Oscars 2014: Predicting 10 Best Director Nominees

martin-scorsese-la-invencion-de-hugo Auteur theory states that the final product that is any film solely belongs to the film's director, as he is ultimately the "author" of the film. Some may see this as narcissism and egotism run rampant, but it is a theory I fully subscribe to. While film is obviously an extremely collaborative art form, as can be attested to by staying to the end of the credits of any movie, it is on the directors shoulders that the responsibility of the film's final outcome rests. He or she is the one who must make the decisions that shape the voice and the aesthetic framework of the film which will eventually come to define it. Given my view on the paramount role that a director has on their film, it will probably come as no surprise to you that the Academy Awards' Best Director category is one of my favorite and most eagerly anticipated awards of the Oscars. Outside of Best Picture, there is no category that makes me more passionate than Best Director. The directors who have and haven't won this award have come to define some of biggest blights on the history of the Academy Awards. Critics who would delegitimize the worth of Oscar's ability to proclaim any film as a significant piece of cinema will often sight that fact that such highly regarded directors as Orson Welles, Alfred Hitchcock, and Stanley Kubrick never received a Best Director Oscar from the Academy and there really is nothing the Academy can say to refute this unfortunate fact. As Woody Allen once stated, "When you see who wins those things - or who doesn't win them - you can see how meaningless this Oscar thing is." This is why I view Best Director as such an important award. In the end, who receives this award really says more about the Oscars themselves than it does about any particular director. Currently, there is a plethora of talented directors who have yet to be crowned with an Oscar, while other, maybe not as highly thought of directors (Tom Hooper anyone?) have managed to gain approval from the Academy. While the Academy has managed to rectify some of their more obvious omissions in the past decade by rewarding such cinematic giants as Martin Scorsese, the Coen Brothers, and Danny Boyle with a Best Director award, other great contemporary auteurs such as Quentin Tarantino, Paul Thomas Anderson, Terrance Malick, David O. Russell, David Fincher, Ridley Scott, and David Lynch have yet to win the Best Director award, where as directors such as Christopher Nolan, Wes Anderson, David Cronenberg, Richard Linklater, and Tim Burton have never even received a nomination in the category, much less a win. In some of these cases, there is still time to for the Academy to redeem itself and award some of these immensely talented directors. This year in particular, the Academy may have the opportunity to award would-be first time winners such as David O. Russell, Ridley Scott, Bennett Miller, and Paul Greengrass, or they could add to the totals of such vaunted directors as Martin Scorsese and the Coen Brothers. Or, maybe, they'll just give George Clooney an Oscar, because... well, he's George Clooney. Whoever the Academy finally decides to deem the best director of 2013, it's likely to be a competitive race this year, which makes it entertaining for pundits such as myself. In the meantime, check out my list of the ten likeliest directors to end up with a nomination come 2014, and be sure to catch my next article too, which will dissect 2014's Best Original Screenplay category.

10. David O. Russell - American Hustle

davidorussell600 It's strange now to think about it, but just a few short years ago David O. Russell's name was kryptonite to Hollywood. After some infamous dust ups on the set with his actors in the late 1990's and early 2000's, Russell was finding it hard to get a movie made. He was absent from the world of movie-making for a relatively long six year period in between 2004's I Heart Huckabees and 2010's The Fighter, but like his protagonist in the latter film, he may have been down but he most certainly wasn't out. The Fighter was somewhat of a surprise sensation in 2010, grossing over $93 million domestically and receiving seven Oscar nominations including two Oscar victories for Christian Bale and Melissa Leo. Russell followed that up with last year's Silver Linings Playbook, and even bigger hit grossing over $132 million domestically and receiving eight Oscar nods, winning Jennifer Lawrence the Best Actress Oscar. Suffice it to say then, Russell has more than redeemed himself and is now quite the hot commodity in Hollywood. Given his new found cache, Russell has decided to use his clout to make his newest feature, American Hustle. The film chronicle the true story of the Abscam scandal, a sting operation in the 1970's where the FBI employed professional con artists to expose corruption among the political elites. Russell has assembled an astounding all-star cast (the actors equivalent of The Avengers) that includes Bradley Cooper as the FBI agent running the operation, Christian Bale and Amy Adams as the professional con artists who also happen to be lovers, Jennifer Lawrence as Bale's troubled wife, and Jeremy Renner as a particularly over-the-top corrupt mayor of the town of Camden, New Jersey. There are also promised appearances from actors such as Robert De Niro, Michael Pena, and comedian Louis C.K., and the patron saint of auteurist cinema herself, Megan Ellison, is producing the film. The film's plot promises to be the mix of absurdist humor and drama that David O. Russell has blended so effortlessly in the past. I seriously could not think of more appropriate material for Russell to tackle than this, and given his ascendancy as of late, this very well could be the crowing jewel of his recent work. Whether this hyperbole turns out to be the true or not, as long as the film is decent, I expect Russell to receive a nomination, and given that his next film is said to feature Robert De Niro and Leonardo DiCaprio in a film accusing the mafia of being responsible for the JFK assassination, I hardly think this will be Russell's last rodeo either way.

