Insidious: The Last Key - 2 Ups & 7 Downs
The worst one yet.
The fourth entry into the Insidious franchise, The Last Key, is in UK cinemas now, and...it's not good. Not at all.
Critics have had their say and tend to agree: this is your garden variety January horror movie, cynically dumped in cinemas by a studio well aware that there's nothing else for the teens to watch right now.
Though the franchise had surprisingly solid beginnings, it almost immediately fell into lazy habits with an array of speedily churned-out sequels, and The Last Key is just the latest uninspired effort to hoover up easy cash from the wallets of teens craving some harmless jumps on date night.
There are a few encouraging elements which suggest a movie with much more to offer, but they're mostly drowned out by the aggressively bland script and general lack of interest in doing anything adventurous or interesting.
You know what you're getting with this one, so proceed accordingly...
Downs...
7. It's Boring & Lacks Suspense
Despite clocking in at a totally reasonable 103 minutes, the film feels far longer than that due to the poor pacing and the simple fact that most of what populates the runtime is incredibly boring.
Though things kick off intriguingly enough with a flashback to Elise Rainier's (Lin Shaye) past, the present-set mystery, as Elise explores the remnants of her childhood home, is painfully dull for the most part.
It doesn't help at all that the various set-pieces within the house are agonisingly slow and totally bereft of anything approaching suspense or tension. Ultimately you're just left waiting for the next inevitable jump scare, and it makes huge portions of the movie an absolute chore to sit through.
The best movies in the series - the first one, basically - thrived on atmosphere, but this one is almost entirely lacking anything approaching an unsettling mood or tone.
6. The Painfully Bad Comic Relief
Because you don't want people to get too scared, The Last Key is filled with plenty of humour by way of the series' comic relief sidekicks Specs (series creator Leigh Whannell) and Tucker (Angus Sampson).
While it was mostly tolerable in the prior movies, here their one-liners and mugging reaches an unbearably cringe-worthy apex.
It doesn't help that most of the "laughs" in the second half of the film revolve around them creepily leering at Elise's two attractive young nieces (Spencer Locke and Caitlin Gerard). It's more offputting than funny, and even in their more harmless moments, the pair have never been more irritating.
5. It Can't Escape The Prequel Problem
An issue that faces the vast majority of movie prequels is that they're inherently less suspenseful than their predecessors, because the audience knows that certain key characters must survive the events of the movie.
That was true in the previous Insidious film - which was also a prequel - and it's true again here. We know that nothing substantial can happen to Elise, Specs or Tucker, and considering that the film doesn't give the audience any other characters to care about either, it puts a major dent in viewer investment.
Again, this might be fine for the undemanding teen crowd who are happy with some jump scares and little else, but for anyone craving something remotely visceral or substantial, it's an undeniable problem.
It's a tough bind for the filmmakers because, of course, Elise's fate is sealed. Still, for the fifth film they really need to do a better job coming up with new characters for the audience to actually give a damn about.
4. Too Many Jump Scares
This shouldn't be surprising to anyone who has seen an Insidious movie, but yes, there are a lot of jump scares in this film.
In fairness, they do feel a little less obnoxious and scaled-back compared to the previous entries, but there are still the usual loud noises and tension chords to get easy shrieks from the Friday night horror crowd.
To anyone who watches their share of horror, though, it's all painfully predictable and played-out, to the extent that most of the movie's set-pieces may find you simply groaning as you wait for the jump to sound off.
Crafting real suspense and horror takes effort, but when these movies continue to make insane bank regardless of how creatively stagnant they are, there's clearly no incentive to change things up.
3. All The Unintentional Comedy
While the actual, earnest attempts at comic relief mostly fall flat, there are some sure laughs to be had of the unintended, accidental variety.
From the wooden dialogue through to the ludicrously melodramatic, over-the-top "scares" and one excessively brutal death scene involving a bookcase, you can get some giggles out of this if you adopt the right mindset going in.
Mileage will probably vary for those craving a so-bad-it's-good night at the movies, because for as many laughs as the film musters, long stretches of it are also just stamina-sappingly dull and totally humourless, even when factoring in unintentional entertainment.
2. There's No Internal Logic
This is a frequent criticism of modern horror movies and the Insidious franchise is certainly no exception: the supernatural shenanigans throughout The Last Key have no clear, defined logic, which makes it even tougher to care about whatever nonsense is going on.
The very best horror movies lay down a clear set of rules about what can and cannot happen, and how the human characters can interact with the supernatural ones, but as with most of the previous Insidious films, there's basically a "throw everything at the wall and see what sticks" approach to the otherworldly mechanics.
The Further is an intriguing locale for sure, but the movie's array of paranormal phenomena sadly doesn't amount to much if you're constantly asking yourself why it's happening in the first place.
Some might defend the movie's slippery supernatural logic as willfully defying human understanding, but it's clear the filmmakers just didn't put much effort into it because they know the teen crowd doesn't care.
1. It's The Worst Film In The Franchise...So Far
Aside from the original film, the Insidious franchise hasn't exactly set a high bar for each successive sequel to clear, and even with that in mind, The Last Key is most definitely the worst film in the series to date.
Critics seem to agree, with the film scoring the worst reviews of the franchise, having surely been worn down by the series' patent refusal to introduce many interesting new ideas or change its formula up.
Of course, with The Last Key already making its budget back more than five times over, a fifth film will be in cinemas by 2020 at the latest, so there's always the potential for things to get much, much worse.
As bad as the fourth Insidious is, there are a few plusses that prevent it from being a total one-star trainwreck...
Ups...
2. Lin Shaye Steals The Show, As Usual
As regular as clockwork, Lin Shaye once again steals the show as elderly parapsychologist Elise Rainier, and to the filmmakers' mild credit, they have at least leaned into the character's popularity, effectively making her the series' protagonist.
A 74-year-old woman playing the lead in a horror franchise is virtually unheard of, and Shaye once again does fine work with what she's given, but let's be honest, she's not exactly given much, and deserves far better.
Shaye's presence keeps the film from falling into terrible territory, but far too much of the film still has her slowly walking around dingy locales or re-explaining things the audience has already been shown.
1. The Solid Supporting Cast
In addition to Shaye, the entire movie is honestly much better-acted than the film really deserves, which has been a frequent trend in the franchise.
Kirk Acevedo is suitably frazzled as the current owner of Elise's childhood home, Bruce Davison makes an entertaining, unexpected appearance as Elise's estranged brother, Josh Stewart is sinister in flashbacks as Elise's abusive father, and Locke and Gerard bring an affable quality to Elise's two troubled nieces.
It's mostly for squat, ultimately, due to the feckless script, but at least the acting never becomes eye-rolling or laughable. The cast are pros and they're trying their hardest to sell it all convincingly, even if they're fighting an uphill battle for the most part.
What did you think of Insidious: The Last Key? Shout it out in the comments!