The Meg Review: 4 Ups & 5 Downs

Exactly what you're expecting.

The Meg Jason Statham
Warner Bros

The Meg is out now in cinemas worldwide, and it's pretty much exactly what you should expect from the movie's marketing. A fun, brainless shark movie that knows exactly what it is and delivers accordingly, you pretty much already know if you're gonna dig this one.

Critics were sharply divided on the film, to the surprise of few, though polarising reviews for a movie about a gigantic prehistoric shark is pretty much par for the course.

Narratively braindead but bolstered by strong visuals and a talented cast, The Meg isn't an ambitious or thoughtful tentpole flick, but it serves up the high-calorie goods for those prepared to forgive its many, many flaws.

It's not necessarily something you need to catch at the cinema, but as a giddily dumb time at the movies with some pals, it isn't without its pleasures.

Could it have been better with some pretty simple changes? Absolutely, but given how few shark movies actually make it into cinemas, if you're a fan of the genre this might be a ride worth taking...


Downs...

5. The Totally Boring First Act

The Meg Rainn Wilson
Warner Bros.

There's no getting around it: the first 30-40 minutes of this movie are pretty damn rough.

Rather than hit the ground running with insane shark shenanigans, The Meg's first act mostly focuses on a dull, uninteresting rescue mission which culminates with the belated introduction of the titular prehistoric shark.

This opening portion wastes far too much time on expository dialogue, introducing the forgettable characters and, strangely enough, keeping Jason Statham off-screen for a surprising amount of time.

Ultimately, the awkward first reel just feels like needless padding, when a more streamlined introduction to the scenario would've made much more sense. After all, did this movie really need to be almost two hours long?

Things thankfully pick up significantly for the final hour-plus of the film, but getting there is honestly a bit of a slog.


4. Not Enough Meg

The Meg
Warner Bros.

This isn't terribly surprising, but it is definitely disappointing. While Steven Spielberg's Jaws taut us all the value of keeping the monster mostly obscured from view, a movie featuring a 70-foot shark is not one that should adhere to that rule.

Sadly, the megalodon itself only makes fleeting appearances throughout the film, not showing up until about one-third through the movie and launching brief, sporadic attacks for the rest of it.

Nobody has any illusions about what this movie is, so why not give audiences a relentless barrage of gigantic shark mayhem? Instead, the focus is more squarely on the human characters who, er, shouldn't really be the main attraction.


3. The Disappointing Lack Of Gore

The Meg
Warner Bros.

No movie studio that wants a good return-on-investment would allow a $180 million shark movie to be released with an R-rating, so Warner Bros' decision to make The Meg a more family-friendly affair is understandable, but still frustrating.

Ideally, this movie would have struck a tone similar to Alexandre Aja's Piranha 3D, which made an art form out of superbly outrageous gore.

Instead, the restrictions of the PG-13 rating ensure there's an almost total lack of blood (human blood, anyway), and director Jon Turteltaub has to awkwardly cut away from several potentially gnarly death scenes.

It probably would've made more sense for Warner Bros. to cut the movie's budget down to a more manageable $100 million and give it the adult rating it so desperately needed.

Audiences wanted to see a giant shark turning the sea red as it munches its way through fleets of holidaying tourists, but sadly the end result is offputtingly tame.


2. Ruby Rose's Atrocious Performance

The Meg Ruby Rose
Warner Bros.

Ruby Rose appears in the film as Jaxx Herd, a wise-cracking marine scientist who is basically your typical sassy techie character without much deviation.

From her recent roles in the Resident Evil, xXx and John Wick franchises, it's clear that Hollywood's aggressively attempting to make her a thing, even though her risible performance in The Meg is more of a distraction than a net benefit.

From her hilariously unconvincing fake-crying to her read-off-a-cue-card line readings, her acting is by far the worst in the movie, and considering how substantial her role is, she drags things down almost every time she's on screen.

In an otherwise solid ensemble, she's basically dead weight and could've been easily written out of the movie without changing much at all.


1. It Doesn't Set Up A Sequel...For Some Reason

The Meg Jason Statham
Warner Bros.

While The Meg doesn't serve up many narrative surprises, you might be a little bemused to learn that it doesn't in fact end with an enthusiastic set-up for a sequel.

As cynical as sequel-bait endings can be, if there's any movie where audiences could get on-board with it, it's surely this. Instead, the movie just...ends without even the slightest hint of more shark shenanigans to come.

Sure, a sequel remains a dicey prospect given the movie's huge budget and the $400+ million it needs to make to break even, but still, why the hell didn't this film end with a 200-foot megalodon jumping out of the ocean and flying towards the screen? Come on.

If you can let these gripes slide, there is undeniable fun to be had with this movie, so here's what The Meg gets right...


Ups...

4. The Impressively High Production Values

The Meg
Warner Bros.

Easily the most laudable thing about this movie is how shockingly good it looks. Considering the film could've easily gotten away with looking pretty awful, it's a pleasant surprise that it actually boasts sharp, clear visual effects, throwing every penny of its stonking budget on the screen.

Given how ropey even far better blockbuster movies can look - Black Panther, for instance, touted some disappointingly rough CGI - the majority of the effects here are incredibly robust, basically making the film feel like a SyFy movie with a mega-budget.

The cinematography is also unexpectedly eye-popping, especially during the many underwater sequences, where green screen effects are integrated totally seamlessly for the most part.

Whatever complaints you'll have about the film, few will take issue with The Meg's visuals.


3. Jason Statham's Charismatic Performance

The Meg Jason Statham
Warner Bros.

Even more appealing than the titular giant shark is Jason Statham, whose laid-back, charismatic performance as protagonist Jonas Taylor is the easy highlight of the film.

Statham knows exactly what sort of movie he's in and is just having a ton of fun here. He's not averse to cracking some goofy one-liners with a wink at the audience, but at the same time it never undermines his credibility as an action hero.

It helps that The Stath was a real-life competitive diver in his younger days, ensuring he seems extremely capable during his aquatic run-ins with the megalodon. As capable as he can be when battling a 70-foot CGI shark, anyway.

Statham's one of those under-appreciated talents who really deserves stronger material then he generally gets, but he's easily the most compelling and likeable character in the entire movie.


2. The Shamelessly Goofy, Campy Tone

The Meg Pippin
Warner Bros.

Nobody will complain that The Meg takes itself too seriously, because while a lot of the hilariously cliched dialogue is fired through with a surprising poker face, once that awkward first act is over with, the film largely embraces its utter, undeniable silliness.

The characters are largely cardboard, it ticks off disaster movie cliches with an almost admirable enthusiasm, and during the barmy third act it doubles down on the cartoonish action you'd hope for.

What more could you want, really? This is a movie that devotes time to a tiny puppy, Pippin, facing off against the megalodon, and there's perhaps no greater proof that this is a film with no pretensions to being anything more than a trashy, proudly dumb shark movie.


1. The Surprisingly Likeable Child Character

The Meg Meiying
Warner Bros.

Child characters are always a huge gamble in action-adventure movies, but surprisingly enough, young Meiying (Shuya Sophia Cai), the daughter of Li Bingbing's character, is an adorable and charming addition to the cast.

It helps that she's cute as a button and gets a lot of the movie's best dialogue, trading cheeky quips with Statham throughout and basically avoiding most of the "annoying arbitrary child character" cliches.

If a sequel does indeed happen, hopefully they'll bring her back, because while the trailers suggested she was only in the movie to make it more appealing to Chinese audiences, she was actually an unexpected credit to the film.

What did you think of The Meg? Shout it out in the comments!


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.