Scream VI Review: 6 Ups & 4 Downs
An intense but wildly uneven sequel.
Barely a year ago Scream fans were hailing the long-awaited return of the franchise after a decade-plus hiatus, and following the fifth movie's success Scream VI was fast-tracked into production and is now impressively already upon us.
Expectations are certainly high for a sequel that's been hyped up as the series' most violently intense entry to date, while shifting the setting to New York City for the first time.
And while Scream VI does offer some fun revisions on the series' formula and nerve-shredding set-pieces, it's in the details where fans might find themselves most disappointed.
No, you probably won't miss Neve Campbell's Sidney Prescott as much as you might expect, yet the narrative core of the movie ultimately lacks the fun and intelligence of the better Scream movies.
For the sixth entry into any horror franchise this is still a solid effort, even if it fails to touch the brilliance of the first two Scream movies and settles comfortably as a lower-middle-tier installment.
And so, without giving any spoilers away, here's what doesn't quite work about the sixth Scream...
Downs...
4. Ghostface Falls Flat
The marketing played-up Scream VI as featuring both the most viciously violent Ghostface to date and one who was a little "different" to the others, and while the murders certainly rank among the series' most gnarly so far, the overall execution of Ghostface this time around is rather disappointing.
It's tough to say too much about that without getting into spoiler territory, so we'll be incredibly careful how we word this.
Basically, if you're hoping for a clever and surprising whodunnit mystery akin to most of the prior movies - Scream 3 excepted - prepare to have mixed feelings.
The narrative chicanery surrounding who is behind the mask and their motive is ultimately some of the series' silliest and least-imaginative to date - perhaps even flatter than the Roman reveal in Scream 3 - enough that you don't need to be paying that much attention to figure things out.
It's a shame for a series that's prided itself on thoughtful, tough-to-guess reveals, and while predictability isn't the worst thing in the world, the fact that the Ghostface element of Scream VI pales massively compared to most others in the series majorly dents its overall entertainment value.
All in all, it'll ensure Scream VI is decidedly less rewatchable than most of its predecessors, no matter that Ghostface does mete out some of their nastiest attacks in this movie.
3. The Bloated Runtime
Scream VI is the longest film in the franchise at 123 minutes, and while that's only a few minutes longer than the two-hour Scream 2, it does result in a film that lacks the tight leanness of the original in particular.
Though the film's characters literally talk about this new "movie" being bigger and more epic than what came before, as if to justify that extended runtime, the length does verge on over-indulgent at times, particularly with regard to some of the more pedestrian character drama and especially the drawn-out finale.
This absolutely would've benefitted from another pass in the editing room to trim the flabbier first and third acts, because while it's in no way a torturous sit, its less-appealing elements are made worse by how distended they are.
There's probably a good reason that most slasher movies run well under two hours.
2. The Underwhelming, Convoluted Third Act
Where Scream VI suffers worst is undeniably in its final reel, where the cards are all played and we finally get to the heart of the slasher whodunnit story.
Without getting into spoiler-y details, this is by far the weakest part of the movie, and perhaps suggests that the filmmakers should've spent another year to finesse the narrative particulars before going into production.
It's the big reveal and everything associated with it which ultimately drags Scream VI down the most - at once being relatively uninspired, over-familiar, and worst of all heinously contrived to the point of near-parody.
Every whodunnit needs a satisfying climax, but Scream VI's feels disappointingly warmed-over and low on creativity, especially following on from Scream 5's devilishly funny takedown of toxic fandoms.
1. It's One Of The Weakest Entries Into The Series
Now, while reviews for Scream VI have been mostly positive so far, and it's certainly a decent sequel, it's nevertheless one of the weaker entries into the franchise overall.
Yes, Scream 3 is easily the worst of the bunch and this gets nowhere near that, but it's also a far cry from the first two Screams and, by lacking the compelling reveals of the fourth and fifth movies, slides comfortably into second-to-last place.
Granted, it's still impressive that the series only has one genuinely bad movie to date, but for anyone hoping that Scream VI would be a super-charged sequel to the franchise-rejuvenating entry, it ultimately ends up conventional to a fault and a pretty standard fare effort.
These issues aside, though, there's plenty for Scream fans to enjoy. And so, here's what Scream VI gets right...
Ups...
