X-Men: Supernova - 10 Big Questions We Need Answering
Bryan Singer has got to be out after Apocalypse, so who's even directing this thing?
The latest mutant-based movie news suggests that Fox will set up shop in Montreal this May to begin production on a film entitled X-Men: Supernova.
This information came to light not through an official press release from the studio, but through the film's commencement date being listed on a number of industry websites.
Because of that, details are scarce. It's easiest to assume that Supernova is based on the X-Men 7 script that Simon Kinberg is known to be working on, making it the direct sequel to last year's major disappointment X-Men: Apocalypse. Kinberg previously penned Days Of Future Past, The Last Stand and Apocalypse, making his record with X-scripts extremely chequered.
The Supernova title has everyone suspecting that Sophie Turner's Jean Grey, and the fiery Phoenix powers she discovered last time, will take centre stage. But that hasn't actually been confirmed, which leaves the fandom with these massive questions...
10. Who's Directing It?
X-Men, X-2, Days Of Future Past and Apocalypse director Bryan Singer told Fandango last year that he'd like to make a movie with "a big alien, interstellar tenant within the X-Men universe". An X-Men movie set in space? That would fit nicely with a title like Supernova. Although the identity of that 'interstellar tenant' is anyone's guess.
But it looks incredibly unlikely that Singer will direct this next X-flick. He's currently deep into 20,000 Leagues Under The Sea, another Fox film (and hopefully a franchise-starter) which only began production in autumn 2016. There's no way he could get that finished in time to start Supernova in May.
So Fox may have to find a new director. First Class helmsman Matthew Vaughn is hard at work on Kingsman: The Golden Circle and The Last Stand's Brett Ratner is despised by X-fans, so it'll probably be a newcomer to the franchise that ends up in the chair.
Joss Whedon would be a dream choice for many (he's even written X-Men comics), but his ties to Marvel Studios surely rule him out. He'd be quite expensive, too. Someone like Assassin's Creed director Justin Kurzel could do the job. Someone with experience in action but not A-list salary status may be what Fox is after. But only time will tell who gets the gig.
9. Which Cast Members Will Return?
Jennifer Lawrence told Entertainment Weekly that her, Michael Fassbender and James McAvoy have decided to stick together when it comes to renegotiating their X-Men contracts (which all lapsed after Apocalypse). "Fox should be terrified," she explained, "because the deal we made was like if one of us doesn’t come back, none of us are!" It was harsh of them to leave Nicholas Hoult out of that agreement, wan't it?
At this stage, it's unclear if that lot have signed on for Supernova or not. That would be one massive cheque for Fox to write, if they did. Luckily for Fox's finance team, getting the younger cast to return should be much easier, since their contracts probably aren't running out anytime soon.
Sophie Turner's Jean Grey is the hot tip to be centre of attention, with Evan Peters' Quicksilver, Tye Sheridan's Cyclops, Kodi Smit-McPhee's Nightcrawler, Alexandra Shipp's Storm and Ben Hardy's Angel seeming most likely to join her. There could even be room for Lana Condor's Jubilee and Olivia Munn's Psylocke.
As it stands, no one has publicly ruled themselves out or said they're definitely on board.
8. What Happens In The Comics?
There's a Marvel superhero named Supernova, but this film won't have anything to do with him (because he's a member of Nova Corps, the film rights to which are held by Marvel Studios). Instead, the title of this new X-Men film is almost definitely a reference to one iconic comic book run: The Dark Phoenix Saga.
Yep, that's the same story they butchered for X-Men: The Last Stand, where Jean Grey turns heel and her powers become dark and uncontrollable, bursting out of her like fearsome flames. The story has one of comics' most grim endings: Jean being killed for everyone else's safety.
Simon Kinberg, who wrote The Last Stand and is believed to be working on Supernova, told Entertainment Weekly last year that he "would love to take another stab at the Dark Phoenix story." And it looks like Fox have given him the go-ahead to do just that.
The comic book version was much more epic than The Last Stand film: at one point, Jean fled Planet Earth and recharged her powers by absorbing a faraway star. This caused a supernova, which destroyed an entire populated planet. If the Supernova film ends up including cosmic sequences like that, it would be very different to the previous Dark Phoenix movie. And it would ask an awful lot of Sophie Turner, who's performance in Apocalypse was very divisive.
7. When Will It Be Set?
"The next one is set in the 90s", Simon Kinberg told ComingSoon.net during the publicity tour for Apocalypse. Following the pattern of the last few X-Men movies, Supernova will be another period piece that resumes the story a decade after the previous film's events. That is, unless the plans have changed majorly since Kinberg gave that interview.
Fans of the 1992-1997 X-Men animated series will have a lot of questions about the prospect of a 90s-set X-Men movie. Will Jubilee have a hugely expanded role? Will we get to see Storm's wacky white costume? Will there be red X badges on everything? Will Wolverine don his iconic yellow threads? Will Gambit flirt outrageously in inappropriate situations? And could Rogue be in it?
Sadly, some of those answers won't be the ones fans want. Hugh Jackman seems adamant that he's done with Wolvie after the Logan film, and a Gambit appearance seems unlikely while Channing Tatum is still trying to get his solo movie off the ground. But the Jubilee thing could happen, and the costumes might be brilliant. And they could stick Rogue in it if they wanted - it's not like they've adhered religiously to the original timeline before.
6. Will There Be A New Mutants Connection?
The New Mutants is an X-Men spinoff film starring new young adult heroes, which The Fault In Our Stars' Josh Boone is helming. According to the same industry websites that broke the Supernova news, its production will start in Montreal in April 2017. That's less than a month before work on Supernova kicks off in the same area. Will these films be connected in some way? It's plausible, that's for sure.
