10 Reasons Zelda: Skyward Sword Is WAY Better Than You Remember
Apologise to Fi, you ANIMALS.
Every franchise that's run as long as Zelda is going to accrue its fair share of black sheep. Not necessarily BAD games, just ones that people tend to agree aren't as good as the others.
So long as people remember the CD-I games, no one in their right mind would ever dare call Skyward Sword the WORST Zelda game, but as far as an entry from the mainline series goes? There seems to be this consensus that Skyward Sword is lacking or even straight up bad.
Why no one ever consults me before making decisions like this is beyond me, but whatever.
If you were on the internet for the first two or so years after this came out, you've probably heard every criticism launched at this game with the kind of Pavlovian repetition that's usually reserved for deep cover sleeper agents planted in the government.
Well, I'm here to tell you that this game deserves a serious reevaluation by the Zelda fandom. This game isn't just nowhere near as bad as so many declare, and instead, is easily one of the best Zelda games ever made.
10. It's Drop Dead Gorgeous
Let's get the most obvious point out of the way, this game is absolutely stunning. Easily one of the most graphically impressive games on the Nintendo Wii.
Not only do the textures pop, lacking any glitches of any kind in the game unless you go actively looking to break it, but the game is just flat out pleasing to the eye. Its painterly style, clearly inspired by art of the European impressionist era, give the world both a serenity and a surprising harshness when the darker forces at play in the story make their move.
The character designs are also top quality, with easily the prettiest Zelda after Breath Of The Wild's version of her, the most practical and realistic Link's clothes have ever looked, and thanks to the stylized graphics, designs that would otherwise be generic like that of Demise, are given this ethereal quality. Demise isn't that interesting a villain, but you BELIEVE he's a higher cosmic being from his design alone.
One thing you can never take away from this game is that it dazzled you at every turn.
9. One Of The Best Links
Even though Link is meant to be an empty vessel for the player to slot themselves in for the adventure, recent games have made more of an effort to insert subtle bits of characterization into the silent elf boy.
Hardcore Zelda fans have learned to pick up on these hints, and have thus been able to discern personalities for each version of Link. From Wind Waker's knuckleheaded goofball, to Breath Of The Wild's feral survivalist pyromaniac, and then we have Skyward Sword's Link, a slacker with a tongue as sharp as his sword.
At various points in the game you're given the usual yes or no responses to certain conversations that we've had since Ocarina Of Time. But the game, subtly copping to the fact that these choices really don't mean anything and everyone knows it, instead puts a third option into each of these responses, wherein Link proceeds to roast whoever he's talking to.
Sure the sarcasm is pretty basic, but again, this isn't exactly the most energetic Link (I imagine if Zelda didn't drag his ass out of bed every morning, he'd sleep through the whole game) so him putting in the minimal effort even into insulting people scans.
8. Combat Feels Amazing
Yeah, I said it. Go ahead and link your favorite incoherent screaming YouTube video you prefer. All I ask is that the other side of the argument be heard.
This game could not exist without the Wii Motion Plus. Skyward Sword lives and dies on its combat feeling like you're actually making real movements with your sword.
Thanks to the Wii Motion Plus, the remote and sensor bar are able to pick up and process far more complex movements than before. What this means is that, if you miss a swing with Link's sword, it's because you flat out swung it wrong.
Sure it wasn't perfect, but only by the metric that no control scheme is completely perfect. But as long as you actually listen to what the game is telling and showing you during combat encounters, and don't just swing wildly like a moron and blame the game when you inevitably get your ass thrashed, the combat is some of the best feeling in the entire Zelda franchise.
7. Ghirahim Is A Fantastic Villain
Being made primarily for kids, Zelda villains are rarely allowed true complexity. Oh sure, once in a while you'll get something like Wind Waker's tragically nuanced depiction of Ganondorf, but it should come as no surprise that Nintendo just made Ganon a giant miasma of vague evil in their latest outing.
While nowhere near as complex or almost-sympathetic as Wind Waker's Ganon, Ghirahim succeeds by being just so delightfully sadistic and evil.
You'll forget you're playing a kids game for just a moment when you read his dialogue, describing in almost pornographic detail the inhumane, horrendous things he has in store for Link and Zelda. Him being the first boss of the game was a fantastic way to not only establish him as a villain - taunting you, stealing your sword and using it against you, and generally toying with you - but through it, and him, it establishes the main premise of the world below: this savage land - personified in the Lord of Demons - laughs at your efforts to command it. There are way bigger players in this game than you realize, and if you don't shape up and get your head in the game, this world will eat you alive.
Many criticized his fate of being revealed to just be a servant (in the most literal sense) to Demise, but it's the perfect fate for him. For all his boasting and gloating, the same is true of him: Whether it's a kid from the skies, or a Lord of Demons, this savage land laughs all the same at any who try to command it.
6. The Best Supporting Cast
While games like Breath Of The Wild and Wind Waker have perfectly fine supporting characters, they rarely go through many story arcs in their own way (and don't you DARE imply that Tetra is a supporting character in Wind Waker) and you don't see that much of them outside of when you need something from them. Probably why many Zelda games make their major supporting characters shop owners. They can't think of anything else to do with them.
And then there's the citizens of Skyloft. We'll get into Skyloft itself in just a bit, but the people inhabiting it give the game so much more character than it would have had otherwise. Every citizen in the town has a name, a job, relationships with other characters, and their own little mini-arcs that they go through and even rewarding side quests. From Link's classmates - charismatic and loyal Pipit, intelligent and empathetic Karale, and wimpy but passionate Fledge - to his teachers at the Knights Academy, to the staff of the Pumpkin landing.
