Oscars 2017: 8 Things The Academy Screwed Up

Wrong envelope, wrong Best Picture, wrong dead lady.

Oscar Moonlight
A24

When the dust settles, 2017's Oscars will go down as one of the most progressive ceremonies so far: after a year marred by racial controversy, they evened the keel, opening their eyes to more diverse productions (which the studios seemed to push more, rather helpfully) and casting off the #OscarsSoWhite nastiness of 2016.

Unfortunately, they're still run by The Academy, and an Oscar ceremony without something massively wrong would be like a Disney film not winning Best Animated Feature. Unthinkable, grotesque, illogical.

So it's lucky that the Gods Of Fortune smiled mischievously on the event to make up for the good progressive work, causing one of the most memorable, ridiculous moments in Oscar history. And that's not even to mention the Academy's usual knack for picking entirely the wrong winner in at least a handful of their own categories.

You can't depend on much in Hollywood these days, but you can bet your house on the Oscars screwing several things up every year. At least it was morbidly entertaining this year...


8. Zootopia As Best Animated Feature

 Zootopia Selfie
Disney

What Happened

Somewhat predictably, Zootopia (called Zootropolis in Europe, because they obviously didn't understand the utopia pun for some reason), walked away with Best Animated Feature, beating Moana, Kubo And The Two Strings, My Life as A Zucchini, and The Red Turtle.

Sure, it's a great movie, and like Moonlight and Hidden Figures, it has a very important message, but it absolutely was not the best Animated Feature of the year.

What Should Have Happened

Kubo And The Two Strings should have won. It shouldn't even have been close, frankly, but the all-powerful Disney machine did what it does best and hoovered up the award that might as well be called Walt's Statue.

Kubo was stunning, not only in visual terms (stop motion to that level is just astonishing), but in terms of story, characterisation and imagination. It was wholly unique, utterly transformative and it has just as important a message about life and death and family as Zootopia's rather on-the-nose sentiments on progressiveness and cultural integration. The best film did not win.


7. Best Documentary Going To The Wrong Film

13th Documentary
Netflix

What Happened

While White Helmets winning Best Documentary Short was absolutely spot on, ESPN's excellent 30 For 30 Film, OJ: Made In America wasn't the best candidate to win. It was great, obviously, and it won a very, very good category, but it was not the best.

What Should Have Happened

13th should have won, and not simply for political reasons. Though there is obviously an unwritten sentiment that documentaries are to be enjoyed for their slick productions and all of the technical flair you expect from normal feature films, there's also a higher regard placed on truth and on emotional transaction. In that respect, 13th deserved to win.

Also take into account the fact that Ava DuVernay's story of systematic failings in the American prison system is a far more difficult story to tell than OJ Simpson's (though it's reductive to say that's all it's about, of course), but it definitely faced more struggles to tell its truth. Again, it was a close-run thing, but the best documentary did not win.


6. They Killed The Wrong Person

Janet Patterson Oscars
Oscars

What Happened

It's not just in the awards that they goofed: during the “In Memoriam” segment, The Academy included a tribute to costume designer and four-time nominee Janet Patterson — but ran a photo of the very-much-still-alive Australian producer Jan Chapman by mistake.

And then they failed to acknowledge Alexis Arquette's death, at a time when trans rights are a hot topic (or should be) across America. That doesn't look like an oversight as much as a f*ck up.

What Should Have Happened

Well, using the right image would be a start, considering how Jan Chapman must now feel. And there's no real excuse for not including Arquette, when she was in a considerable number of films (more than 700) - many of which were Oscar nominated.


5. Fantastic Beasts Winning Best Costume Design

Warner Bros.

What Happened

Fantastic Beasts And Where To Find Them won Best Costume Design, despite basically being a period piece with very few actual wixarding costumes compared to the Harry Potter films. They were pretty and well observed, but they absolutely weren't the best costumes - or the best USE of costumes - in the list of nominees.

What Should Have Happened

The only film not to have a historical reference should have won.

