Colin Firth: 5 Awesome Performances And 5 That Sucked

This week sees the release of Colin Firth's new film The Railway Man, an adaptation of Eric Lomax's true story of working on the Thai/Burma railway as a prisoner of war and, later in life, meeting the Japanese officer who'd tormented him. We're in awards season now and Colin Firth has become one of those actors that every year or two seems to be in an 'important' film. He is a worthy English gent in the time of Danny Dyer DTV releases and foreign financed Vinnie Jones films. He has won an Oscar for Best Actor, his films have grossed nearly a billion dollars worldwide and he is a thoroughly likeable chap. He's come a long way since his debut as 'Jack Frost' in the infant's school pantomime. Is he more than this though? Unlike his, well, stable-mate Hugh Grant, Firth can jump from genre to genre. We're just as likely to see him in an award winner as a romantic comedy or even a teen film. Whereas Grant started in more serious fare like Maurice and The Remains of the Day, now he seems happy, Cloud Atlas apart, to appear in romantic comedies. Of course, there's nothing wrong with that but Firth does seem to want to challenge himself as much as he wants to have fun. So, with his new film release, once again on a Friday we present you with five awesome performances and five that, well, sucked big time (spoilers included).

5 Awesome Performances...

5. Vince Collins - Where The Truth Lies

Colin Firth has always played more serious roles and he's not afraid of going to darker places. His work in the UK has regularly shown this. Hollywood, however, saw a slightly tubby British gent who could take supporting roles to more aquiline leading men like Ralph Fiennes in The English Patient. It wasn't until his starring role in Atom Egoyan's Palme d'Or nominated drama that they saw it for themselves. A noir-esque dissection of a 1950's comedy duo Vince Collins (Firth) and Lanny Morris (Kevin Bacon), it tells, through flashback, how their stand-up relationship fell apart and a young girl mysteriously died. The film is a sex and drug-fuelled journey into how a friendship can be destroyed by one mistake and a career can be derailed in 1950's America by rumours of bisexuality. Through a convoluted plot, the two men meet again in 1972 when Collins is having his biography written by a young female journalist. When it appears she's getting closer to the truth, the noose then tightens around her own neck. It is Bacon who has the showier role here but Firth is brilliant as he underplays but still manages to exude both bitterness as to how his career ended, and manipulation as he forces the female journalist into sex with a young actress just so he can blackmail her (and keep her away from the true 1950's tale of drugs and deceit). He plays a man who not only made an error that destroyed his life (trying to have sex with Morris during a threesome) but also being blackmailed by his apparent friendly valet. This performance was a calling card to Hollywood that Firth was more than just another British actor. He had hidden depths too.

4. Robert Lawrence MC - Tumbledown

Okay, this might be a bit of cheat because this was a TV drama and I've not included that other huge success, Pride and Prejudice, but as will become apparent for this top five, he has made so many good pieces of work that some will fall by the wayside. If Where the Truth Lies was his Hollywood calling card then this Falklands drama was quite simply his call to arms. Focussing on Scots Guard officer Robert Lawrence, this tells his story as he arrives in the conflict and, at the Battle of Mount Tumbledown, is shot in the head by an Argentine sniper. He is left paralysed through his injury and the film tells of this rather difficult individual as he is forced into a painful rehabilitation. The piece was incredibly controversial when it was aired on BBC because it not only depicted Lawrence as an arrogant egotist but also a man who loved the smell of the battlefield. It also showed the indifference of many of the people back in Britain when he returned for his rehabilitation. It gave particular criticism of the government in the face of their 'heroes' although both sides of the House held criticism for the piece. This was a brilliantly brave, and stark, performance from Firth at a particular turning point in his career. The criticism of the piece was harsh but the praise for his performance was unflinching. He was nominated for a Best TV Actor Bafta for this honest portrayal of a wounded man left for dead by his country.

3. Mark Darcy - Bridget Jones's Diary

This might not have the depravity of Where the Truth Lies or the stark, brutal realism of Tumbledown but this film, more than any other, cemented Firth as a mainstream romantic lead and, at the end of the day, he's bloody good in it too. Taking what could have been Hugh Grant's part as the 'nice guy', Firth gets to play off Renee Zellweger's manic Bridget and Grant's villainous Daniel Cleaver as both men fight for her affections. From the moment you see him in his silly green Christmas jumper to when he tells Bridget he likes her 'just as you are' it is a fleshed out performance in what could have been a throwaway comedy. His role as Mark Darcy harks back to Pride and Prejudice and also to the stereotype of the traditional English gent in the face of Cleaver's randy Romeo. He plays it pretty straight too in a film filled with 'big' performances and when he does confess his love for Bridget it is a great moment in a warm film. Also, let's not forget, a few films aside, including cameos in The English Patient and Shakespeare in Love, this was his first big hit at the box office where he played a significant character. To top it all off, he has street fight with Hugh Grant which, for British audiences, is like putting Stallone and DeNiro into the ring for a boxing match.

