Every Transformers Movie Ranked From Worst To Best

Bumblebee finally got it right.

Bumblebee Hailee Steinfeld
Paramount

The seventh Transformers movie to date, Bumblebee, has just begun its international rollout, and you know what? It's pretty damn great, even winning over critics and scoring the first critically fresh entry into the franchise.

Indeed, it's fair to say that Transformers has been a mixed bag at the movies, starting with 1986's animated cult classic, before Michael Bay's five-film live-action franchise kicked off in 2007.

Bay's films have been routinely torn apart by critics, and rightly so, though it's worth bearing in mind that at least two of them dare to be somewhat decent. As for the others? Yikes.

If early box office tracking is to be believed, Bumblebee just might rejuvenate the franchise after The Last Knight was a commercial disappointment (yet still proved immensely profitable).

Either way, with over $4 billion in box office revenue, it's likely fans won't have to wait too long for yet another go-around.

Until, then, though, here's a stock-take of all seven Transformers movies released to date...


7. Transformers: Age Of Extinction

Transformers Age Of Extinction Optimus And Grimlock 1700x956
di Bonaventura Pictures

Picking a worst of the bunch is actually pretty tough because there are at least a few solid contenders, though 2014's fourth entry takes the cake for its sheer unapologetic, monotonous excess and that troubling moment.

Clocking in at a stamina-assaulting 165 minutes, Age of Extinction ditches Shia LaBeouf and drafts Mark Wahlberg in as his replacement, yet the core of the movie remains as crass and immature as ever.

This is a film where the boyfriend of Wahlberg's character's daughter (Jack Reynor) has to produce a card to prove he's not a statutory rapist, and it doesn't get much better from there.

The China setting is clearly just a transparent attempt to boost the box office (and it worked), while the movie is jam-packed with aggressive product placements, including a borderline-hilarious sequence where a Transformer crashes into a Bud Light truck, catapulting beer bottles all over the road.

The too-good-for-this Kelsey Grammer and Stanley Tucci provide some light relief, and Titus Welliver delivers arguably the series' most knowingly absurd one-liner to date ("My face is my warrant"), but the Dinobots get disappointingly lost in the movie's exhaustingly chaotic shuffle.

Also in a moment of surely wilful trolling on Bay's part, he has the nerve to have a character complain about Hollywood's lack of imagination. Jeez.


6. Transformers: Revenge Of The Fallen

Transformers Revenge Of The Fallen Shia LaBeouf Megan Fox
Paramount

Revenge of the Fallen is probably the most inane of the Transformers movies, lacking the vague air of self-awareness that blessed the later films and truly believing its Decepticon-with-testicles and racist caricature Autobots were genuinely cool.

The first Transformers sequel effectively doubles down on everything iffy about the original, namely the overtly sexualised female characters and humour which manages to be both vulgar and goofy as hell, yet rarely actually funny. Did anyone really need to see Sam Witwicky's (Shia LaBeouf) mother getting stoned?

It would be disingenuous to call the effects anything other than stellar, but without even a vaguely coherent plot, it's hard to much care. The third act is a disappointing mess and oddly doesn't deliver nearly enough of Bay's signature bombast.


5. Transformers: The Last Knight

Transformers 5 Last Knight
Paramount

Many consider The Last Knight to be the worst of the Transformers movies, but Michael Bay's final time in the director's chair benefits considerably from its go-for-broke weirdness.

This is a movie where Stanley Tucci is re-cast as a drunken Merlin who hangs out with the Autobots, Anthony Hopkins co-stars as a hammy, exposition-spouting old coot with a robot ninja for a butler, it's revealed that Hitler was assassinated by a Transformer, and Mark Wahlberg gets to swing Excalibur around.

A big part of the reason The Last Knight is fairly tolerable is the massively dialled-back sexism and racism - in large part due to casting the underage Isabela Moner as the female lead - not to mention a general lack of the embarrassing "humour" from previous movies.