9. Martin Scorsese - The Wolf of Wall Street

Martin Scorsese There probably is no more a legendary director working in the film business today than Martin Scorsese. Francis Ford Coppola has never been able to regain his peak form post-Apocalypse Now, George Lucas sold out his artistic cred a long time ago, and Steven Spielberg still has Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull to answer for, which leaves Scorsese the most unscathed of his peers. In fact, in terms of his success with the Academy, Scorsese is really in the prime of his career. The iconic director has been nominated for the Best Director award a total of seven times. Of these seven nominations, four have come since the dawn of the new millennium (the three previous nominations being for Goodfellas, The Last Temptation of Christ, and Raging Bull, as inexplicably, he was not nominated for Taxi Driver, possibly the worst omission in the history of the Oscars), so to say he has been on a role with the Academy lately is quite an understatement. Out of all his feature films since the year 2000, only Shutter Island was shut out of both the Best Director and Best Picture categories. It doesn't take an individual with an especially high ID then to figure out that Scorsese's newest film, The Wolf of Wall Street, will likely end up in the 2014 awards conversation. The Wolf of Wall Street is based on the autobiography of the same name by Jordan Belfort. Belfort was a successful stockbroker during the tech boom of the 1990's and he lived his life to excess until it all came crashing down on him when the FBI came a-knocking at his door. Frequent Scorsese collaborator Leonardo DiCaprio will star as Belfort, while a string of other excellent actors such as Matthew McConaughey, Jonah Hill, and Jean Dujardin are set to make appearances as well. The film's script was written by Terrance Winter, the show-runner of the excellent HBO series Boardwalk Empire, of which Scorsese is an executive producer on, so all the pieces are set for an excellent, awards-friendly movie. With the pedigree of the people involved and the choice subject matter of the film, it would really be more of a shock if Scorsese didn't get nominated for Best Director than if he did. Sight unseen, I would still say his chances of a nomination are probably at least 60%. If Scorsese does manage to get the Best Director nomination, it will be quite the historic one, because it would tie him with the legendary Billy Wilder as the second most nominated director in Oscar history. And who knows, if Scorsese still has another good decade left in him, he may even surpass William Wyler's record for the most Best Director nominations (12).

8. Bennett Miller - Foxcatcher

Bennett Miller Director Bennett Miller has been very successful with the Academy thus far in his extremely young career. On his first feature length outing, Capote, Miller managed to get the film a Best Picture nomination (back when there was still only five nominees) as well as a Best Director nomination for himself and a Best Actor win for the film's star, Phillip Seymour Hoffman. On his second film, Moneyball, he again managed a Best Picture nomination, as well as netting Brad Pitt his acting nomination. At this point then, he is pretty much batting 1.000, so the third film in his blooming oeuvre, Foxcatcher, has to be considered a serious contender. The film has a fascinating premise. Based on the real life murder of former Olympic champion David Schultz at the hands of the schizophrenic heir of the du Pont fortune, John du Pont, the film sounds ripe for Oscar's plucking. Miller proved how adept he is at handling this sort of high drama material with Capote, and mental illness that results in such tragic events as this usually plays well with the Academy. Miller has a pretty good cast in place for the key roles in the film. Mark Ruffalo will play the former Olympic champion and future homicide victim David Schultz, while Channing Tatum plays his bother, a former wrestling champ himself, Mark Schultz. There will also be appearances from the likes of Vanessa Redgrave and Anthony Michael Hall, but perhaps the most interesting bit of casting in the film is that of comedian Steve Carell as the paranoid multi-millionaire John du Pont. Carell has dabbled in dramatic material before, but this is a challenge of a whole different level, and if he manages to stun everyone with his dramatic deftness, is will be the type of image-altering role that can't help but reflect well on the director too. It is inevitable that at some point, Bennett Miller will take a misstep in his career. All directors stumble along the way in their careers, even the great ones, but Foxcatcher just sounds too promising not to believe it will be a major awards player. And if it is a serious contender during the season, Miller will unquestionably be in the hunt for a Best Director nomination.

