10 Severely Underrated PS4 Games That Deserve A Second Chance

Despite their flaws, these titles are well worth your time.

Mafia 3
2K

Though we'll have to wait at least another year before the jury hands in their verdict on this generation of consoles, it's fair to say it's been a divisive one.

Everyone has their favourite games, but it feels as though the last four years have been more polarised than most. Metacritic averages, user scores and the flow of online chatter have all contributed to the sense that, when any game releases, a divisive response could lie in wait. This counts for titles both triple-A and otherwise, and though there's no denying that many games of the last generation certainly deserve criticism, the fact that so many met a negative - or even lukewarm - reaction, just seems like a step too far.

This isn’t to be confused with some of the PS4’s most overlooked titles either. Though that is a topic worth discussing, games that fell afoul of the Metacritic average is our primary concern today.

It's been five years of highs and lows for Sony's latest console, but with underrated titles both exclusive and otherwise, the PS4's library of soon-to-be-forgotten classics grows by the day.


10. The Evil Within 2

The evil within 2
Tango Gameworks

The sequel to 2014's Evil Within might be able to boast a cult following, but it's yet to achieve the mainstream recognition it sorely deserves.

Though it isn't without its flaws, the Shinji Mikami sequel is a compelling third-person horror title and one that manages to retain its drive from start to finish, with only a few wobbles in between.

Yes, those final corridor-sequences aren't as exciting as the title's earlier moments, but The Evil Within II is atmospheric above all else, having picked up three or so years after the finale of the first game.

It's not a sequel just for the hardcore either, as although the lore is certainly deep, it doesn't take long to get to grips with, lending this particular horror title an appeal others in the genre can lack at times - particularly so, once you factor in its intuitive combat mechanics.


9. Dying Light

Dying light
Techland

Dying Light looks set to gain a whole new level of prominence curtesy of a surprise appearance from Techland at E3, which means it's the perfect time to give the original another chance.

Although the first entry in the studio's open-world zombie title reviewed decently, it fell short of the rating it probably deserved. Yes there were flaws - particularly in regards to the tile's protagonist and antagonist - but gameplay was intuitive, the environment was interesting enough, and the deluge of post-release content managed to retain a strong community from which to build the follow-up.

With the sequel set to release next year, and with the first's Enhanced Edition readily available, there hasn't been a more appropriate time to reappraise Dying Light, and to take a trip back to Harran (potentially with a friend too, if you're a fan of co-op).


8. Sniper Elite III

Sniper Elite 3
Rebellion

Though pretty much everyone seemed to hail Sniper Elite IV as the moment Rebellion Development's WW2 series finally matured, gamers who dismiss the previous entry in the franchise are only depriving themselves of an enjoyable title.

Sniper Elite III, which is set in the North African campaign during the Second World War, succumbed to criticism pertaining its protagonist, storyline and setting, and though there's nothing particularly memorable about SOE operative Karl Fairburne, his inoffensive personality in no way impedes the crux of the title - killing Nazis.

Following in the footsteps of Lt. Aldo Raine, the player is tasked with wreaking havoc on the Nazi war machine and with outfoxing the original Desert Fox, Erwin Rommel. It's great fun, with the series' infamous x-ray animations making each shot feel just that little bit more important, whether you be sabotaging or causing different kinds of chaos behind enemy lines.

It's not quite Sniper Elite IV, but it's still a cracking WW2 action game and one worth checking out all the same.


7. Call Of Duty: Infinite Warfare

Call Of Duty Infinite Warfare Multiplayer
Infinity Ward

Call of Duty might not be the franchise it once was, but while the series' hardcore audience seemingly rails against the increasing integration of science-fiction into the shooter, some of the best entries in the series have placed those elements front and centre. Infinite Warfare - the thirteenth instalment in Activision's most profitable franchise - is a testament to that, even if initial backlash to the title persuaded gamers to look elsewhere for their next FPS.