2. George Falconer - A Single Man

This is a beautiful film. Yes, Firth is its centre and heart but I mean beautiful in the traditional sense. Directed by former Gucci creative director Tom Ford, everything looks exquisite from, obviously, the costumes to the cinematography. Ford wanted to make a truly handsome film so, for that, he needed a truly handsome actor with depth and baggage and he found one in Colin Firth. Based on Christopher Isherwood's heartbreaking novella, it tells the story of George Falconer, an English professor whose heart was broken when his lover, Jim, died in a car crash eight months earlier. The film is brilliantly constructed over one day as George prepares to commit suicide and looks through the eyes of someone who is seeing the world for the last time. It is only through his old friendship with Charley (Julianne Moore) and college student Kenny (Nicholas Hoult) that he begins to realise the isolation he has subjected himself to for the past few months is the reason for his suicidal thoughts and that the "only thing that has made the whole thing worthwhile has been those few times that I was able to truly connect with another person". Unfortunately, George's realisation comes just too late as he collapses and dies. Each performance on this 'awesome' list has taken Firth further forward in his career and this one did the same as it not only put him on the awards circuit winning a Bafta and Golden Globe (and narrowly missing out on the Best Actor Oscar to Jeff Bridge's performance in Crazy Heart) it also reminded the world that this actor, this man who wore a silly jumper in Bridget Jones was actually one of the most subtle and nuanced British screen actors of his generation. Obviously, it was a shame he missed out on Oscar glory but that would come soon enough...

1. King George VI - The King's Speech

To some, this might seem an obvious choice, to others, a cop-out. Firstly, a few honourable mentions. Tinker, Tailor, Soldier, Spy and The English Patient missed out on the list because I wanted more than a supporting performance. For TV work, I went for Tumbledown over Pride and Prejudice and for the romantic comedy, Love Actually has too many loose strings (but is saved by Firth and Hugh Grant's respective plots). Maybe A Single Man is the better overall performance but what could have been yet another costume drama awards baiter actually became something far more. It is a sad, emotional and, quite often, very funny account of King George VI and his attempts, with the help of the radical Lionel Logue (Geoffrey Rush) to cope with his debilitating stammer. In Firth's performance we find a man who is trying his best for his country but finds his own physical and emotional limitations keep letting him down. He is supported by a great cast too with not only Rush but Helena Bonham Carter, Guy Pearce and Michael Gambon on top form. To be honest, when you act opposite that lot, you're going to raise your game but Firth's George becomes both the head and the heart of a film which connected with audiences of all ages and grossed over $400million. Is it too obvious to put this as the number one when it is his biggest hit and garnered him the Best Actor Oscar? Maybe, but if you want a film which shows an actor at the peak of his powers (coming twelve short months after A Single Man) you won't find any better.

And 5 Performances That Sucked...

5. Harry - Mamma Mia!

This was a worldwide smash at the box office. Audiences around the world love it. People sing along to it. Dance to it. When it's finished (after its never ending closing credits sequence) they play it again. This is a 'fun' film that people love. And it's rubbish. If I wanted to see people singing and dancing badly but, you know, having fun, I'd take a camcorder to the next wedding I go to and watch that ad nauseum. I can find nothing positive in a film which centres on a woman who doesn't know who the father of her daughter is (hey, it could be one of THREE men) but we're supposed to take her to our hearts. If people like ABBA so much, they should stick on the CD and close the door. To make matters worse, Colin Firth phones in a performance so one dimensional that it's almost insulting. This is the man who brought depth to the romantic lead in Bridget Jones's Diary and yet his performance as Harry Bright, a gay English banker, is the hellish flipside of his A Single Man performance. The only reason he doesn't steal the 'worst singer' plaudits is because Pierce Brosnan got in there before him and hacked When All Is Said And Done to death. Firth is poor in a bad film and just to prove how bad it is, during the Dancing Queen 'sing-a-long' Julie Walters sprained her ankle so, how do they cover that when the cast run down a hill? They cover the replacements face with a towel. I kid you not. This film is not solely Firth's fault, but I lay a lot of it at his feet for agreeing to it in the first place.

