Suicide Squad 2: Casting James Gunn's DCEU Sequel
How about Dave Bautista as Solomon Grundy?
In a move that has the potential to completely reinvigorate the Suicide Squad movie series, James Gunn is in talks to write and direct the follow-up to David Ayer's divisive first film. News suggests that he's being given free reign to relaunch the film, but the fact that it's still being called Suicide Squad 2 suggests there will be some sort of continuity. The logical assumption is that that will come in the shape of the cast.
Not everyone can make the cut and sadly, there can't be many people out there who care about Joel Kinnamon's Rick Flag and even fewer who want a return for Cara Delevigne's Enchantress, so let's just say they went off and got married somewhere quietly, retiring to whisper sweet nothings to each other.
Naturally, though, some of the big faces from the first movie will HAVE to return and they're bound to be joined by some exciting new additions too. But who will return and who will play the new breed?
13. Jared Leto - The Joker
No matter how much criticism he received for his lack of restraint (and some worrying set behaviour), Jared Leto's Joker has unfinished business in what was once called the DCEU.
The real problem with him in Suicide Squad came down to the film-makers: David Ayer didn't keep Leto on enough of a leash and then the studio essentially just edited out most of his performance. Everything that might have been interesting ended up on the cutting room floor and he ended up just being a grotesque glorified cameo.
Bringing him back - which looks inevitable in at least one film - would be a smart move and allowing James Gunn to channel Leto's weirdness but giving him more focus would be good for the character. He could even get to be the main villain this time rather than playing second fiddle to a dancing girl and her CGI goon.
12. The Rock - Black Adam
We know that Dwayne Johnson's Black Adam is coming to the DC film universe sooner or later, even though he's apparently not involved in Shazam! at all (don't rule out a cameo, though). Right now, it looks like that will be in his own movie, but it would be a lot more interesting - particularly with him eyeing up a clash with Superman - to have him established as a big deal elsewhere first.
Dropping him into the end of Suicide Squad 2 as the sequel-tease for a third movie (assuming they WANT to continue their lucrative brands isn't too silly at this stage) would be a great way of doing that and it would establish him as a threat big enough to warrant the Squad's involvement.
Hell, if that sort of cameo seeding works for the MCU, why not here?
11. Dave Bautista - Solomon Grundy
It might not be entirely possible, but it would be great if Dave Bautista's commitment to following James Gunn to Suicide Squad actually lead to him playing a character in the sequel. Because as good as he is as Drax, you have to suggest that a lot of his performance has to do with the direction of Gunn.
With that consideration taken, it would make sense for Bautista to follow Gunn AND to play a character who could take advantage of the work they've already done together. Ideally, that means someone large, with an emotional core and the potential for a comedy dynamic with the other characters because of difference.
Why not Solomon Grundy then? He matches all of those requirements and it's about time we got to see him on the big screen.
10. Bobcat Goldthwaite - The Mad Hatter
An odd name to throw into the ring out of nowhere though he might be, Bobcat Goldthwaite has played a part in the James Gunn Disney saga, and it may be the case that the director would want to recognise that support.
Goldthwaite was among the first famous names to throw their support behind Gunn in the wake of his firing, suggesting that he too should be removed from his Disney job (he voices a character in Hercules that is reused in Disney World) in case Disney appeared hypocritical.
And there's a pretty good character for him to play too. Given the requirements of his famous voice, you'd need a very specific match and someone who perhaps wouldn't be on screen too much. So why not cast him as The Mad Hatter and have him as a Hannibal Lecter style character who enables the Squad to find their target or complete their mission in some way?
9. Margot Robbie - Harley Quinn
Even if Gunn recast 90% of his cast and started everyone else's stories from ground zero again, there's surely no way Warner Bros would let him drop Margot Robbie's Harley Quinn. She was, after all, the most valuable brand to emerge from Suicide Squad (all you need to check out is the Halloween costume trends in the wake of the film's release).
To drop her would be counter-productive and even if Gunn reinvents her completely and chooses to cut the Joker (he shouldn't, but he COULD), she needs to be the one playing the character and she needs to be the main focus of continuity. Even with her own Birds Of Prey film coming.
Without her, Gunn would be scrapping one of the only positives of the entire first movie and Warner Bros really aren't that dumb. Particularly when they're calling it Suicide Squad 2 at the minute.
8. Josh Gad - Penguin
For a while, Josh Gad was very public about his enthusiasm to play the Penguin for Warner Bros at some point and rumour has it he had a conversation with the studio. Whether that would lead to anything concrete in the next few years - or the next few DC projects - is a matter for debate, but it certainly turned thoughts towards him.
He might be something of a surprising choice, given the other suggestions seem to follow the Arkham games' reinvention of him as a gruff gangster type, but Gad has proved himself a great character actor already. He's also got an edge of weirdness that all Batman actors should have and he'd be following Danny DeVito's path of comedy roles to the character, so it's not like there's no precedent to his potential casting.
There's always something more theatrical about comedy actors and when they get pathos, they REALLY get it. So there's every chance he could end up being the best part of this entire thing if it came off.
7. Karen Fukuhara - Katana
Let's be perfectly honest here, Karen Fukuhara's Katana wouldn't have been the most devastating omission from a Suicide Squad sequel. No matter how cool the character was as an idea, that's pretty much all she was: an under-nourished concept with a bad-ass sword and backstory that we didn't even get to see. Leaving her out would have caused precious few ripples.
