10 Video Game Sequels That Made Everything Worse

Dead Space 3 wasn't what any fan wanted.

Dead Space 3
EA

Like death and taxes, video game sequels are one of life's absolute certainties - though at the best of times, they're a good deal more enjoyable.

But the pressure that falls upon the developer of a successful game is unmistakable, to deliver a sequel that's at least as good as its predecessor if not significantly better.

And though the likes of Rockstar Games and Naughty Dog have constantly one-upped themselves with each new sequel release, the history of the medium is filled with sequels which botched their attempts to deliver a rich new experience.

While countless good-to-great sequels have basically just given fans more of the same, there's a clear desire by many developers to push the envelope and help move the series - if not the genre or even the art form itself - forward.

But that ambition - whether cynically motivated or not - often ends up falling flat, where a game forgets its beloved roots and in turn loses the sense of identity that brought it to the dance in the first place.

These 10 video game sequels all sought to make drastic changes to their established IP, but in turn just left fans questioning whey they even bothered...

10. Resident Evil 6

Resident Evil 6
Capcom

After Resident Evil 4 thoroughly revitalised the survival horror franchise with its over-the-shoulder combat and more expansive locations, Resident Evil 5 began pivoting the series further towards action while de-emphasising the horror aspect.

Resident Evil 6, then, saw Capcom commit fully to a new era for the franchise, where genuine atmosphere and terror was bafflingly scarce, replaced with comically over-the-top, Michael Bay-aping set-pieces that left little lasting impression.

Add to this a bloated single-player mode comprised of several over-extended mini-campaigns, and the result is game that simply strayed too far from the rejuvenating brilliance of RE4.

While Leon's campaign at least attempted to homage Resident Evil's earlier years, the game as a whole feels uneven and schizophrenic, and is in turn unlikely to fully satisfy either the action or horror crowds.

On the plus side, its divisiveness eventually led Capcom to give the series a soft-reboot with the brilliant Resident Evil 7, which by returning to its survival horror roots and radically unfolding from a first-person perspective, was a game-changer for the better.


9. Prince Of Persia: Warrior Within

Prince of Persia: Warrior Within
Ubisoft

There is actually a rather fun game nestled somewhere inside of Prince of Persia: Warrior Within, the follow-up to the much-loved franchise reboot The Sands of Time.

Warrior Within is a baffling project for many reasons, most of all that despite releasing barely a year after The Sands of Time, Ubisoft decided to take the sequel in a drastically different direction.

The result is surely one of the most aggressively early 2000s video games ever made - a self-consciously Edgy game touting a new grimdark style and tone, complete with an emo-baiting redesign for the Prince, and the addition of gory new finishing moves.

In a decision that's aged like milk, Ubisoft also adorned Warrior Within with a metal soundtrack, including use of Godsmack's "I Walk Alone" during the game's chase sequences.

Between all this and the needlessly sexualised characters Kaileena and Shahdee, Warrior Within is what happens when executives decide they want their game to appeal to angsty, hormonal teens, despite the previous game being a commercial juggernaut on its own merits.

Mercifully the next game in the series, The Two Thrones, achieved a more suitable compromise between the swashbuckling of The Sands of Time and the more atmospheric darkness of Warrior Within.


8. Halo 5: Guardians

Halo 5: Guardians Master Chief Spartan Locke
Microsoft Studios

Though many fans hoped that Halo 5: Guardians would cement 343 Industries as the confident caretakers of the FPS franchise following the slightly uneven Halo 4, it sadly only further shook faith in their ability to deliver a product worthy of the namesake.

Despite being marketed on the strength of a campaign which would pit Master Chief against Spartan Locke, the bulk of the single-player mode shoves Chief to the sidelines, while even the much-ballyhooed showdown with Locke is a massive anti-climax.

Many fans also took umbrage with both the addition of iron sights aiming and the portrayal of Cortana, which was perceived as inconsistent with previous depictions.

