The Predator: 7 Biggest Overlooked Positives

Time to let old painless out of the bag and defend this shambolic sci-fi.

Ultimate Predator
20th Century Fox

The Predator should have been truly great. Given that it's an R-Rated, 80s throwback, written and directed by Shane Black and featuring the galaxy’s ugliest head-hunter, it’s about as close as you can get in the industry to a ‘’sure thing’’. For fans of old-school action, this was surely destined to be the coolest film of 2018. Right?

Well, not exactly. And things went badly early on: first, the marketing campaign was too slow and started with a terrible trailer, then came talk of heavy reshoots, worrying test screenings and rumours that the entire third-act had been hastily reworked from scratch. Following months of agonising uncertainty, critics eventually swooped in to hammer the last nail into the coffin, pronouncing the flick dead-on-arrival. This negative reception was hardly surprising, but it sure was disappointing.

Sure, The Predator is a scrappy, borderline incoherent mess, but there is a fantastic B-Movie buried within, along with some vaguely redeeming qualities in the finished product. You just have to be willing to look for them.

7. The Gore Is Pleasingly Inventive

The Predator
Fox

Praising a movie for simply being R-rated is like applauding it for having a specific run-time. It’s not an inherently positive quality, just like a PG-13 isn’t innately negative.

In fact, contrary to popular belief, strong violence does not automatically make an action film more entertaining. If that were the case, then A Good Day to Die Hard would outclass Mission Impossible: Fallout, simply because there’s some blood in it and people occasionally say naughty words. However, we all know that the former is a festering pile of odious discharge, whereas the latter is actually one of the best cinematic spectacles in a long time.

So an R-Rating is neither ‘’good’’ nor ‘’bad, because it has no merit on its own. It’s just a neutral certification. However, there is something to be said for a genre movie that makes creative use of that rating , taking full advantage of the freedom and liberties that it affords. This is exactly the case with The Predator, as Shane Black and Co. take gleeful delight in displaying all manner of unmitigated carnage and bloody viscera.

You see, rather than indulging in bland, been-there-done-that slaughter, the filmmakers continually find imaginative new ways of dispatching their red-shirts and main characters, ensuring that the mayhem never grows stale or repetitive. Say what you want about the rest of the movie, but that death-by-tranquilliser-dart is inspired, as is the badass image of a cloaked alien being revealed by torrents of cascading blood. Sure, gore doesn’t always improve a film, but this kind of deranged imagination does earn some bonus points.


6. Sterling K Brown Is A Blast

The Predator Traeger
Fox

Credit where credit's due, almost everyone in The Predator puts in a fantastic performance, even if some of them have more to work with than others. The script may let them down- saddling certain individuals with clunky exposition and tasteless jokes- but they’re a capable bunch and each cast member get a few moments to shine.

Nevertheless, the highlight is undoubtedly Sterling K. Brown as Will Traeger, a human antagonist who surprisingly upstages the titular E.T as a villain. Indeed, whilst the aliens themselves are slightly mishandled throughout the movie (lacking their usual menace and given weirdly comical things to do), this sarcastic government agent is consistently there to pick up the slack. He's such a charismatic and engaging screen-presence, that you almost wish the film was a straight-up action movie about taking him down, rather than a clunky sci-fi.

What's more, Traeger is the only character in the film who actually feels like a traditional Shane Black creation: dispensing with killer quips and exuding effortless, sardonic cool. For the most part, the movie's dialogue is a mixed-bag, but almost every good line belongs to this guy, i.e. ‘’ They're large, they're fast, and f*cking you up is their idea of tourism’’


5. The Practical Effects Are A Joy

The Predator
Fox
.

The use of practical effects was critical to Shane Black’s retro pitch for the film, so much so that he famously took to social media in order to promote it as one of the big draws. Back in April 2017, he proudly boasted on Twitter that he was standing next to ‘’a 7-foot tall gentleman in a Predator suit -- so no, it is not all CGI’’. This was a dream-come-true for movie fans, who have remained sceptical of digital effects intruding upon nostalgic franchises, ever since the green-screen migraine that was The Phantom Menace.

Now as with the aforementioned R-rating, it’s worth noting that the mere use of things like animatronics is not necessarily a virtue. After all, it was the default method for doing things a few decades ago and it didn’t always pan out successfully. That’s because, just like anything else in filmmaking, practical effects are only worthwhile if they’re done right.

Luckily, The Predator’s prosthetics are universally great, even when put under harsh lighting conditions, such as in the lab sequence. There’s something nice and tactile about having a real creature interacting with the cast and Stan Winston's Yautja design is obviously iconic, so it was fulfilling to see it done justice by expert craftsmen.

It's a shame that this impressive work is later supplanted by a wonky cartoon monster, because the dodgy CGI in the third act (presumably a knock-on effect of the infamous reshoots) has regrettably dominated discussion of the film’s effects, effectively undermining the top-notch practical stuff.


