Ranking Chucky Films From Worst To Best
As a child, I had a strange relationship to horror movies in general. I was born in 1985, so I grew up right in the middle of one of the biggest overall horror booms in the history of the genre. I felt then about horror movies much like a child born in the previous decade must now feel about superhero movies, as if they had always been popular and always existed. As a result, there was no escaping these films. They aired them on television all the time. All of my friends talked about them. They were everywhere. So, since they were a large part of my life, I grew to love them...from a distance. I would get lost in the mythology of the endless buffet of sequels. I would debate which slasher killer was the best. I would get amazingly excited whenever a marathon of said franchises would air...until they actually came on. Then I would play a sort of "chicken"-type game with the remote control. If you were a hyperactive child as I was, you know what I'm talking about. The character would quietly enter into a dark area by his or herself. The background music would stop. A quick shadow would race across the background. Then, just as the killer would make his or her presence felt...I changed the channel. I was too scared to stick around for the good stuff. I was completely and utterly fascinated and thrilled by the characters and their worlds, but I was way too scared to fully commit to whichever film I was watching. No other character embodied this for me more than Chucky. Never mind that the idea of your toys coming to life and killing people was a twisted concept for a kid to handle anyway. I mean, to take such a universally shared childhood wish of one's playthings coming alive and subvert it in such a way as to potentially ruin the play-time experience for any child who might see your film? That's pure psychological horror on a fairly deep level. However, the idea alone isn't what made Chucky scary. Chucky was scary because Brad Dourif and the very talented effects crew combined to make a pint-sized serial killer into a wide-eyed, foul-mouthed demon from Hell. It's the eyes. It's the laugh. It's the whole package. Jason and Michael had no personalities. Freddy did, of course, but he could never really find the humor/horror balance, always leaning too far one way or the other. Chucky though, Chucky was a piece of work. Chucky's sheer, unapologetic sadism exploded through Dourif's voice, never failing to make him scary despite all the obvious physical limitations that the character exhibits. Yet, even through the rage, Dourif manages to make the serial-killer-possessed doll hilarious at times (because, honestly, how are you going to do a movie about a killer doll without some humor?) At his best, the character could be legitimately unnerving while genuinely funny ("How's it hangin', Phil?"). To a kid who spent a lot of time with toys, Chucky was completely terrifying... and impossible to resist. As the new direct-to-Blu Ray Chucky film, Curse of Chucky, is on its way soon, I thought this would be a good time to talk about the series so far and rank the films from worst to best. The Chucky series is a pretty big rarity in its genre in that each film really does try to do something different each time and, on average, it usually benefits the character more then it hinders him. Unfortunately, since I believe in saving the best for last, we have to start with the worst of the bunch. If you're a fan of Chucky, then you won't be surprised what number five is (click "Next to find out)...
5. Seed of Chucky
Pure crap. From start to finish, this is pure crap. Don Mancini is Chucky's creator. Where most other horror directors have abandoned their characters in the past to often horrible results (I'm looking at you, John Carpenter), Mancini has stuck with Chucky for every single film. I have to give him props for that. He has written all the films on this list. With Seed of Chucky, the fifth entry in the series, Mancini decided it was time for him to take the reigns as director. Many attribute this to Seed of Chucky's awfulness, but I don't think that's fair. There's nothing inherently wrong with Mancini's direction. On the contrary, I believe it was his time spent directing that may have had a hand in the real problem: that Godawful script. Perhaps, if Mancini had spent less time familiarising himself with lenses and more time reading what he had written, Seed of Chucky might be higher on this list. But he didn't, and here we are. Seed of Chucky takes the wonderfully terrifying concept of a demon spawn who was never supposed to exist inflicting terror on the world, and turns it into a strange-for-the-sake-of-strange Ed Wood parody. Chucky's son (daughter?) is born following Chucky and Tiffany's almost impossible conception in the previous film. Although that film ended with a fanged, bloody, plastic infant exploding from Tiffany's womb and violently killing a cop, Seed fast-forwards several years later to find that terrifying demon has grown into a whiny, gender-confused goof named Glen who pees himself when he's (she's?) stressed. I mentioned that all the Chucky films try to do something different? This is the only real instance of that going completely and horribly wrong. When you think about that from a horror series perspective, that's pretty good on the whole, but it doesn't let Seed off the hook. Glen's complete failure as a character would be bad enough on its own. However, not content with the sheer pointlessness of Glen, Mancini proceeds to give this film the most unwatchable A-plot of all the films, as Chucky and Tiffany are brought back to life by Glen through new dolls made for a new Chucky-based film in Hollywood. The trio then spend the movie trying to possess the bodies of Jennifer Tilly (Tiffany's real-life voice playing herself as a desperate actress - get it?) and rapper-turned-actor-turned-hot dog vendor after this movie, Redman, while also debating whether Glen is a boy or a girl, debating whether they should continue killing at all (you can guess Chucky's feelings on that), and killing John Waters with acid. Yep. At his best, Chucky is funny and scary. In Seed, he's neither. How Mancini could have come up with something this awful is beyond me. This was not a quick turnaround between films. Seed was released six years after Bride of Chucky. He had six years to come up with something and this is what he came up with. All of Chucky and Tiffany's edge from the last film is gone. Glen is a completely obnoxious character with an arc that makes