Set in the far future, Infinite Warfare came to represent everything the series' hardcore had come to loathe about the franchise. Wall-running, jet-packs, lasers and space combat rounded out Infinity War's mindbogglingly successful shooting mechanics, and while a glance was enough to put plenty of people off, those that took a chance on the title found a competent, if not slightly overstuffed shooter lying in wait.

Critics - for the most part - seemed to agree, with the PS4's edition of the title garnering a 77 rating on Metacritic. Contextualising this average within past ratings given to CoD does, however, illustrate that Infinite Warfare was underrated by both the series' followers and by mainstream outlets more generally. Either that, or franchise fatigue had begun to set in - in any case, it seems bizarre that the CoD that made innovation a primary concern fell afoul of critics and audiences more-so than its less adventurous predecessors.

Press 'F' to pay respects.


6. Infamous First Light

InFAMOUS First Light
Sony

Sucker Punch may look set to bring a new IP to market in the stunning Ghost of Tsushima, but there was another Sony exclusive that used to get PS4 owners really excited.

inFAMOUS hasn't been heard from since First Light dropped in 2014, and that's a massive shame for all concerned. The series, which took inspiration from the superhero genre of comic books, was a staple of the PlayStation 3 before debuting on the current gen with Second Son - a title that managed to nail an average rating of 80 on Metacritic. The sequel's spin-off, First Light, didn't fare as well (even though it probably should have).

Acting as a prequel to Second Son, First Light followed Abigail 'Fetch' Walker (a supporting character from Second Son) in the events leading to her meeting with Delsin. Criticism at the time came down to the fact that, having given players such a wide array of powers in Second Son, only being able to use one of them with Fetch seemingly presented a step-back for the series.

It worked within the context of the story though, and while First Light isn't discussed much these days, it's a worthy addition to the inFAMOUS lore and one worth any fan's attention, especially with the price it's available for these days.


5. Until Dawn

Until Dawn
Sony

Until Dawn is just about the best horror title the PS4 has, and yet it's not held in nearly as high a regard as it should be.

Though the game fared well among most critics, it fell short of a Metacritic average of 80, sitting just below on 79. Though such a minuscule difference shouldn't denote the difference between a 'good' game and a 'great' one, it's fair to say that Until Dawn's cult status amongst gamers and horror fans in particular has cemented its status as a forgotten classic, and as an IP Sony have failed to ever properly capitalise on. (Any word on an Until Dusk at all?)

A point-and-click horror title that should never be spoiled for those yet to play it, Until Dawn features the talents of Rami Malek, Hayden Panettiere, Brett Dalton and Peter Stormare as a group of teens set up camp in a house on a haunted hill with a dark past. The game only gets zanier and more terrifying from there on in, with every decision the player makes having the potential to be a matter of life and death.

With star power, atmosphere and horror aplenty, Until Dawn is the must-have exclusive PlayStation owners can't afford to miss, and a title long overdue a genuine sequel.


4. Driveclub

Driveclub ps4
Sony

Make no mistake, upon its release, Driveclub was not a good game. It released with bugs aplenty and had a bunch of features missing but, four years on from its original release, Evolution Studios' racer has managed to make a name for itself as one of the PS4's best exclusives.

With mind blowing weather effects, a compelling selection of racetracks and a decent array of vehicles, the Driveclub of today is a markedly different one to the one that released during the PS4's second year. Racing fans in particular should alert to this sooner, rather than later, as this generation has seen a dearth of compelling racing games on the PlayStation in particular.

Sadly, Driveclub's long and winding path to success wasn't enough to save Evolution Studios, but the title is still available to play and one worth checking out if you've felt shortchanged by the lack of genuine racers during this console generation.


3. Assassin's Creed Syndicate

Assassin's creed syndicate
Ubisoft

Assassin's Creed Syndicate is just about the best AC game everyone seemed to miss, and it's all thanks to the fallout surrounding Unity.

Unity, which was Ubisoft's first current gen Creed title, was panned for numerous reasons, not least because the launch edition was a buggy, unplayable mess. That reputation unfortunately carried over for Syndicate, which released just a year after Ubi buggishly broached the French Revolution during a period in which annualisation was coming under heavy scrutiny.

