10 Gaming Endings That Basically Doomed The Franchise

What is Batman without The Joker?

Black ops 3
Activision

Endings can make or break just about any piece of media: get it right and you've crafted an indelible moment fans won't ever forget, but screw it up, and they'll never let it go for a whole other reason.

That's certainly as true in the world of video games as it is in movies or TV, especially where beloved, epic franchises are concerned.

Though games as a whole aren't as singularly dependent on storytelling as other visual media, that doesn't mean fans will simply put up with a poorly-executed ending.

And so, we have these 10 video games, all of which dished up highly divisive, contentious, and even fanbase-splitting finales, in turn throwing the very future of the franchise into doubt as fans scrambled to make sense of what they'd just witnessed.

Whether it was a fatal creative misstep or a sign of the changing tide, in each case these endings left a major section of the fanbase alienated and perhaps even feeling that their time had been wasted...

10. Choices Mean Nothing - Mass Effect 3

Mass Effect 3
BioWare

It's tough to think of a AAA gaming franchise that burned its bridges with fans more thoroughly than Mass Effect, which for its first two games was unquestionably one of the most immersive and smartly written blockbuster video game IP ever made.

Fans were chomping at the bit to see how BioWare would wrap up Commander Shepard's story in Mass Effect 3, while factoring in the choices they'd made throughout the series...only for the ending to reduce dozens if not hundreds of play-hours down to a simple choice: pick a colour.

That's right, Mass Effect 3's ending lays out three rigid, delineated choices which take zero account of the player's decision-making up to that point, leaving an entire fanbase feeling like they'd been bait-and-switched. The release of a "clarified" extended ending didn't much help, either.

In addition to souring fans on the third game entirely and retroactively lessening the power of the two prior games, it ruined all of BioWare's goodwill moving forward, surely contributing to the fourth game, Mass Effect: Andromeda, flopping commercially.

Reports subsequently emerged that EA had put the franchise "on ice" for the foreseeable future, and though Andromeda was hardly a great game, the series' downfall was clearly caused by Mass Effect 3 aggravating so much of the fanbase.


9. The Non-Ending - Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain

Metal Gear Solid V The Phantom Pain
Konami

From a mechanical perspective, Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain is one of the greatest open-world action games of the generation, but it also dealt major damage to the brand through its highly contentious conclusion (or rather, lack thereof).

Though MGSV's climactic twist, that Venom Snake was actually a doppelganger of Big Boss, proved plenty divisive with the fanbase, fans were generally far angrier that the game ended on such a ridiculous cliffhanger.

It's no secret that MGSV was effectively released unfinished by an impatient Konami, resulting in the story more-or-less ending in flux as a young Liquid Snake flees to parts unknown with Metal Gear Sahelanthropus in tow.

A scrapped third chapter, remnants of which have since been revealed (below), would've given the game a more concrete ending, rather than the deeply unsatisfying one on which, given Hideo Kojima's departure from Konami, the main franchise has most likely concluded.

Ultimately MGS V's dispiriting climax underlined the building discord between Kojima and Konami, serving as a monument to both unrealised potential and the consequences of corporate meddling.

Even if Konami eventually decides to move ahead with a sixth Metal Gear Solid sans-Kojima, for many fans the franchise has been irreparably tainted.


8. Desmond Dies - Assassin's Creed III

Assassin S Creed 3 Desmond
Ubisoft

Though the Assassin's Creed franchise continues to be a critical and commercial success to this day, for many fans the series' lustre wore off considerably following the infuriating ending of 2012's Assassin's Creed III.

After all, the franchise's big conceit was its unexpected sci-fi twist, where the historical settings are actually genetic memories being accessed by the series' real protagonist, Desmond Miles.

Yet despite the clear implication that Desmond would eventually become an action hero in his own right, AC3 concluded with him semi-randomly sacrificing himself in order to save humanity.

