Avengers: Infinity War Vs Avengers: Endgame - Which Is Better?

There can be only one.

Avengers Infinity War Avengers Endgame
Marvel Studios

With Avengers: Endgame now in cinemas around the world, the 22-film Infinity Saga has finally been completed, giving fans an enormously satisfying and emotional farewell to some of the MCU's top-line superheroes.

And though Endgame has released to some of the strongest reviews in the history of the superhero genre, it's only inevitable that fans will compare it to not only the classics of the genre, but also its direct predecessor, Avengers: Infinity War.

As two parts of the same epic climax - and in fact, they were originally conceived as Infinity War Parts 1 & 2 - Infinity War and Endgame are certainly more fitting for comparison than most other comic book movie sequels, yet of course, only one can prevail.

It's fair to say that the two superhero tentpoles are very different films as much as they cover many of the same characters and narrative through-lines, but when the dust has settled and the hype evaporated, one takes a sure edge over the other.

And before we proceed, be aware that MAJOR SPOILERS WILL FOLLOW, if you haven't seen Endgame yet...


13. Direction

Captain America Avengers Endgame
Marvel Studios

Both Infinity War and Endgame are of course directed by Anthony and Joe Russo, and there's a clear tonal and stylistic consistency across the movies that makes this a tough battle to win.

On one hand, Infinity War is a more snappily-paced and cleanly focused movie with less questionable narrative elements, but Endgame is a far more demanding film from a technical perspective, requiring the brothers to juggle a mind-boggling number of characters and moving parts.

WINNER: It's an extremely close call, but Endgame barely clinches it largely due to the absurd level of ambition throughout, and also the impressiveness with which the Russos make that beefy three-hour run-time speed by. That's not easily done, no matter how much audiences love the characters.


12. Narrative

tony stark avengers infinity war ending
Walt Disney Studios

Infinity War tells a far simpler story, simple enough that it allows the film to effectively become a Thanos (Josh Brolin) character study for the most part, culminating of course in his devastating victory.

By comparison, Endgame is extremely complex, weaving a logic-stretching time travel plot which naturally climaxes with the heroes mounting their all-encompassing last stand against the Mad Titan.

Both movies upended expectations in satisfying ways, with one making the most of its grim potential, while the other launched off to become a crowd-pleasing showcase for incredible fan service.

WINNER: Infinity War definitely had an easier job, but it also feels more successful overall. Endgame raises the scope and stakes, but is also a bit bloated in parts, and the internal logic of the time travel is frustratingly wishy-washy.

That's not to deny how satisfying Endgame was overall, but Infinity War's more streamlined and focused story ultimately felt more water-tight.


11. The Heroes

Avengers Endgame Team 1
Marvel Studios

In terms of the treatment of the MCU's superheroes, Infinity War and Endgame are very much two sides of the same coin.

Infinity War largely pushes the O.G. Avengers to the background, with Captain America (Chris Evans), Black Widow (Scarlett Johansson), The Hulk (Mark Ruffalo) and Hawkeye (Jeremy Renner) having small (or non-existent) roles, while focusing instead on the newer (and younger) Avengers.

Endgame flips this by having the likes of Black Panther (Chadwick Boseman), Spider-Man (Tom Holland) and most of the Guardians of the Galaxy turned to dust for about 85% of its run-time, while serving instead as a farewell for the original six.

Though they're basically Side A and Side B of the same incredible album, only one can win.

WINNER: As novel as it was to see these heroes all interacting for the first time in Infinity War, Endgame barely clinches it on the merits of its heightened emotion, of paying-off over a decade of build-up and giving Iron Man (Robert Downey Jr.) in particular an extremely fitting send-off.


10. The Villain

Avengers Endgame Thanos
Marvel Studios

This is an interesting one to consider given that the villains in both movies are the same (well, sort of).

Infinity War does an astounding job finally living up to over five years of anticipation for Thanos, and thanks to sharp writing and an incredible Josh Brolin performance, the Mad Titan instantly became one of the greatest superhero movie villains ever.

If Infinity War was more Thanos' movie than the heroes', Endgame is the opposite, relegating Thanos to a smaller role, and one where he's surprisingly killed early on, only to be replaced by a 2014 version of himself for the remainder.

WINNER: Infinity War and it's not even close, but this is clearly by design. Infinity War delved deep into Thanos' characterisation and devoted much of its screen time to quiet, dialogue-driven scenes centred around him, while Endgame kept his chatter to a minimum and mostly focused on him as a physical threat.