7. Joel and Ethan Coen - Inside Llweyn Davis

coens600 If I had written this article pre-Cannes, the Coens would have just missed making the cut. Post-Cannes, the Coens are easily one of the heaviest contenders of the race, that's how well Inside Llewyn Davis went over at Cannes. While it may have not taken the Palme d'Or (the three-hour French lesbian drama, Blue is the Warmest Color, took that prize, but will unlikely be a serious competitor for the Oscar), instead settling for second place with the Grand Prix prize, the real winner of Cannes in terms of 2014's forthcoming Oscar race was inarguably Inside Llewyn Davis. Everybody, and I mean that in its most literal sense, liked the newest film from the Brothers Coen. Some were ecstatic, some were just sufficiently pleased, but all Oscar prognosticators on the Croisette agreed that we have a major awards player on our hands. Despite my fanboy-ish devotion to all things Coen, I was rather skeptical of their newest film's awards prospects before Cannes. The reason being was two-fold: 1. The film sounded too slight to garner the necessary support of the notoriously non-nuanced Academy voting body and, 2. The film's distributor, CBS Films, doesn't have the greatest track record when it comes to running Oscar campaigns. On the first part, it is still an issue that mildly concerns me. The film chronicles the attempt of a struggling folk musician to make it into the big leagues of the music industry in Greenwich Village during the heyday of the scene in the early 1960's. The film apparently lacks a strong narrative and even those who professed to loving the film described it as "intimate", not a typical adjective that comes to mind when you think of films nominated at the Oscars for Best Picture. On the second front, my fears have been greatly allayed. While it is true that CBS Films doesn't have a great track record in procuring its films Oscar nominations, they sound like they have a good plan in place for Inside Llweyn Davis. The film is set for an early December release, which is prime real estate for Oscar season, and the film will undoubtedly make the rounds of the festival circuit to make sure it doesn't disappear from the conversation as new shinier films make their debut. Most excitingly though maybe CBS Films' plan to put on a tour for the film's music, which is said to play an essential part in the movie. This sort of out of the box thinking will likely make voters take notice and can only help the chances of the film. Of course, the fact that it's the Coens doesn't hurt either. They would be receiving their fourth Best Director Oscar nomination if it does occur, and the fact they were able to sneak in over directors such as Christopher Nolan for True Grit show they have become established members of the club in the mindset of the Academy. We won't know for sure before the competition shows it stuff, but I wouldn't bet against the Coens.

