The Greatest Showman Review: 5 Ups & 4 Downs

Flawed, entertaining Oscar bait.

The Greatest Showman Hugh Jackman Zac Efron
Fox

Not content to chase Oscar buzz solely for his fantastic performance in Logan earlier this year, Hugh Jackman is back in cinemas with a far more traditional awards prospect: a musical based on the life of legendary American entertainer and businessman P.T. Barnum, The Greatest Showman.

Though the movie recently scooped three Golden Globe nominations, reviews have been firmly split, mostly praising the film as an enjoyable three-star jaunt, but one that also falls short of its potential to be so much more. How much that bothers you will ultimately dictate whether you enjoy the movie or not.

As far as slushy holiday efforts go, though, it's certainly a solid enough proposition, at a time of year where just about everyone lowers their cinematic expectations. It could've been much better, sure, but it's also an incredibly watchable awards movie with plenty of bombast to make it worth catching on the biggest screen you can find...


Downs...

4. The Plot Feels Pretty Rushed

The Greatest Showman Hugh Jackman Michelle Williams
Fox

Though it's pretty common for musicals to feature fairly thin narratives in service of the music above all else, The Greatest Showman's plot feels especially like an afterthought.

Jenny Bicks and Bill Condon's script rushes through the set-up without ever really explaining why P.T. Barnum is so interested in the world of the bizarre, and before you know it he's quickly recruited a band of misfits to help him put on a show.

It doesn't take the time to actually let events breathe, and during the few talky moments you can sense director Michael Gracey itchy to move onto the next showy set-piece.

Ultimately it feels like the plot's basically just going through the motions, and how prepared you are to accept that will largely depend on your appreciation for the music.


3. Rebecca Ferguson's Blatantly Obvious Lip-Syncing

The Greatest Showman Rebecca Ferguson
Fox

Rebecca Ferguson plays the supporting role of Jenny Lind, a famous European opera singer who joins Barnum's troupe to bring something "real" to the show.

The irony, ultimately, is that Ferguson's singing is all dubbed over by Loren Allred, and during her character's center-piece performance ("Never Enough"), it's comically obvious that Ferguson isn't singing.

For starters, Allred's singing voice sounds absolutely nothing like Ferguson's spoken voice, and Ferguson's attempts to lip-sync aren't terribly convincing.

It's all the more problematic as Never Enough is meant to be a major emotional turning point for Barnum, yet it's hard not to be distracted by Ferguson's off-kilter work.

She's absolutely radiant in her spoken dramatic scenes, but in this sequence? A total dud, sadly.


2. There's Not Much Character Development

The Greatest Showman Bearded Lady
Fox

Again, like most musicals character development does have to take something of a backseat to accommodate all those songs, but unfortunately many of the movie's characters don't really end up feeling like actual people, rather than props on which to hang the impressively elaborate set-pieces.

Though Barnum, his wife Charity (Michelle Williams) and Zac Efron's alcoholic playwright Phillip Carlyle are sufficiently fleshed-out, the "freaks" are weirdly malnourished in this department, with most of them not even being named on-screen beyond their stage monikers.

In addition, there are real problems with Ferguson's Jenny Lind character, whose personality seems to change on a dime in act three simply to service the plot, even though it doesn't really make a ton of sense.


1. It Sanitises The Real-Life Story

The Greatest Showman Hugh Jackman
Fox

Without question the most controversial aspect of the movie is how blatantly it sanitises the grimmer aspects of Barnum's life, namely his famously buying an elderly, black female slave and making a spectacle out of her (eventually even creating a paid event out of her live autopsy), as well as his generally dubious representations of black people and noted animal rights abuses.

The Greatest Showman instead wants to be a happy, peppy musical with virtually no reference made to the shadier side of Barnum's business: here he's seen as nothing but a charming go-getter, and while that's clearly more a financial decision than anything, it also makes this one of the more patently dishonest biographical films in recent memory.

Clearly, there's plenty of room for a gritty drama about Barnum's life to be made in the future, but this sure ain't it.

