With Bryan Singer's triumphant return to the X-Men franchise, the future is once more rosey for the mutant movie series, and if First Class was the shock to the heart that was needed, Days Of Future Past was the blood transfusion that meant that longevity is again a possibility. Singer was clearly a man on a mission in Days Of Future Past, and when you think back to some of the missteps and flat out errors that have been committed in the name of the franchise that he created, and that for many he still owns as much as Fox, his intent was well-placed. But even despite those well-publicised problems, and even with the threat that The Last Stand might have killed the franchise entirely, the series remains impressive as a whole, and though the worst films and worst moments are obvious, picking out the best is a difficult prospect. It is far easier to rank the directors: Bryan Singer wins it by a few lengths, James Mangold takes second from Matthew Vaughn (just), and then Brett Ratner finishes second last, and Gavin Hood barely limps over the finish line to a round chorus of boos. Singer's vision for the X-Men universe is simply superior to Vaughn's and obviously also Ratner's (though his is closer to Singer's than the British director), and the director who has now made his trilogy feels fundamentally like the most tuned into the characters. You can probably guess which film comes top, but what of the others? How do the X-Men movies look ranked from best to worst?
7. X-Men Origins: Wolverine
Some may have expected that Brett Ratner's ambitious but distinctly wayward threequel would be the immediate choice for the bottom rung of the X-Men ladder, but despite its manifold errors (more of which very soon) it is easily better than Gavin Hood's misguided origin story. Despite the strength of the source, and some incredibly good characters to play with, the script forX-Men Origins: Wolverine is very poor (laughably so in places) and it's a case of some great components and a major opportunity being swallowed up in bad execution, as well as some woeful directing that basically turned Wolverine into a moody caricature of himself. Best Moment Up until he is horribly screwed by the script, and we're forced to watch an enduring comic book character dragged through the mud in the misguided attempt to introduce a villain who poses a genuine threat to Wolverine, Deadpool is very good. The casting of Ryan Reynolds - like that of Liev Shrieber - is nailed on, and hopefully it will lead to the mooted Deadpool spin-off the character deserves. Worst Moment Everything that involves Deadpool after the reveal that he has become Weapon XI.
6. X-Men: The Last Stand
For all of its problems, The Last Stand is definitely the second most ambitious of all of the X-Men movies: it is grand in cast, massive in scope and both the set-pieces and the fundamental idea of the Mutant cure are very engaging. Had Ratner's script been better, and some of his casting decisions smarter, we could have actually had the Mutant War that the franchise should have built up to. Sadly the enduring memory of the film is one that placed way too much faith in poor second string mutants and relegated most of the main cast to bystanders or headstones. Best Moment The climactic battle remains an impressive feat, and for all of the logical errors that came afterwards, the moment when Phoenix shows Professor Xavier the extent of her powers by turning him into molecules is a great moment in the franchise. Worst Moment How could it be anything other than "I'm the Juggernaut, bitch!"? In truth, almost everything Vinnie Jones' Juggernaut does and says is a bitter tasting joke, considering the potential of the character, and it is a travesty that he is reduced to being a circus act.
5. The Wolverine
After Gavin Hood fudged Fox's desire to give Hugh Jackman his own movie, they turned to James Mangold and one of the most enduring early storylines in Wolverine's library and managed a revival worthy of the self-healer, even with its flaws. The elements of Wolverine without his powers and as a vengeful bodyguard are very entertaining, and the undertones of honour and family add a completely different element to the character that was sorely needed after the cartoonish grump that was painted by X-Men Origins. Best Moment Wolverine's demeanour and personality is a dramatic step forward from Origins, and he even returns to some of the snark-laden comedy of the first two films and which would return for Days Of Future Past. He might be in a different world, but this is Singer's Wolverine once more. Worst Moment The pace - the editing makes it feel like we're bouncing between fight scenes with no real stakes. And the sequence in which Wolverine becomes a pin cushion is just silly.
