What Does The Ending Of Gone Girl Really Mean?

This is the film's real ace and where Fincher's aims really lie.

Before we even begin, from the off this article has MAJOR SPOILERS for Gone Girl. If you haven't seen David Fincher's latest, bookmark this and come back later. Trust us, you'll want to read up on it. Gone Girl is one of those movies that, in the hands of a lesser director, could have ended up rather trashy. This is something of a hallmark of David Fincher, who has across an impressive twenty year directing career has turned cynical English language remakes of beloved foreign classics, true crime thrillers and male fantasy into something really special. The Social Network may have boasted an impressive script from Aaron Sorkin, but it was Fincher's direction and whip-fast delivery of the dialogue that really turned the story of Facebook's founders into a masterpiece. His latest, an adaptation of Gillian Flynn's novel, boasts a twist half-way through that could easily be viewed as exploitive if it didn't come after such a masterfully measured first hour. This mid-point reveal (seriously if you haven't seen it go now) is where many would have expected the film to reach its climax, leaving audiences with a movie totally different to what they sat down for (and all the better for it). Exploring the expectations of modern relationships to such a diabolical length, Gone Girl is probably the worst date movie of the year (again, a good thing). The ending has left a few audience members feeling a little let down; having the film's big pay-off coming much earlier in the story leaves the last fifteen minutes or so to tie everything up in the most compromising (for the characters) way possible. While narratively the ending is rather slight, it pays off many of the film's central themes and poses some rather interesting questions. Today we're going to dive into these, looking at what Fincher's saying with his movie and resolving some of the niggling queries people may have.

The Story

The first half of Gone Girl is essentially a masterclass in misdirection and after the reveal that (last warning) Amy is still alive things move so quickly there's hardly time to even put everything in place, so before we dive into some of the questions and themes of the ending let's get the overview of the plot straight. Nick (Ben Affleck) and Amy (Rosamund Pike) meet at some point in 2005, fall in love and get married a couple of years later. With the pair losing their jobs in the recession and forced to move back to Missouri when Nick's mother falls ill, their marriage begins to suffer. Nick starts an affair with one of his students and upon discovering this Amy plots a complicated revenge scheme. She has a history of manipulating and abusing former partners - she's even framed one of sexual assault - and this one takes her to new extremes. Planting clues (primarily through a forged diary) and presenting herself as a lovely-but-abused wife, she fakes her disappearance, leaving just enough evidence behind to implicate Nick. Everything goes to plan until, while in hiding, Amy gets robbed and finds herself penniless and must call on former flame Desi for help. Realising Nick has figured out what she's done, she changes the plan. Killing Desi and framing him for her abduction, she returns home and attempts to rebuild her life with Nick. The film ends with Amy stalemating a Nick eager to reveal the truth by getting herself pregnant. Realising he can't desert his child, he ends up going along with it, stuck in his marriage once again.

Desi's Real Motivations

To Amy, ringing Desi was a last resort when her savings were stolen. She called him because she knew he was someone who would help unconditionally and given how skittish she was initially in his lake house, it doesn't seem that it was always her plan to kill him. That point seems to be when Nick gives the interview on TV; she sees he does understand her and realises she can go back to marriage and be free. Cue one of the most gruesome scenes in Fincher's entire filmography. But what of Desi. Was he the creep he will forever be known as or just another innocent roped in by Amy? We know from Scoot McNairy's Tommy O'Hara that previous claims she's made against people are entirely fabricated, so it's not unreasonable to think the same is true of Desi (who allegedly tried to kill himself in Amy's bed). And yet when the duo are in the lake house it's almost a game of who is the creepier of the two. However, really look at what we learn about him. Desi is played a bit off-kilter, yet his actions are all pretty explainable. When confronted about his past with Amy as a student, he attempts to immediately get rid of Nick, but that could be out of embarrassment of the truth or anger at the lies. And when Desi has Amy back at his he may be drinking excessively (to build confidence) and immediately be rather touchy-feely, suggesting an intimate reunion is already on his mind, but given how he's kept his distance until she called, it's likely he wouldn't have made a move if she hadn't first. With the letters the two shared keeping him on the hook, really he's just another emotionally manipulated man. The ambiguity isn't helped that Desi is played by Neil Patrick Harris, an actor best known for despicable womaniser Barney Stinson. It's a move of smart casting that, despite there being no tangible link between Desi and Barney, we assume the characters are coming from the same psychological place when in fact that doesn't seem to be the case.