But Katana fits the mold of James Gunn's powerful female characters - or at least the idea of her and the source material behind her fits him - and she deserves a chance to actually deliver on her promise. In Gunn's hands, that could lead to something great.
We don't necessarily need to see her backstory, but having her wrestling more with her demons (as most of Gunn's Guardians did) and use them is one of the most interesting prospects for a Suicide Squad sequel.
6. Will Smith - Deadshot
Whether you like it or not, Will Smith still has huge star power (which is sort of why his casting in the first movie was so strange) and he's the kind of name you'd probably like to see continue in the franchise. Especially if you're James Gunn.
Gunn has proved himself a great director and Smith IS a truly gifted actor when he has the right guidance (which he didn't on Suicide Squad) and the idea of removing him from Deadshot simply for a clean slate is just not a smart move. Particularly since Deadshot still had good presence and was the real hero of the piece, even when he was lumbered with some of the worst lines of any film ever.
Even though he didn't return for the Independence Day sequel (a very smart move), you'd like to think that he sees this as unfinished business that he needs to deliver on. And the prospect of lining up with Gunn has got to be a draw for him.
5. Michael Rooker - Clayface
Michael Rooker is one of James Gunn's favourites, so it makes sense that he might be in line for a return to familiar working conditions. He was also one of the best parts of Guardians Vol 2, so seeing him working with Gunn again would definitely be a good thing.
So who could he play? Well, Clayface has quickly emerged as a fan favourite to be added to the Squad in the sequel and there's definitely something about Rooker's gruff demeanour and that voice that would work for the most complex character to bring to life.
Ideally, Rooker would combine mo-cap for the clay version of the character with a more human form because robbing him of the chance to emote would be wrong, since it would take away the human element of Clayface that would be so important - and was so important for his performance as Yondu.
Even if it's not Clayface, you have to suspect there's going to be some sort of role for him.
4. Jai Courtney - Boomerang
Jai Courtney's Boomerang (no Captain here) was legitimately one of the biggest and most pleasant surprises of the first movie. He actually seemed to be the only character who had any idea what sort of tone the film should be, for a start and he smashed all of the low expectations fans seemed to have for him.
Boomerang was an absolute riot and he's the kind of character you could actually see in Gunn's Guardians movies (though perhaps not as one of the titular heroes). He's also one of the most befitting of Gunn's Guardian loser mentality, since he spends most of the first movie playing the punchbag.
Courtney's got to see this as a positive step for his own career at this stage, so let's hope he gets the chance to bring the character back. And also that Gunn doesn't change a great deal about him.
3. Sean Gunn - King Shark
As long as James Gunn has a job, he's bound to send out a call to his brother Sean, who plays Kraglin in the first two Guardians movies and stands in for Bradley Cooper as Rocket Raccoon on set. That's assuming his Marvel contract (if he has one the same as the "bigger" stars) would allow him to jump ship, anyway.
Gunn has got to be the most conflicted of all of the actors now and he's also probably one of the easiest to drop from Marvel's point of view since Kraglin disappeared from Infinity War without mention. He could even be retrospectively added to the victims' list for Thanos' snap, if it turned out to be best for all parties that he didn't return.
Gunn knows mo-cap work thanks to Guardians, but he's also good as himself so something like King Shark that could combine mo-cap with his more human sensibilities might be the best approach. It'd be a lot better than simply casting a hulking actor who might not necessarily be able to act, because King Shark's best characteristics are his most surprising - like his intellect. That's why someone like Gunn fits best.
2. Viola Davis - Amanda Waller
Some of the writing of Amanda Waller in the first movie was a little iffy, to say the least, but Viola Davis' performance was genuinely great and she's as key a part of the sequel as the puppeteer behind the Squad.
Waller needs to be the driving force in the Sequel again because she works both as the untouchable government villain (too powerful and too tenacious for even Batman to take down) and also the catalyst for the Squad to work against something potentially worse. She's a perfect love/hate figure and abandoning Davis' strong performance would be a huge disappointment.
As Gunn proved in Guardians, he's best when he's playing with a broad, complex moral spectrum of characters and Waller is very much key to that working in Suicide Squad 2.
1. Nathan Fillion - Hawkman
Bringing Ben Affleck's Batman back might be logistically difficult, but even if it wasn't, it wouldn't be the right thing for the Suicide Squad sequel. He's just not needed and he fired a warning shot at Amanda Waller that suggested his involvement would make too little sense.
But that doesn't mean we shouldn't have a hero involved in Suicide Squad all the same. And there's a ready-made stand-in for the Bat thanks to the location of the first Suicide Squad movie's action. David Ayer's movie was set in Midway City, known to comics fans as the prowling ground of the Silver Age heroes Hawkman and Hawkgirl. So why not involve them this time, since they were notably absent last?
The best option to play that hero - no matter how little he's involved - is the same Gunn veteran that the director used in cameos in his Guardians movies (or planned to anyway): Nathan Fillion. It's about time he had more of a chance in a superhero movie and if this potentially led to more appearances (even in his own title), then it'd be an even better idea.
Just imagine how hard the audience would pop for that cameo.
Would you watch this version of Suicide Squad 2? Share your reactions below in the comments thread.