Oscars 2016: 8 Biggest Mistakes The Academy Made

There'll be a journalistic expose on how Mad Max didn't win.

For all the controversy, the Oscars 2016 will ultimately go down in history as the year Leo finally won. The whole "#OscarsSoWhite" debacle hung over the ceremony like a bad smell that some people wanted to just address, while others would happily plug their nose, but by the end of it all people could say was, "thank f*ck all those Leonardo NoOscaro jokes are going to go away." Leonardo DiCaprio has his Oscar. Good. Now we can all move on with our lives (where the f*ck is Gary Oldman's Academy Award?!). What makes it so unbearably satisfying is that he got it for the right movie. It wasn't an honorary award or a consolation prize for missing out previously; The Revenant is a great movie and Leo's performance is a key (if not total) part of its success. But not every choice made on the night was quite as on-point as it should have been. The 88th Academy Awards had quite a few mistakes, with awards going to the wrong film even with the already shaky shortlist. In the wake of Mad Max's technical sweep and Spotlight's shock win (oh, and that's in there), here's the eight biggest the Academy made this year.

8. Best Supporting Actor

Who Won? Mark Rylance - Bridge Of Spies It was great to see Bridge Of Spies win an Oscar; Steven Spielberg's latest was a competent-cum-masterful thriller that risked getting lost in the shuffle merely because the quality of those involved meant it was nothing special (Tom Hanks and the Coens are so dependable at this point). But, while Mark Rylance was indeed brilliant in the film, it's hardly an awards worthy performance; it fits snugly in the movie and, if I'm being honest, never matches what Hanks brings. Who Should Have Won? Sylvester Stallone - Creed Sylvester Stallone has delivered an amazing performance as Rocky Balboa over a period of four decades. It is a painful, nuanced portrayal of a Philly meathead becoming a success, then turning into a humbled man. While the Rocky movies varied in quality, Stallone always worked on them, but nothing (bar the original) matches Creed. Ryan Coogler's movie is incredible anyway - it wrongly missed out on consideration for Picture, and Actor - but his tortured turn, bringing a character we already knew to deeper levels, was the sort of thing Oscar was made for.

7. Best Original Song

What Won? Writing's On The Wall (Spectre) - Sam Smith I am one of the few living people who didn't hate Sam Smith's Bond theme - the opening credits for Spectre were pretty awful (hentai, seriously?) but the song wasn't terrible and much better than the sh*te we got from Quantum Of Solace. But was it as good as Skyfall? Hell, no! Given that Adele's song was the first Bond score to win this award, it feels pretty paltry for her achievement to be sullied by it being comparable with Smith's effort. What Should Have Won? 'Til It Happens To You (The Hunting Ground) - Lady Gaga 'Til It Happens To You was this year's "impact song" - the performance of Original Song that got the members of the audience in tears, and that is so definitely testament to the quality of the song at hand. It is not only a well written song delivered by an incredibly talented singer, but it has a strong, hurting message behind it. Lady Gaga's performance on stage in the Dolby Theatre was accompanied by a crowd of survivors of rape, hammering home the importance of her performance. A minor film should not mean awards ignorance.

6. Best Supporting Actress

Who Won? Alicia Vikander - The Danish Girl Wait, what? The Danish Girl is an Oscar winning movie? THE DANISH GIRL?! OH COME ON! Alicia Vikander is admittedly the best thing in the movie, but that is like saying Michael B. Jordan is the best thing in Fant4stic. The movie is a boring artistic splurge from a director so up his own arse that he kills his own actors by nature of his own tunnel-vision. If anything, Vikaner's win is a miracle because she was working with Tom Hooper. Who Should Have Won? Rooney Mara I genuinely thought Kate Winslet was going to bag her second golden baldie for Steve Jobs, although even then I'd have said it was undeserved. Supporting Actress was a strong category this year (hence Winslet and Vikander both being worthless), but my far the most deserving of the win was Rooney Mara for Carol. Despite not being the titular character she carried that film, with her emotionally restrained Terese defining the events. She co-won Best Actress in Cannes and a loss here is a major tragedy.

