SCTV, Meatballs, Stripes, Ghostbusters, and Back to School. He also directed National Lampoon's Vacation, The Ice Harvest, and more recently episodes of the U.S. version of The Office. Finally, he served both creative roles on Caddyshack, Groundhog Day and Analyze This, among other films. One of the most impressive aspects of Ramis' movies is how they range from slapstick (Caddyshack) to more philosophical humor (Groundhog Day). The only major film award Ramis received was a BAFTA for Best Original Screenplay for Groundhog Day, which he shared with co-writer Danny Rubin. Despite all of his brilliant screenplays, the Writers Guild of America only nominated him once for Best Original Screenplay for 1979's Animal House.

1. Terry Gilliam

Terry Gilliam is not only the sole American member of Monty Python, but he is responsible for the group's iconic animations and co-directed the group's movie Monty Python and the Holy Grail. When the members began to focus more on their individual work in the mid-1970s, Gilliam emerged as a visionary film director. Though beloved by his fans, Gilliam's films are often too quirky for mainstream audiences and are often hampered by insufferable production problems. Nonetheless, it's impossible to find much fault with Gilliam's funniest fantasy films, including Time Bandits, The Adventures of Baron Munchausen, The Fisher King and what is considered his masterpiece, Brazil. While the humor in his non-Python work is darker and more subtle, it proves Gilliam is a immensely versatile comedian. Gilliam's movies have won major awards - including several BAFTA Awards for Brazil and Baron Munchausen - but they are all in categories like Production Design, Visual Effects, and Costume Design. Gilliam's sole Oscar nomination was for the screenplay of Brazil, which he co-wrote with others. In recent years he has been awarded a number of Lifetime Achievement awards from several prestigious organizations, but considering Gilliam's gifts as a comedic filmmaker they seem like consolation prizes. Are there any comedy filmmakers that you think should have made this list? Share your pick in the comments below.

Contributor
Contributor

Chris McKittrick is a published author of fiction and non-fiction and has spoken about film and comic books at conferences across the United States. In addition to his work at WhatCulture!, he is a regular contributor to CreativeScreenwriting.com, MovieBuzzers.com, and DailyActor.com, a website focused on acting in all media. For more information, visit his website at http://www.chrismckit.com.