Problematic though the film undeniably is, it's also fitfully fun if you're willing to switch your brain off and just enjoy the ride. Here's what it got right...


Ups...

5. It's Goofy As Hell (And Totally Knows It)

The Greatest Showman Hugh Jackman Michelle Williams
Fox

For all of the film's flaws, few will accuse it of taking itself too seriously. Though many musicals become self-serious to the point that it's offputting or even unintentionally comical, The Greatest Showman leans into its inherent silliness and has fun with it.

You'll laugh at the absurd pomp of it all, but you'll be laughing with the movie rather than at it. The actors play-up to the hamminess, and you won't find many eye-rolling moments where the characters sing forlornly about their laundry list of problems.

It's peppy and upbeat for the most part, which while not representative of the true nature of Barnum's story, does at least ensure the film is a fun, undemanding sit for this time of the year.


4. The Catchy, Energetic Songs

The Greatest Showman Hugh Jackman
Fox

The Greatest Showman's soundtrack isn't full of songs destined to be heralded as classics decades from now, but they do serve their purpose as catchy, energetic, bubblegum pop tunes that suitably accompany the flashy visuals.

The movie's signature song, "This is Me", is a persistent earworm that comes complete with an especially memorable dance routine, and is most certain to score a Best Original Song Oscar nomination (if not the win outright).

Again, there aren't any needlessly dreary, depressing or overly sappy songs: most of them are upbeat and easy to listen to, even if the majority might not leave a majorly lasting impression.


3. The Strong Central Performances

The Greatest Showman Zac Efron
Fox

With the exception of the aforementioned issue with Rebecca Ferguson's performance, this is an extremely well-cast film, with Hugh Jackman in particular giving a typically charismatic performance, undeniably giving it his all in both the singing and dramatic scenes.

Elsewhere Michelle Williams is much cheerier than usual as Barnum's luminous wife, while Zac Efron is perhaps the film's most interesting character, an alcohol-sodden playwright with clearly deep-rooted personal issues. Efron continues to prove he has much more to offer than mere "hot funny guy" roles, and he's great opposite Jackman.

It would also be remiss not to mention Zendaya as trapeze artist Anne Wheeler, who represents the movie's attempt to engage with the racial politics of the era, and Tony Award winner Keala Settle, who is fantastic as Lettie Lutz aka The Bearded Lady.


2. Michael Gracey's Stylish Direction

The Greatest Showman Hugh Jackman Zac Efron
Fox

Watching the film, it's pretty tough to believe this is the feature debut of director Michael Gracey, who delivers stylish, dynamic visuals for the most part, even if his lack of experience may account for the narrative feeling a little rushed at times.

The movie's highlight, a song and dance routine in which Jackman and Efron's characters strike a deal to work together while downing countless shots in a bar, boasts all the stylistic aplomb of a classic movie musical, with slick, tight camerawork, precise editing and fantastic choreography.

For a debut, it's a hell of a calling card, and with a better script to work from for his next movie, Gracey could have a bright future as a filmmaker.


1. It's Fast-Paced & Easy To Watch

The Greatest Showman Hugh Jackman
Fox

And finally, above all else, The Greatest Showman is a frothy, Christmas-time release aimed at the family crowd full of turkey and eggnog, and to that end, it delivers a snappy, enjoyable time even if it doesn't offer much food-for-thought.

Considering that this time last year audiences had to deal with the one-two punch of Monster Trucks and Collateral Beauty being dumped in cinemas, a breezy, historically inaccurate Hugh Jackman musical is practically fantastic by comparison.

A lot of musicals buy into their own portent and end up being wildly overlong messes, but at a crisp 105 minutes, this is a movie that doesn't ever begin to outstay its welcome with its breakneck pace and unapologetic sense of glamour.

It's very flawed, sure, and that brief run-time does mean the first act indeed feels rushed, but overall The Greatest Showman is an incredibly easy sit that largely succeeds as a stylish charm offensive.

What did you think of The Greatest Showman? Shout it out in the comments!


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.