10 Best Skill-Check Bosses In Gaming History

Pass this bar or get flattened by it.

final fantasy 16 Benedikta Harman boss fight
Square Enix

Who doesn't love a good boss battle?

Final bosses, Resident Evil bosses, final bosses in Resident Evil - these represent just a fraction of the overpowered digital pugilists gamers have had to overcome over the decades, using nothing more than wit, reflexes and good old-fashioned trial and error. (If you ever want to see a Bloodborne veteran give a thousand yard stare, simply whisper "Orphan of Kos" into one ear. Four hours of effort to win a fight that lasts less than five minutes...)

Of all boss types, however, none are more vital to developing a player's skill-set than the subject of today's article: the Skill-Check Boss.

To clarify, a Skill-Check Boss is a mandatory fight that exists to make sure you've been paying attention to the fundamental mechanics of the game you're playing.

Whether that game prioritizes parrying, stat-juggling or sheer ruthless aggression (to borrow a phrase from world-famous streaker John Cena), unless you're au fait with the systems underlying its combat then these bosses will end your journey before it really begins.

Which brings us to the first entry on our list. (And yet another name that should be familiar to Bloodborne fans...).

10. Father Gascoigne (Bloodborne)

Bloodborne Father Gascoigne
Sony

Father Gascoigne contains one of the greatest bits of trolling in the history of boss fights.

During the first half of the fight - when Gascoigne is in his doddering old man form - there's a group of gravestones in the arena that provide a handy barrier between you and the hirsute priest. With a little maneuvering, it's possible to position Gascoigne in a manner where your attacks can reach him, but his can't touch you. It's an undeniably cheap strategy, but an effective one.

That is, until you whittle down Gascoigne down to half his health.

At that point, he transforms into a werewolf, shatters the gravestones with a single punch, and proceeds to massacre your health bar before you've had time to pick your jaw up off the floor. It's such a masterful sucker punch that you can almost hear director Hidetaka Miyazaki chuckling alongside you.

"Nice try, Padawan, but you'll need to learn how to actually fight to get past this one".

And so it goes, with Gascoigne's monstrous form proving nigh-impossible to get past unless you've got a good grasp of Bloodborne's projectile-based parrying. (Or at least a good sense of timing for when to roll out the way of his feral lunges).

Father Gascoigne is the point where it becomes clear that Bloodborne brooks no quarter from the player, and that the only way to proceed is to, as the saying goes, "git gud". That the game goes about teaching this in such a delightfully wicked manner is one of the many reasons Miyazaki's masterpiece is remembered so fondly.


9. The Mantis Lords (Hollow Knight)

Hollow Knight
Team Cherry

Hollow Knight's reputation for masochist-level difficulty is well earned, but if you only played through the game's opening hours you'd be forgiven for wondering what the fuss is about.

Like a dominatrix easing a first-time client into their role, Hollow Knight takes things gently at first with a handful of easily-dispatched bosses - the digital equivalent of a gentle nipple tweak. The Mantis Lords, however, are when Hollow Knight slaps the player in the face, puts on its stilettos and starts digging its heels into their chest.

Hollow Knight's combat is all about leaping, dodging and finding the space and time to heal yourself. And while previous bosses gave you enough time to undergo a full spa service during their fights, the Mantis Lords are the first bosses whose relentless attacks make finding the time to heal a challenge in and of itself.

This dilemma only gets worse throughout the game - to the point where it becomes routine for a split-second to decide the difference between successfully healing yourself or getting smeared across the floor - but it's the Mantis Lords who offer the first real introduction to Hollow Knight's sadistic tendencies.


8. Master Murai (Ninja Gaiden Black)

Murai ninja gaiden
Team Ninja

Years before any game with a difficulty level higher than sucking your thumb and picking your nose at the same time was referred to as "The Dark Souls of [insert genre here]", Ninja Gaiden Black was the go-to comparison for any game that offered a stiff challenge.

Unlike the previous entrant, which at least brought you dinner before bringing out the whip, Ninja Gaiden wastes no time in bringing the player to their knees.

After button-mashing your way through a horde of disposable ninjas in the game's tutorial level, the player comes across protagonist Ryu Hayabusa's imposing instructor, Master Murai.

Being a teacher, Master Murai wastes no time in instructing the player of the skills needed to conquer Ninja Gaiden Black's many, many challenges. Simply hammering the attack button results in poor Ryu being nunchucked to death by his overzealous instructor, forcing the player to adapt to the rhythms of Ninja Gaiden's combat in order to pass this literal do-or-die exam.


