Oscars 2017 Nominations: 5 Things They Got Right (& 4 They Got Wrong)

The good and the bad, the pleasant surprises and shocking snubs, from this year's Oscar noms.

Oscars Nominations Right Wrong
Summit/Warner Bros.

It's time for the awards season race to enter its final stretch.

The Golden Globes are well out of the way, and now the nominations for this year's Oscars have been revealed (in an audience-free announcement, a departure from tradition).

We now know who'll be donning the tuxes, getting asked which designer dresses they're wearing, and all other sort of red carpet nonsense before the awards themselves are handed out, in a ceremony presided over by Jimmy Kimmel (which should guarantee it's a better hosted affair than the Globes).

La La Land was expected to lead the way, but it's still managed to surprise with a mammoth 14 nominations - equalling the record. Next up are Arrival and Moonlight with eight, then Manchester By The Sea, Lion, and Hacksaw Ridge with six. As ever, some things went exactly as predicted (Best Picture, Actor, and Supporting Actress for example), while there were surprises and snubs a-plenty too.

Here's what the Oscars got right this year, and where they went wrong.


Got Right...

5. The VFX Surprises

Kubo And The Two Strings.jpg
Laika

As expected, The Jungle Book, Rogue One: A Star Wars Story, and Doctor Strange were all nominated in this category - and all very well deserved too.

But while the expectation had been for the category to be rounded out by the likes of Arrival and Fantastic Beasts, the Oscars instead went with Deepwater Horizon and, even more surprisingly, Kubo and the Two Strings.

It's hard to argue with their nominations, and both were said to have seriously impressed when they showcased the VFX reel, but neither are particularly big, well-known movies, and it's a category that can often favour the major blockbusters. Kubo's isn't just deserved, but it's also the first time this century (!) that an animated featured has been nominated in this category. That's some achievement.


4. The Lobster Gets Best Original Screenplay Nod

The Lobster Colin Farrell Rachel Weiz
Picturehouse Entertainment

A couple of surprises here, with both The Lobster and 20th Century Women getting nods, while Zootopia missed out. Although it's a shame for the Disney movie, it's great to see a film as weird (and as good) as The Lobster getting some recognition.

The screenplay, which comes from Efthimis Filippou and Yorgos Lanthimos, is a real treat, crafting a story that is outright bizarre, dark, bold, funny, and yet also quite moving.

Given its offbeat nature, and the fact it was released so long ago (it competed at Cannes in 2015, and was released in the US in May last year), it would've been pretty easy for the Academy to overlook it - and its nomination here is completely deserved.


3. No Deadpool

Deadpool Colossus
20th Century Fox

The most surprising narrative in the build-up to this year's Oscars nominations was the gradual rise of Deadpool. The R-rated, fourth-wall breaking superhero movie is far from your typical Oscar flick, but started to build hype when it received big nominations from the Golden Globes.

That could've been attributed to the HFPA doing their own thing and trying to be different, but then the Guilds - often reliable bellwethers for the Oscars - followed suit. So there was a genuine chance of the movie receiving a Best Picture nomination.

Thankfully, it didn't happen. Although the movie is enjoyable, it wasn't even the second best superhero movie of 2016, and while the Oscars could always do with widening their scope, there's no metric by which Deadpool was worthy of a Best Picture nomination.


2. La La Land Leading The Way

La La Land Ryan Gosling Emma Stone
Summit Entertainment

As mentioned previously, La La Land was expected to get a lot of nominations here. What is surprising is just how many it received.

14!

That ties the record for most nominations ever, putting it alongside All About Eve (which went on to win 6), and Titanic (which went on to win a record-equalling 11). And looking at the categories it's nominated in, a couple of things come to mind.

Firstly, they're all very much deserved - even the two noms in Original Song. The film is utterly beautiful and magical, and deserves every bit of recognition it gets. Secondly, there's a serious chance it could break the record for most wins.

Obviously it'll lose out on one of the Song noms, and Ryan Gosling - barring a HUGE upset - won't win Best Actor. Apart from that, though, it's either the favourite or at least serious contender in every other category, which means we could be looking at La La Land: winner of 12 Academy Awards. Wow.


1. Diversity

Hidden Figures
20th Century Fox

After the controversies of the past two years, there's to be no repeat of #OscarsSoWhite this time around.

Four of the nine films nominated for Best Picture feature predominantly non-white casts and stories (Moonlight, Fences, Hidden Figures, and Lion), around 1/3 of the acting nominees are people of colour, Barry Jenkins received a Best Director nod, and Bradford Young is a rare black cinematographer to get recognised for his work (on Arrival).