The key difference, however, is that Thanos in Endgame wouldn't be particularly interesting without being informed by everything we first saw in Infinity War.


9. Performances

Endgame 1
MCU

One of the Russos' most consistent qualities is their ability to garner exceptional performances from their epic ensemble casts, and that's certainly true in both Infinity War and Endgame.

The centre-piece of Infinity War is unquestionably Josh Brolin's performance as Thanos, which is right up there with Heath Ledger's Joker as one of the most deftly-crafted in the superhero genre.

On the superhero side, Chris Hemsworth basically steals the show with his strongest MCU work yet, and Tom Holland broke all our hearts with his devastating final scene in particular.

If the bulk of Infinity War is far more of an action movie, Endgame is focused more closely on drama following the snap, and as such gives most of the cast - especially the O.G. Avengers - more flavourful dramatic meat to chew on.

WINNER: No complaints either way, but Endgame gives the core Avenger line-up some of their most affecting material to date, and the film's overall more dramatic tenor simply gives it more opportunities to let the actors, you know, act.

Infinity War is more crafted around a single fantastic performance, while Endgame gives audiences several (who also happen to be much-loved heroes they've been following for years).


8. Visuals

Avengers Infinity War Thanos
Marvel Studios

Both movies are undeniable visual effects spectacles, making the most of their colossal budgets to give audiences a show like can't be seen anywhere else.

Infinity War is a visually dynamic film which ventures from leafy New York to the eerie pallor of Vormir to the barren wasteland that is Titan and also Wakanda. The vast majority of its locales feel extremely fresh.

Endgame inherently feels a bit less imaginative stylistically because it's re-visiting many locations we've seen before, even though it certainly makes great use of them.

It's also fair to say that the final battle could've taken place at a slightly more interesting location than a murky digital battlefield (compared to Titan, which actually felt like a tactile place).

WINNER: Both movies look grand so there's no real loser here, but Infinity War pops far more throughout its run-time, if it also has the obvious advantage of coming first. Endgame's CGI meanwhile feels a little less precise, especially in the more cluttered final battle.


7. Music

Avengers Endgame Trailer
Marvel Studios

The brilliant Alan Silvestri composed the scores for both movies, and he's one of the few MCU composers to bring a decent amount of personality to the table, having been responsible for crafting The Avengers' iconic theme.

Infinity War's score features several distinctive tracks in additional to the expected orchestral bombast, especially "I Feel You" when Scarlet Witch (Elizabeth Olsen) destroys Vision (Paul Bettany), and the haunting string piece, "Porch", which plays out as Thanos presides over a job well done.

It's a tough act to follow, but Silvestri pulls it off in Endgame, which opts for a more playful score for the most part, especially during the time heist sequence, which features a number of brilliant nods to Silvestri's own score for Back to the Future (because how could he resist?).

And of course, The Avengers theme itself is brilliantly re-incorporated into the film during numerous crowd-pleasing third-act moments, to say nothing of the soul-rending score that accompanies Tony Stark's funeral.

WINNER: Both are unique and distinctive, but because it pulls at a wider range of emotions while employing a more distinctive style, the W just barely goes to Endgame.


6. Stan Lee's Cameo

Avengers Infinity War Stan Lee
Marvel Studios

What would an MCU movie be without a customary cameo from Stan Lee, of course? Lee has fairly inconsequential cameos in both Infinity War and Endgame, so picking a winner isn't terribly easy.

In Infinity War, Stan the Man plays the driver of Peter Parker's school bus, who starts mumbling about UFOs when Thanos' army arrives in New York.

In Endgame, he meanwhile appears in the 1970s portion of the film, playing a younger hippie version of himself for a passing second (achieved with the help of CGI and possibly a stand-in).

WINNER: Neither cameo is particularly remarkable, but Infinity War's is certainly funnier and more memorable, even if Endgame's is a cute way to incorporate Lee's cameo into the time-manipulating narrative.


5. Dialogue

Avengers Infinity War Thanos Gamora
Marvel Studios

Christopher Markus and Stephen McFeely have proven themselves to be the most consistent screenwriters across the entire MCU, managing to deftly blend comedy and pathos better than even the mighty Joss Whedon.

They've got a penchant for penning witty dialogue but knowing when to pull the laughs back and focus squarely on the drama. Infinity War, for instance, was absolutely jam-packed with one-liners both hilarious ("I am Steve Rogers") and savagely iconic ("Perfectly balanced, as all things should be.")

