DCEU: 10 Changes From The Comics That Were Totally Justified

Deviating faster than speeding bullet.

Harley Quinn Origin Suicide Squad
Warner Bros.

How close should a comic book adaptation stick to the source material? A fierce debate has raged around this question since superheroes first made the jump from the page to the screen, and it has taken on a new level of prevalence since the Marvel Cinematic Universe and its DC counterpart conquered Hollywood.

Some fans are firm in their belief that movies should never deviate from the comics. To so much as tweak the colour scheme of a character's costume, in their eyes, is sacrilege of the highest order. Others are more flexible, accepting that adaptations, by their very nature, involve alterations to tailor the property for a new medium.

In reality, source material deviations are unavoidable. What works on the page wouldn't necessarily work on the big screen, often because of special effects limitations or simply because it would look too corny rendered in live action.

Where the film franchise unofficially known as the DC Extended Universe is concerned, Warner Bros and its creative teams have exercised their right to deconstruct the iconic superheroes and villains at their disposal, and while not all of the changes have been a resounding success, some were for the best.

10. Vengeful Clark Kent (Man Of Steel)

Man of Steel truck
Warner Bros

Zack Snyder's deconstruction of Superman is one of the most divisive aspects of the DC Extended Universe. Man of Steel introduced the world to a darker Kal-El, a character who is tonally closer to Batman than the source of hope, optimism and clean-cut justice traditionally depicted in the comic books.

Sure, there were many things wrong with this portrayal, hence why Supes received an overhaul for Justice League, but not everything about it was a misfire. Man of Steel took the audience out of their comfort zone by placing the character in unfamiliar situations that forced him to betray a set of rules the comics laid down as absolute.

Take the scene where Clark Kent has a pint of beer tipped over his head while working as a busboy at a remote mountainside watering hole, for instance. He responds by destroying the offending patron's truck the moment he leaves the bar.

Traditional Superman from the comic books would never have given into this temptation, regardless of how much that douche bag barfly had it coming. This is character who is traditionally humbled by the extent of his own superpowers, not one who is quick to showboat them in acts of vengeance.

But having Clark smash up that guy's truck was completely justified. Not only was it satisfying to see a scumbag get some form of comeuppance, it presented the budding Supes as a more relatable hero than the outdated personification of truth, justice and the American way from the source material ever could.


9. Superman's Use Of Lethal Force (Man Of Steel)

Dead Zod Man Of Steel
Warner Bros.

By far one of the most controversial aspect of Man of Steel was the lengths Superman was willing to go to in order to defeat his Kryptonian nemesis, General Zod. Sure, Supes has reluctantly taken the lives of his enemies in the comics, but to have him snap a neck with his bare hands was too out of character in the eyes of some.

Here's the thing, though: Supes had no choice but to kill Zod in the context of the no-win situation Zack Snyder had placed him in. Allowing the villain to live was signing the death warrant of the innocent people he was threatening to fry with his heat vision.

Again, this was about taking fans out of their comfort zone. Generally speaking, they aren't used to seeing Supes use lethal force but nor are they accustomed to seeing a character so powerful with the odds stacked up against him.

Having to end Zod's life clearly had an effect on Superman, a fact emphasised by the blood-curdling scream he releases immediately after. This is what happens when a character like Supes is placed in a world with more complex morality than the black and white system favoured by some of his early comic book outings.


8. Batman Violating His No-Kill Rule (Batman V Superman)

Batman V Superman Batman
Warner Bros.

Broadly speaking, Superman shouldn't take lives and neither should Batman where it can be avoided. Bruce Wayne's unwillingness to kill is often the fine line that separates him from anti-heroes like The Punisher.

Like The Man of Steel, Bats has been known to begrudgingly kill the occasional villain in the comic books, but in Batman v Superman, the Dark Knight has no qualms about using lethal force. He mows down criminals with his car, fires various weapons at them and doesn't care how much damage he does in unarmed combat situations.

