Kong: Skull Island Review - 6 Ups & 5 Downs

John C. Reilly is the hero we deserve.

Kong Skull Island
Warner Bros.

Kong: Skull Island is the textbook definition of a mixed-bag movie. While it's clocked up a solid critical consensus on Rotten Tomatoes so far, it's also worth noting that the average score is only hovering around the 6.5 mark, indicating a film that's in or slightly above the three-star region.

Kong will likely end up frustrating many because it absolutely doesn't live up to the potential of the talents both behind and in front of the camera, but if you go in with the right mindset and take lofty expectations out of the equation, it does manage to serve up two hours of dumb popcorn escapism.

Almost every positive is counter-balanced by a negative point here, making Kong's latest reboot a resoundingly average, watchable effort. Here's why...

Downs...

5. The Cast Is Totally Wasted

Kong Skull Island Tom Hiddleston Brie Larson
Warner Bros.

First things first: if you're expecting anyone to put on an acting clinic here, this isn't the movie for you. Sadly the overwhelming majority of the admittedly strong cast aren't put to particularly compelling use, especially Tom Hiddleston's ex-SAS tracker and Brie Larson's photographer, both of whose character names you'll likely not remember, nor much of what they do throughout the movie.

Furthermore, John Goodman appears and disappears out of the film so much it feels like he had to rush off for a personal emergency during filming, Toby Kebbell is wasted on a lame-brained personal subplot that goes almost nowhere, Straight Outta Compton's Corey Hawkins and Jason Mitchell and indie darling Thomas Mann don't even make a dent, and finally, the brilliant Richard Jenkins shows up for a single forgettable scene at the very beginning of the movie.

The cast is an embarrassment of riches that the script frankly doesn't deserve, but it's safe to say the actors were at least well-compensated for simply being present and serving as recognisable faces for the marketing.


4. The Direction & Editing Are Incredibly Messy

Kong Skull Island Kong
Warner Bros.

Yeesh, this one was apparent from the trailers and is naturally amplified many times over in the final product. It's clear as day that The Kings of Summer director Jordan Vogt-Roberts wasn't ready for a $185 million movie after his indie debut cost maybe 5% of that at a push.

From leaning back on cheesy slow-motion to employing irritatingly choppy editing during many otherwise terrific moments, the potentially awe-inspiring visuals are undercut by Vogt-Roberts' lack of technical expertise, though honestly, it's hard to blame him for accepting such a potentially prosperous directing gig.

Though the film is clearly indebted hugely to Apocalypse now first and foremost, the elemental iconography is frequently usurped by impatient cutting away and a refusal to simply let images linger and breathe.


3. A Lot Of The Humour Falls Flat

Kong Skull Island John Goodman
Warner Bros.

A lot of people were bemused by the movie's second trailer, which featured much more humour than the fairly stoic and serious first, a common trend by movie studios when they're unsure of how to market a movie with a challenging tone (but more on that in a moment).

Yes, this version of Kong is filled with one-liners and quips, though sadly very few of them land with any impact. Some topical jokes most likely added in reshoots hit the mark and there's one hilarious action beat you won't forget anytime soon, but more often than not the jokes are so mild and effortless they needn't have been included at all.


2. The CGI Is (Mostly) Bad

Kong Skull Island Samuel L Jackson
Warner Bros.

Combined with the sloppy direction and editing, the CGI in this movie is really, really disappointing, especially considering that monstrous budget. Yes, the creature effects are mostly good, but the green screen sequences are almost laughably obvious for such a lavish production, with characters frequently outlined by a garish blur which makes it clear they've just been keyed-in in post-production.

There's also a lot of motion blur during action sequences which is a common tactic to try and conceal digital seams, but here it just looks incredibly ugly, especially during Kong's initial attack on the choppers, where one wax-like render of a soldier is hurled out of a chopper. It's a cliche to say it, but at its worst moments, it looks like a bad video game from about a decade ago. Not good.


1. The Tone Is Incredibly Weird

Kong Skull Island John C Reilly
Warner Bros.

This is sure to be one of the weirdest blockbusters of the year, largely because it doesn't really seem to know what it wants to be. Parts of the film are deadly serious and often horrifically violent, and then a gag will come wildly out of left-field in an attempt to lighten the mood.

It rarely works as intended, but more curiously, it makes one wonder exactly what this will mean for Warner Bros' "MonsteVerse" moving forward. After all, 2014's Godzilla took itself incredibly seriously for the most part, whereas Kong is much sillier in tone, so will one of the characters change their mood for the upcoming Godzilla vs. Kong movie, or will they attempt to meet somewhere in the tonal middle?