no sense. The mythology gets completely jumbled beyond repair. Even the once great Demalla chant, which is often used to transfer one's soul from one vessel to another, gets the shaft as Glen only half-way sets it up before mommy and daddy come back to life. They come back to life, by the way, in the worst dolls in the history of the series. The animatronics here are the worst they've ever been and when you're talking about the newest, supposedly most technologically advanced chapter in a franchise, that's bad. The only redeeming idea presented in this film is Chucky's ultimate epiphany that he would rather stay a doll than continue to attempt to possess another human body. After five films, that was a nice piece of character growth on his part. Unfortunately, it was buried in a film that has no idea what it's trying to accomplish, ending with Chucky and Tiffany's doll son (daughter?) transferred into two separate twin, infant human bodies, Tiffany pretending to be Jennifer Tilly, and Chucky's hand coming back to life on its own to terrorise them all. The only thing scary about this entry is how bad it is.
4. Child's Play 3
The jump in quality from the fifth ranked Chucky film to the fourth ranked Chucky film is pretty big to me. Many fans don't consider Child's Play 3 to be that great, but I don't think anyone would deny that it's worlds better then Seed. Child's Play 3 follows young Andy Barclay, the little boy stalked by Chucky in the first two films, as he becomes a teenager and is sent to military school. Unfortunately for him, his old pal Chucky isn't far behind. This is, by far, the darkest of the films. Andy's life has been nothing but misery ever since Chucky entered it and here we see how low he's gotten because of his little friend's murdering ways. This Andy is much older and much more world weary, although new actor Justin Whalin does retain some of Alex Vincent's innocence (the fact that the two actors do resemble each other a bit helps with the time jump as well). Above all, I feel that making Andy significantly older gave this film a great new dynamic to play with. Andy isn't a child anymore. He knows Chucky's game better than anyone. Unfortunately, his militant surroundings and more mature stature make his crazy ramblings far more harmful to him personally then in the two previous films. He's no longer a child with a wild imagination in fear of a time out. He's a young adult making seemingly insane allegations surrounded by hard-case Army lunatics. The setting itself makes the film darker. There's no mom here. There's no spunky, older foster sister. This is Andy against the world and it's a world that doesn't care one bit about his feelings or his tragic background. Once again, the series tries to do something different. Instead of trotting out yet another "Chucky chases little Andy" plot, Mancini attempts to explore, fairly realistically, what life would be like for a child in this situation. How would the world react to a young boy who's constantly surrounded by dead bodies with no other explanation than "my doll did it"? Where would he ultimately end up? It's one thing to kill Chucky. That solves the immediate problem. However, there are still many long-term problems that would logically arise from such a scenario and it was really interesting to see Mancini attempt to look at the situation from a realistic psychological standpoint. Okay, enough with Andy. What about the Chuckster? I think it's safe to say that Child's Play 3 is the film that really, truly fleshes out the character. The first film only barely introduces him. The second gives us more. The third really lets him loose. This is Chucky at his most wise-cracking, most mean-spirited point yet in the series. Not only do we see the indirect results of Chucky on Andy's life, we see the direct results of Chucky's plan to possess the body of a new child, Tyler. Andy is punished and repeatedly bullied as a result of Chucky's actions. The one adult in the whole movie that is anything close to nice to Andy dies of a heart attack at the sight of the little red demon. Even a seemingly innocent game of war games-style paintball is ruined horribly as, in one of the most horrible acts we've ever seen Chucky commit, he loads the guns with real ammunition and watches the kids unwittingly shoot at each other all while throwing live grenades and cracking wise. Probably wasn't a great idea to have a pint-sized psychopath running around a compound with that many projectile weapons and explosives. Nope. Not at all. Ultimately, part of what keeps this entry so low on the list is that the darkness and mean-spirited nature of its story makes it kind of hard to have fun with. While I applaud Mancini for attempting to give the story some depth, there's only so much torment an audience can take in a movie about a killer doll. If Seed of Chucky went too far in the comedic direction, it could be said that Child's Play 3 goes too far in the serious direction. Yes, Chucky does have his one-liners, but it's hard to laugh at anything while you're watching kids shoot at each other. Another detriment to the proceedings is the little actor who plays Tyler. This kid is beyond annoying. He's every plucky, too-naive-for-his-own-good caricature of a kid combined. He makes little Alex Vincent look like Natalie Portman. Now, I may be laying too much on the actor. His role wasn't written that well. But, surely they could have found a kid who could dial it down just a little more. As a result, you find yourself cringing every time he's on screen and not caring terribly whether Chucky possesses him or not. Maybe being possessed by Chucky would have made him less annoying. We'll never know. Finally, the effects here are not good. They're not the worst, but you can't call them good. Child's Play 3 was released less than a year after Child's Play 2, and the main casualty of that rush is the effects. There's no attempt made to make the "still" doll look like the "action" doll. Chucky's angry brow is always larger when he's moving around and nonexistent when he's not. There's no shot of him coming to life. The camera always cuts away. What was a great hallmark of the previous entry is a shabby mess in this one. What's worse is that the inferior effects really take you out of the story as they really are that noticeable when compared to the previous two films. Combine all those elements with a pretty lame level of suspense and you get a film that, while admirable for its attempt, takes all the fun out of what makes Chucky work in the first place.