7. Giganto (Sonic Frontiers)

sonic frontiers
Sega

At this point, you'd be forgiven for thinking Skill-Check Bosses only exist in the hardest of video games. And while that's generally true, there are some notable exceptions.

Sonic Frontiers may not be known for its high level of difficulty (its absurdly hard DLC aside), but its first boss - the Evangelion-inspired Giganto - plays a crucial role in instructing the player on the importance of parrying.

Simply wading in to attack him results in the mechanical kaiju repeatedly swatting Sonic away, making it impossible to finish the fight before the time limit expires. Instead, the player needs to watch out for Giganto's attacks and successfully parry them to continue piling on the pressure.

Truthfully, doing so is a simple task - especially when compared to most of the other entrants in this article. However, the battle against Giganto is arguably the most purely entertaining one in this particular Top Ten.

Watching Sonic go full Super Saiyan on a colossal robot while "Undefeatable" (the best Sonic track since 2001's "Live and Learn") blasts in the background is the coolest the blue blur has been since he was introduced to starry-eyed kids back in the 90's, and is sure to bring a grin to even the most jaded of Sonic fans.

(And lord knows there's been a lot to be jaded about).


6. Matador (Shin Megami Tensei III: Nocturne)

shin megami tensei 3 matador
Atlus

If the previous boss was all about making the player feel cool, this one is about reminding them of their ignorance.

Seconds after the fight against Shin Megami Tensei III's Matador begins, you'll likely leap to the conclusion that you've wandered into an unwinnable fight. You know the kind - where a massively overleveled boss obliterates your party, you get saved by a deus ex machina, and hours later you have the rematch to get your win back.

That... doesn't happen here. Matador is just that good, and now you have to be that much better.

Before this fight, it's entirely possible to get by in SMT III through doing nothing fancier than healing your party when their health gets too low. Matador, however, is a roadblock that's impossible to pass unless you learn the ins and outs of how to buff your party - specifically, their Evasion stat.

Matador's attacks hit so hard that the only way to win is to ensure they don't hit you. As such, you need to buff your party's Evasion, while simultaneously lowering the skeletal sod's Accuracy to ensure he misses more than he hits.

Matador is a timely reminder to familiarize yourself with the intricacies of SMT III's combat, and by the time he falls you'll be far better equipped to deal with the remainder of ATLUS' extraordinarily tough RPG.


5. Blade Wolf (Metal Gear Rising: Revengeance)

metal gear rising revengeance blade wolf
Platinum Games

Metal Gear Rising is many things. One of the best action games of the past fifteen years; a fountain of memes ("NANOMACHINES, SON!"); and the the answer to the question posed by the first Metal Gear Solid: "Do you think love can bloom, even on a battlefield?"

Turns out the answer to that question is an emphatic "Yes!", as long as the object of that love is a robotic dog with a chainsaw on its back.

Blade Wolf makes his debut as an early boss, and despite his diminutive stature he offers a stern test for the player. He's the first boss with attacks that are simply too fast to dodge, ensuring you need to master Metal Gear Rising's best-in-class parry system in order to beat him and move on with the game. Given that later bosses are literally impossible to beat if you can't parry their attacks, you'll be glad the cybernetic canine gave you a crash course on the subject.

Even better, once you've beaten Blade Wolf he joins the good guys and becomes one of the game's best sources of humour. Frankly, it's hard not to fall in love with a robot dog who responds to franchise chew toy Raiden's pitiful jokes with "I understand your attempts at humour. I just don't find them entertaining".

Speak your truth, Blade Wolf. Speak your truth.


4. Benedikta Harman (Final Fantasy XVI)

final fantasy 16 Benedikta Harman boss fight
Square Enix

Alongside Sonic Frontiers, Final Fantasy XVI holds the distinction of being one of the easiest games on this list.

Anyone who's played an action game in the past five years should find FFXVI's relatively simplistic combat a doddle to master, but that doesn't mean the game isn't capable of entertaining even the most battle-hardened gaming veteran. Case in point: one Benedikta Harman.

Benedikta isn't the first boss in Final Fantasy XVI's gigantic menagerie of foes, but she is the first to offer a real test of the player's capabilities. In order to survive Ms. Harman's wind-based assault, you'll need to be at least passingly adept at each aspect of the game's basic combat - special attacks, dodging and Quick Time Events.