4. Lord Henry Dashwood - What A Girl Wants

Oh, Colin, Colin, Colin. If anyone, ever, wanted to see you in leather pants we can pretty much guarantee that it would have been in a film directed by Atom Egoyan and not, er, Dennie Gordon. Again, similar to Mamma Mia!, he takes all that rich work of layering the traditional English gent stereotype, and throws it all away as Lord Henry Dashwood, a rich British politician who's, you know, forgotten his hippy roots. Really? Really. Granted, this is a teen flick starring teen queen Amanda Bynes but even looking at the film like this, it's hard not to see the glazed expression in Mr Firth's eyes as he bounces off Four Weddings' Duck-Face, ice-queen Anna Chancellor and Hollywood hippy Kelly Preston. In fact, this film is so full of cultural stereotypes it's sickening. In a world where teen flicks can be well constructed and well acted, this plays off like a Hollywood Polaroid of staid Britishness in the face of American free spirits. Tumblr Lfapalhezf1qat7rw Gif It's the act that Firth plays up to all of this. We know he can do subtle. We know he can do romance. We know he can do comedy. Do we see any of it here though? No. In fact, he uses that slightly high-pitched voice that we hear in most of his awful films (see Mamma Mia!) almost as if he's pretending to be Colin Firth's slightly less talented younger brother. Colin. You were in Tumbledown. Stop it.

3. Mark Darcy - Bridget Jones: The Edge Of Reason

Just for the sake of symmetry, opposite the 'awesome' performance in the first film, here is the 'awful' performance in the sequel. Actually, it's not a sequel. It's a remake. And a bloody awful one at that. It's not as though the leads don't try their best, it's just that it must have been clear from the script that this was a shadow of the first film. When you take a photocopy of a photocopy, the image isn't as good. This is Firth's performance here. Faded black and white. It's a bad cover version of his own good work in the first film. Again, those glazed eyes appear. The voice goes up a few notes and, by and large, he sleepwalks through the film, even when rescuing our Madonna-singing heroine from a Thai prison. Oh, and guess what Mark Darcy does after that? Have a fight with Hugh Grant. It's the rematch no-one wanted to see. Also, I can only assume Firth is sleepwalking through the film because most of the characters are so annoying that if he was even vaguely aware of this, he would have married his new colleague Rebecca and left the country so they could all rot. Too much? Maybe, but with the threat of a third film we can only be thankful that Helen Fielding has killed off Mark Darcy.

2. Harry Deane - Gambit

There was so much good spirit towards this film when it was getting made. Colin Firth, Cameron Diaz and Alan Rickman in a remake of the 1966 Shirley MacLaine and Michael Caine caper movie. Hell, even the Coens scripted it. However, when those two great film-makers pass the script on to Michael Hoffman (previous best film? One Fine Day with George Clooney in the days where he wanted to be James Stewart) you know there's something wrong. This is a comedic heist movie with no comedy and no tension, and that takes some doing. Just as the great cast in The King's Speech helped Firth to his best performance, here we have a group of actors phoning it in and therefore, so does our Colin. Cameron Diaz has never been as nauseous as here playing an OTT rodeo queen PJ Puznowski. Alan Rickman looks like he's looked in the mirror and realised he's not Hans Gruber anymore and Firth? Well, his dishevelled appearance on the poster must only be because he tried to escape the set and got dragged back by the producers.

1. Geoffrey Thwaites - St Trinian's 2: The Legend Of Fritton's Gold

There is no film that Colin requires a greater kicking for than this. The first film, as awful as it was, played to a certain demographic that got it. Fair enough. This, however (are you noticing a trend here) must only have been done for the money because there are no redeeming features whatsoever. Colin returns as Geoffrey Thwaites, the now former Education minister. Obviously, this means he can now kick back in his relationship with Miss Camilla Dagey Fritton, unhilariously played by Rupert Everett. I hope those two sat in their trailers and felt bad about what they'd done here. It's an unremarkable adventure film which sees Frith teams up with the girls of St Trinian's to get revenge on David Tennant's Sir Piers Pomfrey...by sailing the reconstruction of the Golden Hind down the Thames and taking down the bad guy. Then they have a disco. Several words have been bandied about this particular top five, sleepwalking most among them but I like to think that Colin looks thoroughly disgusted with himself. Not only is he in a terribly made film, with no script to talk of, he's also playing to stereotype and also second fiddle to, amongst others, Sarah Harding. This film is all sorts of wrong, mostly because Colin Firth is so much better than this but, then again, he probably knew that as he'd just recently finished filming The King's Speech.

Contributor
Contributor

Suit. Wine. Sport. Stirred. Not shaken. Done. Writer at http://whatculture.com, http://www.tjrsports.com and http://www.tjrwrestling.com