10 Pointless Video Game Reboots NOBODY Asked For

So Modern Warfare released in 2007 AND 2019?!

devil may cry 2013
Capcom

For as long as there have been ideas, there have been reboots. Hollywood can't get enough of them, and neither can game designers. It's easy to see why: They get to reuse a concept that's already been set up and ready to go. Then they get to make sequels that put their own spin on the concept.

There have been quite a few successful video game reboots, such as Killer Instinct (2013), Mortal Kombat (2011) and Doom (2016). Unfortunately, for every good reboot, there's a poorly-handled, completely pointless one that nearly kills its franchise.

If a reboot fails to hit the mark, it makes companies believe that there's no market for the game. That's why it's so difficult to recover from a lacklustre one.

In the end, there are many reboots no one asked for, ultimately being forgotten about as the main canon inevitably resumes going forward.

10. Star Fox Zero

Star Fox
Nintendo

Overview: Star Fox is a space aircraft shooter game franchise. You command a fleet of space animals that are tasked with defending the Lylat system from various bad guys including the evil Andross (a giant floating monkey head, don't ask).

Star Fox Zero was the first unique Star Fox game in ten years at the time of its release. It was also the first (and last if you don't count Star Fox Guard) Star Fox game on the Wii U. The idea for the game was born from playing around with assets from an unused Star Fox for the Wii.

Star Fox Zero is a unique game in that while you control your ship with the left stick, you can only aim by looking down at the Wii U Gamepad and using that to aim and fire your reticle. It's impossible to control the Arwing the same way that every other Star Fox game controlled like.

Why It Was Pointless: The game's most unique feature: its control scheme, ended up being its biggest downfall (but far from its only flaw). Even though it wasn't inherently a bad idea, it failed to function as well as it should have. Most players reported it barely working at all.

Star Fox Zero also suffered from being what was essentially a remake of Star Fox 64. Not only was Star Fox 64 already a reboot of the series, but it also had a 3D remake that released just five years prior to Star Fox Zero. This meant that despite Star Fox 64 being a great game, fans were burnt out on it by the time Star Fox Zero rolled around.


9. Call Of Duty: Modern Warfare

Call Of Duty Modern Warfare 2 2574
Activision

Overview: This game is the only one on the list to not be released yet. It also hasn't been officially confirmed, but multiple reports label the next COD as Call of Duty: Modern Warfare.

It'll be a reboot of, well, Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare, which was the first Call of Duty to make everyone go "Oh, shooting people is fun."

Why It's Pointless: The whole reason they're making this a reboot is so they can avoid naming it Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 4. That would be confusing, considering that the original also has an oddly-placed "4" in the title that everyone forgot about until now.

Too bad everyone's still going to call it Modern Warfare 4.

Call of Duty isn't the type of franchise to really require a reboot, to be honest. A few of the games do have lingering plot lines that carry over to the next, but they're nothing important.

In November 2016, Activision ported Modern Warfare to the Xbox One, PlayStation 4, and PC. It was titled Call of Duty Modern Warfare Remastered. That makes three Modern Warfare games that all share pretty much the same name, and technically, the same identity.

If you didn't realize that Activision is struggling with Call of Duty's direction, this should be a real eye-opener.


8. Turok (2008)

Turok Game
Propaganda Games

Overview: Turok is a video game series about killing dinosaurs, aliens, or alien dinosaurs. The games are based on a series of comic books, although they don't take much inspiration from them. Especially not the reboot that released in 2008 for the Xbox 360, PlayStation 3, and PC.

Instead of revolving around time-traveling warriors like the previous Turoks, the 2008 game stars a military soldier who crash-lands on an alien planet while in pursuit of a traitor. Gone are all the mystical elements that fit the insanity of fighting alien dinosaurs. All this game wants to do is be Gears of War meets Jurassic Park.

Why It Was Pointless: Who asked for a Turok reboot?