3. Child's Play
There might be some who feel this should be number one simply because it was the first. However, if we're being honest, I have to put Chucky's initial outing at number three. It started the whole shebang and Dourif does a great job as always, but once you've seen the twist, it's not a movie that is very re-watchable. In the first film in the series, serial killer Charles Lee Ray is shot by Detective Mike Norris, nearing death, when he comes across a "Good Guy" doll in a toy store. As a somewhat novice student in voodoo, Ray transfers his soul to the doll and soon begins a new killing spree while attempting to possess the body of young Andy Barclay. There's a story structure mistake that happens right at the film's start that really undercuts the entire first half. The first half of the movie attempts to give the audience some doubt as to whether little Andy is telling the truth about Chucky. There is at least some effort put in to make us feel like it could be just as likely that Andy himself is the killer and making the whole story up. The point-of-view shots of the first kill especially are shot from a low vantage point, suggesting it could be a killer doll... or a small child. Andy even wears the "Good Guy" overalls, further confusing matters when a little "Good Guy" hand comes into the frame to make the kill. This suspense would be pretty cool... except the very first scene of the film shows us exactly what happened. We know that Chucky performed the spell and put himself into the doll. Either that, or Ray's dead body attracts lightning for some reason. Had the scene been inserted later as Detective Norris described the night's events after we had already discovered that the doll was alive, the first half of the movie may have had more suspense. Since it doesn't, you spend what seems like an eternity just waiting for the doll to come to life because you already know that's what's going to happen. It really dampens the experience and makes the movie feel slow and boring as you wait for the shoe to drop. Yet, once that shoe drops, it drops hard. I can't imagine the sheer anxiety experienced by the first crowds who saw this film during Chucky's coming-out scene. The scene, like the rest of the film up to that point, takes its time. Catherine Hicks is as close as she's been so far in believing her son's story, but her rational mind can't let her get there completely. She wrestles with her doubts. She tries to talk herself out of it. But, eventually, she checks the doll for batteries... and finds none! How could the doll work without batteries? Even at this point, Chucky doesn't tip his hand. Maybe she'll think it's a malfunction of the doll? There's no way she thinks he's alive, even without the batteries. Human nature will give in and she'll come up with an excuse on her own...or she'll throw it in the fireplace and watch it burn. Okay. That's it. No more play time. Chucky's face, which had been innocent and pure the entire film, suddenly comes to life with anger and panic. He screams, he bites, he yells obscenities. I'm sure audiences thought the animatronics would be good; I don't think they knew how good. Chucky is alive in that moment. Alive and p*ssed. Hicks' performance is what sells it, though. If she hadn't taken so long to come around, the shock of the moment wouldn't have had nearly as much weight. Again, the mistake the film makes is not that it takes so long to reveal Chucky, it's that it kills the suspense of that reveal by telling us from the start what the truth is. Hicks' acting is what makes it work despite the poor structure decision. From that point on, however, the film really kicks into high gear. The original Chucky puppetry work was phenomenal. As we watch the doll stand in a doorway and threaten his ex-partner, we see every muscle in his face move. We feel all of his personality through Dourif's voice. We see the various advantages to his doll form. With every kill and every swear, Chucky resuscitates the movie back to life and, in turn, provides the seed (pun only partially intended) for which the entire franchise would grow. Had Chucky not worked, either because of the effects or Dourif's performance, this would just be another silly horror movie to poke fun at. Yet, through the magic of cinema, Chucky is brought to horrible life. The efforts of all those involved turn a potentially ridiculous idea into a legitimate scare fest.