Action-wise you know what you're getting here and it's all pretty tired by this point, to say nothing of the distracting ratio-switching during action scenes because Bay decided to shoot the film in about a dozen different ratios.

But it's about 10 minutes shorter than Age of Extinction, which is nice.


4. Transformers: Dark Of The Moon

Transformers Dark Of The Moon
Paramount Pictures

Easily the best of the sequels, 2009's Dark of the Moon actually offers up a fairly fun and interesting frame story, centred around the Space Race and the Transformers' role in it.

Though new female lead Rosie Huntington-Whiteley is sadly no substitute for Megan Fox - which, honestly, isn't saying much at all - the supporting cast is hilariously over-qualified, with not only John Malkovich and Frances McDormand grabbing some easy paychecks, but also Leonard Nimoy returning to the franchise to voice Sentinel Prime.

What really makes the movie work, however, is its firm commitment to insane action while scaling back the inane melodrama.

The climactic Battle of Chicago is pretty much a solid hour of explosions and gorgeous CGI, and while some might call it too much, it's easy to admire Bay's desire to one-up what came before.

You could probably trim an additional half-hour off the first two acts and it'd actually dare to be genuinely good. As it stands, you probably want to start watching about 90 minutes in and just enjoy the final hour of Bayhem.


3. The Transformers: The Movie

The Transformers The Movie
De Laurentiis Entertainment Group

Look, the 1986 Transformers animated movie is basically just a toy commercial strung together by a scarcely coherent plot, but it's also a breathless, action-packed and ludicrously entertaining effort.

Clocking in at roughly half the length of any of Bay's films, The Transformers: The Movie also gives The Last Knight a run for its money in the weirdness stakes.

This is a film where Orson Welles voices the all-devouring planet Unicron, Optimus Prime dies at the end of the first act, a character randomly says "s***!" and Eric Idle appears as a warbling, motormouth Autobot. And it's all set to an incongruous yet weirdly fitting glam rock soundtrack. Yup.

Honestly the narrative isn't leaps ahead of the Bay movies, but it generally has a firmer handle on what this world of characters is supposed to be and delivers snappy, easy viewing within a reasonable run-time.


2. Transformers

Transformers Megan Fox Shia LaBeouf Optimus Prime
Paramount

It's easy to just lump all of Bay's Transformers movies together, but the 2007 original actually had a little more going for it.

Yes, the goofball humour is still there in abundance, but the "boy and his pet" appeal of Sam Witwicky's bond with Bumblebee is really quite endearing, even if it clashes somewhat with the hormone-infused tone of it all.

The action has aged spectacularly well and is decidedly less busy than its more "ambitious" successors, while the plot is streamlined for simplicity's sake, making this decidedly easier to tolerate, if not actually enjoy.

Bay's usual excesses are still there, but considering the direction the franchise took thereafter, this is a positively restrained effort.

It was also fortunate enough to be the first of the Bayformers films, and therefore the mere mention of such didn't yet elicit groans from millions.


1. Bumblebee

Bumblebee movie
Paramount Pictures

Bumblebee is effectively a reboot-prequel to the Bay movies, by imitating Bay's house style but blatantly contradicting many elements of those films while also establishing a more affable, family-friendly tone.

Under the assured direction of Travis Knight (Kubo and the Two Strings), Bumblebee manages to be both a sweet tale of friendship between Hailee Steinfeld's young protagonist and her new robot pal, and also a rock solid family drama.

The comparisons to E.T. are unavoidable, and though the film arguably leans a little too much on that, the gorgeous action sequences and compellingly-acted drama meshes together startlingly well.

This is exactly what the live-action Transformers movies should've been from the start: ditch the sexist/racist/cringe-worthy garbage, keep it simple and focus on emotion and smaller-scale set-pieces.

Fingers crossed the movie performs well at the box office, because if it does, it could save the Transformers franchise from returning to the juvenile tone set by the Bay films.

How would you rank the Transformers movies? Shout it out in the comments!


In this post: 
Transformers
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.