Since the game's studio, Propaganda Games was hit by several layoffs and eventually closed before they could develop Turok 2, the answer's obvious.

There hasn't been a new Turok since, so this could be considered the reboot that killed the franchise. If someone else were to take a shot at it, hopefully they understand that no one wants to play Call of Duty: Turok Edition.

Regular Turok worked just fine.


7. Need For Speed (2015)

Need for Speed
EA

Overview: Need for Speed has more games than there are Skittles in a bag, but in 2015, EA decided to publish a reboot, simply titled Need for Speed. It's an online open world racing game. That means it requires an internet connection at all times, even if you're just playing through the single-player campaign. EA was infamous for trying to make that system work at the time.

Why It Was Pointless: Almost every Need for Speed is its own separate entity, with its own story and gameplay features. That means there is literally no reason for a reboot. It's the exact same issue that Call of Duty has.

The game itself isn't popular, either. Especially not with online-only functionality. No game should have internet connectivity as a mandatory requirement, and it's a lesson EA should have learned by 2015.

EA has only published one Need for Speed game since the reboot, which was Need for Speed: Payback in 2017. That game was also critically unsuccessful due to having its own myriad of issues. Even though a Need for Speed reboot proved to be pointless, the series could definitely use some sort of return to its roots.


6. SimCity (2013)

SIM CITY
Maxis

Overview: In 2013, the first major SimCity game was released a decade after the last: SimCity 4. This new title acted as a reboot, and was simply named SimCity. Before it released, it looked like the best SimCity yet. It even had a brand new engine that was developed just to make everything run better than ever.

What could possibly go wrong?

Why It Was Pointless: Remember how Need for Speed required an internet connection at all times?

SimCity was exactly the same but much more problematic. When the game came out, Origin (EA's distribution platform at the time) received a high volume of traffic due to how many people that were trying to download it. This resulted in network outages, and lots of them.

The game was unplayable on launch and remained borderline unplayable for weeks (and then months) afterward. The game's developers, Maxis, had to supply frequent updates just to make the game workable, eventually resulting in a patching-in offline mode.

SimCity 2013 remains the most recent major SimCity, but its reputation as the once-unplayable game persists as well. You can't even mention the problematic title without reminding gamers of what happened on March 6, 2013 - the day SimCity took a steep nosedive it has yet to recover from.


5. Bomberman: Act Zero

Bomberman act zero
Microsoft

Overview: Bomberman is a game franchise in which you (usually) play as a cute little fella in a white outfit.

Bomberman: Act Zero though, was a drastic departure from every other Bomberman in existence. It featured a more realistic art style and a darker, dystopian setting.

Keep in mind that Bomberman usually sports a cutesy, kid-friendly art style, and that helped make it popular in the first place.

Why It Was Pointless: Bomberman: Act Zero is one of the worst games ever made. The game was absolutely panned upon launch due to its long loading screens, generic level design, repetitive gameplay, dark setting, and overall lack of fun.

Despite the game's negative reception, it didn't damage the franchise at all. Bomberman games went back to normal the very next year with Bomberman Land, and the series is still going strong today. Bomberman himself even made it into Super Smash Bros. Ultimate as an Assist Trophy!

The one and only positive thing to be said about Bomberman: Act Zero is that it did not kill Bomberman.


4. Sonic The Hedgehog (2006)

Sonic Princess 2006
Sonic Team

Overview: 2006 marked Sonic's fifteenth anniversary. To commemorate the occasion, Sega released a brand new Sonic game for the Xbox 360 and PlayStation 3. Seeing as it was also the first major Sonic game developed for the (at the time) new and revolutionary consoles, Sega decided to make it a reboot of the franchise.

Sonic the Hedgehog (now commonly referred to as Sonic '06) featured a brand new setting, new characters, and gameplay heavily inspired by the Sonic Adventure titles.

Why It Was Pointless: Oh boy.