And of course, the most important one of them all, Groose. Starting off as Link's foil and bully, once the two get trapped on the world below, Groose has his life redefined, grows up, and blossoms as Link's most stalwart ally in his quest.
This is by far the most eclectic and interesting supporting cast in a Zelda game thus far, making the world the game creates feel all the more alive.
5. The Best Hub World
What sets Skyloft apart from every other main area of every other Zelda game is one factor: Character. Not just the people living within it, but the feel of the hub world itself.
Now for games like Breath Of The Wild, the isolated feel of Hyrule was the whole point, so it gets a pass that Twilight Princess and Wind Waker just don't get. Sure there are areas of concentrated character and charm, but the world you have to travel to get to those areas just doesn't have anything going on. Skyloft meanwhile is the most interesting hub area in the series since Clock Town from Majora's Mask.
Before you're even close to being half done with the game, Skyloft's memorable design, good use of landmarks, and small, easy-to-traverse size will make you intimately aware of it and everyone in it. You know where everyone lives, what they eat, where they eat it, how they grow their food and where they get their water. And the game directly tells you NONE of this, you figure all of this out just by naturally walking around the place on your own.
Skyloft is one of the best designed worlds in Nintendo's entire library.
4. The Game Is Linear (And That's A Good Thing)
One of the biggest sticking points critics had against the game when it came out was its linearity. This being a game series that, for the most part but not always, tried to give the player as much freedom as possible. To the point where the original NES classic gave you a gray box and said "you want a map, there's your damn map" and people were fine with it because they didn't know better.
But 2011 was a LONG ass time ago, and the game industry is a very different place. Back then, it was the age of the follow-the-leader murky military shooter where players were led by the literal nose from point to point.
Now that we are in the age of the extreme opposite - where every game has to have a sandbox the size of Texas with miscellaneous activities all over the place and absolutely NOTHING of interest to see during the treks between those activities - looking back, it's clear that game journalists were just taking out their frustration with COD on Skyward Sword when it didn't deserve it.
Breath Of The Wild IS a stone cold masterpiece, but linear game design can generally tell a more engaging and faster paced story, as well as come up with interesting maps and encounters that would never have happened in a game where you have to take into account that the player may never even come across them at all.
3. The Best Link And Zelda Relationship
Link and Zelda's relationship has always been a tricky thing to get right. Due to Nintendo's insistence on Link never speaking and generally being a skin suit for the player to zip on like an otaku Buffalo Bill, it's hard to portray them as having any sort of chemistry when only one half of the romantic duo is putting in the work.
But in certain games, they manage to find ways of working within those boundaries and pulling it off. Some of them DON'T have them get together like Twilight Princess or Wind Waker (c'mon guys they're little kids in that one) but Skyward Sword does something far more clever.
For one, the multiple choice answers lets you get a feel for Link's personality, especially since there aren't many of them so not a lot of chances for contradiction like with what can happen in Bioware games. And Zelda is always given complete agency over her actions. Hell, the end credits of the game show the story from Zelda's point of view, and the adventure SHE had while you were off on yours.
This, combined with her sweet but sassy personality makes for a pair that you want to see come out okay and a Zelda that you want to save. Not because she's a damsel in distress plot device, but because you share in Link's fear and love for her, and want to rip Ghirahim's arms off, shove them up his ass and down his throat, and make them shake hands in the middle whenever he talks about harming her.
2. YOU Made Fi Annoying
My personal theory for why the Master Sword, The Blade Of Evil's Bane, the sword that seals the darkness, only goes through maybe 5 fights if you fight smart before needing to recharge in Breath Of The Wild, is because Fi is still upset at the internet for making fun of her for 6 years (and only coming up with original jokes about her for like half of one of them) and this was her revenge.
Was she just a tiny bit overbearing? Yeah, but during gameplay segments she only ever came out when you pressed on the B button, so you have no one to blame but yourself. And at least she always provided pertinent information about your objective, instead of - say - Navi, whose only purpose was reciting information you already know.
The only real problem with her is that, unlike Midna - who interrupted you quite a bit herself - Fi was just the magical equivalent of an onboard AI for the Master Sword. So while Midna's expository dumps were laced with her sassy and charmingly egotistical demeanour, Fi is very straightforward, giving you the info with zero dancing around.
But say whatever you want about her, Fi's Lullaby is still utter class.
1. Motion Controls Work Just Fine
Motion Controls were the butt of the internet's joke for a long time, only going away because they became so integrated at some point that people just accepted them. But boy was it hard to be a game built on them as a cornerstone function back in the early 2010's.
The motion controls in Skyward Sword work just fine. Sure a movement doesn't register correctly if you're swinging like a crazy person in every direction or just moving in desperate rapidity because you've just been surrounded by three lizalfos on your last couple of hearts and it's time to PANIC! But if you stay calm, clearly move in the direction you wish to go, and most importantly, LISTEN to what the game is telling you, you should manage just fine.
The whip and the beetle drone are particularly good examples of the motion controls being implemented well, and as we went over previously, using the sword is a lot easier than some folks would lead you to believe.
Skyward Sword isn't perfect, some of the boss fights are the actual spawn of satan, annoying escort missions immediately cost you points with me - I don't care how fun the dungeon I get out of it is - and several plot elements could have been improved.
But if you look back on this game after a decade since it came out, I think you'll find that this supposed black sheep that drove a wedge in the Zelda fandom itself had a lot more merit to it than you gave it credit for.