It comes after the Academy expanded its membership to include more women and people of colour, and is a much-needed shift from the past couple of years. Of course, it'd be reductive to say that the industry has suddenly figured itself out. The Academy is still mostly old white men, and while this year had a larger number of films with people of colour that appealed to Oscar voters, there still needs to be greater opportunities for women and people of colour (and this extends far beyond just the Oscars, of course).

It's a step in the right direction, though; an acknowledgment from the Oscars of the failures of the last couple of years, and hopefully the start of a proper shift within the industry.


Got Wrong...

4. Making Suicide Squad An Oscar Nominated Movie

Suicide Squad Cast
Warner Bros. Pictures

It'd be easy to dismiss this as being *just* for Makeup/Hairstyling, which is one of the more minor awards (it only has three nominees). That does a bit of a disservice to the great work makeup and hairstyling teams do though, and means a film as awful as Suicide Squad can now be called an Oscar-nominated movie.

Presumably it's there mostly down to the work done on Killer Croc, but it's still hard to feel that it's deserving of this award. Indeed, of the seven on the shortlist - the others being A Man Called Ove, Deadpool, Star Trek Beyond, Florence Foster Jenkins, The Dressmaker, and Hail, Caesar! - it was the least likely to get a nod here, and a surprising pick over more worthy candidates such as Florence Foster Jenkins and The Dressmaker (or even Deadpool, with this being the spot the Academy really could've recognised it).


3. Scorsese And Silence Overlooked

Silence Andrew Garfield
Paramount Pictures

On a purely subjective level, I struggled a bit with Silence. A big part of this is that as an atheist the film isn't really 'for me', and it's incredibly unyielding in its approach to religion.

More objectively, though, it's still an impressive achievement from Martin Scorsese - and one he's been trying to bring to the screen for decades. The sheer scale and scope of what he's attempted is astonishing, and it's hard to feel like it hasn't been unfairly overlooked in a number of categories. The Cinematography nod is well-earned, but that's the only one it got - meaning it has the same number of Oscar nominations as Suicide Squad, and less than Passengers.

Costume Design, Production Design, Editing, and most of all Director are all areas where Scorsese's epic would've been worthy of a nomination, and he and his team can be feeling hard done by here.


2. Two Noms For Passengers

Passengers Chris Pratt Jennifer Lawrence
Columbia Pictures

Passengers - nominated for two Academy Awards.

Not words I thought I'd be typing. Passengers hasn't had any real look-in during awards season; the film didn't get a great critical reception, didn't set the box-office alight, hadn't seemed to mount a serious campaign, and, well, it wasn't really in the conversation at all.

Out of nowhere, it feels, it's received the nods for Original Score and Production Design, neither of which are deserved, and both of which result in more worthy nominees missing out. Thomas Newman is a talented composer, but his score isn't really anything special, while the design is your typical run-of-the-mill sci-fi/spaceship.

Jackie and Silence can consider themselves unfortunate to miss out on the Design award here, while a host of movies - Nocturnal Animals, The BFG, Florence Foster Jenkins - seemed better placed for an Original Score nomination.


1. No Amy Adams For Best Actress

Arrival Amy Adams
Paramount Pictures

Granted, the Best Actress race was hotly-contested, but this still comes off as the most egregious snub of the lot. Of all the contenders, Amy Adams was one of the actresses seemingly considered a lock for the nomination - only Emma Stone felt like a safer bet, and I could've seen the race coming down to just the two of them in the end.

Arrival has a lot going for it, which is why it's so widely recognised here, but the film wouldn't work as well without Adams' performance at its very core. She is absolutely terrific in the movie, and provides it with a hell of a lot of its emotional heft; there's a broken nature to her character, a real feeling of turmoil, and she's incredibly relatable too, even while her appearance affects an otherworldliness. Deftly handling the highs and the lows her character is dealt, Adams gives this alien movie its most human element.

There's a feeling that Adams is fast-becoming the new DiCaprio, in terms of lack of Oscar recognition, and this will only contribute to that. Her time will surely come one day, and I don't know if she'd have won for this, but she definitely deserved to be nominated.

What do you think of the Oscars nominations? Share your thoughts down in the comments.


Contributor
Contributor

NCTJ-qualified journalist. Most definitely not a racing driver. Drink too much tea; eat too much peanut butter; watch too much TV. Sadly only the latter paying off so far. A mix of wise-old man in a young man's body with a child-like wonder about him and a great otherworldly sensibility.