6. George Clooney - The Monuments Men

george_clooney_37190 Putting last year's snub of Ben Affleck aside, the Academy has a long history of rewarding actors who try their hand at directing. Whether it be Clint Eastwood, Ron Howard, Mel Gibson, Kevin Costner, Robert Redford, or Warren Beatty, the Academy has crowned a fair share of their actors as the best "director" of the year. If I were cynical man, which I am, I would say that this phenomenon might have something to do with the fact that the Academy's Actors branch is the largest branch of the voting body, but whether the actors-turned-directors won their directing awards on merit or not, it's safe to say that you should always be on the Oscar lookout anytime an actor makes a successful transition from in front of the camera to behind it. Given these statistics, it is merely just a matter of time before the Academy declares George Clooney, one of the most beloved figures in the history of Hollywood, the best director of some future year, and that year may very well likely turn out to be 2014. In fact, when all is said and done, George Clooney may end up being awarded more Oscars in separate categories than any other human being in history, but that's a subject for a different article. What is for sure though is that there will be much pre-release awards buzz for Clooney's next directorial effort, The Monuments Men. The Monuments Men, based on a real event, spotlights the efforts of art historians and museum curators to save priceless paintings from the clutches of the Nazis during the Second World War. With its mix of suspense and historical basis, many are comparing the film to last year's Best Picture winner, Argo, which won Mr. Clooney his second Oscar as a producer of that film. While no one has seen The Monuments Men yet, judging by appearances, the comparison seems apt, which is likely good news for Clooney and company. Clooney, who stars in the picture as well, has an all-star cast to help make him look good. This includes the likes of his buddy Matt Damon, Cate Blanchett, John Goodman, Bill Murray, and the man who beat him out in the Best Actor category just a few short years ago, Jean Dujardin. Clooney was nominated once before in this category (for his directorial work on Good Night, and Good Luck), so we already know he has some respect from the Directors branch (unlike Ben Affleck). If the film feels too similar to Argo, there may be some in the Academy who are reticent to go back to that same well so quickly, but in all likelihood The Monuments Men will be a monumental player in the 2014 awards season, as will Mr. Clooney himself.

5. John Wells - August: Osage County

John_wells If you are scratching your head and saying, "Who in the Sam Hill is John Wells?" (because I assume the majority of my readers talk like Yosemite Sam), don't fret, Mr. Wells is easily the most low profile name to make it on this list. John Wells up to this point in his career has worked mostly in television, as a writer and producer on a myriad of different shows. His one foray into the feature film business came in 2010 with The Company Men, an economic recession drama starring Ben Affleck that received a middling response from critics and audiences alike. This may all change though this fall, because Wells is directing August: Osage County, an adaptation of a very successful Tracy Letts play that is likely to be a player in this Oscar season. The play, which focuses on a bitter family reunion in Oklahoma when the family learns of their sardonic matriarch's diagnosis of cancer, was wildly popular among theatre awards bodies, so there is reason to suspect it can pull off the same trick with cinematic awards bodies as well. Particularly given the fact that the film has a staggering cast that includes the venerable Meryl Streep as it star, Julia Roberts as it co-star, and supporting players such as Juliette Lewis, Ewan McGregor, Sam Shepard, Benedict Cumberbatch, Chris Cooper, and Abigail Breslin, its hard to imagine it won't be seeing some awards attention. In fact, the biggest question mark for the film is Mr. Wells himself. Hardly a proven director, it's somewhat surprising to see a movie with this prestigious a cast to be handed over to a relative newbie. In all honesty though, and this is meant as no disrespect to Mr. Wells who may be a fine director, the film doesn't really need that great a director to be successful. Plays such as this are usually fairly well mapped out by the screenwriter and the director can often times act mostly as a facilitator for the actors to work through (like a head coach in the NBA), and although this hasn't been so much the case recently, the Academy has often rewarded films based on plays helmed by inessential directors. We do know that, with George Clooney and Grant Heslov producing, as well as Harvey Weinstein (whose 2013 awards lineup looks a little subpar this year), the film will be aggressively campaigned for during the Oscar season. Even if the film is incredibly successful with the Academy though, the question remains whether or not the Directors branch will view the film more as a triumph of writing and acting than directing? Of course, we will not know the answer to this question until the film is released, but I have the sneaking suspicion that this narrative may begin to develop as the season plays itself out, possibly leaving Mr. Wells out in the cold while better known directors take his place in the Best Director lineup.

