Star Trek Beyond: 10 Things It Did Better Than J.J. Abrams
Boldly going where J.J. Abrams failed to go...
As someone who despised both Star Trek ’09 and Into
Darkness, Beyond was a welcomed respite in a series that had continually
failed to impress. Generally, the first two films aren’t
regarded too negatively, but there was always something about their
relationship to the source material that felt uncooperative, or even natural.
In the first film, the characters are overstated to comical proportions, completely misrepresenting the efforts of their predecessors, and the general tone is so generic you’d be forgiven for thinking the movie was called “Space Adventure”, or “Adventures In Space”. Worse still: the plot is so riddled with holes it can barely keep its feet, and while some of the cast are managing some decent impersonations, nothing about the movie feels genuine.
Somehow, Into Darkness was worse, and managed to get nearly everything wrong. For one thing, the tone was so dreary, and generally depressive that it barely felt like a Star Trek movie, which is surprising when you consider how extensively (and shamelessly) the film borrows from previous entries in the franchise, notably Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan. Add to that an incomprehensible plot about super clones, and you’ve got yourself an underwhelming movie, and some fairly low expectations for the sequel.
Perhaps as a direct result, Star Trek Beyond had a tough time from the get-go, but it somehow managed to impress in some substantial ways, and more importantly improve on both Star Trek and Into Darkness.
Here's how...
10. New Characters, New Faces
Star Trek: The Original Series would constantly
introduce new characters, as well as countless alien races, each of which was
invented to serve a very particular purpose. Sometimes, the secondary cast would feature more prominently than the regular crew, and were more
important to the story, and generally more interesting, well-rounded characters.
Unfortunately, Star Trek ’09 was predominantly concerned with reintroducing familiar faces, such as Captain James T. Kirk, and Mr. Spock. Naturally, this made sense at the time, seeing as how audiences needed to become reacquainted with those characters. However, Into Darkness essentially made the same mistake, failing to create anything new, and relying wholeheartedly on established images, and already recognisable characters.
Star Trek Beyond feels remarkably fresh, successfully introducing countless original alien designs, and having the story revolve around an entirely new character, Jaylah. As a result, Beyond manages to avoid the mistakes of previous instalments, cultivating its own unique sense of personality without having to rely on the same handful of tired concepts.
9. The Tone Of The Movie Is Perfect
I touched on this point in my introduction, but it
really does warrant elaboration: Star Trek Beyond is a genuine Star Trek movie,
an honest attempt to recapture the spirit, as well as the tone of the original
series. Somehow, it manages to achieve just that, perfectly replicating the
joyful optimism of Roddenberry’s creation, and successful navigating itself away
from the sombre, gloomy cheerlessness of Into Darkness, which might as well be
be the cinematic equivalent of pouring salt onto self-inflicted wounds.
Star Trek ’09 was trying too hard, and it ultimately came across as glorified fan-fiction, desperately trying to convince the audience it was legitimate, and failing as a direct result. Into Darkness went almost the opposite direction, becoming noticeably gloomier in an attempt to appeal to a more mature audience.
It was also a pandering mess which might have singlehandedly butchered one of the greatest scenes in cinematic history, and ruined one of the most iconic characters to ever grace the silver screen. Still, Beyond fixed all that.
8. The Performances Are Much Improved
In Star Trek Beyond, Chris Pine is Captain James T. Kirk, instead of an irritating frat-boy who happened to share the same name.
It took them three movies, two directors and
handful of writers, but they finally got his characters right. In Star Trek
Beyond, Captain Kirk is played with conviction, maturity and restraint; he doesn’t
get into fights on the bridge, and he isn’t cracking wise every few seconds. He’s
even got a more appropriate haircut.
In fact, most of the cast have rained in their performances considerably, and the characters themselves seem to have been written with more care and attention. Chris Pine in particular is much improved, but pretty much every performance has been upped. The only exception might be Zachary Quinto who still doesn’t fully embody the character of Spock, which isn’t too surprising given that he has the most difficult task of following in the shoes of Leonard Nimoy.
7. The Plot Doesn't Revolve Around Earth
In both Star Trek ’09 and Into Darkness, the plot has
involved Earth, because it is assumed that an audience will only invest in a
story that directly affects them. This is an erroneous assumption, and it
clearly assumes very little of humanity. After all, the theory is essentially
suggesting that people only care about themselves, and cannot sympathise with
the struggles and plights of outsiders.
In the original series, the plot rarely involved Earth, and Earth was rarely in danger. In the show, the audience would be introduced to new races, and would be given reasons to care about the continued survival of those races. Having the plot constantly revolve around humanity is selfish, and as a narrative device, it’s exceptionally cheap. It involves no effort, or thought. I mean, you’re told to care about Earth because it’s Earth, and that’s where you live, so care about it.
In Star Trek Beyond, the story takes place predominantly on an alien world, and the only humans in danger are those who occupy the remote space-station, Yorktown. The Earth is mentioned sparringly, and is never in any real danger. There is a small suggestion that the planet might one day be affected by the threat of the film, but it's only a passing comment, and it isn't elaborated upon.
Instead, we’re introduced to a brand new place, and all new characters, and we’re given plenty reasons to care about each of those things, which might be a first for this particular trilogy.
6. The Level Of Destruction Is Restrained
Lately, movies have become conscious of their own destructive
tendencies. Both Captain America: Civil War and Batman V Superman addressed the
concern directly, and other movies have been following suit, moderating their
depictions of unnecessary carnage and excessive, unfathomable mayhem. With that
said, this mentality has only just started to manifest itself, hence Into
Darkness features some of the most gratuitous, overblown and ludicrous carnage
ever put to film. We’re talking Man of Steel calibre.