The fact that it innovated in a great many areas didn't seem to matter, and neither did its fantastic recreation of Victorian London - franchise fatigue had set in, and Syndicate, unfortunately, was its first victim.

Releasing in 2015, Syndicate told the story of Jacob and Evie Frye as they navigated Templar-controlled London during the closing decade of the nineteenth century. It was a fantastic exploration of the city, and with players being able to switch between Jacob and Evie at the flick of a switch, each boasting distinct play-styles, the title provided the rejuvenating kick the franchise sorely needed - two years before Origins released.


2. Tom Clancy's Rainbow Six: Siege

Rainbow Six Siege Outbreak
Ubisoft

Rainbow Six Siege might not've been the game it is today when it first released, but it's fair to say that a lot of critics wrote it off without giving Ubisoft the appropriate time to develop it as a platform.

Today, Siege is something of a phenomenon. There are few shooters on the market as competitive as it, and though the title did divest from the classic Rainbow formula, combat is still tactical, impactful, and uniquely gratifying, finding the perfect balance between 'hero' multiplayer titles like Overwatch and Heroes of the Storm, and the tactical building blocks with which Ubisoft approached each Tom Clancy title before it.

Gamers would seem to agree, with Siege having gone from strength to strength since its launch, cultivating a community that numbers in the millions and can always be found on Steam's most-played list. A lot of this comes down to the fact that Ubisoft have diligently stuck by the game since its release, producing free DLC every three months or so and providing a reason for players to return each and every time they do. (The latest DLC, Para Bellum, released last month.)

It's not quite on the scale of Overwatch, but Siege is only going to get bigger and better. With a roadmap planned for months to come, Ubisoft's essential shooter is showing no signs of stopping, and is bound to exert an influence on military titles currently in development.


1. Mafia III

mafia 3
2K

Mafia III's story is a tragic one, but if reports are to be believed, it could be set to get a lot worse.

Hangar 13's first foray into the world of 2K's mobster series was anticipated for a whole host of reasons, not least of which because LucasArts alum and comic book writer Haden Blackman would be heading development. Together with the rest of 13, who assembled colleagues formerly of LucasArts and 2K Czech, Blackman set out to tell the story of Lincoln Clay - a Vietnam veteran who falls in with the Black Mob on the eve of the United States' most tumultuous year: 1968.

Gameplay wise, yes, it did leave some things to be desired. The open world looked impressive but gameplay could get repetitive at times. That said, combat felt fast, impactful and frenetic, and the overarching narrative surrounding Clay's revenge was among the most compelling the medium has ever seen.

Treat Mafia III as a story worth exploring, and it's impossible not to appreciate. Throw in all the DLC for good measure, and taking another trip to New Bordeaux is pretty much a no-brainer, even if it didn't look an enticing prospect in 2016.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Mafia III
 
Posted On: 
Content Producer/Presenter

WhatCulture's very own resident movie guy, Ewan has been working in the content creation biz for over 10 years now, having started as a freelance contributor to WhatCulture Gaming all the way back in 2015. After graduating with a First-Class Honours in History from Northumbria University in 2017 (where he won a prize for a totally killer dissertation on the Watergate years), Ewan took on the role of Comics Editor at WhatCulture and quickly developed WhatCulture Comics into one of the biggest superhero-focused channels on YouTube. He followed this with a brief hiatus at Screen Rant in 2021, where he worked across the Gaming and Film sections as a writer and editor, before returning to WhatCulture as a Senior Content Producer / Presenter in 2023. He started his own podcast, We Love Dad Movies, in 2022, and has contributed several written pieces to the Eisner-nominated comics website Shelfdust as well. In his current role, Ewan incorporates his love of cinema, comic books, and history into written pieces and video essays for WhatCulture's Film & TV channel, as well as WhatCulture Gaming and WhatCulture Horror, with a particular focus on nineties-era Dad Movies, old school Westerns, and Golden Age Hollywood Noir. John Carpenter is his fave, and he thinks Batman Beyond should never have been cancelled. If that's your vibe, you'll probably like his stuff.