4. X-Men: First Class
Had Matthew Vaughn had his intended way, he would have been involved in more films than Bryan Singer, and we might have had a different tone for the franchise, entirely. He was originally intended to take Singer's place on The Last Stand, he was originally charged with helming Days Of Future Past, and he of course brought First Class to the screen. But what he didn't quite bring was Singer's spirit and his obvious passion for the characters, and it shows in the different tone of the reboot. That isn't to say the film is in any way bad - on the contrary it is extremely entertaining - but like The Last Stand there is an over-reliance on the wrong characters, and some of the younger players just aren't as worthy of attention as the old cast. Best Moment Fassbender's Magneto steals the show, and while the climactic Cuban missile crisis sequence is the film's tense best, his goading and assassination of the tailor and the pig farmer is almost Tarantino-like in its power. Worst Moment The plot-holes it creates, while dismissable at the time thanks to the film's intention to be a true reboot, are rather problematic when taken in the context of the franchise as a whole. And Nicholas Hoult's Beast is no more than a face-pulling moron for most of his screen-time after his transformation.
3. X-Men: Days Of Future Past
Considering the requirements placed upon Bryan Singer - not only to make a great X-Men film, but also to mend some of the errors of past films that came after his franchise openers - the fact that Days Of Future Past is even remotely watchable should be classed as an impressive feat. That it is very good is an absolute triumph. Singer's vision for the X-Men is just irresistible, and even when charged with taking on a cast that is not his own, he brings the same diligence, aided massively by the bridging influence of Hugh Jackman's Wolverine, who is the most important figure in the entire film, rather fittingly. The addition of more gags and a fan's thirst for Easter Eggs and references from Singer are to the film's benefit, and though there is a certain amount of timeline mud to ignore, the director achieved both a fitting end for his cast and an exciting base for the new cast to move on from. Best Moment The Quicksilver sequence when he helps rescue Fassbender's Magneto from his prison vault is just genius. Worst MomentThere are a lot of questions left unanswered.
2. X-Men
If it weren't for Bryan Singer's first X-Men movie, we might not have comic book movies at all now. Coming three years after Joel Schumacher managed to get Batman movies cancelled, the ensemble proved that with a strong script, a wonderful cast and a fan's eye for the kind of spectacle that comic book movie fans eat up, the genre was still bankable. In perfectly casting the three key characters in the franchise (Magneto, Professor X and Wolverine) Singer offered a strong spine to which he added a great wider cast, and a great story that matched the potential of the source. The decision to focus on Rogue as the emotional heart of the narrative, and to introduce Wolverine along with her, rather than simply as a lone wolf also pushed the film on, as it added a familial element that hadn't been seen in the genre to date. Best Moment Wolverine's introduction is easily one of the finest character introductions in any comic book movie. Worst Moment Halle Berry.
1. X-Men 2
Though it's impossible to talk about the X-Men franchise without acknowledging the importance of the first film on the formative years of the current comic book movie boom, it was surpassed in almost every way by its sequel. Singer was able to go stronger on storyline having already set the character foundation, and in resisting the urge to double-stuff with more new mutants, the director was able to focus more on the core of character and story. And introducing the key narrative element of humanity's suspicions of the mutants, as well as Wolverine's quest for his past was a master-stroke. The villain of the piece was skin-crawlingly unlikeable thanks to Brian Cox's performance, the key X-Men felt more comfortable in their skin, and the set-pieces were fitting for a film seeking to outdo its predecessor, and X2 remains one of the best sequels of all time. Best Moment Nightcrawler's attempted assassination of the President is a high point in a film that rarely drops. Worst Moment The silliness of Jean Grey not simply manipulating the X-Jet from inside it, as is clearly possible within the boundaries of her abilities (she's more powerful than Magneto after all, who can move an entire bridge while on it) is a slight black mark in X2's ledger. Oh, and Halle Berry again. Which is your favourite X-Men movie? Share your ranking in the comments thread below.