3. Josh Holloway
Holloway seems to be a name that comes up often on message boards when people discuss the EFNY remake. I always ask myself why. I'm also curious if people aren't just repeating his name because they've seen others bring it up. I suppose being one of the cast members for Lost has earned him a lot of goodwill but I'm hard pressed to find any logical reason he qualifies to even be considered for one of the most iconic characters in pop culture history. I'm reminded of a line Seth Rogen said in Knocked Up when talking about Matthew Fox (also a co-star on Lost, which I'm now thinking is not a coincidence,) "you know what's interesting about Josh Holloway? Nothing!"