Ben Affleck's Caped Crusader is a far cry from his traditional comic book counterpart in this respect, but in the confines of the DC Extended Universe, this works well. In fact, there's a legitimate reason why this version of Batman is more hazardous to the health of Gotham City's criminals: he's been in the job for too long.

Batfleck has been fighting crime in the darkest corner of the DC Universe for two decades, he's lost a Robin, and has been left jaded and damaged by his experiences.

Plus, if you have a Superman who breaks necks and has little regard for collateral damage, it seems only fitting that Batman within the same universe is only too happy to murder his way through Gotham's underworld.


7. Lex Luthor Creating Doomsday (Batman V Superman)

Doomsday Batman V Superman
Warner Bros.

Lex Luthor's plan to unleash Doomsday on Metropolis at the end of Batman v Superman wasn't particularly well thought out and the creature itself was a mass of horrible CGI, but altering the alien powerhouse's origins wasn't a cardinal sin.

In the original DC Comics, Doomsday is an ancient monster created by Kryptonian genetic engineering gone awry. Luthor had no hand in his backstory, though it's easy to see why Zack Snyder played fast and loose with this fact.

Batman v Superman had to up the ante in the final act somehow, and that proved difficult considering a hero-on-hero showdown takes place in the middle of the story. Introducing Doomsday was one way to achieve that, and having Luthor create him after gaining access to Kryptonian technology ushered him in organically.

Many fans were unhappy with the way Doomsday was depicted, and it's easy to see why. Poor CG aside, he looks like a rejected Cave Troll design from the Lord of the Rings movies, but it's important to point out that altering his origins wasn't the problem here.

Snyder needed a threat big enough to require the pooled resources of DC Comics' holy trinity of Superman, Batman and Wonder Woman, and he introduced one in a way that made sense in the context of the plot.


6. Wonder Woman's World War I Setting (Wonder Woman)

Wonder Woman 2961251
Warner Bros.

There are many versions of Wonder Woman's origin in the comic books and its difficult to pick out a definitive one. A majority of DC Comics fans, however, will tell you her formative years took place during the World War II era.

That's when the original Wonder Woman comics took place, but director Patty Jenkins opted to take Diana Prince further back in time, to the trenches of World War I.

On paper, this sounds like a dramatic shift from the source material, though in reality, it didn't have a huge bearing on the story. But setting Wonder Woman further back in history did help differentiate the movie from Marvel's Captain America: The First Avenger and the countless other films that have taken place during this period.

On a side note, removing the United States of America from the movie almost entirely also set it apart from The First Avenger. Having Steve Trevor assigned to British intelligence, despite hailing from the US, was a smart move in this respect.


5. Ares's Secret Identity (Wonder Woman)

Wonder Woman Ares David Thewlis
Warner Bros.

Wonder Woman's big twist occurred in the final act with the revelation that the villainous Ares had been hiding in plain sight all along, pulling strings from the shadows while disguised as British political leader Sir Patrick.

This is quite a departure from the comic books in which the evil Greek deity has never adopted this particular secret identity.

Patty Jenkins cherrypicked elements of traditional Ares for the movies. For instance, the villain does send warmongering thoughts to the Axis leaders telepathically, though the Sir Patrick guise was created specifically for the film.

Ares taking on human form isn't unheard of in the comics. In one story, he possesses a criminal called Ari Buchanan, and later assumes the moniker Ares Buchanan.

Given that there's precedent for Ares as a master of disguise, the creation of an original secret identity for the movie was justified, not least because it helped keep the big twist under wraps until the final act.


4. Harley Quinn's Origin (Suicide Squad)

Harley Quinn's Bat Suicide Squad
Warner Bros.

Like much of the DC Extended Universe, Suicide Squad took its cues from the New 52 era of DC Comics continuity, and this is true for many of its character designs.