Amy The Sociopath

What quite made Amy into the person who would do all this is never explicitly said. The way her parents have, through the Amazing Amy books, corrected all wrongs in her life suggest this is her taking a similar tact; whenever something doesn't go her way she adjusts her life to make it the perfect image (Tommy found her too intense, so she accuses him of raping her). The way she believes all relationships involve both partners striving towards an ideal outside of themselves (while arguably having a ring of truth) suggests a lack of real empathy; she desires the feeling of love, hence why she goes in strong with guys in an attempt to capture that, but as a sociopath is fundamentally unable to fully empathise and finds herself adjusting herself in the belief this will make things work. When this reaches an extreme, with circumstances pushing her relationships apart or the lack of feelings making them feel perfunctory, she feels wronged and then the real psycho comes out. She clearly understands emotions from the way she could convincingly write a diary implicating Nick, but whether she ever actually felt them isn't clear and there's definitely a sense of aspirations here. The ending really highlights this, with her ending one life and beginning another just because Nick going on TV and showing a knowledge of how her mind works makes her want to be with him again.

The Baby

In the first half, before the twist, Nick and Amy's conflict over having a baby plays a central part. You have Nick saying he was initially interested, but increasingly less so as his relationship with Andie grew, while Amy presents a version where she wants one, but only out of a self-aware attempt to reignite the marriage. And of course you believe Amy because, well, her story's the more extreme. It's one of the central contradictory parts of the case against Nick that totally sucks you in into the lies. In the final moments, in what could best be described as the film's climax, Amy reveals to Nick she's pregnant, scuppering his plans to reveal the truth in an interview with Ellen Abbott. This is one of Amy's sickest manipulations, bringing a whole new life into her scheme. And, unlike in the book, she's doing this without explicit knowledge of Nick's plans, showing a kind of forethought she's previously lacked. What makes this most interesting is that it's the usage of something he once loved to control him. Sure, it's not the same emotion driving the relationship, but it makes Nick's ultimate decision (to stay with her) that little more twisted. One point that, reading various comments across the web, has bemused film-only viewers is quite how Amy got pregnant when Nick, by his own admission, hasn't touched her. The explanation, which is elaborated slightly more in the book, is given in a one sentence reference to Nick's previous tests; she used his frozen sperm.

Nick Hitting Amy

When representing domestic abuse on screen there's always an attempt to present the vitcim as far from being a 'type' as possible; there's no one out there who inherently deserves it to happen to them. What's often less explored is that it can be the same on the other side; there are people out there who are naturally violent, sure, but most domestic abuse regrettably comes from people who wouldn't even expect it themselves. The film plays with the dark nature of this with Amy's accusations; like you'd expect any man to be, Nick was noticeably shocked by the initial claims of domestic abuse, with him clearly uncomfortable with having to later on accept the accusations on TV to clear Amy's story. Which only makes the moment when, after slinging the c-word back and forth, Nick slams Amy into a wall all the more shocking. She could of course use this as fuel against Nick, but given how all the previous claims were false it's less what she could do with it and more what it says about him. Even though it's after murder and arrests, the moment is still one that leaves you taken aback and serves as one of many ways the fictional thriller feels incredibly relevant. It's not in any way condoning or excusing it, but here we're seeing how even the most docile person can be pushed to extremes. How it happened is borderline fantastical, but the general notion - that anyone can have a lapse of control - is a potent one.

