Heath Ledger: 5 Awesome Performances And 5 That Sucked

Can't take our eyes off him...

Who know's where Heath Ledger could have been now. One of the most promising actors of modern Hollywood, his career, which had seen him work with some of the biggest actors and directors in the business, was tragically cut short when he accidentally overdosed on prescription medication. Given the direction his career was taking at the time of his death it's conceivable he could have become one of the all time greats. Rising up through Australian TV (although eschewing the usual stint on Neighbours), Ledger's star rocketed high in the early-naughties with the actor quickly becoming a dependable leading man. Mixing critically lauded turns with more mainstream fare that saw him show off his charisma and good looks, Heath found himself increasingly well revered. The actor's posthumous win of Best Supporting Actor at the Academy Awards the year after his death is one of the most emotionally wrought in the history of the ceremony, with the Kodak Theatre falling silent as his family paid tribute to the star. It serves as testament to the respect Ledger had amongst the acting community. In tribute to the great actor, this week our 5 Awesome Performances And 5 That Sucked segment turns its eye at the work of the late Heath Ledger.

5 Awesome Performances...

5. Patrick Verona - 10 Things I Hate About You

10 things i hate about you Ledger€™s Patrick is written as an Australian relocated to America, just so he can speak with an Ozzie twang. It seems lazy screenwriting to keep the actor from putting on a convincing accent (something we know he can do). But it doesn€™t really matter because he€™s so engaging the lapses never bother. 10 Things I Hate About You is Shakespeare€™s The Taming Of The Shrew reimagined as a teen comedy and just about does the whole concept justice thanks to a winning cast. Joseph Gordon-Levitt is as likeable as he always is and Julia Stiles is an entertaining shrew, but Ledger completely steals the show. Modernising Petruchio as a too-cool-for-school rebel (certainly too cool to use that phrase), he's effortlessly watchable. That all takes a back-seat, however, to his rendition of Can't Take My Eyes Off You. Totally in the spirit of John Hughes and played with swagger and a hint of earnest it's the film's standout scene and signalled to the world that Heath Ledger had arrived.

4. Dan Carter - Candy

Even as his star rose in America, Ledger would still return to his native Australia for the occasional project. The last one is a mixed bag, feeling rather unoriginal, but it features a convincing performance from Ledger. The idea behind the film is quite interesting - it charts a couple€™s wrestling with heroin use in three aptly titled segments, heaven (yay drugs), earth (ooh, this is hard - let€™s quit) and hell (we only bonded over heroin, let€™s break up) - but Trainspotting this ain€™t. The actors never become too disheveled and the film doesn't have much insight into the world of drugs. Thankfully it still works on a relationship level, with Ledger and Abbie Cornish working convincingly as a couple. Likable as a drug-using poet and convincingly taking us through addiction and recovery, Candy is a great example of how Ledger could elevate an otherwise average film.

3. €˜Robbie Clark€™ - I'm Not There

There€™s a reason some actors choose to take mainly supporting roles; there€™s a lot more opportunity to stretch their thespian legs when not carrying a whole film on their shoulders. That€™s why from an audience perspective its always refreshing to see a leading man do something a little smaller and remind us what made them so successful in the first place. I€™m Not There was a high-concept biopic of Bob Dylan that had six different actors portray the €œmany lives€ of the musical legend. Ledger was one of these versions, an actor starring in a biopic of a previous €œlife€ who acts as a way into Dylan€™s divorce from his wife Sara (it makes more sense in the film). He even gets to recreate the iconic cover of The Freewheelin' Bob Dylan, which is pretty damn awesome. It€™s a tricky concept to explain without giving the film's brilliance away, but make sure you check it out; all the actors, including Ledger, give it their all.

2. Ennis Del Mar - Brokeback Mountain

Coming with the both succinct but misleading nickname of €œthe gay cowboy movie€, Brokeback Mountain caught the attention of many less for the hanky-panky and more for bringing a totally convincing relationship to the screen. The two lovers in the movie are played by Jake Gyllenhaal and Ledger who both convincingly play the longing and social difficulty with none of the childishness the film was met with. It€™s kinda funny that a film that has its characters hated and shunned would find itself the centre of a similar controversy, despite there being forty years between when the (fictional) story is set and the film€™s release. Ledger certainly gets the meatier role, with his Ennis having to deal with the conflict of love for Gyllenhaal€™s Jack and duty to his family, as well as having to deal with the loss of his lover. The performance earned Ledger his first Oscar nomination, although like the film itself he lost out.