Anya Taylor-Joy (who's rumoured to be playing the magic-wielding inter-dimensional teleporter Magik in The New Mutants) was asked by ComingSoon.com to clarify whether she's involved in the X-spinoff earlier this month. After dodging the question, she said, "I mean, I think James [McAvoy] is already a part of it, isn’t he?"
Was that an innocent assumption or some insider intel she wasn't meant to share? Nobody outside the Fox bubble knows for sure. But either way, the idea sounds feasible. And if McAvoy has signed on to reprise Charles Xavier, perhaps he'll provide some connective tissue between The New Mutants and Supernova. An official press release to clear this all up would be nice.
5. Do The TV Shows Link Up To It?
One X-Men TV show is definitely on the way our screens: Legion, which will star Dan Stevens as Charles Xavier's son, a powerful mutant whose gift includes multiple personalities and powers to match.
One of the network executives behind Legion has told the press it exists "in a parallel universe" to the films, in which "the US government is in the early days of being aware that something called mutants exist but the public is not." He added that he "wouldn’t foresee characters moving back and forth because they really are parallel universes.” So that's a big no from that one: Supernova and Legion will not have a crossover.
There is another X-Men TV show in development, though, from writer Matt Nix. It's about a mutant family going on the run, and according to Mr Nix it will reference the films if it gets a series order. He told Collider, "if you like that world and the world of the movies, there are definite nods to it, it definitely exists in the same general universe."
So, if Nix's as-yet-untitled shows does make it to screen, there could be some connectivity with Supernova.
4. Will They Stick Deadpool In It?
Deadpool made more money at the American box office than any of the previous X-Men movies, including the spinoffs and prequels. On the same leader board, X-Men: Apocalypse stands third from the bottom, having only beaten First Class and The Wolverine.
It's not hard to imagine a studio head looking at those numbers and deciding the mainline X-Men films need an injection of snarky Ryan Reynolds goodness. Deadpool poking fun at Charles and his merry mutants all over the marketing materials would be a surefire way to drum up interest for Supernova. He wouldn't even need a massive part in the final film, as long as potential viewers knew he had some sort of presence.
But would Reynolds want to do this? Would he even have the time in his schedule? It's hard to say at this stage, but if there's something in particular he wants from Fox (extra characters or dosh for Deadpool 2, for example), he could use a cameo in X-Men: Supernova and some marketing assistance as a powerful bargaining chip.
And you needn't worry about the timelines failing to sync up. Deadpool 2 will introduce the time-traveller Cable. Supernova could use his skill-set as an easy way to explain Wade Wilson's antihero existing in the 1990s.
3. When Will It Reach Cinemas?
The X-Men: Supernova release date has not yet been announced, and it might be quite a while before it is. But there could be clues to be found in the previous X-Men movie's production schedule. The first rumblings about Apocalypse began in October 2014, followed by a cast announcement in January 2015. Shooting began in April 2015, and the film eventually reached cinemas in May 2016.
Right now, Supernova seems to be at the earliest stages, with no proper announcement, confirmed cast or even a director. It will surely be pre-production (building sets and so forth) that starts in May 2017, with the shoot proper kicking off a few months later. If they can turn the film around in a year and a bit from that point, as they did with Apocalypse, Supernova could light up cinema screens in mid-to-late 2018.
But following the critical bashing and middling box office returns of X-Men: Apocalypse, Fox might want to be a bit more careful this time around, and spend longer honing the script, mastering the VFX and doing other quality control stuff. If they do take a cautious approach, Supernova might not arrive until 2019.
2. What Will It Add To The Franchise?
This is a question that Fox needs to ask themselves, and Simon Kinberg needs to address in his script. What's unique about this film? If it's not the basic premise (which, as aforementioned, could be similar to The Last Stand's Jean storyline), then what is it? What makes this film stand out? What does it add to the franchise?
After the blubbering mess of Apocalypse, there's no point rushing out another X-Men film just for the sake of it. There needs to be a USP here, something that film fans will spot in the trailers and be intrigued enough to shell out the ticket price for. Apocalypse was a big dent in the reputation of this franchise, which had been rebuilt so well with First Class and Days Of Future Past. To correct course, there will need to be something special here.
First Class had young X-Men. Days Of Future Past had time-travel. What does Supernova have? A Deadpool cameo? A dark tone? Connections to other films and TV shows? More 90s nostalgia than you could shake a Furby at?
A combination of all those things, and an epic adaptation the Dark Phoenix Saga, might be enough to get moviegoers back on side.
1. Will It Be Better Than The Last Stand?
Lastly, the most important question of all: this isn't going to be a naff retread of an already-naff film, is it? Please? The X-Men franchise and its fandom might not survive another disappointment on the scale of The Last Stand. Fox has shown some serious bravery to give that film's screenwriter another shot at Dark Phoenix, which will start to look like super stupidity if Supernova turns out badly.
For one thing, nobody wants to see if another film where Jean Grey's downfall gets overshadowed by a completely different plot strand. Famke Janssen couldn't make Phoenix work as a subplot, and it's doubtful that Sophie Turner could either. This film has to really focus in on Jean; it should showcase the limitless nature of her power, and explore in depth the toll it takes on her psyche.
Supernova should have some huge, inventive visuals and some seriously dark scenes. There should be death and destruction that actually means something. Here's hoping Fox bring in a director who can deliver all that, and don't rush out a bad movie in a bid for quick bucks. The Dark Phoenix Saga means a lot to people, and screwing it up once was bad enough.
What do you think of the X-Men: Supernova news? Do you trust Kinberg and Turner with Dark Phoneix? Who would your dream director be? Sound off in the comments below...