2. Child's Play 2
If you visit Rotten Tomatoes, you will discover that Child's Play has a higher rating then Child's Play 2. This is total and complete hogwash. I don't know one person who's seen them both that likes the first one better. While you might say that the first film is a better "film", no one can say that it's more fun. You need a certain level of fun for a good Chucky movie. Child's Play 2 has fun in droves. The reason this film is more fun then its predecessor is the same reason most superhero sequels are better than the originals: getting the introduction of the character out of the way allows for much more freedom the second time around. By the time Child's Play 2 starts, we know who Chucky is and we know what he's about. There's no mystery to protect in Child's Play 2. So, while on the surface the film seems like a total rehash -C hucky stalks Andy in order to possess his body - it actually takes on a completely new tone because, now, we as the audience are in on the act. We get to see what Chucky's like on his own. We get to hear Brad Dourif in all his charismatic glory. We get to see Chucky really enjoying himself. We get to watch him set up his victims. We get to be a part of the plan. Whereas the first film went straight horror almost all the way, the second, thanks to more Chucky exposure, lends itself to a slightly more comedic bent. It never goes so far with it that Chucky seems non-threatening, but it does provide a much needed chuckle to relive some pretty serious tension. And there is quite a bit of tension. The first movie put little Andy in danger, but his mom was still right there to protect and believe him. The second movie puts Andy in the foster home system with no family and no friends. His foster mom seems warm to him, but his foster dad isn't sure at all. His foster sister wants nothing to do with him. Andy is alone and under complete suspicion from the start...and then the quacks at the toy company decide to put Chucky's body back together again. Once Chucky finds Andy, he does everything he can to ruin Andy's life. He gets him in trouble at home. He gets him in trouble at school. He murders and maims all around him. Andy's life is hell. What makes it worse is the characterization of the foster parents. While most horror films like to make the victims so obnoxious and one-dimensional that you find yourself glad when the killer shows up to dispense of them, our main adult victims in Child's Play 2 each have real, fleshed-out characters with believable arcs. It would been so easy to make the skeptical foster dad a complete, unapologetic pr*ck. Instead, his fears regarding Andy are played as totally understandable. He never seems out of line given the information he has and he never seems selfish as his concerns seem stemmed in his love for his wife. While the foster mother is played fairly loving and simple in the beginning, always having Andy's back, it's her reaction to Andy following her husband's death that provides the most substance. Her rejection of Andy in the presence of her dead spouse in spite of how much she genuinely cared for the boy is really heartbreaking. It's a small tease of the anger that Andy would face from the whole world in the next film and it shows how much more effective horror always is when you actually care about the bodies that are piling up. Yet, through all the rough spots, Child's Play 2 really amps up the humor. Chucky's spouting of "How's it hangin', Phil?" while dangling ole foster pappy from the basement steps still cracks me up. And nothing beats Chucky staring at his new-found knife-hand and declaring, "I hate kids." Obviously. "Damn, woman drivers!" "Snap out of it! You act like you've never seen a dead body before!" "Let me out of here, Andy! I promise I won't kill anybody else!" The comedy is plentiful. The fact that they went through the trouble of crafting a little Chucky "middle finger" hand just so he could flip somebody off is marvelous. Did I mention this movie was fun? Of course, you can't talk about Child's Play 2 without talking about the effects which are, for the time, quite top notch. Chucky has to be on screen much more in the second film then he did the first, which means the effects work had to really sell him as a living creature. Thanks to a much more versatile puppet, Chucky is able to fluctuate from angry to funny to calm to scary and back again with ease. Besides the scenes of Chucky alive and moving around, the filmmakers have Chucky doing little things with his eyes in scenes where he has to play still that really drive home the situation at hand. It's a total effects commitment and it really works. Then, finally, in some weird form of therapy, the guys behind the film decide to spend the last third destroying their creation in every way imaginable. Andy and his foster sister end up at the Play Pals warehouse surrounded by doll makings and find about six different ways to totally eff Chucky up. From losing his hand, to getting chopped in half, to being burned with wax, to getting his damn head blown up, Chucky absolutely gets his in this film. The carnage is so extreme that none of the films even attempted to copy it afterwards. There's just no way they could. With better effects, more fleshed-out characters, and a greater focus on what made the first film great, Child's Play 2 is easily the best of the Child's Play series. However, it is not the best Chucky film...1. Bride of Chucky

