10 Reasons AAA Video Games Keep Bombing

Kill The Justice League looks like the same game that we've played a hundred time before.

Harley quinn suicide squad kill the justice league
Warner Bros.

For every incredible new game that we're treated to, there seems to be an increasing amount of blockbuster titles that have failed to impress. Despite the excitement surrounding them, Gotham Knights, The Callisto Protocol, and Forspoken each crashed hard upon release with disappointing gameplay and lacklustre receptions.

However, it's not difficult to see why AAA titles keep bombing after looking at the reasons behind their failures. Whether it's troublesome development practices or tired tropes studios can't let go of at the risk of losing profits, the same issues continue to rear their heads whenever a highly anticipated game flops.

Nobody wants a game to be bad, especially one that fans have been eagerly waiting for. Unfortunately, if audiences so much as get the slightest whiff of any of these factors, the odds of said game doing well are severely decreased.

While the appearance of any of these issues aren't an automatic death sentence, the following reasons are nevertheless harmful to a game's enjoyment and the health of the industry itself.

If developers and publishers can move past these bad practices and tired tropes, we could see a massive improvement in the games we play.

10. Rushing Out Unfinished Games

cyberpunk 2077 judy
CD Projekt RED

With so many huge game releases constantly being announced, there's always something to look forward to. The problem is that we, as an audience, are incredibly impatient and would prefer to have these new titles sooner rather than later.

However, video game development is a complicated procedure that requires massive amounts of work from passionate teams. Especially as games are getting bigger and more advanced, ensuring they work as intended subsequently becomes a greater undertaking.

But deadlines need to be met to please shareholders and customers. Consequently, too many games are being released unfinished.

While day one patches can mend some of the issues, many AAA games nevertheless arrive in a sorry state, with Cyberpunk 2077 being one of the worst offenders.

Just as bad is when games release with only a fraction of the content that was promised. Halo Infinite releasing without campaign co-op or forge mode proved to be a huge misstep for 343.

The games industry needs to learn to take its time and be more patient in future. As Shigeru Miyamoto said, "A delayed game is eventually good, but a bad game is forever bad."


9. Too Much Studio Interference

Forspoken game
Square Enix

It's vital that everyone involved in a large AAA project understands what needs to be done to achieve a singular creative vision. From art design, voice acting, and music, every one of the various components in the development process must come together into one cohesive whole if a game is going to succeed.

While ideas will organically change and evolve throughout the development process, things tend to go wrong when studio executives meddle with the developers' vision too much.

Look no further than recent PlayStation outing Forspoken to see what happens when ideas are interfered with.

According to one of the original writers, Gary Whitta, the version of the game that he worked on was "nothing like" the final product.

After creating the initial idea for the game alongside conceptualising the magical world it would take place in, Whitta was approached by the studio and informed that the story was going to be rebooted. He, however, was unavailable to work on this new script.

What happened was a new team of writers were brought in to bring a version of somebody else's idea to life. The result was a bland game that lacked in both originality and personality.


8. Focusing On Live Services

Halo Infinite
Xbox Game Studios

There was a time when the prospect of a live service game sounded appealing. With updated content being added over time, there would always be something new to do so that players would keep coming back for more.

With Destiny, Fortnite, and Warzone dominating the charts during the honeymoon period with live service titles, nowadays the love affair has officially worn off. Now, this model has become little more than a lazy means of studios to generate money.

While there are still a handful of games out there that know how to implement a live service into their ecosystems (look no further than Sea Of Thieves' constantly evolving world), this is the exception to the rule. Nowadays, AAA games put their live service front and centre.

To see how damaging this business move can be, just look at Halo Infinite.

With progression in the multiplayer mode tied solely to overpriced season passes and cosmetics, grinding through the challenge-based level system quickly becomes a soulless endeavour. Likewise, with 343 putting all their focus into the free multiplayer mode rather than the paid-for campaign, it was clear to players that the studio was more interested in making money than the next gen Halo game fans wanted.


7. Big (But Empty) Worlds

saints row 5
Deep Silver

There's a conception within the games industry that sequels need to be a substantial improvement upon what came before. They must have shinier graphics, slicker gameplay, a grander story, and (most importantly) the map needs to be far bigger than before.

It's a cliche now that developers will proudly boast about how vastly expansive the map is and that everything you see is explorable. The trouble, though, is that bigger doesn't always mean better. Especially in open-world games where it's not so much the map's size that matters, but the quality of the content that's in it.

Whereas games like Breath Of The Wild, The Witcher 3, and Red Dead Redemption 2 brought their respective environments to life with meaningful interactions and surprising discoveries that fully immerse players within their settings, this is unfortunately less common in contemporary games.

Typically, modern games are set within expansive but empty worlds. Instead of meaningful and meaty content for players to discover, the maps of Forspoken, the Saints Row reboot, and even Cyberpunk 2077 were packed with empty space and lackluster checklists of objectives to complete.

These lifeless worlds detract from a game's quality, and audiences are starting to get tired of it


6. Unoriginal "Spiritual Successors"

The Callisto Protocol
Krafton

The term "spiritual successor" has been thrown around in the games industry for some years now. The term is used to inform players about a game's influences while giving them an idea about what they can expect from the title when it launches.

Though the term itself isn't an indicator of failure, with plenty of incredible games like BioShock and Outer Worlds being dubbed spiritual successors (System Shock and Fallout: New Vegas respectively), the problem arises when said game is unable to bring any of its own ideas to the table.

The Callisto Protocol is the perfect example of this happening.