Then we get to the multiplayer, which has always been the reliable meat-and-potatoes of the Halo franchise, and yet which was infested with microtransaction nonsense here, while 343 also made the decision to eliminate the popular split-screen multiplayer mode entirely.

The moment-to-moment gunplay is still fun enough that it'd be unfair to call Halo 5 bad, but it nevertheless represented the series at its most utterly pedestrian and uninspired.

Hopefully the upcoming Halo Infinite might course-correct things, though given its evidently rickety development and quasi-open world presentation, it could very well be another disappointing misstep.


7. Devil May Cry 2

devil may cry 2
Capcom

Though it originally started out as a prototype version of Resident Evil 4, the original Devil May Cry was ultimately very much its own beast - a deliriously entertaining character action masterpiece which introduced the world to silver-haired demon hunter Dante.

Expectations were through the roof, then, for the sequel, no matter that Capcom rushed it to market less than 18 months later.

Despite this expedited development cycle, Devil May Cry 2 was a shockingly marked departure from its predecessor, with both the combat and puzzle systems being significantly simplified for a more casual audience, while the original's famous difficulty was also massively nerfed.

The environments lacked the ornate quality of the first game, the set-pieces were less refined, and perhaps worst of all, Dante's signature cocky chatterbox routine was severely reined in.

Even the decision to introduce a second protagonist on a separate disc, Lucia, felt half-baked given that it so thoroughly re-trod everything from the Dante missions.

Thankfully DMC2 proved to be a minor blip in the grand scheme of things, as Devil May Cry 3 restored basically everything missing from its predecessor, and the series has been flying high ever since.


6. Tomb Raider: The Angel Of Darkness

Tomb Raider angel of darkness
Eidos Interactive

Though it's right to say that the Tomb Raider series began to spin its wheels around the turn of the millennium, it wasn't until the release of 2003's The Angel Of Darkness that those wheels fell off entirely.

Developers Core Design, who were clearly thoroughly fatigued at having produced annual Tomb Raider games between 1996 and 2000, nevertheless endeavoured to make their first outing on PS2 hardware a far cry from the series' formula.

The hope was that The Angel of Darkness could compete with more modern action-adventure games by touting a grittier, more cinematic style, introducing RPG elements such as interactive NPCs, offering a greater emphasis on stealth ala Metal Gear Solid, and even a second playable character, Kurtis Trent.

Yet due to the game's infamously roughshod development, it ended up being littered with bugs, forced players to contend with a terrible camera, and was basically an ambitious-yet-failed attempt to move the series forward.

As a result, the Tomb Raider IP was put on ice for the next few years, and only fully regained its popular footing with Crystal Dynamics' Uncharted-esque reboot in 2013.


5. Spyro: Enter The Dragonfly

Spyro Enter The Dragonfly
Universal

You couldn't really go wrong with the original Spyro the Dragon trilogy, after which developers Insomniac Games moved on to the Ratchet & Clank series, leaving the fourth Spyro game, Enter the Dragonfly, to be helmed by lesser-known studios Check Six Studios and Equinoxe Digital Entertainment.

Still, how bad could it be, right?

Pretty bad, as it turns out. Enter the Dragonfly wasn't just a crushing disappointment - it was the pure antithesis of the joyous, intelligent craft present in the original trilogy.

Even if you could forgive the short play-time and scant amount of content, the level design lacked the nuance of its predecessors, the framerate was wildly inconsistent, the controls were weirdly unresponsive, and it was full of bugs.

This basically felt like a pale shade of what came before, with Insomniac President Ted Price even calling it an "absolute travesty" and referring to Spyro as an "abused stepchild." Oof.

Much like Tomb Raider, Spyro's transition to the next generation of games hardware presented challenges the development team simply wasn't able to resolve.

As a result a planned sequel was cancelled, and the series fell out of mainstream popularity until the release of 2018's Reignited Trilogy.


4. Mass Effect: Andromeda

Mass Effect Andromeda 4k
Bioware

As much as Mass Effect 3's release was met with a fierce fan backlash, that had little to do with the core gameplay, but rather BioWare's inability to provide fans with a satisfyingly fluid, branching ending as originally promised.

