Mute Review: 4 Ups & 6 Downs

Another Netflix disappointment.

Mute Alexander Skarsg Rd
Netflix

Moon and Source Code director Duncan Jones has been developing his new straight-to-Netflix sci-fi thriller Mute for over a decade, with the director first posting concept art online way back in 2009.

Due to the trickiness of the premise, however, Jones was unable to secure funding until recently, with Netflix backing the project and once again allowing a talented genre filmmaker fertile ground to do what they do: create.

A shame it is, then, that despite Netflix giving him free reign to realise his Blade Runner-inspired vision, Mute just isn't that good. Though not the abject disaster many other early reviews paint it as, Mute is nevertheless an underwhelming monument to failed potential.

With Jones' clear directorial skill and a cast this splendid, it's clear that the filmmaker needs to let others write his scripts, because four films into his career, a clear pattern has already emerged.

Is Mute worth a watch if you've got a Netflix account? Probably. There are merit-worthy elements for sure and it's interesting enough, but given the lengthy gestation period and how much of a passion project this was for Jones, it's a damn shame the end result feels so utterly pedestrian...


Downs...

6. The Plot Is Surprisingly Dull

Mute Alexander Skarsgard
Netflix

Though Mute wears its cyberpunk and film noir influences on its sleeve, it's surprising just how uninteresting the core narrative is.

We follow mute bartender Leo (Alexander Skarsgård) as he attempts to locate his missing girlfriend Naadirah (Seyneb Saleh), a simple and familiar premise that one hoped Duncan Jones would elevate with his heightened setting.

Sadly, though, when you strip away the shiny gloss, the actual plot itself feels stuck in neutral for pretty much the entire runtime, plodding along and failing to pay off in many ways subversive or unexpected.

It is a story that, more often than not, feels like it's just going through the motions, and as such it's hard to get too invested in what's going on. You'll generally see where it's going a few beats ahead of time, and as such it's easy to see why so many conventional movie studios probably passed on Jones' script.


5. The Pacing Isn't Great

Mute Alexander Skarsgard
Netflix

Mute clocks in at a meaty 126 minutes, and you will certainly feel the extent of that length by the time it's all over.

Pacing is a real issue here, with Jones taking his time to tell his not especially compelling story, and clearly hoping that the visuals will help fill in the blanks.

Jones is obviously trying to pull a Blade Runner and create a meditative, moody film that's in no rush to move along, but without the filmmaking finesse of a director like Ridley Scott or Denis Villleneuve, nor a sufficiently involving script, it ends up feeling more airless than contemplative.

There are frequent lurches in pace where it feels like things should ramp up, but Jones usually goes in the total opposite direction and cranks things down a few more notches.

Simply, the film could've used another pass in the edit bay before being picture-locked.


4. Sam Rockwell's Cameo Is A Total Disappointment

Sam Rockwell Moon Movie
Sony Pictures Classics

Jones piqued a lot of fans' interest when he confirmed a long time ago that Sam Rockwell would have a cameo in the film, reprising his Sam Bell role from Jones' brilliant directorial debut Moon.

Sadly Rockwell's appearance, which is spread over two separate scenes, lasts maybe 30 seconds in total and adds very little to the film or the overall sense of world-building.

It's a vaguely cute Easter egg for Moon fans more than anything, but if you were hoping to see Sam Bell interacting with this world and a significant bridge being created between the two films, you'll most certainly be left wanting.


3. The Tone Is A Mess

Mute Paul Rudd
Netflix

Though it at first seems like Jones is trying to craft a moody, downbeat slice of grim cyberpunk noir, Mute's tone ultimately ends up fluctuating quite violently at times, typically when the director attempts to inject some humour and eccentricity into his world.

While the clear intention to stop things from getting self-consciously grimdark is admirable, the effort just doesn't quite work.

Some comical exchanges between Paul Rudd and Justin Theroux's surgeon characters Cactus Bill and Duck fall especially flat, and there's a baffling scene featuring Dominic Monaghan that, well, really has to be seen to be believed.

