Who Should Play The X-Men In The MCU

The mutants are coming, but who should play who?

Armie Hammer Cyclops
Marvel / Warner Bros.

With Phase 4 on its way, the Marvel Cinematic Universe is preparing to expand again. But there is still a little uncertainly as to what direction the series will go. Massive changes have occurred, and right now it's difficult to predict what's next for Marvel. The Avengers are still in play but having lost Cap and Tony, there is a feeling that the the star power of the franchise has faded.

However, the introduction of new heroes and worlds is bound to bring in a lot of attention, and a group that MCU fans desperately want to see are the X-Men.

One of their biggest and most successful properties, the X-Men are an embodiment of what makes Marvel so fun, yet in all of their career in film they have belonged to another company, unable to interact with some of the Marvel Universe's most famous characters.

Once Marvel can create their version of the mutant super-team, viewers are inevitably in for a treat. Right now one of the most exciting things to speculate on is who will be taking which role within the cast.

The X-Men are filled with beloved and iconic characters, and any of the following actors would be sure to do them justice.

10. Rogue - Ana De Armas

Blade Runner 2049 Ana De Armas Joi
Warner Bros.

Ana de Armas is a very successful performer, evident from her impressive role in Knives Out and her upcoming position in the latest Bond film. Her experience puts her into the perfect place to take on this potentially leading role.

She is enough of a name brand to draw in some attention, but simultaneously her celebrity isn't going to overpower the part and prove too distracting.

Giving her the signature white streak in her hair would make for a fascinating look, and overall De Armas has a youthful aesthetic that would match the position Anna Paquin had in the original series.

Although ruined to an extent in the first attempt, Rogue acting as the audience's guide into the mutant world was a strong concept, and Ana de Armas - with her likeable charm - could make it work a lot better.


9. Mystique - Eva Green

Eva Green Casino Royale
MGM

Eva Green has made a career out of playing characters who are simultaneously seductive and frightening. This persona is conducive with her immense talent and unique look. She could easily bring this signature energy to the role of Mystique, and make her feel important.

Mystique's blue body is a constant challenge for actors to remain visible under, and one element that can combat this is an actor's eyes. Green has always had a potent stare, her ability to convey meaning and intention purely through subtle glances are impressive. With that approach Green could bring a lot of purpose to the part, making the character feel compelling and relevant despite their overwhelming aesthetic.

In addition to the previous points, Eva Green would be a fantastic fit for a villainous turn in the MCU. Her career has been mostly built on these kind of roles and it would be logical for her largest project to share this energy.


8. Jean Grey - Jessica Chastain

Ava Jessica Chastain
Vertical Entertainment

Jessica Chastain is the perfect Jean Grey for many reasons , one of the main ones being that she looks the part. But further from that, she has proved time and time again that her level of performance is immaculate, and there's no doubt she would bring the same amount of quality to the character.

Chastain has already taken a turn at the X-Men franchise, appearing as the primary antagonist in Dark Phoenix. Unfortunately this film was a disappointment for fans and the final nail in the coffin for the X-Men with Fox. Although Chastain has a reputation for delivering great performances in bad films, in this case her presence felt like too much of an afterthought.

It is time for her to get another chance at being a part of the X-Men franchise. Her reliability in the industry is undeniable, and she deserves a role that will truly show off the quality of her acting.


7. Beast - Antony Starr

The Boys Homelander
Amazon Studios

Antony Starr's appearance as Homelander is an absolute highlight of Amazon's The Boys. His performance is indicative of how talented he is, managing to appear both terrifying and charming at the same time.

It's clear not only that Antony Starr is a great actor, but that he has an impressive athletic build, which would suit Beast's physicality. Compared to Nicholas Hoult and Kelsey Grammer, Starr could bring a much more believable athleticism to Beast. This would work really well to contrast the character's primal attributes with his well spoken intelligent personality.

Additionally, it's clear that he has excellent comedy skills, which would be deeply beneficial for the character.

Starr is a fantastic choice because his star power isn't significant enough to overpower the role and this performance would help him to become a bigger name in the industry. It seems like the right direction for him to move in after Homelander, giving audiences the ability to see him as a real superhero and not just a villain.


6. Nightcrawler - Finn Wolfhard

Stranger Things 3 Mike Wheeler Finn Wolfhard
Netflix

Nightcrawler is a fan favourite character, and he has had a rather strange legacy on screen.

Starting strong with Alan Cummings in X2, the character was a highlight of the film and many were excited to see where they would go with him. Unfortunately that was the last we would see of the character until Kodi Smit-McPhee would take up the mantle in X-Men Apocalypse. Smit-McPhee did a decent job, but unfortunately the films he appeared in in were all underwhelming.

The decision to make Nightcrawler younger works in the character's favour, and Finn Wolfhard would be a perfect choice for the role. His performances in Stranger Things and the IT movies are evidence of his ability, and this opportunity could give him the chance to bring out a side of himself that people would not expect.