4. Jason Reitman - Labor Day

Jason Reitman As with Bennett Miller, Jason Reitman has been considerably successful with awards bodies in his short career as a director. His first film, Thank You for Smoking, may have gone unnoticed by the Academy (although it did manage to snag two Golden Globe award nominations), but his next movies, Juno and Up in the Air, were both nominated for Best Picture and also earned Reitman himself Best Director nominations. His last film, Young Adult, which did receive some good notices, ended up being way too dark and biting for the Academy's taste. His next film though, Labor Day, based on the novel of the same name by Joyce Maynard, is much more likely to be up the Academy's alley. The film tells the story of a struggling single mother (Academy favorite Kate Winslett) and her teenage son who pick up a distressed hitchhiker (Josh Brolin) on their drive home. The hitchhiker turns out and escaped convict on the run from the law, which puts mother and son in a very precarious situation, as they are basically held hostage in their own home. While Reitman's films have often had serious subtext behind them, this appears to be his first attempt at straight out drama, leaving his satirical comedy roots behind. It will be interesting then to see how he handles such material, but as long as he doesn't completely bungle it, I suspect the Academy will be kind to his newest venture. Both critics and voters alike have showered praise on Mr. Reitman whenever he has shown his more humanist side, and Labor Day promises to be an exercise in humanism if nothing else. The key for Reitman's prospects will likely be where the film ranks among its Best Picture competitors. With the expanded field, it is very likely Labor Day could receive a Best Picture nomination without a corresponding Best Director nomination for Mr. Reitman. With such lofty directors as Martin Scorsese and the Coen Brothers in the mix, the Directors branch may feel Labor Day is too much of a trifle compared to others' work, even if they respect the job Reitman does on the film. If this turns out to be the case, Reitman may be attending the Oscars without being an actual nominee himself.

3. Paul Greengrass - Captain Phillips

paulgreengrass600 Paul Greengrass' mix of documentarian-realism and quick-cutting action hasn't exactly caught on with the Academy yet. The Bourne movies were obviously never going to compete for Oscars outside of the technical categories, but Greengrass' last feature, Green Zone, pretty much bombed on all accounts. The only film of his that met with minor success at the Academy was his 9/11 flick, United 93, which earned Greengrass a Best Director nomination. Due to this history, I have been a little skeptical of both Greengrass' chances and the chances of his newest film, Captain Phillips, when it comes to the 2014 Oscar season. The film, which as typical of much of Greengrass' work, is based on a true story. It tells the tale of a Captain of a U.S. cargo ship who offered himself up as hostage to Somali pirates in order to attain the freedom of his crew. It was kind of a big event on the news when it occurred and if modern society and technology hasn't shortened our memories to the point of a few years (the events occurred in 2009), the film will likely draw in viewers who were captivated by the story when it occured. As I was saying though, while many Oscar pundits have been high on this film's awards prospects since the beginning of the year, I have been a bit more hesitant on its odds until very recently, when the first trailer for the film dropped. While you must always take precautions about putting too much importance on a trailer (as I'm sure many of you have learned over the years), as trailers go, this is quite the gem. Terse, focused, and self-restrained, this looks to be Greengrass' most unfussy, straight forward film to date (which is a good thing in my book). Greengrass may have some good narratives (other than the film's story) to go along with the movie too. Particularly with the film's star, Tom Hanks, there will be a lot of Hollywood insiders who will be all too eager to welcome Hanks back into the awards season shuffle after nearly a decade away. This attention on Hanks can only benefit the film's, as well as Greengrass', prospects at receiving awards notices. Until we get some early reviews, this film will definitely remain somewhat of a mystery, and if it is too action-oriented, I think we can all but dismiss its chances, but as time goes on, I am only becoming more convinced that Captain Phillips and everyone associated with it will likely be major awards players come a few months time.