There's severe mood whiplash between these moments and the more serious core narrative, to the extent that Jones probably should've just committed to making something totally straight-faced.


2. The Totally Pointless Justin Theroux Subplot

Mute Justin Theroux
Netflix

No spoilers here, but there's an eyebrow-raising subplot in this movie involving Justin Theroux's character that just feels wildly unnecessary.

It's sure to be Mute's most controversial and debated element, a thoroughly unsavoury aspect of his character that feels tacked on in order to reinforce that, as if it isn't clear already, this guy's not exactly a kosher dude.

While Jones could've found a way to give this subplot a substantial payoff by film's end, he instead settles for something much lazier and less interesting, likely leaving you wondering why he threw something so gross and left-field into the film at all.


1. It's An Exercise In Style Over Substance

Mute Alexander Skarsgard
Netflix

Calling a movie "style over substance" can be an incredibly trite complaint, but it absolutely holds true for Mute.

Some might argue that the style is indeed the substance here, but considering that much of the world-building on display feels like it's cribbing over-eagerly from Blade Runner, that's not really good enough.

It is a film propelled by its style, but that's not nearly sufficient to paper over a narrative that treads water for so long and ultimately doesn't add up to the gritty, consistently intriguing whole fans of Jones' first two films were clearly hoping for.

While Mute is an undeniable disappointment, it's certainly not the flaming trainwreck a lot of early critics are implying. Here's what Jones got right...


Ups...

4. Alexander Skarsgård Is An Impressively Subdued Lead

Mute Alexander Skarsgard
Netflix

Alexander Skarsgård has quite the task on his hand here as a voiceless protagonist who must use his physicality and facial expressions to sell his character to the audience.

Though the actor certainly isn't working with the best material, he at least does a solid job conveying the downtrodden heartbreak of his character, especially in the third act when things naturally get their diciest.

Did he deserve better? Absolutely, but he rises to the challenge of an unconventional lead part, and generally won't leave you wishing he'd just open his damn mouth.

Plus, his chiseled good looks make him an easy fit for Jones' visually vibrant world, ensuring the camera loves him in just about every moment.


3. The Gorgeous Visuals

Mute Alexander Skarsgard
Netflix

For the many mistakes Jones makes creatively, it's hard to fault the film's impressive visual spectacle. Again, the world does feel overly indebted to Blade Runner - right from an early glimpse of a dust sweeper that feels ripped straight from it - but the general production design and visual effects quality help create a film that, above all else, is incredibly easy on the eyes.

Jones could definitely have done more with his shot selections, which sometimes feel rushed and a little too TV-esque for their own good, but from moment to moment, it's a handsomely mounted effort that makes it a little easier to put up with the film's scripted pitfalls.


2. Paul Rudd's Against-Type Performance

Mute Paul Rudd
Netflix/EW

Paul Rudd gives one of the more intriguing and against-type performances of his career in this film as American surgeon Cactus Bill, who holds a key to Naadirah's whereabouts and sees Rudd cleverly flipping the script on his usual charming persona.

From the early glimpses of his character's offbeat sensibilities, it's clear that a sinister undercurrent percolates underneath, and Rudd does fine work slowly unraveling the full extent of this.

Yes, the aforementioned tonal and scripting issues do chip away at the full potential of his performance, but he's easily its most praise-worthy aspect, and acquits himself far better than many may have anticipated.


1. Clint Mansell's Entrancing Musical Score

Mute Alexander Skarsgard
Netflix

The fantastic Clint Mansell provides the film's musical score - just as he did on Moon - and true to form, it's another hypnotic, synth-driven sci-fi score from one of the best composers in the business.

It's probably fair to say that the score is not among his very best work - it feels a little derivative and familiar in places - but it nevertheless helps create an emotional cushion for the film's less-assured moments.

More than anything, it ensures that even when the script or direction falters, as it frequently does, Mute is an absolute feast for the ears.

What did you think of Mute? Shout it out in the comments!


In this post: 
Mute
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.