Thankfully, Beyond moderates itself. The Enterprise is destroyed towards the start of the movie, but Yorktown isn’t obliterated into a million pieces, and most of the action that takes place on the planet’s surface is restrained, and elegantly done. At no point are buildings ripped from the ground and thrown through the air, and no cities are pulverised into a million tiny pieces for the sake of spectacle.
There are some truly momentous scenes, but the carnage is kept in check, and the heroes do all they can to prevent needless destruction.
5. Everyone Has Something To Do
To its credit, Star Trek ’09 had an almost impossible
task: it had to balance multiple characters, making sure not to completely
forget any of them. To its credit, it succeed in tremendous fashion as every
character served a unique purpose, and everyone was given adequate time to
shine. Kirk and Spock were certainly prioritised, and Scotty wasn’t actually
introduced until the end, but everyone got their moment, and no one was
forgotten.
Unfortunately, the same cannot be said for Into Darkness, which somehow managed to forget entirely about Sulu and Chekov, and only remembered Bones sporadically.
Somehow, Beyond manages to succeed where its predecessor failed so spectacularly. It introduces new characters whilst managing to maintain the relevancy of the regulars, which is pretty impressive for a movie with such an enormous cast. In fairness, there have been some complaints about the underutilisation of Lieutenant Uhura, but given how redundantly her character was treated in Into Darkness, Beyond is a huge improvement.
4. Acknowledging The Past, Tastefully
The plot of Star Trek ’09 is intrinsically connected
to the original series, and Into Darkness references The Wrath of Khan so
excessively that it becomes detrimental to the overall experience. With that
said, each film does acknowledge the history of the franchise, and makes a
conscious effort to bridge the gap between the old and the new.
However, isn’t that a little counterproductive? Instead of boldly going forward, the current films have been stuck in reverse, wallowing in the past, and refusing to evolve. Into Darkness was almost completely derailed by its commitment to the past, recreating scenes from previous movies, quoting entire lines of dialogue, and pointlessly reintroducing everything from Klingons to Tribbles in a desperate bid to appeal to nostalgia.
In Star Trek Beyond, the history of the series is referenced only sparingly, and it is never allowed to interfere with the larger narrative. In fact, the legacy of the series is compressed into a single moment, a powerful scene in which a photo of the original crew is discovered amongst the possessions of Spock, who we learn has recently passed away.
The scene serves as a perfect tribute, a respectful tipping of the hat to the original crew of the Enterprise.
3. Action Scenes Are Well Executted
This should come as no surprise to those familiar with
the work of Justin Lin, but the film does feature some exception action scenes,
and a great deal of variety too. From space battles to smaller skirmishes on
the ground, Beyond is a more than serviceable action blockbuster, proving fully
capable of delivering the goods. Fight scenes are well shot, and the action
itself is paced splendidly, never quite verging on the exhaustive proportions
of Into Darkness.
Best of all: the action itself is shot logically (no pun intended), as clearly a great deal of thought has been put into the framing and execution of each individual scene. The destruction of the Enterprise is a particular highlight, and happens to feature rotating stages, as well as countless practical stunts, some of which look genuinely spectacular. You won’t lose track of the action, and despite the seemingly chaotic nature of the entire sequence, it is masterfully handled and executed without too much of a reliance of special effects.
2. The Villain Had Decent Motivations
SPOILERS FOR THIS PARTICULAR ENTRY! RUN AWAY, SPOILERS FOR THIS ENTRY!
Do you remember Nero from Star Trek ’09, the Romulan from the future who blamed Spock for the desolation of his homeworld, and the genocide of his entire race? Chance are, you probably don’t, because Nero was utterly forgettable, and his motivations were fuelled almost entirely by his own insanity, and were utterly unfounded. In reality, Spock had attempted to save Romulus from a supernova, ultimately failing in his mission.
Is this Spock’s fault? No. In fact, he seemed to be the only person trying to prevent the catastrophe, and was risking his own life in the process. Still, Nero blamed Spock, and that was his motivation for destroying Vulcan, attacking The Federation, and generally acting like a homicidal maniac, intent in wreaking untold havoc across the universe. It made sense, but a simple conversation would have cleared things up, which just made Nero seem immature.
Good villains need great motivations. In Star Trek Beyond, Krall is revealed to be a Starfleet Captain, a soldier breed from conflict, utterly inexperienced in diplomacy, abandoned for lifetimes on an alien planet in an uncharted nebula of space. Like Nero, he’s somewhat insane, but his motivations are understandable; he knows only conflict, but Starfleet is not a military organisation, essentially making his role in life completely redundant.
Now that’s motivation.
1. The Enterprise Is Destroyed
The Starship Enterprise has been destroyed exactly
three times, discounting alternate realities and various incidents involving
time travel. It was destroyed in Star Trek III: The Search for Spock, and it
was destroyed in Star Trek: Generations, and in both cases, the destruction
itself was something of a disappointment. In Beyond, everything humanly
possible is done to prevent the destruction of the Enterprise, and the
destruction itself is handled excellently.
Clearly, the ship means something to the crew, as well as to the Captain. As it descends towards to the ground, there’s a certain degree of magnitude, almost as though we’re witnessing the death of an actual character, rather than the obliteration of some easily replaceable, meaningless scrap of metal. In fact, the image of Kirk reflected across the ship pretty much says it all, and is symbolic of how much of himself is tied to the Enterprise.
Maybe I’m reading too much into it, but at the very least, this was the first time the destruction of the Enterprise was handled correctly. It felt as though a genuine loss, rather than a simple inconvenience. And I only cried for maybe fifteen minutes.
Were you a fan of Star Trek Beyond? Share your own reflections below in the comments thread.