6. The Strong Opening Sequence
Perhaps the most talked-about aspect of Scream VI will be its delirious, expectation-defying opening sequence, which rejigs the franchise formula in some interesting ways.
While not as suspenseful or immediately iconic as the pre-title kills from the first two Screams, the willingness to do something different and lead the audience down an unpredictable path is a lot of fun, while steering clear of Scream 4's excessively meta intro.
Combining brutal violence with some neat twists on what fans anticipate from the start of a Scream movie, it's perhaps the best part of the entire film, suggesting a far more subversive sequel than we actually ended up with.
5. The Refreshing New York Setting
Though the Scream series has moved away from Woodsboro twice in the past, Scream VI is the first movie in the franchise to take place in New York City, and it was certainly a smart move to give the film its own distinct flavour.
The smoky urban sprawl of NYC couldn't feel much more different to sunny California, the densely-packed metropolis proving a far more convincing locale for Ghostface to operate in relative anonymity among so many millions of busy strangers.
It goes without saying that the much-hyped set-piece featuring Ghostface on the NYC subway is an absolute blast, and for all of the film's many flaws, this felt like the right time to take the carnage to the other side of the U.S.
4. The BRUTAL Kills
The new Ghostface was hyped up as the most aggressive and violent yet, and in that regard they basically live up to the hype. The deaths in this film are nasty, with characters being stabbed in various orifices and body parts sure to leave even die-hard gore-hounds wincing.
Regardless of your opinion on how Ghostface's motives shake out, you can feel their ferocity in each of the kill sequences, nicely upping the brutality quotient that audiences have come to expect.
After all, this is the first Scream movie to feature a shotgun-totting Ghostface - a controversial choice, perhaps, but in the context of the scene in which it's featured, it absolutely works, and only further confirms the much-stated claim that this Ghostface isn't like the others.
3. It Proves The Series Doesn't Need Sidney
Let's address the elephant in the room - no, Neve Campbell is not in Scream VI in any way, shape, or form, so don't go in expecting a surprise third-act return from Sidney.
Campbell chose not to return due to her salary requests not being met, and while it's an unfortunate situation that the series' leading lady got lowballed by Paramount, ultimately the film doesn't really suffer from her absence.
The previous film already began the process of transitioning out the legacy trio, what with Dewey's (David Arquette) death and Gale (Courteney Cox) and Sidney's rather limited screen time.
Scream VI follows this lead, with Gale ultimately having a relatively contained role that doesn't in any way feel essential to the fabric of the story. Sidney is briefly mentioned, of course, but if she never returns to the series it seems like it'll do just fine without her.
That said, don't be shocked if Paramount comes to terms with Campbell and she does return for the inevitable, already-in-the-works Scream 7.
2. The Great Cast Chemistry
Even when it doesn't quite work, Scream VI at least follows its predecessor's lead by again boasting a strong ensemble cast of likeable characters.
Siblings Tara (Jenna Ortega) and Sam (Melissa Barrera) are of course the focus once more, and combined with other siblings Chad (Mason Gooding) and Mindy (Jasmin Savoy Brown), form an affectingly trauma-bonded quartet who call themselves the "Core Four."
Elsewhere Courteney Cox gets some of her stronger recent dramatic material as a still-grieving Gale, while it's undeniably great to see Hayden Panettiere back in the role of Kirby, and Dermot Mulroney provides solid support as Wayne Bailey, the lead detective investigating the killings.
It's certainly a film that doesn't want for the enthusiasm of its cast, who bring a lot of energy, humour, and emotion to the forefront throughout.
1. The Stressful, Suspenseful Set-Pieces
Where Scream VI succeeds best is with the strength of its numerous suspense set-pieces, several of which rank among the finest of the entire series.
Directors Matt Bettinelli-Olpin and Tyler Gillett feel far more assured behind the director's chair this time, and put their larger budget to good use with a number of elaborate, gut-wrenching sequences fans won't soon forget.
The bodega and ladder sequences featured extensively throughout the trailers are terrifically entertaining, as is Gale's nerve-wracking penthouse showdown with Ghostface, ensuring that for all of its narrative problems, Scream VI at least brings the tension in stressful spades.
If the filmmakers indeed return for Scream 7, as one suspects they might, they'll need to go some to one-up this movie's thrilling creativity where its various attacks, chases, and escapes are concerned.