Some of you may be rolling your eyes at the mention of that last part, but those QTEs are actually why this boss battle makes the list. Final Fantasy XVI's bosses are the undisputed highlight of the game, and Benedikta is an early preview of the delights ahead.

There are several fist-pumpingly entertaining moments spread throughout this fight (including one of the best utterances of the f-word in the history of video games), and they're almost all kicked off by Quick Time Events.

QTEs may be divisive, but when they lead to this much adrenaline-infused joy, it's hard to argue against them.


3. Jeanne (Bayonetta)

bayonetta jeanne
Platinum Games

Arguably the best pure action game on this list, 2010's Bayonetta still stands as the high water mark for Spectacle Fighters/Character Action Games/ Games That Let You Kick Ass And Look Good Doing It.

Bayonetta launched to the top of its polyonymous genre by virtue of its exquisite boss battles and Witch Time mechanic, whereby time slows down upon successfully dodging an enemy attack.

Launching a counterattack into a decelerated foe is a viciously satisfying sensation, and it's Jeanne who acts as Bayonetta's primary instructor in the ways of this particular pleasure.

Without making judicious use of Witch Time during your first face-off against Jeanne, you'll find most of your attacks whiffing like fake punches from a bad wrestler. Jeanne is simply too fast to land a good hit on at normal speeds, and the first time you face her marks the point where Bayonetta's signature time-slowing mechanic transforms from a bonus into a necessity.

To top it all of, Jeanne herself also proves to be one of the best characters in the game. Effortlessly able to match Bayonetta blow for blow and quip for quip, Jeanne is a worthy rival to one of gaming's most charismatic protagonists.


2. Balteus (Armored Core 6)

armored core 6 balteus
FromSoftware

As German rock legends Falco once (almost) sang:

Oh Balteus, oh Balteus, oh Balteus,

Oh Balteus, oh Balteus, oh Balteus,

Oh Balteus, oh Balteus, oh oh oh Balteus,

Stop goddamn shooting me, Balteus!

Skill-check specialists FromSoftware Inc. further proved themselves as the undisputed masters of their craft with Armored Core 6's Balteus - the end result of a mech designer taking the Frasier Crane approach to deciding exactly how many missiles a robot should be able to fire at once. ("If less is more, just think of how much more "more" will be!").

Unless you've mastered your own custom-built mech's fighting style, each round against Balteus will end with you disintegrating in a rain of rocket-fuelled lead.

Fortunately, Armored Core 6's combat is open-ended enough that you can avoid Balteus' ballistic discharge in a variety of ways, from dancing through the onslaught in a zippy, lightweight mech to absorbing the punishment with a well-timed burst of a forcefield in a mobile fortress. (And any number of strategies in between, from sniping to sword-swinging).

Of course, doing any of the above is easier said than done, but the feeling of accomplishment derived from Balteus meeting his end makes it worth the effort.

And the fact that FromSoftware Inc. deliver this feeling again and again throughout AC 6's campaign shows why they're seen as gaming's premier provider of quality boss battles.

Which brings us to the final entry on this list...


1. Ornstein & Smough (Dark Souls)

Ornstein Smough
FromSoftware

It had to be them, didn't it?

Dark Souls' diabolical duo are the stuff of legend - the most infamously hard boss fight in an infamously hard game. Ornstein & Smough fully live up to their controller-wrecking reputation, as the fight against them puts every skill Dark Souls has taught you to the test.

Focusing all your damage on one enemy before attacking the other? Check. Using the environment to avoid enemy attacks? Check. Making sure to keep every enemy on screen at all times? Check. Dying again and again before headbutting the TV screen in frustration and using the shards to carve a blood sigil onto your chest to summon a demon that will curse the developers unto a thousand generations? OK, maybe not the last one (tempting as it is).

Ornstein & Smough are a work of uncommon magic. Excruciatingly hard, each failed attempt against them nevertheless feels like a stepping stone on the journey to mastering your chosen playstyle in Dark Souls.

No other dual boss fight comes close to the armor-clad pairing - even FromSoft themselves failed to recreate the magic with Elden Ring's irritating Godskin Duo - and no other boss in gaming does a better job preparing you for the battles ahead.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Hello! My name's Iain Tayor. I write about video games, wrestling and comic books, and I apparently can't figure out how to set my profile picture correctly.