Ever since, the franchise has dialled-back the modern day elements as it became clear nobody knew what to do with them post-Desmond, even though they were easily the most interesting and ambitious aspect of the series' mythology.

Though the subsequent games are (mostly) still fun to play, many fans are mentally checked out on the scrawled remnants of a plot that actually remain.


7. Chloe Or Arcadia Bay - Life Is Strange

Life Is Strange Max
Dontnod Entertainment

Despite its frequently cringe-worthy dialogue, the first season of Life Is Strange is a brilliantly emotional slice of supernatural fantasy drama, albeit one which served up an ending that, one way or another, has basically condemned the franchise.

Life Is Strange concludes by giving the player a choice: they can either save protagonist Max's best pal Chloe and allow the town of Arcadia Bay to be destroyed, or they can allow Chloe to die in order to save the town.

For starters, many fans were dismayed that the end of the game came down to a binary choice after Max demonstrated far more fluid and far-reaching time-rewinding abilities throughout the rest of the game.

But the wider implication of this choice is that, with Dontnod refusing to acknowledge either ending as canon, they forced themselves to rustle up an entirely new story and fresh set of characters for the recent sequel, all of which sharply divided fans.

After all, fans fell in love with Max and Chloe, and so to shift so abruptly to an entirely new setting and cast for Life Is Strange 2 rubbed a lot of players the wrong way - especially as young Daniel was, well, a bit annoying.

Whether or not a Life Is Strange 3 ever in fact happens, the series as a whole feels incapable of escaping the shadow of the brilliant Max-Chloe relationship.


6. It Was An MMORPG All Along - Star Ocean: Till The End Of Time

Star Ocean Till The End Of Time
Tri-Ace

Star Ocean: Till the End of Time plays host to one of the most infamous plot twists in gaming history, as unfolds in the latter stages of the game.

It's eventually revealed that all of the game's characters are actually NPC avatars existing within a computer simulation, and so this rich, dense world players have become invested in over the course of four games is...nothing more than a glorified MMORPG.

In an overzealous attempt to surprise fans, developers tri-Ace ultimately left many of them re-evaluating their opinion of the entire series, and worse still, it completely ruined the trust that fans had in the series' storytelling.

As a result, every Star Ocean game released since has been a prequel, as though tri-Ace themselves appreciates that a sequel would be immediately handicapped by the knowledge that it's all pretty much meaningless.

Many fans were so abhorred by the game's ending that they've sworn the franchise off ever since, and who can blame them?


5. Status Quo Restored - Shadow Of The Tomb Raider

Shadow Of The Tomb Raider Ending Lara
Square Enix

The marketing for Shadow of the Tomb Raider seemed to suggest that the game was going to offer up an atypical spin on the adventure franchise's formula, by examining the impact of Lara Croft's globe-trotting, artefact-thieving behaviour on the civilisations that reside there.

But despite teasing Lara to be the game's true villain with some of her more reckless actions throughout the game - namely stealing a dagger which brings forth the apocalypse - she's ultimately restored to her regular white saviour mode by game's end.

While the game could've ventured in one of several truly bold directions, the status quo is largely restored by the time the credits roll, with the asterisk that Lara will now try to protect rather than steal things during her adventures.

But now that the series has fully drawn attention to how much of a douchebag Lara is, doesn't it somewhat take the fun out of it?

By showing the consequences of her blinkered, privileged adventuring upon indigenous civilisations - as in, literally getting innocent people killed - it's going to be tough to engage with the next game with quite the same oorah flippancy.


4. What Just Happened? - Call Of Duty: Black Ops III

Call of Duty Black Ops 3
Treyarch

In recent years the Call of Duty franchise has made some misguidedly ambitious attempts to move away from the more typical campaign narratives players are used to, culminating in the comically absurd plot - or what passes for one, anyway - of Black Ops III.

Making even basic sense of the game's wildly convoluted story isn't easy, though the end of BO3 reveals that the unnamed protagonist actually died at the start of the game, and most of the subsequent events have in fact been taking place inside a simulation.