5. Best Visual Effects

Who Won? Ex Machina Ex Machina was the shock win of the awards for sure. It's an amazing movie, and we all knew that, but for it to win an Academy Award is astounding. It's the sort of movie the Academy ignores wholesale, too indie to matter and too sci-fi for them to care. And it's consularly nom for Visual Effects didn't seem up to much either - how could it beat out heavy hitters like Mad Max and Star Wars? Well, it did. Albeit not quite deservedly. Who Should Have Won? Star Wars: The Force Awakens Every movie nowadays is a mix of practical and CGI, and no two movies personify that than Ex Machina and Star Wars. There's something incredibly skillful about being able to that, and to do it without the audience knowing, which Ex Machina certainly does. But, if we're being straight, The Force Awakens should have trounced Machina here. It's expansive and the special effects are dominate, despite there bing only 30 fully-CGI shots. There also the consideration of legacy, with Episode VII managing to live up to the expansive heights of the original.

4. Best Adapted Screenplay

Who Won? The Big Short Due to its inability to win elsewhere, The Big Short is going to go down in history as a nothing movie; nobody will really remember it. And that's fine; it's totally good, but not all that great. Its screenplay is its best thing (Margot Robbie in a bathtub plays better on the page that on-screen), but that does not in any way make it the best of the year. Who Should Have Won? Carol Wow, wasn't Carol given the short shrift? It was a movie that presented homosexuality in such an honest way that it being a lesbian movie almost ceased to matter. Not that that impacted Academy votes - the Cannes favourite didn't get nominated for any of the big big prizes and won nothing. An award in screenwriting, which it deserves given that it comes from an emotionally complex Patricia Highsmith novel, would have been a really nice way to rectify that. But no, it went to the cheap option.

3. Best Documentary

Who Won? Amy I know why Asif Kapadia won the Oscar for Best Documentary for Amy. His previous movie, Senna, was not even long-listed for the Academy Awards due to it being made entirely of archive footage. So I can understand why the award went to him this year for Amy, which adopts the exact same technique to similar effect. However, it's certainly not as powerful here, with an excess of older recordings making the development of time more flippant and odd directorial choices - song lyrics on screen - not really working. What Should Have Won? Cartel Land It feels almost disingenuous to suggest a movie about cartel violence should trump a movie about a singer just by its very nature, but Cartel Land is one of those movies that manages to take an affecting subject and make it a story well worth telling. Matthew Heineman was all but robbed of an Oscar for his brutal presentation of a world entirely different from those consuming it.

2. Best Director

Who Won? Alejandro González Iñárritu (The Revenant) The Revenant is a masterpiece. Iñárritu is one of the greats. But, f*ck me, he should not have won Best Director for "Leo Is Cold For A Bit Then Kills Tom Hardy". And it has nothing to do with his direction of The Revenant. That movie lives and dies off him; the construction of the sequences is as masterful as Leonardo DiCaprio's performance. It's just, if not right, that he was the best director this year. Who Should Have Won? George Miller (Mad Max: Fury Road) Mad Max: Fury Road swept the technical part of the awards, which gave hope to it winning Best Director, the most technical of the big awards. It was certainly my pick (if, admittedly a wild card, and with the assumption of a different Best Picture win) and Miller fully deserved it. He made that movie, in every meaning of the word, constructing a world we'd never seen before (even in his other Mad Max movies) and telling a character-driven story almost entirely through action. I called it "action as art" when it first came out and I stand by that.

1. Best Picture

Who Won? Spotlight Spotlight is brilliant. Absolutely brilliant. My review of it was an argument why it should be an Oscar favourite. Although the key work is favourite. Spotlight is masterfully acted with restrained direction and a careful understanding of its tricky subject, and is something that will no doubt sit alongside All The President's Men As one of the greatest journalistic thrillers of all time. But Best Film?! Gimmie a break. What Should Have Won? Mad Max: Fury Road Discounting the movies not nominated that should have won (Inside Out and Carol), Best Picture should have gone to one of Mad Max: Fury Road and The Revenant. And, as much as I love Iñárritu's movie, even if he'd won Best Picture I'd be saying the award should have gone to Mad Max. Fury Road is a seminal action picture that develops its characters through car chases and violent clashes as much as it does dialogue, and I think the six technical Oscars it won (despite maybe not deserving one of them) are testament to that. What do you think the biggest mistakes of the 88th Academy Awards were? Are we on the money or were all these awards deserved? Share your thoughts down in the comments.

Contributor
Contributor

Film Editor (2014-2016). Loves The Usual Suspects. Hates Transformers 2. Everything else lies somewhere in the middle. Once met the Chuckle Brothers.