2. Alexander Payne - Nebraska

alexanderpayne600 Before the film's premiere at Cannes, I originally had Payne ranked much higher on my list of potential Best Director nominees. Since then, given the generally positive, but relatively cool response the film received at the world's most prestigious film festival, I have obviously adjusted my expectations of its shot at awards glory accordingly. Now it is true that the film did win Bruce Dern the festival's Best Actor award, so there were obviously aspects of the film the Cannes jury (which was made up of more than a few Academy members) did appreciate, and anyone who doesn't count Bruce Dern as a serious Best Actor contender for the Oscars is lying to themselves. The more important question remains though, what about the film's chances in other categories? While many awards pundits have begun to write Nebraska off as a potential Best Picture player, I contend it is still too early to do so. The black-and-white, father-son road trip movie about a senile man who takes the journey from Montana to Nebraska in order to claim a fictitious sweepstakes prize is not the type of stuff the Cannes crowd dreams of. Instead, it is the bread-and-butter mix of comedy and drama that fans of middle-brow films, such as the bulk of the Academy, devour on sight. They did so with Payne's last film, The Descendants, and while that film received better notices overall, it had its fair share of critics as well who were leveling very similar negative remarks as to what is being said about Nebraska, yet that didn't deter the Academy from nominating The Descendants for a slew of awards. Alexander Payne has been very lucky with the Academy thus far, and it is inevitable that not every film he releases will be nominated for major awards. As many who have seen the film are saying, Nebraska may be simply too insignificant to pick up real awards traction during the season. If this is true, even if the film somehow managed to sneak into the expanded Best Picture lineup, Alexander Payne would be unlikely to be nominated for Best Director. Before we can make that final judgment though, quite a few more audiences need to weigh in first.

1. Steve McQueen - Twelve Years a Slave

Steve-McQueen Perhaps above all other branches (with the possible exception of the Writers branch), the Directors branch is inclined to stick up for artistic achievements that fall on the outside of mainstream cinema. Whether it be foreign auteurs, such as Truffaut, Bergman, Fellini, Kurwosawa, and Haneke, or simply directors expanding the boundaries of cinema like Stanley Kubrick with 2001: A Space Odyssey or Terrance Malick with the Tree of Life, the Directors branch have time and again showed their willingness to fight for directors and films that the Academy as a whole tends to ignore. This is why it is key when considering the Best Director category to always keep your eyes open for auteur-oriented films that would undoubtedly prove too esoteric for almost any other branch of the Academy. Sometimes, these are well established directors who take a chance outside their comfort zone and are thusly rewarded by their peers for stretching their pre-established abilities. Other times, the branch chooses to reward a relatively new director who has been gaining esteem for sometime and then finally galvanizes significant support among the artistic community by making a breakthrough film that is almost impossible to ignore. This second case is a possible scenario I could see happening with director Steve McQueen and his newest film, Twelve Years a Slave. McQueen thus far has had two feature films: Hunger and Shame. Hunger, a movie starring Michael Fassbender as an inmate of a Northern Irish prison who leads the other inmates on a hunger strike, received good notices from those who saw it, but still remained mostly as background noise of 2008's cinematic conversations. In 2011, McQueen teamed up with Fassbender again, this time to tackle the taboo subject of sex addiction in the movie Shame. Shame received much more attention (no doubt in part due to its focus on sex), but the film proved too toxic for the Academy to even nominate Fassbender as Best Actor, despite the plethora of fawning reviews thrown his way. With McQueen's newest outing though, Twelve Years a Slave, he may finally earn the recognition of the Academy. The film, based on the memoirs of a free black man living in the North who was kidnapped into slavery in the Deep South during 19th Century, pre-Civil War America, has an all star cast in place, including the ubiquitous Michael Fassbender, Brad Pitt, Benedict Cumberbatch, Paul Giamatti, Paul Dano, Scoot McNairy, and Michael K. Williams. My biggest concern for the film's chances with the Academy is that the film may simply be too bleak and uncompromising in the way it depicts slavery for some Academy members to stomach, but I suspect this may actually be a plus in the Directors branch. For McQueen to generate enough support to pull off a stealth nomination though, Twelve Years a Slave must be the unquestionable pet project of the high-minded critics community, such as The Tree of Life and Amour where in the previous two years. If for instance, equal love among cinephiles is split between McQueen's film and say Alfonso Cuaron's Gravity, neither will likely get a nomination and someone like John Wells will probably sneak in instead. This concludes my preview of 2014's Best Directors, but there were a number of great filmmakers I had to leave on the table, so if you feel other auteurs are more likely to be recognized next year, let me know which ones in the comments section below.

In this post: 
Oscars 2014
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

A film fanatic at a very young age, starting with the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtle movies and gradually moving up to more sophisticated fare, at around the age of ten he became inexplicably obsessed with all things Oscar. With the incredibly trivial power of being able to chronologically name every Best Picture winner from memory, his lifelong goal is to see every Oscar nominated film, in every major category, in the history of the Academy Awards.