The final moments of the game see the player voluntarily wiping themselves from existence in order to allow comrade John Taylor to regain control of his body, but by this point, most players were simply scratching their heads in bemusement.

More than anything, Black Ops 3's migraine-inducingly incoherent story underlined an overall problem with the franchise: the fast-ramping sci-fi silliness of the series had reached a fever pitch.

And so, when it came time for Treyarch to develop Black Ops IIII, they responded to the vocal fan criticism of BO3's campaign by...just not including a campaign at all. Instead, they controversially chose to focus instead on a new battle royale mode, Blackout, to fans' further frustration.

Though subsequent Call of Duty games from other studios have thankfully restored campaigns to the fore, it's fair to suggest that the Black Ops brand has been permanently tainted by the hostile response to BO3's horrendous campaign - especially its ending.


3. To Be Continued...(Again) - Shenmue III

Shenmue 3
Ys Net

Shenmue III was one of the most anticipated video game sequels of all time, arriving almost two decades after the second game left fans on an epic cliffhanger, with Ryo Hazuki's vengeance against his father's killer Lan Di still unfulfilled.

And though franchise director Yu Suzuki did tell fans that Shenmue III wasn't the end of Ryo's story, given the sheer time and effort it took to get the third game made, fans surely deserved to see the story significantly moved forward, no?

Instead, Shenmue III ends in hilariously anti-climactic fashion, as a brief boss fight with Lan Di - who is absent for 99.8% of the game, by the way - culminates in Ryo getting his ass kicked and Lan Di escaping once again.

A closing title informs us, "The story goes on...," as though to rub salt in the wound that near-two decades of waiting really wasn't worth it after all.

Considering that Shenmue III's mere existence is a freaking miracle, and there's no guarantee at all that a fourth game will ever come to pass, the game's refusal to move Ryo's story on left many fans feeling burned for all the time and money they invested in the project.

As a result, a Kickstarter for Shenmue IV surely won't have anywhere near the same uptake should it actually happen.


2. The Joker Dies - Batman: Arkham City

Batman Arkham City Joker Death
Warner Bros. Interactive Entertainment

On paper, Batman: Arkham City featured one hell of a ballsy ending, as The Joker died from Titan poisoning, seeming to indicate that the Arkham series wasn't simply going to use the Dark Knight's most iconic foe as a dramatic crutch forever more.

But the brilliance of The Joker's demise was effectively undermined by the games that followed.

Arkham Origins managed to bring The Joker back by functioning as a prequel to the two prior games, while Arkham Knight again had The Joker appear posthumously by way of hallucinations in Batman's head, courtesy of his own poisoning.

Clearly, Rocksteady realised they screwed up by killing off The Joker, because as fantastic as Arkham City's ending was, the rest of the franchise was left wanting whenever he wasn't around. And so, he was continually brought back to the fold by any contrived means necessary.


1. What A Twist! - Danganronpa V3: Killing Harmony

Danganronpa V3
Spike Chunsoft

The ending to Danganronpa V3: Killing Harmony is one of the most fiercely debated of the last few years, a bold and ambitious finale which nevertheless ran the risk of alienating most of the core fanbase.

The franchise as a whole follows a group of highly skilled students caught in a series of killing games, and each time a murder takes place, the player must investigate as part of a class trial, which can result in the accused being brutally slaughtered.

The big twist is that Danganronpa is in fact a reality TV show watched by millions, and the memories and personalities of the characters in the game are mere fabrications for the sake of entertainment.

There's a lot more to it than that, but V3 basically attempts to deconstruct the series and poke fun at the player's own bloodlust.

However, this not only irked some fans who didn't like being the target of the game's derision, but also those who felt the twist effectively invalidated the characters and story of the first two games.

Though it's pretty much inevitable that Danganronpa V4 will eventually surface, much like Star Ocean it'll likely suffer from many of its fans being disengaged following a context-shifting reveal.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.