The Media Coverage

Although one of its central goals is looking at the effect of the media, with the scathing coverage of the story helping turn Nick into the chief suspect before him being christened a loving family man the moment Amy returns, the film doesn't push this to a nicely rounded conclusion. Fincher understands that it can't summed in a lovely quote and instead leaves it as in real life; an irritating constant. It could have been sorely mishandled; Rosamund Pike's other recent release, the dire Brit-com What We Did On Our Holiday, featured a third act that explored similar elements in a fleeting, but horrendously more explicit manner. The only form of any real pay-off to this strand is when Nick, in private, confronts Ellen Abbott about how she's being so friendly after previously relishing in the fact he may be killed by the state, to a dismissive response. In fact, the only public confrontation between the press and a key player in the story is when Detective Boney tells the press to get off Nick's lawn, which is only because that's in violation of the law. And it's in this distance that the film really makes its condemning look at the media. People can complain about how the press hounds victims and will make stories ahead of morals, but unless it's illegal (see the ongoing phone hacking scandal) people don't bat an eyelid.

Tanner Bolt's Ambivalence

One of the most unexpected treats of Gone Girl was Tyler Perry's performance as wife-killer lawyer Tanner Bolt. And one of the most unexpected moments of that character is that in the aftermath, with Nick desperate to find a way to reveal what Amy really did, he laughs the whole thing off and leaves the "the most f\ck£d up people" he's ever met to live their woefully dysfunctional marriage (and that is putting it lightly). The thing is, that's very much in his character, with a similar outlook to the previously discussed press approach. Throughout the film there's an underlying clash between him and Nick over what should be said; the suspect wants to tell the truth, while his lawyer wants to present things in a way skewed towards gaining him his freedom. Tanner doesn't give a toss about whether Nick killed his wife or not, only that he wins the case. At the end, Nick isn't facing going to jail, which is the extent of Tanner's interest in him; he may be living with a psycho who tried to frame him for murder, but at least he's not in prison, right?

Police Procedure

The other outsider aware of Amy's manipulation is Detective Rhonda Boney, who immediately relies on Nick's opinion the moment it's apparent he's not guilty. Although she fully believes Amy has orchestrated the whole thing she's utterly powerless to do anything about it. The case is now in the hands of the FBI and the presented story is airtight enough to not warrant further question. It's of course required from a narrative stand-point so why Nick didn't just go to the police isn't left as a niggling question, but it also adds to the downbeat compromise of the whole ending. Throughout the film the red tape of modern policing is ever present - the cliché of a hunch is repeatedly mocked for its ridiculousness and a murder case can't be made despite small pieces of evidence racking up - and the ending shows how, while this rigour helped Nick maintain his freedom, it's far from perfect. The downsides of police procedure was something Fincher has previously explored in Zodiac, with various neighbouring police departments poorly coordinated to such an extent that they didn't corroborate evidence on the titular serial killer.

The Final Moments And Marriage

Gone Girl kicks off with a dreamy soliloquy from Nick where he talks about scooping Amy's brains out. Playing into our expectations of a mystery thriller, it's quickly twisted to be a metaphor for the usual relationship ponderings of what the other person is really thinking. In the final shot this moment is returned to, with the same questions presented with a much more malicious meaning; "What are you thinking? What are you feeling? What have we done to each other? What will we do?" are a lot more probing than just whether someone's a little stuck in a rut. This is the film's real ace and where Fincher's aims really lie. Although the movie is an incredibly extreme case, the sort of compromise and façades Nick and Amy are engaging in are, to an extent, universal. The questions Nick asks about his murderous wife are the same a regular husband asks about his loving partner and the desire to be the happiest couple out there is common motivation to overlook various ingrained issues. It's not a condemnation of marriage or even love, but a show of how in the fog of a relationship glaring issues can be ignored in a bid to maintain the status quo. Amy's concentration of modern romance into an act of attaining the "Cool Girl" is an incredibly cynical outlook that serves as an embodiment of that many people fall in love with the idea of a person, rather than the person themselves. And while in Nick's case he fell for a psychopath who is seemingly only capable of this sort of manipulation, it's easy for two utterly unsuitable people to end up forging a life together (and, as Amy does at the end, believing it works). What did you think of Gone Girl? And what was you're lasting impression of the film's message? Let us know in the comments below.

Contributor
Contributor

Film Editor (2014-2016). Loves The Usual Suspects. Hates Transformers 2. Everything else lies somewhere in the middle. Once met the Chuckle Brothers.