And so, the inevitable fourth game didn't really need to give the series a major makeover or readjustment, but that didn't stop BioWare from making Mass Effect: Andromeda a bold step away from the existing formula.

Though distancing itself from the events and characters in the prior trilogy wasn't an inherently bad thing, BioWare ultimately failed to populate Andromeda with a cast of characters nearly as interesting as Commander Shepard and co.

The most radical change from the first three games, however, was the addition of open world-style gameplay, while while a natural fit for the expansive Mass Effect universe, ended up feeling more blandly generic than truly lived-in.

Elsewhere many players were frustrated with the myriad bugs, and of course, the infamously terrible facial animations apparent upon launch.

Andromeda isn't a bad game all things considered - the combat is pretty solid, for one - but it is a solid step down from its three predecessors, smacking of another developer basically trying to create an imitation Mass Effect game.

Given that BioWare tapped their Montreal outfit to lead development - rather than the Edmonton team who made the original trilogy - it's not terribly surprising that it made players feel this way, or that its production was massively troubled.


3. Driv3r

driv3r driver 3
Atari

The original Driver is one of the PS1's most beloved video games, for those who could actually make it past that infuriating opening driving test level, anyway.

Driver 2 didn't reach the same heights despite including positively ambitious on-foot functionality, yet it was still a solid enough sequel for the most part.

Then came the obnoxiously-monikered threequel Driv3r, which like the aforementioned Tomb Raider and Spyro games, marked the series' big leap onto next-gen hardware.

Despite the power of the PS2 and Xbox, however, Driv3r was an absolute shambles of a game, not only making on-foot action a bigger part of the experience but also introducing gunplay in a desperate attempt to capture a slice of the Grand Theft Auto fanbase.

Sadly the gunplay was rancid and only kept players at arm's length from the only really fun part of the game - the driving - while also demonstrating how generally joyless it was to behold.

Had it been executed correctly, Driv3r could've catapulted the franchise to new heights, but instead cratered it into the Earth, such that it's endured as a mere moderate curiosity ever since.


2. Dead Space 3

Dead Space 3 Co Op
EA

The original Dead Space was one of the most innovative and unforgettable survival horror games of its generation, while the sequel served up a brilliantly barmy rollercoaster ride of stomach-knottingly intense action.

However, Dead Space 3 ended up basically pulling a Resident Evil 6 by venturing too far from the series' horror roots and placing a far greater emphasis on action schlock - including, oddly, human enemies - which while fun to a point, lacked the gut-wrenching atmosphere of the two prior games.

Again like RE6, the threequel is a distended, wildly overlong experience, and though the optional co-op adds a neat enough wrinkle, EA's decision to plug microtransaction nonsense into the game's crafting system was met with justifiably intense backlash from the fanbase.

Dead Space isn't awful by any means, but it is a sequel that jettisoned the soul of its predecessors.


1. Dynasty Warriors 9

Dynasty Warriors 9
Koei

Even the most casual Dynasty Warriors fan knows that the series hasn't ever been much for evolution - you pretty much know exactly what you're getting in each new installment, and that's basically fine.

But 2018's ninth game made the shock move to dispense (slightly) with the hack 'n' slash formula by introducing an open world, with players able to freely traverse a map of China as they saw fit.

There were far worse ideas for the future of Dynasty Warriors, honestly, but the end result was a predictably cynical attempt to cash-in on the popularity of open world games today.

And so, Dynasty Warriors 9's open world was bereft of life, packed to the gills with generic missions, collect-a-thon busy-work, and somnambulant NPCs.

It is basically everything fans feared when the changes were first announced, and proof perfect of how difficult it is to make a truly worthwhile open world game.

Amusingly, the upcoming strategic expansion, Empires, was recently confirmed to be ditching the open world elements, which is really all that needs to be said about how egregiously they failed here.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Dead Space 3
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.