Sonic '06 is plagued with numerous unfixable issues that made it the laughing stock that it remains today. It has glitches, ugly character models, realistic humans even though Sonic and his friends retain their cartoonish bodies, bad gameplay, and the list goes on. It's infamously known to be one of the worst games ever.

The game's main female protagonist, Princess Elise, acts as Sonic's love interest. His human love interest. The one that revives Sonic with a magical kiss after he's murdered in the game's final act. As you do.

The game may have been a critical failure, but luckily for it, the Sonic franchise is invincible. The very same year, Sega released a new Sonic game for the PlayStation Portable titled Sonic Rivals.

They moved forward like nothing happened, and so did the rest of us.


3. Mirror's Edge Catalyst

Mirror's Edge Catalyst
EA

Overview: In the original Mirror's Edge, players are tasked with guiding Faith Connors through the game by climbing onto, sliding under, and jumping off of anything in her way.

In 2016, EA Dice released a game titled Mirror's Edge: Catalyst. It's both a reboot and a prequel, focusing on Faith's origins, but the events that take place in the game contradict the events of the first. It's basically a Tomb Raider 2013 situation.

Why It Was Pointless: Mirror's Edge Catalyst is a flawed game. It has a rushed story, clunky combat, and a lifeless world. It's not a bad game, but at the time, it wasn't exceptional enough to stand out.

Poor scheduling may have also been a factor. Catalyst was released only two weeks after Overwatch, which was a massive game at the time of release, and still remains a highly-played game today. When Catalyst came out, it was the second best-selling game in the UK, behind Overwatch itself.


2. Star Wars Battlefront (2015)

Mario And Sonic At The 2014 Sochi Olympic Games
Nintendo

Overview: Before EA acquired the rights to make Star Wars games, we had LucasArts and Pandemic Studios. The latter is responsible for creating the first/third-shooter franchise known as Star Wars: Battlefront.

The first two games were widely successful, and while a third game was never officially announced, it was definitely in development. The leaked build is proof of that.

At E3 2013, an EA Dice-developed Battlefront game, simply known as Star Wars Battlefront, was unveiled. It wasn't Star Wars Battlefront III, but it was close enough.

Why It Was Pointless: No it wasn't. The game was closer to EA Dice's Battlefield than it was to the original Battlefront series. The reboot's gameplay was fine, but nothing intuitive for its time. The game launched with only half the content of the game that inspired it. It failed to keep players' interest for long, despite being a financial success.

The most interesting part about the Battlefront reboot is that it spawned an even worse sequel. Star Wars Battlefront II (2017) is an infamous game. It struggled with microtransactions for months after its launch.

To this day, it remains a disappointment of a game, and it never would have existed without Battlefront 2015.


1. DmC: Devil May Cry

DmC Devil May Cry
Capcom

Overview: A success to fans, but not to Capcom, after Devil May Cry 4's sales failed to meet Capcom's expectations, they ordered a reboot in an effort to revitalise everything from the ground up. The result was Ninja Theory's DmC: Devil May Cry.

Why It Was Pointless: Where to begin?

Much like its protagonist Dante, DmC is Devil May Cry in name only. It features a slightly dumbed-down version of the franchise's signature gameplay but none of its charm or style. It strips Dante of his laid-back and somewhat dorky personality, and replaces it with a cocky, punk type of attitude. One that's nowhere near as appealing as the old Dante's.

Fans reject the reboot so much that they refer to its version of Dante as "Donte" or DINO (Dante In Name Only). Despite Devil May Cry's director Hideaki Itsuno (who wasn't involved with DmC) claiming that he'd be up to make a sequel to the reboot, he and Capcom ultimately made Devil May Cry 5 instead, which greatly satisfied fans.


Contributor
Contributor

Kesten Harris is a published author and freelance writer. He loves the Nintendo Switch more than any human should and owns almost exclusively Batman shirts.