4. It Largely Retains Alan Silvestri's Peerless Score

Alan Silvestri
Anthony Skelton [CC BY 2.0 (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0)], via Wikimedia Commons

Like 2010’s Predators (which is oddly experiencing a resurgence in popularity right now), this reboot features numerous musical call-backs to the franchise progenitor. Composer Henry Jackman clearly reveres Alan Silvestri’s work on the original film and so lovingly sprinkles the motifs throughout this reboot. The benefits of this are twofold: as it's in keeping with the fan-servicing attitude of the movie, reminding you of why you fell in love with the series in the first place.

More importantly though, it also gives the action a suitably propulsive edge, one that is sadly absent from a lot of modern soundtracks. There’s certainly no competing with the intensity of that memorable theme, with its thunderous brass and unnerving staccato strings, so it just makes sense to preserve it.

Also, it’s simply refreshing to hear a classically orchestrated sound again, instead of another over-produced Hans Zimmer rip-off.


3. There Are Funny Moments Scattered Throughout

The Predator 2018 movie Keegan-Michael Key
20th Century Fox

We are now reaching the stage where the list entries come accompanied with heavy caveats, because whilst the jokes in The Predator are not all bad, some of them are frankly inexcusable. As many have already pointed out, the scattershot nature of the comedy results in jarring tonal shifts and some egregious misfires, like that cutesy predi-dog thing. Meanwhile, the over-reliance on broad humour does sabotage the slasher-horror element of the story and generally damages the credibility of the rest of the film.

That being said, a decent amount of the gags do still land, mainly the understated ones. As previously mentioned, Sterling K. Brown gets to sink his teeth into some sharp one-liners and a couple of the deaths have a sadistic, gallows humour to them that's quite effective. Take Traeger’s death for example. Although the presentation of his accidental suicide was somewhat botched by the dizzying editing, it still remains a very funny and surprising moment.

Elsewhere, the propensity for ‘’Yo Mama’’ Jokes has come under a lot of flak, with the automatic assumption being that any witticism of this kind is fundamentally artless and dumb. Honestly though, the one about circumcising a homeless man was genuinely inventive and even Shakespeare indulged in these crass innuendos from time-to-time, so you can't be too harsh on it.

In short, the comedy aspect of The Predator is a mixed bag. What that means however, is that there are many overlooked hits to accompany the overly-scrutinised misses.


2. It Willingly Embraces Its Inner B-Movie

The Predator RV
Fox

When they can actually be discerned amidst all the ADHD editing and dim lighting set-ups, the shootouts in The Predator have an enjoyably over-the-top charm, ideal for Friday night viewing. For example, consider the absolutely insane moment wherein the Loonies surf the roof of an alien spaceship, in order to unload a barrage of ammunition into the engines.

As a set-piece, it’s patently ridiculous and very, very silly, but at least it’s not bland or dull like some contemporary Blockbusters (Ant-Man and the Wasp, The Meg)

Instead it’s just endearingly stupid, in a giddy, juvenile kind of way. This anything-goes craziness permeates the entire movie, like the filmmakers were getting carried away with excitement every single time that they turned on their cameras. The result is a manic energy that is extremely infectious and makes for a nice change of pace after a year of largely dour and morose blockbusters (i.e. Black Panther, Infinity War, Solo and Jurassic World: Fallen Kingdom).


1. It Tries To Take The Franchise In Bold New Directions

Olivia Munn The Predator
Fox

In terms of narrative, The Predator is undeniably jumbled, as it is riddled with disjointed plot-points, out-of-nowhere developments and eyebrow-raising decisions. Yet on a purely conceptual level, there are some interesting ideas being tossed around, things that we’ve never seen in a Predator movie before. In that sense, the film is a distinct instalment in a franchise that has otherwise been creatively dormant since 1987.

You see, rather than wallowing in the past and regurgitating the same old routine, Shane Black has bravely opted to expand upon the mythos in unique ways. We consequently learn new things about the Yautja, like why they insist on repeatedly returning to earth and how they have been splicing their own DNA in order to accelerate the evolutionary process. Outside of the confines of extended universal materials, this is the first time that such fertile ground has ever been explored. Because of this ambition to build upon the lore and add to the legacy of the first film (as opposed to just recycling it), this feels like the first Predator sequel to actually move things.

Likewise, the team also try to innovate upon the series’ fairly rigid structure and so rather than deferring to the same old slasher formula, they've given us something more sprawling and intricate. To that end, there are evil government agencies, inter-species feuds, and even a child-in-peril. It might not all work, but at least it’s not another lazy rehash.


In this post: 
The Predator
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Perpetually cynical and prone to excessive rants. Talents include proficient nitpicking, condescending to people and also typing.