Marketed as the next Dead Space game, there were a lot of striking similarities between The Callisto Protocol and the survival horror classic. Both saw protagonists fighting grotesque alien creatures in confined environments, they had similar HUD designs, and each had a strong focus on establishing atmosphere. However, while Callisto Protocol excelled in creating sickening gore and an eerie setting, it, unfortunately, fell short when it came to its combat and storytelling.

With nothing unique to distinguish it from its inspirations, TCP (alongside other soulless successors) fell into the realm of uninspired mediocrity and consequently flopped hard.


5. Grinding Isn't Fun

Sea Of Thieves - Battle Of The Sea Of Thieves
Xbox Game Studios

As games become bigger and more exciting titles compete for players' attention, developers have found themselves in a position where keeping their game relevant for longer is necessary to avoid being drowned out by the competition.

One way that studios have found a means to do this is by making their games a massive time-sink for players who want to see it through to the end.

While it's important that games are balanced in such a way that earning the rarest rewards never becomes too easy (that just wouldn't be satisfying), there are too many games these days that opt to make acquiring anything a tiresome and never-ending chore.

Whether it's the mind-numbing cycle of acquiring loot in Destiny's endgame, playing countless matches in Halo: Infinite to complete challenges, or even trudging your way through the 1000 levels for each faction in Sea Of Thieves' PvP mode, it doesn't take long for the enjoyment to dissipate from these tasks.

It gets to the point when the work and time players are expected to put into a game isn't worth the rewards. Seeing that an upcoming game will require plenty of grinding is now enough to stop audiences from giving it their time.


4. Lifeless Sequels

Saints Row 2022
Deep Silver

The games industry is one built on franchises that will have players coming back on name recognition alone.

However, even within these mammoth AAA titans, innovation is needed to stop these things from becoming stale. Whether it’s having multiple and ongoing spin-off series, introducing new gameplay mechanics, or toying with genre, creativity is required if a series is to survive for long.

What doesn’t work, though, is when developers take the easy option and serve players another helping of the exact same experience as they’ve had countless times before.

The recent Saints Row reboot did just that.

Though this modern reimagining of the series put aside the over-the-top campiness from the later games in favour of the more ground approach of the first game, the fifth installment nevertheless was overflowing with all the same outdated tropes and gameplay mechanics from the 2006 original.

The same cut-and-paste objectives from the Saint Row franchise were already starting to wear thin by the time it ventured into literal hell; playing the same mission types in 2022 was just overkill.

Relying on name recognition isn't enough to guarantee success. It, therefore, wasn't a surprise that barely anyone joined the Third Street Saints on their latest crime spree.


3. Too Many Games, Not Enough Time (Or Money)

Midnight Suns Spider Man
Firaxis

With the games industry as big as it is today, there are now so many releases for players to choose from at any given time. While this sounds like it could only be a good thing, there is a downside to a crowded market.

There’s not enough time in the world to work your way through each big release, and with games becoming more expensive in recent years, players will often find themselves having to decide more carefully about which of the dozen new game they’re willing to spend their hard-earned money on.

The unfortunate result of this is that some games will get left behind in the sales charts, even if that game is genuinely good.

Look no further than Marvel: Midnight Suns. An XCOM-style RPG that boasted exhilarating turn-based combat featuring a roster of fan-favourite characters, this superhero game was praised from both critics and fans alike. Despite being a solid outing, however, Midnight Suns was a catastrophic failure in terms of sales.

Releasing close to the holiday season and on the same day as The Callisto Protocol, Midnight Suns was an unfortunate case of a great game that was overshadowed by other releases.


2. Bodged Marketing

Halo Infinite Craig
343 Industries

With so many releases vying for players' attention at any one time, all it takes is one misstep from developers to see all goodwill towards a project disappear.

For audiences to become interested in a game, they want to be impressed by the trailers and gameplay footage that's shown. Especially now in this digital age where the internet and social media have become judge, jury, and executioner, perspective audiences have become exceedingly more critical about the marketing material they see.

When something falls short of the expected standard, however, it doesn't take long for it to become the centre of ridicule. It happened when the bug-riddled footage of Mass Effect: Andromeda hit the internet, when disapproving onlookers saw the new Dante in DmC: Devil May Cry, and Microsoft had their work cut out for them after a disastrous Xbox One reveal.

Another notable example came when the comically unpolished character model that was dubbed Craig by the internet appeared in footage for Halo: Infinite. This was not the level of fidelity that Halo fans were hoping for from the next-gen entry in Microsoft's flagship series.

Hundreds of memes were consequently born as excitement for this AAA game took a nosedive.


1. Relying Entirely On Current Trends

Suicide squad kill the justice league
Rocksteady

When Rocksteady released gameplay footage for Suicide Squad: Kill The justice League, audiences let out a collective sigh of disappointment. Though the concept of playing as villains within the Arkham universe remains an exciting one, this game looked to be anything but original.

Combining every overused gameplay trend from four-player co-op, a battle pass, menus overflowing with stats, and looter-shooter mechanics taking centre stage, Kill The Justice League came across like an unappetising concoction of all the worst modern gameplay tropes to the point that it looks to have no discernible personality of its own.

Much like Crystal Dynamics' Avengers game, titles which rely too heavily on the same overdone trends feel more like they were concieved in board rooms by money-grubbing shareholders rather than from the minds of passionate developers.

With these tropes already becoming stale and outdated, any title that bases its core gameplay around them is likely to be a soulless cash grab for publishers to squeeze as much money as they can from players for as long as possible after launch.

While it's possible for developers to smartly incorporate trends into their gameplay, doing so requires a degree of creativity and innovation that Kill The Justice League appears to lack.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Glasgow-based cinephile who earned a Masters degree in film studies to spend their time writing about cinema, video games, and horror.