It's fair to say that Endgame was more focused on crowd-pleasing callbacks and references, but the script was still rife with potent dramatic chatter and hysterical quips all the same. After all, did anyone expect to hear Tony compare Rocket (Bradley Cooper) to a Build-A-Bear?

WINNER: Infinity War certainly benefits from having firmly embedded itself in meme culture over the last year, but its dialogue is also more memorable and effective on the whole, while Endgame is focused on crafting memorable moments above all else.

Endgame may have stirred audiences into a frenzy with Cap wielding Mjolnir, but when it comes to the written word, nothing in Endgame quite left audiences reeling like "Why is Gamora?"


4. Standalone Appeal

Avengers Infinity War
Marvel

This might seem like a paradoxical criteria on which to judge the third and fourth Avengers movies, especially as they're part of a 22-film, decade-plus saga of loosely interconnected pictures.

But not everyone is a hardcore Marvel fan, and it's fair to say that many of the people who contribute to those billion-dollar box office triumphs - or in the case of these two movies, $2 billion - are extremely casual audiences simply turning up for the pure spectacle.

Infinity War is quite clearly a fine standalone film for the most part, because it has to fully introduce audiences to Thanos and also the new Avengers to one another.

You need a basis of the heroes themselves, for sure, but the simple narrative through-line makes it an easy film to follow in isolation. Though of course, with its cliffhanger ending, it certainly doesn't provide closure of any kind.

Endgame would meanwhile be a total nightmare to anyone going in cold, given how heavily it relies on the audience's affinity for prior MCU movies at even a basic level. Moreover, Thanos is decidedly less interesting in Endgame without the context established by Infinity War.

WINNER: Even accepting its inconclusive ending, Infinity War wins this easily. It's a simpler and more accessible film, while Endgame feels far more like a for the fans climax (and rightly so).

That's not even really a ding against Endgame, but in terms of the mainstream, Infinity War is unquestionably the more watchable of the two.


3. Emotional Impact

Avengers Endgame Black Widow Hawkeye
Marvel Studios

If it's a frequently-cited complaint that the MCU lacks tangible stakes, and as a result the potential emotional investment in the story and characters is undermined, Infinity War and Endgame clearly sought to change that.

Infinity War features a number of shocking death scenes which hit the audience in the gut, while firmly establishing Thanos as a potent villain.

And though there was never any doubt that the dusted Avengers would return, the devastation of seeing so many beloved heroes (temporarily) disintegrated nevertheless hit fans hard.

Endgame was meanwhile mounted as the climax to the Infinity Saga, and served as a thoroughly poignant send-off for the longest-tenured superheroes, with a couple of seemingly permanent character deaths in the bargain.

If you're a long-time MCU fan and didn't get a lump in your throat during Tony's funeral, are you even human?

WINNER: Both films are great in this regard, but the sense of "finality" in Endgame is damn-near impossible to argue with. The Russos stuck the landing beautifully.


2. The Test Of Time

Avengers Infinity War Thanos
Marvel Studios

Movies don't exist in a vacuum, and though both Infinity War and Endgame were released to rapturous responses from fans, their true worth will be measured by how they're received long-term.

After all, The Dark Knight continues to be held up as perhaps the greatest superhero movie of all time, though The Dark Knight Rises opened to wide acclaim only to end up nit-picked to death once the honeymoon period was over.

With its uniquely villain-focused narrative, slick set-pieces and pitch-perfect ending, Infinity War feels like it will always endure as an all-timer superhero classic.

Endgame won't be far off, but with its larger canvas and sloppier storytelling, it does also feel likely to receive its fair share of backlash in the coming months, once the fan service-infused glow has worn off somewhat.

That's not to say it'll be rubbished by most fans, but simply that they'll be more willing to accept its flaws.

WINNER: Not to undermine Endgame's incredible accomplishments, but Infinity War stands up far more confidently as a tight piece of blockbuster storytelling.


1. Overall

Avengers Infinity War Poster
Marvel Studios

And finally, it's time to tot up the scores at the doors and determine which movie truly is the best. It's a pretty close one, but Infinity War clinches it with 7 wins to Endgame's 5 wins.

Clearly, both movies are terrific achievements in their own right and form part of a bigger whole, but ultimately, one is always going to be the superior offering.

With its clearer focus and more concise storytelling, Infinity War just feels that much more considered and coherent than its more sprawling and messy successor.

Time will tell how fans, critics and general audiences alike end up viewing the two films, but whichever one becomes your fave, it's clear the Russos did a miraculous job elevating the superhero genre to new heights previously thought impossible.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.