Take Margot Robbie's Harley Quinn, for example: She has the same bleached skin, pigtailed hairdo and edgy dress sense as her New 52 counterpart, but director David Ayer made a significant change to her backstory.

The rebooted Harley from the comic books sports this particular look because of the Joker's actions. He pushed her into a vat of acid against her will, whitening her complexion and turning her into a full-on sociopathic monster. The movie's take on this event is similar, yet with one key difference: Harley willing jumps into the chemicals as an expression of her undying, and in many ways toxic, love for Mister J.

This might sound like a minor change on paper, but it's a significant one because it gives Robbie's Harley the same agency and choice as her counterpart from the pre-New 52 era. Ayer adapted the character's modern look but removed her unwilling victim status with this shrewd tweak to the source material.


3. Green Lantern's Omission (Justice League)

green lantern
DC Comics

As a founder member of the Justice League, Green Lantern had every right to appear in Zack Snyder's big DC Extended Universe team-up last year, though there are legitimate reasons why he had to be benched.

For starters, Snyder was clearly mindful of introducing too many characters at once. Without solo films to feed into Justice League, the likes of The Flash, Aquaman and Cyborg got a raw deal on their screen time, and it would have been even rawer with Hal Jordan, Kyle Rayner or John Stewart also vying for the spotlight.

Moreover, the fact the whereabouts of the Green Lantern Corps is unknown is an important plot point. The intergalactic police force's lack of presence in this corner of the DC Universe is what left the Earth wide open to Steppenwolf's invasion.

No doubt 2020's Green Lantern Corps movie will explain why the Emerald Knights were a no-show while the planet was under attack, and this is for best since their story, with its rich cosmic elements, will need at least one film to flesh out before they're introduced to the mainline DCEU.


2. Superman's Post-Resurrection Costume (Justice League)

Superman Black Suit
Warner Bros.

Superman's resurrection in Justice League was as inevitable as Steppenwolf's defeat, but the risen Man of Steel's choice of wardrobe did surprise some fans.

Many were expecting Henry Cavill's superhero to don his iconic black getup from the comics, the suit he wore after coming back from the dead in The Return of Superman comic book arc, but the rumours proved untrue.

Given what Zack Snyder was trying to achieve with Supes in this movie, the omission of his dark threads is understandable. Justice League was all about rebirthing Superman in a more traditional mould, course correcting from his poorly received portrayal in Man of Steel and Batman v Superman.

Although having Supes decked in all black would have worked well in the scene where he's squaring off against the Justice League, Snyder seemingly didn't want to the audience to dwell on the idea of a dark version of the character, something he had already explored with mixed results.

As much as the fans wanted to see the famous black costume, the traditional red, white and blue was the way to go in Justice League, since the character's resurrection represented a beacon of light in a world gone dark.


1. Batman Assembling The Team (Justice League)

Josh Trank Fantastic Four
Fox

Batfleck took on the Nick Fury role in the DC Extended Universe by bringing the world's mightiest heroes together to save the planet from an intergalactic threat.

This kept him busy in the dying stages of Batman v Superman, Suicide Squad's post-credits sequence and the first act of Justice League, but it was quite the departure from the New 52 era comic books.

In the Justice League: Origin special, the heroes come together naturally, having gone on their own journeys, to join the fight against Darkseid. They pooled their resources of their own accord, having realised exactly what was at stake.

Admittedly, the comic book version of events is more heroic, but having Batman track down each of the Leaguers using his master detective skills worked in the context of the DCEU, and it was freaking cool to boot.

This is a good example of a source material deviation which helped tailor the comics for cinema. Those post-credits stingers and teasers did their part when it came to drumming up hype and anticipation ahead of the Justice League's assembly, and it made sense that Bats, with his unique skills, was the one generating it.


Contributor
Contributor

Been prattling on about gaming, movies, TV, football and technology across the web for as long as I can remember. Find me on Twitter @MarkLangshaw