It's an interesting challenge moving forward and not beyond reconciling, but as for this movie, it just feels like it's got a bit of an identity crisis going on.

And now, here's everything that actually worked in the movie...


Ups...

6. Kong Is Awesome

Kong Skull Island Kong
Warner Bros.

Surprise, surprise, the best thing about this movie is the title character, and that's exactly the way it should be. Though Kong's screen time is typically limited to set-pieces, this isn't like Gareth Edwards' Godzilla: Kong shows up early and frequently without being hidden or obscured.

The sequences of Kong causing havoc and especially fighting other monsters are easily among the movie's highlights, and while this Kong doesn't bring with him the emotional pull present in Peter Jackson's 2005 effort, the creature looks great and will be a fascinating adversary for Godzilla in a few years' time.

As many missteps as the film makes, it nails the most fundamental aspect.


5. Samuel L. Jackson & John C. Reilly Steal The Show

Samuel L Jackson Kong Skull Island
Warner Bros.

Though most of the cast has little to do, Samuel L. Jackson and John C. Reilly give the film's most memorable performances as they attempt to wrestle the screen away from Kong himself.

Jackson is basically at his PG-13 best here, essentially recalling his popular persona as a very p***ed off U.S. Army Colonel looking to avenge Kong's havoc by blowing the beast to smithereens. He's as reliably ferocious as you'd hope for.

Reilly shows up around the mid-way point as a World War II veteran who has spent almost three decades stranded on the island. His oddball persona may not help straighten out the movie's tone, but his nervous energy is highly entertaining, and his back story is the only one with any emotion attached to it that actually pays off.


4. It's Surprisingly Violent

Kong Skull Island Spider
Warner Bros.

It's pretty surprising what you can get away with in PG-13 movies these days, especially as long as you don't show a drop of blood. There are a ton of human casualties in this film (of course), and while many of them simply involve someone getting munched by Kong or killed by a Skull Crawler off-screen, there are two deaths that stand out as especially gnarly.

One involves a man being graphically impaled through the mouth by a gigantic, spider-like creature, and the other involves a man having one of his arms ripped off by a pack of bird-like monsters, but because it's against the silhouette of the setting sun and no grisly gore is shown, apparently that makes it OK.

One imagines it's still pretty horrifying if you're a youngster, so parents best beware before taking their kids. As for adults? It's unexpectedly brutal fun.


3. The Soundtrack Is Awesome

Kong Skull Island Kong
Warner Bros.

Though you can certainly argue that it ends up being a little on-the-nose, the movie's killer soundtrack helps evoke that distinct 1970s vibe. With classic tunes from the likes of Jefferson Airplane ("White Rabbit"), Black Sabbath ("Paranoid"), Creedence Clearwater Revival ("Bad Moon Rising") and David Bowie ("Ziggy Stardust") among others, the musical selections are anything but subtle yet no less enjoyable for it.

In fact, the use of these iconic songs is somewhat at the expense of Henry Jackman's score, which fades to the periphery and is largely forgettable by comparison.


2. There Are Interesting Nods To The MonsterVerse

Godzilla Film 2014
Warner Bros.

Kong is the second entry into Warner Bros' MonsterVerse, which will release Godzilla: King of the Monsters in 2019 followed by Godzilla vs. Kong in 2020, and to its credit, it does manage to nod towards further adventures without feeling like it exists solely to sell those movies.

Aside from a few scattered references to the MUTOs from Godzilla, Kong remains a self-contained story until its post-credits scene, which hints at the battle awaiting Kong as well as the potential for other iconic Toho creatures to join the mix in the future.

Considering how aggressively superhero movies advertise the next movie at the end of the current one, it's refreshing that Kong didn't go overboard with the overzealous hype.


1. It Knows Exactly What It Is (And Delivers Accordingly)

Kong Skull Island
Warner Bros.

And finally, though Kong has a ton of problems and is far from a great movie, it is at least fully aware of its B-movie origins and largely gives itself over to that.

There are mood and tone issues, yes, but if you come to see this movie hoping to witness a giant ape beat the s*** out of some other giant monsters, then you'll probably be satisfied to that end.

It also doesn't get over-indulgent with the run-time, clocking in at "only" 118 minutes, which these days is rather on the slender side for blockbuster fare. It gets in, doesn't make you wait long for Kong, gets out, and won't eat up a massive chunk of your day. Sometimes that's enough.

What did you thing of Kong: Skull Island? Shout it out in the comments!


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.