1. The Joker - The Dark Knight

The fan reaction to when Ledger was cast as the Joker in Christopher Nolan's sequel to Batman Begins makes Batfleck look moderately well received. A role that was viewed as in the sole possession of Jack Nicholson after his performance in Tim Burton's Batman, a dreamy leading man just didn't seem the person to take on the Clown Prince of Crime. How stupid those naysayers must have felt when the The Dark Knight hit. We already knew Ledger had done something special with the character from the trailers, but nothing could have prepared for just how unflinchingly crazed his take on the character was in the finished product. The coverage his performance got, particularly in reference his untimely death, helped boost the film to become one of the biggest of the past decade. It was so defining that now Nicholson€™s version of the character feels ridiculously cartoonish. When Ledger got posthumously awarded his Oscar for the role there was not one person who would claim it was undeserved. There€™s no doubt Ledger was one of the finest actors of his generation. But now let€™s take a look at some performances where we wasn€™t at his best.

And 5 That Sucked...

5. Tony - The Imaginarium Of Doctor Parnassus

The Imaginarium of Doctor Parnassus Heath Ledger died halfway through the shooting of The Imaginarium Of Doctor Parnassus, leaving Terry Gilliam in a very tricky situation; how could he finish the movie so that it works logically, but is also reverential to the great actor? The solution was actually rather simple thanks to the typically Gilliam-esque plot. Taking place half in the €˜real€™ world and half in the titular Imaginarium, Ledger had shot most of the scenes for the former, so it was decided new actors would play Tony in the other world, highlighting the character's duplicitous nature. Johnny Depp, Jude Law and Colin Farrell stepped up and the film ending up just about working narratively. However, while the character of Tony managed to work on screen, Ledger€™s performance didn€™t. With no scenes of him in the zany Imaginarium, what he delivered to the role isn€™t much; all set-up and no pay-off. It€™s a real shame his last role wasn't as awesome as it should have been.

4. Jakob Grimm - The Brother's Grimm

The Brother€™s Grimm had a woefully troubled production, with director Terry Gilliam and producers the Weinstein's not quite seeing eye to eye. You€™d expect Gilliam would be used to such clashes (he had to take out full page ads in newspapers to get Brazil released), but he€™d never come up against Harvey and Bob. So naturally the film ended up being a neutered mess, with style not only dominating over substance, but story as well. Acting as a fictional backstory to the creators of the modern fairytale, the film has Ledger and Matt Damon as the titular brothers, in this world con artists who get wrapped up in real magic. Both lead actors play things rather broad (the accents are eye-rollingly generic), with Ledger being uncharacteristically uninteresting - he has an odd character trait of holding his head down. You have to assume anything interesting he did was drowned out in the production issues.

3. William Thatcher - A Knight's Tale

A Knights Tale Some films you just know really want to be cool. A Knight€™s Tale is one of those films. A medieval adventure that spent obscene amounts of time on jousting matches and how good buddies the central characters were, it made some major (and very obvious) steps to appeal to a young audience; the soundtrack frequently dips into rock music for no real stylistic justification and Ledger was cast as the lead purely for his heartthrob status. Just look at the poster - all it says about the film is that "HEATH LEDGER IS IN THIS!" Heath has very little to work with; Thatcher€™s motivation is typical (oh no, his master died) and key character development is doled in conveniently-timed flashbacks. Worst of all, there€™s some chemistry with the other blokes, but none with the supposed love interests.

2. Casanova - Casanova

Heath Ledger Casanova Giacomo Casanova will forever be known as a massive womaniser. And although to a historian the story of his life offers more than just that, to the general populace his love of the fairer sex is his defining trait. So naturally you€™d expect the film adaptation of life be something so raucous it€™d make Christian Grey blush. Not quite. While the film got an R rating in America its 12 (PG-13 equivalent) in the UK should tell you that it really isn€™t pushing any boundaries, with the film appearing completely disinterested in exploring the sexual drive of the character. Casting Heath Ledger as the lothario, the film was a much more pandering mainstream affair than the reputation of Casanova befits, with no effort being put in to get him to look or even sound Italian. It didn€™t help that the same year BBC released a much better take on Casanova starring David Tennant, who surprisingly felt much more suited to the role.

1. Harry Faversham - The Four Feathers

Heath Ledger Four Feathers If you wanted a film to act as a screensaver The Four Feathers would more than do. It looks great. Well, aside from Heath Ledgers hairstyles that is. Featuring shaggy, bearded, foppish and even LEGO man, the various hairstyles the actor sports throughout the film are unsightly. Which is why it€™s a shame they€™re the most varied element in his performance. The Four Feathers is based on an 1900s novel with a very filmic narrative; our hero leaves the army and is gifted four white feathers as symbols of his cowardice, eventually unearning them through feats of bravery. It's so naturally cinematic that the book had been adapted six times before the bland 2002 attempt. Ledger€™s Faversham sports a totally unplacable 'British' accent and exudes little charisma, feeling indistinct in the usual adventure story. The action scenes are good, but whenever things get talky it falls apart. What do you make of our choices? Was The Dark Knight Ledger€™s best performance? What was his worst? Go to the comments and have your say.

Contributor
Contributor

Film Editor (2014-2016). Loves The Usual Suspects. Hates Transformers 2. Everything else lies somewhere in the middle. Once met the Chuckle Brothers.