Wolfhard is expressive enough to be able to stand out against the presumably heavy makeup, yet his more stoic facial expressions could also help the character feel a lot more genuine despite his outlandish appearance.


5. Storm - Logan Browning

Logan Browning Dear White People
Netflix

Logan Browning is an actor who could be a real star in the making. Her charismatic performance in the series Dear White People shows that she can easily command a leading role in an ensemble piece. This is a useful skill for what would be a rather heavy cast of characters. Browning would definitely be able make sure that Storm isn't lost in the shuffle.

Much like almost every other character on this list, Ororo Munroe has had an unfortunate time finding herself on the big screen. Halle Berry was never particularly impressive, and the character was nearly inconsequential in the later instalments.

Browning could be the change that the character sorely needs. Her ability to convey intelligence and threat could help make Storm a far more important member of the team. The character should be seen as a worthy successor to Professor Xavier's position, and Browning could bring that presence with ease.


4. Magneto - Javier Bardem

Skyfall Silva Javier Bardem
MGM

Magneto is one of the most iconic villains in Marvel, but when introduced to the MCU he will be going up against a lot of stiff competition. It's important that despite this he still feels like a genuine threat. One of the best ways to establish Magneto in this light is to cast someone with an intimidating onscreen presence, and Javier Bardem would be a perfect option.

Bardem has built his career on playing compelling villains, each one having been received with high praise. If he were to bring the same commitment and quality that he established in films such as Skyfall and No Country For Old Men, then Erik would not only be a believable opponent for the X-Men, but possibly one of the MCU's best antagonists.

Bardem is very skilled at taking roles that could be dull and bringing a real purpose to them. This sense of drive and desire is something that Magneto has always required, and he would suit it perfectly.


3. Professor X - Ralph Fiennes

PageEight  Ralph Fiennes
BBC

One of the most critical factors for the dynamic between Magneto and Professor Xavier is for them to feel like similar characters who happen to have walked different paths. Magneto can be fanatical, while Professor X advocates for peace.

With that in mind, an actor who has the gravitas to bring such qualities to the role is Ralph Fiennes. In regards to Xavier's intelligence and elegance, Fiennes would be unmatched. His calm and authoritative voice would establish power and trust, and would also provide the right level of charm the character needs.

The prestige of the role is considerable, and thus casting an actor who has a similarly significant presence in the world of film is essential. Fiennes certainly has this and were he to play the role it would instantly lend credibility to the part and the entire franchise.

What could make him even more compelling is Fiennes' affinity with playing villainous characters. In the same way as Bardem, Fiennes has built a lot of his legacy around playing antagonistic roles, most notably Lord Voldemort. He could bring a slight edge to Xavier that whilst trustworthy and likeable shows the extent of what he could be capable of. This would make the character far more layered and deliver some great options for storytelling.


2. Wolverine - Karl Urban

The Boys Karl Urban
Amazon Studios

Unfortunately Karl urban has already appeared in the MCU. His performance as Skurge in Thor Ragnorok worked for what it needed to be, but it feels like a waste of an actor who could have been utilised in a much better capacity.

Despite his pre-existing role in the Marvel Cinematic Universe, Urban is still the perfect choice for Wolverine. He has proven himself consistently to be a great leading star in action, a notable example being his performance in Dredd.

In addition to this his portrayal of Billy Butcher in The Boys is almost an audition for the role of Logan. The character is charming but at the same time there is a true sense that you should fear what he is capable of.

He has the perfect look for Logan, especially with his excessive facial hair. The scornful faces he can give combined with his physique and dark hair make him incredibly well suited to play such an animalistic yet human character. He could also make great use of his native accent to establish a different vibe to what we have already seen.

This will be one of the most demanding jobs for whoever takes the role, but Urban is a good enough performer to equal the legacy of Hugh Jackman and establish his own take on the character.


1. Cyclops - Armie Hammer

Armie Hammer Man From UNCLE
Warner Bros. Pictures

It seems that Armie Hammer is one of the most unlucky leading men in Hollywood. Not only does he have the perfect look for a series protagonist but he backs it up by being a very competent actor. His performances in The Social Network and Call Me By My Name make this very clear.

Unfortunately for Hammer, it seems that every franchise that he takes a role in ends up being a dissapointment. Two of his most notable attempts are The Lone Ranger and The Man From Uncle, both were decent enough films, but neither were the runaway successes that the studios were hoping for.

Hammer really could take on many roles in the MCU, but it seems that Cyclops is perfect for him. He would fit very well into the position of being an authoritative leader, and bring a great deal more agency than James Marsden's version of the character.

Hammer should get this role, and finally cement himself as the leading Hollywood actor that he is born to be.


Watch Next


You'll Never Get 100% On This X-Men Movie Quiz

X Men Xavier Cyclops Storm
Fox

1. Where Is The Movie's First Scene Set?

Contributor

Michael is my name, overanalysing comedy is my game! Anime, wrestling, TV, movies and video games all live in my head rent free!