La La Land used costumes as a living palette of colour, as much a part of the production design (which was acknowledged) and the art direction (same thing in Oscar's eyes, apparently) as the sets and cinematography. Not acknowledging that is failing to notice one of Damien Chazelle's cleverest directing details, which makes his win for Best Director incomplete.

They may be simpler designs, and not have historical observations to pack in, but the way they're used and primarily the striking use of colours absolutely put them above everything else.


4. No Love For Stop Motion Effects?

Kubo Monkey
Laika

What Happened

The Jungle Book won the gong for Best Visual Effects, thanks to its blend of CGI animals, stop-motion and live action. It was undoubtedly an impressive feat - particularly as the animals looked so real - and it made Disney a boat load of money, but it wasn't the biggest achievement in Visuals of the year.

What Should Have Happened

Perhaps because it was created using stop motion animation, Kubo And The Two Strings wasn't deemed up to the same billing as the computer-rendered work on The Jungle Book. To some extent, you could see why awards-givers would favour a production taking advantage of bleeding edge technology, but to ignore the monumental achievement of Laika's latest in the context of its medium is to do it a major, major disservice.

The stop motion work in Kubo is unprecedented, with achievements in animation that would surely have looked impossible at the planning stage, and done with such flair and personality that the experience is completely magical. The whole technique is part and parcel of the viewing experience too, and unlike The Jungle Book - whose principle aim is to HIDE its effects techniques - it's a celebration of the work. And that deserves more praise.


3. Suicide Squad Winning An Oscar

Oscars Suicide Squad
Warner Bros.

What Happened

Suicide Squad won an Oscar for Best Hair and Make-Up.

What Should Have Happened

Suicide Squad should not have won an Oscar for Best Hair and Make-Up.

Putting aside the argument that giving the terrible film an Oscar cheapens the awards ceremony and calls into question the entire system of acknowledgement, the hair and make-up in Suicide Squad wasn't even the best of the year. Star Trek Beyond's aliens were far broader in design and far more visually arresting and far more worthy of note than Killer Croc's look (the best of the film), Harley and The Joker's paint-work and those bloody awful eye monsters.

They were not well designed, they were a muddy mess.


2. La La Land "Winning" First

La La Land
Summit Entertainment

What Happened

How ironic in 2017's America - obsessed with fake news as it is - that the ceremony would end with an old white guy stating falsehoods as the truth. How ironic in the same year that Hidden Figures was up for Best Picture that a predominantly black production would be overlooked for a glossier predominantly white one (albeit temporarily). How ironic that a film with a gut-punching fake happy ending would be falsely told it had won Best Picture...

You honestly couldn't write it. And yet, The Academy conspired to make it happen: someone gave Warren Beatty the wrong envelope, somehow containing a winner's card that had already been given to Emma Stone, and he pulled a Steve Harvey and got the wrong film crew up on stage. It was agonising, to say the least.

What Should Have Happened

Don't mix up the bloody envelopes, morons.


1. Moonlight Winning Best Picture

Moonlight Chiron
A24

What Happened

Moonlight won Best Picture.

What Should Have Happened

There is no denying that Moonlight is a very good film. Nor is there any suggestion that isn't one of the most important films on a hugely progressive Oscar slate of movies and documentaries. But it wasn't the BEST film.

For almost every facet of its greatness, La La Land is better. It might be a more apparently vacuous film, because all it deals with is love and dreams, but it is a more towering technical achievement (in art design, cinematography, sound, editing), and as the Academy themselves acknowledged it was the better directed film.

There will now be an unfortunate unspoken accusation now that Moonlight won because of something else, which is a shame given its own greatness. And while it is a great thing that a film dealing with such difficult subject matter (which actually never allows itself to preach or to be overwhelmed by the politics others have inevitably attached to it) won Best Picture, on merit, it didn't deserve to.

What other things do you think the Academy messed up this year? Share your reactions in the comments thread below.


Contributor
Contributor

WhatCulture's former COO, veteran writer and editor.